top of page

Search this site

53 results found with an empty search

  • Prehistoric Midwest | Extinct Animal Field Guides

    An online illustrated guidebook about ancient life in the Midwest with extinct animal field guides about life in the Western Interior Sea, the Pleistocene epoch and more. Extinct Animal Field Guides Explore the ancient past of the Midwest! These illustrated online guides are filled with information about the types of extinct animals who were once found in the Midwest and the Great Plains. New guides coming soon! Pleistocene Megafauna Pleistocene epoch 2.5 million years ago - 11,700 years ago Large land mammals and reptiles of the Ice Ages found in the Great Plains, Great Lakes region and the Ohio River valley Explore Western Interior Sea Cretaceous Period 100 - 66 million years ago Marine reptiles, birds and invertebrates found in the seas which covered the Great Plains during the Cretaceous period Explore The Ogallala Formation Miocene & Pliocene epochs 18.5 - 5 million years ago Ancient rhinos, elephant relatives, saber-toothed cats, camels and canids who lived in the ancient savannahs of the Great Plains Explore The Cleveland Shale Devonian period 362.6–360.1 million years ago Giant armored fishes, shark-like cartilaginous fishes and other animals whose fossils are found in north-eastern Ohio Explore Recent Extinctions 250 years ago- Present Over a dozen species of Midwestern animals have become extinct over the last 250 years, including birds, fishes, insects and snails Explore Timeline Of Prehistoric Life In The Midwest The landscape of the Midwest has taken on many forms over the course of Earth's history. At various times in the distant past parts of the Midwest have been covered in rainforests, in shallow seas and in mile-thick sheets of solid ice. Explore the Timeline Welcome to Prehistoric Midwest: an illustrated guide to the ancient past This website is intended to be a catalogue of information about ancient life in the Midwest, as well as a collection of paleoart featuring our many types of extinct organisms! About our project Anatomical Coloring Pages Color in these anatomical and skeletal diagrams to learn more about the finer details of ancient fossils! See our coloring pages 3D Scans and Models Browse 3-dimensional scans of fossil specimens produced by the Virtual Curation Lab Learn More Further Reading Find more sources of information about prehistoric life in the Midwest Learn More The Drawing Process Learn about how all of the illustrations for our website are made! Learn More Updates

  • Perissodactyls | Prehistoric Midwest

    Explore the different types of prehistoric horses and tapirs found in the Midwest during the Pleistocene epoch Perissodactyla Tapirs, Horses, Rhinos and their Relatives During the Pleistocene epoch, North America was home to several kinds of perissodactyls, also known as odd-toed hoofed mammals. The most abundant were horses of the genus Equus , which occupied a wide range of grassland and open habitats. Several Equus species were found across the continent, and three-toed horses were also found in this region at the start of the Pleistocene. Tapirs could also be found in the Midwest, primarily in wooded regions and hilly areas. Earlier rhinoceros relatives had once inhabited North America during the Neogene period but they were already extinct on the continent by the start of the Pleistocene. Anatomy (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeletal anatomy of the Miocene three-toed horse genus Merychippus. Drawing is based on a mounted skeleton at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History Skeletal Anatomy Perissodactyls tend to walk on feet with either one, three or five toes. This is a result of a feature of their skeletal anatomy called mesaxony, a condition in which the body's weight is concentrated on the enlarged third digit of each limb. One-toed horses exhibit the most specialized derived form of this arrangement with only a single functional toe per foot, whereas tapirs and rhinoceroses retain several toes that help provide extra stability when walking over soft ground and distributing their body weights. The gradual loss of toes in horses seems to be an adaptation for running quickly over open grassland habitats. In highly cursorial species certain limb bones have become reduced or partially fused and, like many types of artiodactyls, horses have cannon bones in the areas of their legs just above their feet. The skulls of perissodactyls tend to be fairly elongated with expanded nasal regions. In rhinoceroses, the nasal bones are extra thick in order to support the attachment of their characteristic horns, while in tapirs the nasal openings have become retroverted in order to make space for a short trunk. Some ancient horse genera had a set of deep fossae along the edges of their snouts in front of their orbits which may have held scent glands in life. These fossae are not present in living horse species. The teeth of perissodactyls are specialized for herbivorous diets, with broad grinding surfaces and, in many lineages, high-crowned molars adapted for processing abrasive vegetation. (BELOW) The skull of the extinct horse genus Pliohippus features a series of deep fossae along the sides of its muzzle. These fossae are present in the remains of many types of extinct horses but are absent in the living genus Equus (ABOVE) The skull of a tapir. These animals have particularly heavily built incisors at the front of their jaws and a distinctive retroverted nasal opening which anchors the base of the tapir's trunk External Anatomy Perissodactyls share a number of common physical traits. Their heads are usually rather long and equipped with laterally positioned eyes. Having their eyes on the sides of their heads gives these animals a wider field of view with a larger amount of peripheral vision. Their ears are often tall, rigid and highly mobile and they are able to turn their ears in order to better pick up a sound coming from a particular direction. In some groups, namely tapirs, the front of the skull is equipped with a short, flexible snout used to grasp vegetation, while rhinoceroses have specialized muscles in their upper lips which they use to pull leaves off of branches. Some early horses who fed on leaves may have had similar types of browsing-adapted lips. Body coverings vary a lot between different types of perissodactyls. Horses typically have a coat of hair which can be thin or very thick depending on the local climate, whereas rhinoceroses are covered in thick, protective skin with relatively little hair. Some living tapir species who live at high elevations today have fairly thick coats of fur, which would be what we might expect to see in midwestern ice age tapirs. (BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of a horse (BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of a tapir Horses (Equidae) One-toed and three-toed horses During the Pleistocene, the grasslands and open habitats of the Midwest supported several types of prehistoric horses. The most common were members of the genus Equus , including stout-legged horses such as Equus scotti, a widespread species found across parts of the Great Plains and central North America. Fossil evidence shows that these horses were grazing animals adapted to open environments, much like the wild horse and zebra populations still found around the world today. The region may also have been inhabited by more slender-limbed, “stilt-legged” horses such as Haringtonhippus , which lived alongside Equus species throughout much of North America. Relatives of older horse groups with extra hooves bracing the sides of their main toes could still be found in this area during the early Pleistocene. Equus Temporal Range: 5.3 million years ago to present (outside the Americas) Geographic Range: Genus found on all continents Midwestern species in the Pleistocene: E. scotti, E. simplicidens Diet: Herbivorous grazer, grasses During the Pleistocene, the Midwest was inhabited by multiple species of Equus , the genus that includes modern horses, donkeys and zebras. One of the best-known was Equus scott i, a medium-sized, stout-legged grazing horse that lived in grasslands, open woodlands, and wetlands across much of North America, including parts of the Great Plains and Midwest. Another species, Equus simplicidens, could also be found in this region. This animal, sometimes called a Hagerman horse, had skeletal features similar to those found in today’s zebras. Our knowledge about the coat colors of extinct horses is somewhat limited. Cave art from Eurasia suggests that many Pleistocene wild horses might have appeared very similar to today’s Przewalski's horse, with tan fur and a white muzzle. It may be reasonable to assume that North American species of Equus could have had similar coat colors. (BELOW) A skull from a modern horse on display at the KU Natural History Museum. This particular skull has been cut away to reveal the shapes of the roots of each tooth. Note that some of the rear teeth had not yet fully emerged in this animal. Stilt-legged horse Haringtonhippus francisci Temporal Range: 3 million years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Genus across North America from Alaska to Mexico Species: H. francisci, H. achates, H. quinni, H. cedralensis Diet: Herbivorous grazer, grasses Haringtonhippus was an extinct genus of horse that lived in North America during the Pleistocene. The best-known and only recognized species is Haringtonhippus francisci . This animal is often called a “stilt-legged horse” because of its unusually long and slender lower limb bones, which distinguished it from the more heavily built horses of the genus Equus which would have lived alongside it. Fossils of Haringtonhippus have been discovered across a wide geographic range, from Mexico through the western and central parts of North America and into Canada. For many years, these animals were classified within the genus Equus, but genetic analyses of their bones and anatomical studies of their skeletal features later showed that they formed part of a distinct evolutionary lineage. Research indicates that Haringtonhippus was more closely related to modern horses than to the South American genus Hippidion , yet it remained separate from the lineage that includes all of today’s living horses and zebras. Dwarf three-toed horse Nannippus lenticularis Temporal Range: 3.3 million years ago to 1.8 million years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North America Species: N. lenticularis, N. minor, N. morgani, N. westoni, N. penninsulatus Nannippus lenticularis was a small species of three-toed horse that lived in North America from the late Miocene to the start of the Pleistocene epoch. It belonged to an older group of horses that had been widespread across the continent before the evolution of the larger, one-toed horses such as those of the genus Equus . Fossils of Nannippus have been discovered in Kansas, Nebraska, Alabama, North Carolina, Texas, and Alberta, indicating that it was well adapted to a variety of environments. Unlike modern horses, Nannippus lenticularis retained three functional toes on each foot. The enlarged middle toe bore most of the animal's weight, while the two smaller side toes were positioned higher up and braced the middle toe from each side. Members of the genus Nannippus were relatively small, growing to be around the size of a sheep or a large dog. Dental evidence suggests that Nannippus species were primarily browsers who fed on leaves, shrubs, and other softer vegetation rather than relying exclusively on grasses like today’s horses. This diet allowed them to thrive in woodland and savannah habitats found across North America during the late Miocene, although as grasslands began to spread they faced increased competition from other horses who had become specialist grazers. Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, twigs, leaf buds Tapirs (Tapiridae) Ancient tapirs in the Midwest During the Pleistocene, tapirs lived much further north than they do now, with some making their homes in the Midwest. These large herbivores inhabited forests, wetlands, and river valleys, where they fed on leaves, fruits, aquatic plants and other vegetation. Like modern tapirs, they possessed a short, flexible snout that was useful for grasping and manipulating plant material. Although they fall within the “Odd toed” ungulate group, tapirs actually have four main toes on their front feet. Their hind feet have five toes, each of which is tipped in its own hoof-like nail. Tapirus veroensis Temporal Range: 300,000 years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Eastern North America Subspecies: T. veroensis Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Tapirus veroensis was a species of tapir that lived in eastern North America during the Pleistocene. Fossils attributed to this species have been discovered in Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Missouri, and Tennessee. Although complete details of its external appearance are not known, Tapirus veroensis was likely similar in overall form to living mountain tapirs. We know that these animals had large trunk-like snouts based on the shapes of their nasal openings. The skulls of tapirs have nasal bones which are positioned further back, leaving more space for the soft tissues needed to support a flexible trunk. Although Tapirus veroensis is one of the last types of tapirs to be found in the Midwest, their history in this region goes back millions of years, with the first fossils of ancient tapirs in the Great Plains going back to the Oligocene epoch. Media Gallery Suggested References: Perissodactyla Cirilli, Omar; Machado, Helena; Arroyo-Cabrales, Joaquin; Barrón-Ortiz, Christina I.; Davis, Edward; Jass, Christopher N.; Jukar, Advait M.; Landry, Zoe; Marín-Leyva, Alejandro H.; Pandolfi, Luca; Pushkina, Diana; Rook, Lorenzo; Saarinen, Juha; Scott, Eric; Semprebon, Gina (2022). "Evolution of the Family Equidae, Subfamily Equinae, in North, Central and South America, Eurasia and Africa during the Plio-Pleistocene". Biology. 11 (9): 1258. Eric Scott (2006) “Extinct horses and their relatives, Fossil Treasures of the Anza-Borrego Desert: the Last Seven Million Years”, Sunbelt Publications, p. 253-271 Holanda, E.C.; Ferrero, B.S. (2012). "Reappraisal of the Genus Tapirus (Perissodactyla, Tapiridae): Systematics and Phylogenetic Affinities of the South American Tapirs". Journal of Mammalian Evolution. 20: 33–44. doi:10.1007/s10914-012-9196-z. hdl:11336/18792. S2CID 254697945. Hulbert, Richard C. (2010). "A new early Pleistocene tapir (Mammalia: Perissodactyla) from Florida, with a review of Blancan tapirs from the state" (PDF). Bulletin of the Florida Museum of Natural History. 49 (3): 67–126. Hulbert, Richard C. (1993). "Late Miocene Nannippus (Mammalia: Perissodactyla) from Florida, with a Description of the Smallest Hipparionine Horse". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology . 13 (3): 350–366. MacFadden, Bruce J (1984). "Systematics and phylogeny of Hipparion, Neohipparion, Nannippus, and Cormohipparion (Mammalia, Equidae) from the Miocene and Pliocene of the New World". Bulletin of the AMNH. 179. Spencer, Lillian M.; Scott, Eric (2023). "Resource partitioning among late Pleistocene herbivores of Natural Trap Cave, Wyoming". Quaternary International. 647–648: 88–93. Vershinina, Alisa O.; Heintzman, Peter D.; Froese, Duane G.; Zazula, Grant; Cassatt-Johnstone, Molly; Dalén, Love; Der Sarkissian, Clio; Dunn, Shelby G.; Ermini, Luca; Gamba, Cristina; Groves, Pamela; Kapp, Joshua D.; Mann, Daniel H.; Seguin-Orlando, Andaine; Southon, John (2021). "Ancient horse genomes reveal the timing and extent of dispersals across the Bering Land Bridge". Molecular Ecology. 30 (23): 6144–6161. Weinstock, Jaco; Willerslev, Eske; Sher, Andrei; Tong, Wenfei; Ho, Simon Y.W; Rubenstein, Dan; Storer, John; et al. (2005). "Evolution, Systematics, and Phylogeography of Pleistocene Horses in the New World: A Molecular Perspective". PLOS Biology. 3 (8): e241.

  • Plesiosaurs | Prehistoric Midwest

    Explore the different types of plesiosaurs found in the Cretaceous waters of the Western Interior Seaway, including animals like Elasmosaurus, Styxosaurus, Dolichorhynchops and Megacephalosaurus Plesiosauria Plesiosaurs in the Great Plains The plesiosaurs were one of the dominant groups of marine reptiles found in the world’s oceans during the Mesozoic. Their ancestry is somewhat mysterious but they seem to have been related to many other types of marine reptiles who independently became aquatic during the Mesozoic era. It should be noted that plesiosaurs were not closely related to the mosasaurs, another group of marine reptiles who became very successful during the Late Cretaceous and whose fossils are also found in rocks in central North America. The Western Interior Sea supported a diverse range of plesiosaurs during the Late Cretaceous. The best known members of this group of ocean reptiles are the elasmosaurids, known for their extremely long necks, small heads, cone-shaped teeth and powerful flippers. Species such as Elasmosaurus likely used their long necks to approach schools of fish and squid from below with minimal disturbance. Another important group was the family polycotylidae, which had short necks, long crocodile-like heads, and streamlined bodies. Predators like Dolichorhynchops were adapted for speed and active pursuit of prey, occupying a different ecological niche from the elasmosaurs. The Interior Sea was also home to members of older plesiosaur lineages, such as some of the latest surviving examples of the short-necked pliosaurs. These families filled multiple roles within the ecosystem, from giant hunters with bone-crushing bites to fast-swimming predators. Anatomy (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeleton of the polycotylid short-necked plesiosaur Dolichorhynchops from Kansas Skeletal Anatomy Plesiosaurs came in many different shapes and sizes and their skeletons varied quite a bit depending on their specific ecological roles. Despite this variation many shared broad characteristic features can be seen in the remains of most types of plesiosaurs. Their bodies tended to be wide, streamlined and supported by a sturdy rib cage and a relatively rigid vertebral column that helped give them extra stability while swimming. Plesiosaurs also had a very distinctive neck structure. Their necks were built from dozens of short interlocking cervical vertebrae and the number of neck vertebrae in an animal's neck could vary wildly between species even within a single taxonomic family. Some plesiosaurs had short, muscular necks, while others evolved long and flexible ones. These animals are often shown in older media with coiled snake-like necks but this degree of flexibility does not actually seem to have been attainable for these animals. Even animals with 50 or more cervical vertebrae would have had fairly rigid necks, The skulls of plesiosaurs were typically equipped with an array of sharp, conical teeth well suited for capturing fish, cephalopods, and other marine prey. Openings at the back of their skulls and along their cheekbones provided attachment points for strong jaw muscles. The pectoral and pelvic girdles around the hip and shoulder regions were heavily built and served as strong anchors for the limbones. All four limbs had developed over time into large, paddle-shaped flippers composed of elongated and flattened bony blocks formed from the bones of the arms and wrists. These limb bones can be generally sorted into two types; propodials (humeri and femurs) and podials (forearm bones, lower leg bones, leg and manus bones). The exact swimming motion that would have been used by these ancient animals is still something of a mystery but they are often shown in media as flapping their foreflippers and hindflippers up and down at opposite intervals. (BELOW) Some plesiosaurs had skeletons which included dozens of cervical vertebrae in their very long necks. (BELOW) The waters of the Western Interior Sea were home to both long-necked and short-necked plesiosaurs. The pliosaurs went extinct not long after the Interior Sea first spanned across North America External Anatomy Late Cretaceous plesiosaurs included both animals who had very long necks and others who had extremely large skulls and short necks. The top predators of the seas of the early Cretaceous period were the Pliosaurs, a group of plesiosaurs whose heads measured up to a quarter of their entire body length. Elasmosaurids on the other hand tended to have longer necks and fairly small heads while Polycotylid plesiosaurs had medium-sized necks and long toothy snouts. Plesiosaurs Pliosaurs (Suborder Pliosauroidea) Brachauchenius Megacephalosaurus Elasmosaurs (Family Elasmosauridae) Albertonectes Elasmosaurus Libonectes Nakonanectes Plesioelasmosaurus Styxosaurus Terminonatator Thalassomedon Wapuskanectes Leptocleidids (Family Leptocleididae) Nichollssaura Polycotylids (Family Polycotylidae) Dolichorhynchops Edgarosaurus Martinectes Pahasapasaurus Plesiopleurodon Polycotylus Serpentisuchops Trinacromerum Unktaheela Pliosaurs (Pliosauroidea) Large Skulls and Crushing Bites Pliosaurs were among the most formidable marine reptiles to inhabit the Western Interior Seaway. Unlike their long-necked plesiosaur relatives, pliosaurs had short, powerful necks, massive skulls, and large conical teeth designed for seizing and crushing prey. Their streamlined bodies and four strong flippers made them fast and agile swimmers capable of pursuing large prey. One notable pliosaur from North America was Brachauchenius , an ancient predator from the middle Cretaceous that represented one of the last surviving members of its group. Its robust jaws and strong bite allowed it to occupy the role of an apex predator within the marine ecosystem. Large eyes and keen senses likely helped pliosaurs locate prey in a variety of underwater conditions. Brachauchenius Temporal Range: 100 million years ago - 90 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Morrocco Species: B. lucasi Diet: Carnivorous, large prey, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Brachauchenius was one of the final representatives of the pliosaur lineage. These animals retained many of the adaptations that had made their ancestors successful ocean predators for millions of years during the Jurassic and early Cretaceous periods. Its most notable feature was its large, heavily built head, armed with powerful jaws and sharp, cone-shaped teeth ideal for restraining its prey. Compared to many plesiosaurs, its head was proportionally larger, emphasizing its macropredatory lifestyle. The history of the discovery of Brachauchenius in the Great Plains began in 1884 when a large marine reptile fossil was uncovered near Delphos, Kansas. The specimen was excavated by fossil collector Charles H. Sternberg with support from paleontologist Othniel Charles Marsh and later preserved in museum collections. In 1903, Samuel W. Williston formally described and named the animal Brachauchenius lucasi , identifying it as a short-necked pliosaur based on its skull, vertebrae, and ribs. This animal seems to have been closely related to another pliosaur, Megacephalosaurus. (BELOW) A Brachauchenius tooth from the upper Cenomanian Britton Formation of Texas. Fossil collected and original photo taken by Jared Cooke/ jcookepaleo (BELOW) A photo of the holotype specimen of Brachauchenius lucasi, preserving a skull, cervical and thoracic vertebrae as well as ribs, accessed via Wikimedia Commons, public domain image by the Smithsonian Institute (BELOW) A view of the holotype specimen of Brachauchenius lucasi in which the lower parts of the skull and the palate are visible. Accessed via Wikimedia Commons, public domain image by the Smithsonian Institute Megacephalosaurus Temporal Range: 93.9 million years ago - 92.9 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: M. eulerti Diet: Carnivorous, large prey, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Megacephalosaurus was a genus of pliosaurs whose name translates to “large-headed lizard.” The skull of Megacephalosaurus is among the largest known for a North American pliosaur and would have made up around a fifth of the animal’s total body length Fossils of Megacephalosaurus were first discovered in 1950 when Frank and Robert Jennrich found a large fossil skull while collecting shark teeth near Fairport, Kansas. The specimen was excavated with the help of paleontologist George F. Sternberg and later donated to the Sternberg Museum of Natural History. Initially, scientists believed the fossil belonged to the pliosaur Brachauchenius lucasi and it remained classified as that species for many years. Further study revealed important anatomical differences between the skull and known specimens of Brachauchenius . In 2013 paleontologists Bruce Schumacher, Kenneth Carpenter, and Michael Everhart formally described the fossil as a new genus and species, naming it Megacephalosaurus eulert i. (BELOW) The original holotype skull of Megacephalosaurus eulerti on display at the Sternberg Museum of Natural History, FHSM VP-321. This is the largest skull known for a North American plesiosaur. (BELOW) A three-dimensional model of the shape of the skull of Megacephalosaurus accounting for taphonomic compression, on display near the entryway of the Sternberg Museum. Model produced by the Rocky Mountain Dinosaur Resource Center Elasmosaurs (Elasmosauridae) Plesiosaurs with Extremely Long Necks Elasmosaurids were some of the most easily recognizable reptiles that inhabited the Western Interior Sea during the Late Cretaceous. Their best known defining feature was an extremely long neck composed of dozens of vertebrae which often made up more than half of the animal’s total body length. This adaptation allowed elasmosaurs to approach prey with their small heads while keeping their large bodies at a distance and hidden in the darkness of the water below, potentially reducing the chance of alarming schools of fish and squid. Unlike the powerful, short-necked pliosaurs that hunted through brute force, elasmosaurs relied on agility and precision. Their four strong, paddle-like flippers provided efficient propulsion, enabling them to swim gracefully through the seaway’s waters. Species such as Elasmosaurus , Styxosaurus , and Thalassomedon were among the most notable members of this family. Although nearly all members of the group had very long necks, fossils show us that they still had a great deal of variation between genera in size and neck proportions, which may have allowed different animals to exploit their own separate niches. Albertonectes Temporal Range: 73.5 million years ago Geographic Range: Alberta Species: A. vanderveldei Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Albertonectes is known from fossils found in Alberta, Canada. This marine reptile is well known for having one of the longest necks ever documented in a plesiosaur. With roughly seventy-six cervical vertebrae, its neck was even more elongated than those of many other well-known elasmosaurids. The first fossil of Albertonectes was discovered in 2007 during ammolite mining near the town of Lethbridge, Alberta, when workers uncovered the remains of a large marine reptile in layers of rocks falling within the Bearpaw Formation. Although part of the fossil was accidentally damaged during excavation, most of the skeleton was preserved and later transferred to the Royal Tyrrell Museum for study. The specimen consisted of an almost complete skeleton, including 132 vertebrae, portions of the shoulder and pelvic girdles, nearly complete limbs, and numerous gastroliths. In 2012, paleontologists Tai Kubo, Mark Mitchell, and Donald Henderson formally described the fossil as a new species. (BELOW) A photo of a cluster of stomach stones, or gastroliths, found in association with a skeleton of Albertonectes near the inside of the animal's right, dorsal ribs. Photo by Donald M. Henderson, Sue Sabrowski, accessed via Wikimedia Commons, distributed under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license Elasmosaurus Temporal Range: 80 million years ago - 77 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, possible material known from Germany, Japan Species: E. platyurus Diet: Carnivorous, small prey, fish Elasmosaurus is the namesake of the family elasmosauridae and was one of the first members of this group to be discovered in the 19th century. Although it grew to impressive lengths, Elasmosaurus possessed a relatively small head armed with numerous slender, sharp teeth. These teeth were well suited for gripping fish, squid, and other small marine creatures. Rather than overpowering prey with force it probably relied on swift and accurate strikes to capture its meals. Four large flippers gave these animals the propulsion they needed for efficient swimming and allowed them to maneuver through the waters of the ancient seaway with ease. It may have also had a small diamond-shaped fluke along its tail. Elasmosaurus was first discovered in 1867 near Fort Wallace, Kansas, by Army surgeon Dr. Theophilus H. Turner. The fossil was excavated and transported to Philadelphia, where it was studied by paleontologist Edward Drinker Cope. In 1868, Cope named the animal Elasmosaurus platyurus but mistakenly reconstructed the skeleton with the head attached to the tail. This famous error was later corrected and became a well-known episode in the rivalry between Cope and Othniel Charles Marsh during the Bone Wars. Libonectes Temporal Range: 93 million years ago Geographic Range: Northern Texas, Morocco Species: L. morgani, L. atlasense Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Libonectes was a genus of elasmosaurid plesiosaur whose remains are found in parts of Texas and Morocco. It seems to have been a close relative of Thalassomedon. When compared with related genera such as Thalassomedon , Libonectes had taller neural spines on the back of its vertebrae and more elongated supporting structures. It also had nostrils positioned slightly farther forward on its skull. Another noteworthy feature of Libonectes is the preservation of gastroliths, or stomach stones, within some fossil specimens. These stones are fairly common in well-preserved fossil skeletons of elasmosaurs and they may have been used to regulate the animal’s buoyancy as it swam through the water. (BELOW) A photo of the holotype skull of Libonectes morgani from the Late Cretaceous of Texas. Photo by Kenneth Carpenter, accessed via Wikimedia Commons, distributed under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license (BELOW) A photo of the skull of the Moroccan species Libonectes atlasense , which has a full set of interlocked teeth. Photo by Benjamin P. Kear, Dennis Larsson, Johan Lindgren, Martin Kundrát, accessed via Wikimedia Commons, distributed under a CC BY 2.5 license Nakonanectes Temporal Range: 73 million years ago Geographic Range: Montana Species: N. bradtii Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Nakonanectes an elasmosaurid that lived towards the end of the Late Cretaceous. Fossils discovered in Montana's Bearpaw Formation indicate that it was among the last known elasmosaurids to live in North America. Nakonanectes is especially distinctive because of its relatively short neck. The animal’s neck contained only about 39 to 42 cervical vertebrae. This is considerably fewer than the number found in many classic long-necked elasmosaurids, some of which had 60 cervical vertebrae. This shortened neck would have given it a noticeably different body profile and probably hints at a different type of ecological niche for this animal. Nakonanectes was also fairly small when compared to some of its relatives. It would have only reached an estimated length of roughly 5 to 6 meters, half as long as other elasmosaurids. The species is also known from an unusually well-preserved skull, allowing scientists to study several unique characteristics of its head and jaws which most famously include its distinctive shortened snout. (BELOW) A photo of the holotype skull of Nakonanectes from the Bearpaw Shale. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, uploaded by user Montanaceratops, distributed under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license Plesioelasmosaurus Temporal Range: 94.3 million years ago - 89.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: P. walkeri Diet: Carnivorous, small prey, fish Plesioelasmosaurus was an elasmosaurid that lived in the Western Interior Seaway during the Late Cretaceous. Fossils discovered in Kansas suggest that these would have been a type of marine reptile with a body plan that blended features seen in both early and more specialized elasmosaurids. Although it had the long neck typical of the group, its neck was a bit shorter in proportion than those of highly specialized forms such as Elasmosaurus . The first fossils belonging to this animal were found in 1931 near Holyrood, Kansas. It was informally known as the “Holyrood elasmosaur” for many years before it was finally assigned to its own new genus and species in 2022. Styxosaurus Temporal Range: 100 million years ago - 72 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, South Dakota, Nebraska Species: S. snowii, S. brownii, S. rezaci Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Styxosaurus is a famous member of the elasmosaurid family of plesiosaurs. Despite the fact that elongated necks were a defining feature of many elasmosaurids, Styxosaurus belonged to a lineage that developed some of the longest necks known among vertebrates. In addition to its remarkable neck length, it would have had a unique shape to its skull, including forms of ridges and jaw structures that help separate it from closely related elasmosaurs. In 1890, Samuel W. Williston described the original fossils of Styxosaurus , which consisted of a skull and associated neck vertebrae from Kansas, under the name “Cimoliasaurus snowii ”. The species was later reassigned to Elasmosauru s before Samuel P. Welles erected the genus Styxosaurus in 1943. Additional fossils from across the area once covered by the Western Interior Sea were subsequently attributed to the genus. A lot of what we know about more famous animals like Elasmosaurus itself is based on knowledge gained from the study of far more complete fossils of Styxosaurus. (BELOW) The holotype skull of Styxosaurus snowii, KUVP 1301, on display at the KU Natural History Museum Terminonatator Temporal Range: 72 million years ago Geographic Range: Saskatchewan Species: T. ponteixensis Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Terminonatator was one of the last of the elasmosaurids. Its name translates to “last swimmer,” which reflects its position among the later representatives of the long-necked plesiosaur lineage. Although it shared the characteristic elongated neck of other elasmosaurids, it would have had some anatomical features that made it unique within the group, namely having slightly fewer teeth at the front of its mouth. It also had an unusually long femur which may have extended the length of its flippers. This may have helped it navigate both coastal and open-water environments. Like other elasmosaurids, it had a small skull and slender, sharp teeth well suited for capturing fish and soft-bodied prey. Terminonatator ’s first fossils were discovered in the Bearpaw Formation of Alberta, Canada, a rock unit famous for preserving marine reptiles from the final stages of the Western Interior Sea as it began to retreat again at the very end of the Cretaceous period. Thalassomedon Temporal Range: 99.6 million years ago - 93.5 million years ago Geographic Range: Colorado Species: T. haningtoni Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Thalassomedon was among the largest members of the elasmosaurid family to live in the Western Interior Sea. Its name means “sea ruler,” and adults of this genus could reach lengths of more than 40 feet. One of its most distinctive traits was that it had a long neck even for an elasmosaurid, composed of roughly 60 vertebrae. Thalassomedon was discovered in 1939 when fossil bones were exposed by erosion in a layer of shale in a cliff near Pritchett, Colorado. The remains were first spotted by a man named Fred Roth, who called in local paleontologists and geologists to look at his find. Although some bones had been disturbed before scientists arrived, a large portion of the skeleton was successfully recovered from the surrounding rocks, which fell within the Graneros Shale formation. The fossil was later studied by paleontologist Samuel P. Welles, who described and named the new species Thalassomedon haningtoni in 1943. Wapuskanectes Temporal Range: 112 million years ago Geographic Range: Alberta Species: W. betsynichollsae Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Wapuskanectes was one of the earliest known members of the elasmosaurid group on the North American continent. Fossils of these animals were discovered in the Early Cretaceous rocks of the Clearwater formation in Alberta, Canada where it would have lived long before famous later elasmosaurids such as Elasmosaurus, Albertonectes , and Libonectes . It is known from fossils of parts of its spine, shoulder bones and flippers. Like many other types of elasmosaurids from the Western Interior Sea it was found in association with stomach stones, or gastroliths. (BELOW) A photo of a Wapuskanectes skeleton found near the town of Ft. McMurray, Alberta. Photo credit: Sue Sabrowski, Donald Henderson, Royal Tyrrell Museum of Palaeontology. accessed via Wikimedia Commons, distributed under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license Leptocleidids (Leptocleididae) Early Cretaceous Plesiosaurs The leptocleidids were a family of plesiosaurs that lived in parts of the Western Interior Sea during the early Cretaceous. Unlike the giant long-necked elasmosaurids, leptocleidids were generally smaller and more compact in build. They had relatively short necks and robust muscular bodies. One of the most unusual aspects of leptocleidids was their apparent adaptation to shallow coastal environments. Rather than living exclusively in open oceans, they may have moved through estuaries, bays, and nearshore waters. Their strong flippers and streamlined bodies would have allowed them to maneuver efficiently in these habitats while hunting fish and other smaller aquatic prey. Nichollssaura Temporal Range: 110 million years ago Geographic Range: Alberta Species: N. borealis Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Nichollssaura was a member of the family leptocleididae, a more basal family of plesiosaurs than animals like the elasmosaurids. While some plesiosaur groups evolved into large, long-necked marine reptiles, Nichollssaura remained relatively compact at only about 9.5 feet long. Its body proportions also differed from those of the famous elasmosaurids. Nichollssaur a had a shorter neck and a proportionally larger head, giving it a more heavily-built appearance. Another characteristic that sets Nichollssaura apart is its geological age. These animals lived during the early part of the Cretaceous period, when the Western Interior Sea had yet to span across the entire North American continent as it would a few million years later. Nichollsaurua is also known from a rather complete fossil specimen containing around 160 gastroliths, or stomach stones, a very high number even for a Cretaceous plesiosaur, whose fossils are often found with associated gastroliths. Polycotylids (Polycotylidae) Polycotylids in the Western Interior Sea Polycotylid plesiosaurs were highly specialized marine reptiles that inhabited the Western Interior Sea during the Late Cretaceous. Unlike the classic long-necked plesiosaurs, they typically had short necks, large heads, long snouts and streamlined bodies that made them efficient swimmers and active predators. Their four powerful flippers provided them with a great deal of speed and maneuverability which would have allowed them to pursue fast-moving prey such as fish and cephalopods. Long narrow jaws lined with sharp, conical teeth helped them capture slippery animals in open-water environments. Fossils of important genera, including Dolichorhynchops and Polycotylus , have been found in the chalk deposits of Kansas and nearby regions. One of the most significant discoveries was a Polycotylus specimen containing an embryo, providing evidence that these reptiles gave birth to live young. This rare fossil added a lot to scientists’ understanding of plesiosaur reproduction and suggests that polycotylids were fully adapted to a marine lifestyle. Dolichorhynchops Temporal Range: 87 million years ago - 72 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Saskatchewan, possible material from Russia Species: D. osborni, D. herschelensis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Dolichorhynchops is probably the best known genus of polycotylid. The history of Dolichorhynchops research began around 1900, when George F. Sternberg discovered the holotype specimen in the Smoky Hill Chalk of Kansas. The fossil was collected with the assistance of his father, Charles H. Sternberg, and was later described and named by Samuel W. Williston in 1902. These animals were mid-sized members of the polycotylid family and examples of their fossils can be seen on display at the KU Natural History Museum and the Sternberg Museum of Natural History. (BELOW) A skeleton of Dolichorhynchops on display at the KU Natural History Museum. The skull on the mount is a model but the original skull is displayed next to the skeletal mount. See below for a more detailed image. (BELOW) The skull of Dolichorhynchops which is connected to the skeleton in the picture above, photo taken at the KU Natural History Museum. The skull has been somewhat compressed while it was fossilized within a layer of chalk. Edgarosaurus Temporal Range: 100 million years ago Geographic Range: Montana Species: E. muddi Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Edgarosaurus was one of the earliest known members of the polycotylid family. While it shared the characteristic short neck and large skull of polycotylids, its head and neck together accounted for an unusually large percentage of its overall body length. The fused front section of the lower jaw contained only six pairs of teeth, fewer than in many related polycotylids and its teeth were large, sturdy and fang-like. This suggests it would have had a feeding strategy different from that of some of its relatives, although the exact implications of these differences in dentition are not certain. Additional distinguishing features included a small pineal opening near the rear of the skull, a nearly vertical back of the cranium, and unusually short, broad bones in its forelimbs. Our understanding of Edgarosaurus comes from a single well-preserved specimen discovered in 1993 in the Thermopolis Shale of Montana. The fossil included a complete skull, a series of neck vertebrae, parts of the backbone, and most of one front paddle. After careful study, paleontologist Patrick Druckenmiller determined that the specimen represented a previously unknown genus and formally named Edgarosaurus muddi in 2002. The genus was named after the nearby town of Edgar, Montana. Because no additional specimens have been described, the holotype remains the primary source of information about this important early polycotylid. Martinectes Temporal Range: 80.5 million years ago - 78 million years ago Geographic Range: Wyoming Species: M. bonneri Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Martinectes was a large and distinctive polycotylid plesiosaur that differed from many of its relatives through its robust build and considerable size. Although it shared the short neck and elongated skull common among advanced polycotylids, it was larger than many related genera and possessed strong, interlocking conical teeth adapted for catching fish and other slippery prey. It was initially thought to have been a species of either Dolichorhynchops or Trinacromerum . The fossils of Martinectes have undergone a complex history of classification. Specimens from the Pierre Shale of Wyoming were first described as “Trinacromerum bonneri ”. Later research reassigned the species to Dolichorhynchops in 2008 after comparisons with other polycotylids. Continued study of the skull and skeleton revealed additional unique features eventually leading to the establishment of the new genus Martinectes in 2023. Pahasapasaurus Temporal Range: 90 million years ago Geographic Range: South Dakota Species: P. haasi, P. gillettei Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Pahasapasaurus was a polycotylid whose fossils were discovered in South Dakota, as well as a second species recognized from Utah. The scientific history of Pahasapasaurus traces back to 1934, when Charles Haas and his son Arthur uncovered a plesiosaur skeleton in the Black Hills of South Dakota while searching for shark teeth. The specimen was excavated and eventually donated to the local museum in the town of Deadwood. For many years, researchers identified the fossil as part of a different genus, Trinacromerum . However, renewed study during a restoration project in the 1990s revealed important anatomical differences. Paleontologists subsequently determined that the specimen represented a previously unknown genus and formally described Pahasapasaurus haasi in 2007. The name honors both the Black Hills region and the discoverer of the fossil, Charles Haas. Plesiopleurodon Temporal Range: 98 million years ago Geographic Range: Wyoming Species: P. wellesi Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid, ocean reptiles Plesiopleurodon was a type of polycotylid which was originally thought to have been a part of the pliosaur group owing to its strange proportions which differed significantly from those of other polycotylids. The skulls of these animals were huge and their necks were very short. It also had fewer teeth in the front portion of the lower jaw than many related plesiosaurs. In addition, the skull preserved several ancestral features, including a robustly attached quadrate bone and a backward-sloping profile. These characteristics initially led paleontologists to note similarities with the Jurassic pliosaur Liopleurodo n although this has since been determined to be a case of convergent evolution. The scientific history of Plesiopleurodon is based on a very limited number of fossil remains. The genus was established by paleontologist Kenneth Carpenter in 1996 from a specimen discovered in Cretaceous-aged rocks of Wyoming. The material known from this animal includes a nearly complete skull and lower jaws, associated vertebrae, and a part of the shoulder elements. Polycotylus Temporal Range: 83.6 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Alabama, Russia Species: P. latipinnis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Polycotylus is among the most thoroughly studied of all polycotylids. While it shared many characteristics with other polycotylids, including a streamlined body, large skull, and strong flippers, Polycotylus had a greater number of neck vertebrae than many of its kin which is a trait associated with earlier long-necked plesiosaurs. It is also distinguished by its elongated hip bones, robust teeth marked by a unique banded texture, a narrow upper palate, and a low sagittal crest along the top of the skull behind the eyes. These characteristics allow paleontologists to differentiate Polycotylus from other members of its family. Scientific investigation of Polycotylus began in 1869 when Edward Drinker Cope described the genus from fragmentary remains discovered in the Niobrara Chalk of Kansas. Additional and more complete specimens found later helped researchers develop a clearer understanding of its anatomy and evolutionary relationships. One key discovery was that of a Polycotylus specimen preserving a fetus within the body cavity of an adult. The developing animal was quite large compared with the size of the parent, which would suggest a long gestation period similar to those of today’s whales. (BELOW) A photo of a Polycotylus skeleton preserved with the remains of a fetal skeleton in its abdominal cavity, marked with a white triangle. Fossil on display at the LA County Museum. Photo credit: Jonathan Chen. accessed via Wikimedia Commons, distributed under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license Serpentisuchops Temporal Range: 70 million years ago Geographic Range: Wyoming Species: C. crassidens, C. gracilodens Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid, Serpentisuchops was a polycotylid which appeared to combine aspects of long-necked plesiosaurs and other shorter-necked polycotylids. It had a very elongated neck and a long, narrow snout. Most advanced polycotylids evolved a body plan characterized by large heads, streamlined jaws, and shortened necks. In contrast Serpentisuchops retained a neck with roughly 32 cervical vertebrae while also possessing the elongated jaws typical of its relatives. Paleontologists have proposed that Serpentisuchops may have used rapid side-to-side strikes of its head and neck to capture fish and other agile marine animals. The fossil record of Serpentisuchops is centered on a single important specimen discovered in 1995 within the Pierre Shale of Wyoming. The fossil, designated GPM 5001, includes portions of the skull, lower jaws, vertebral column, and pelvic bones. Although the remains were collected decades earlier, they were not formally studied and named until 2022. Trinacromerum Temporal Range: 93 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Manitoba, Alabama Species: T. bentonianum, T. kirki Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Trinacromerum was a smaller member of the polycotylid family. It would have had an elongated, narrow snout equipped with numerous fine, needle-like teeth, which were ideal for seizing small fish. Although it shared the short-necked body plan typical of polycotylids, Trinacromerum appears to have been particularly well adapted for speed, thanks to its long, powerful flippers and streamlined build. These features could have possibly allowed it to pursue agile prey in open water rather than relying on ambush tactics. Its anatomy suggests that it occupied a niche as an active predator within the Western Interior Seaway, where quick movement and maneuverability would have been important advantages. Unktaheela Temporal Range: 80 million years ago Geographic Range: Wyoming, South Dakota Species: U. specta Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Unktaheela was a small polycotylid with an estimated length of only 8.5 feet, which means that it is considered the smallest known member of its family. Its skull had rather large eye sockets, prominent ridges surrounding the eyes, and broad bony shelves above the orbits that may have reduced glare from sunlight. These characteristics suggest that Unktaheela relied heavily on vision while hunting and may have specialized in pursuing prey in brightly lit surface waters. The scientific study of Unktaheela is relatively recent. Fossils from Wyoming and South Dakota were initially assigned to the genus Dolichorhynchops , and one specimen was described in 1996 as a juvenile individual of that same taxon. Later research demonstrated that these remains represented a distinct genus. In 2023 the genus Untkaheela was named based on two skulls and some additional associated material from other parts of the skeleton. Media Gallery Suggested References: Plesiosauria Angst, Delphine; Bardet, Nathalie (2016). "A new record of the pliosaur Brachauchenius lucasi Williston, 1903 (Reptilia: Sauropterygia) of Turonian (Late Cretaceous) age, Morocco". Geological Magazine. 153 Carpenter, K. (1996). “A review of the short-necked plesiosaurs from the Cretaceous of the Western Interior, North America”. Nues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie, Abhandlungen, (Stuttgart), 201(2):259-287. Carpenter, K. (1999). "Revision of North American elasmosaurs from the Cretaceous of the western interior". Paludicola. 2 (2): 148–173. Everhart, M. J. (2002). “New data on plesiosaur remains found as stomach contents of a Tylosaurus proriger (Squamata; Mosasauridae) from the Niobrara Formation of western Kansas”. (Abstract) Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science Everhart, M.J. (2004). “New data regarding the skull of Dolichorhynchops osborni (Plesiosauroidea: Polycotylidae) from rediscovered photos of the Harvard Museum of Comparative Zoology specimen”. Paludicola 4(3):74-80. Everhart, M.J. (2000). “Gastroliths associated with plesiosaur remains in the Sharon Springs Member of the Pierre Shale (late Cretaceous), Western Kansas”. Kansas Acad. Sci. Trans. 103(1-2):58-69. Everhart, M. J. (2005). “Bite marks on an elasmosaur (Sauropterygia; Plesiosauria) paddle from the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Cretaceous) as probable evidence of feeding by the lamniform shark, Cretoxyrhina mantelli”. PalArch, Vertebrate paleontology 2(2): 14-24. Fischer, V; Benson, R. B. J.; Druckenmiller, P. S.; Ketchum H. F.; Bardet N.(2018). "The evolutionary history of polycotylid plesiosaurians". Royal Society Open Science. 5 (3) 172177. Ketchum, H. F. & Benson, R. B. J. (2010). "Global interrelationships of Plesiosauria (Reptilia, Sauropterygia) and the pivotal role of taxon sampling in determining the outcome of phylogenetic analyses". Biological Reviews. 85 (2): 361–392 Lucas, Spencer G.; Sullivan, Robert M. (2006). “Late Cretaceous Vertebrates from the Western Interior”: Bulletin 35. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. Madzia, D; Sachs, S; Lindgren, J. (2018). "Morphological and phylogenetic aspects of the dentition of Megacephalosaurus eulerti, a pliosaurid from the Turonian of Kansas, USA, with remarks on the cranial anatomy of the taxon". Geological Magazine. 156 McIntosh, A. P.; Shimada, K.; Everhart, M. J. (2016). "Late Cretaceous marine vertebrate fauna from the Fairport Chalk Member of the Carlile Shale in southern Ellis County, Kansas, U.S.A." Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science. O'Keefe, F. R.; Sander, P. M.; Wintrich, T.; Werning, S. (2019). "Ontogeny of Polycotylid Long Bone Microanatomy and Histology". Integrative Organismal Biology. 1 O'Keefe, F. R.; Chiappe, L. M. (2011). "Viviparity and K-selected life history in a Mesozoic marine plesiosaur (Reptilia, Sauropterygia)". Science. 333 (6044): 870–873. Russell, D. A. (1988). “A check list of North American marine Cretaceous vertebrates including fresh water fishes”. Royal Tyrrell Museum Sato, Tamaki (2003). "Terminonatator ponteixensis, a new elasmosaur (Reptilia: Sauropterygia) from the Upper Cretaceous of Saskatchewan". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 23 (1): 89–103. Schumacher, B. A., (2007), “A new polycotylid plesiosaur (Reptilia; Sauropterygia) from the Greenhorn Limestone (Upper Cretaceous; lower upper Cenomanian), Black Hills, South Dakota”: In: The Geology and Paleontology of the Late Cretaceous marine deposits of the Dakotas, The Geological Society of America, Special Paper 427, p. 133-146. Schumacher, B.A., Carpenter, K. and Everhart, M.J. (2013). “A new Cretaceous Pliosaurid (Reptilia, Plesiosauria) from the Carlile Shale (middle Turonian) of Russell County, Kansas”, Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 33(3):613-628 Schumacher, B.A. (2008). “On the skull of a pliosaur (Plesiosauria; Pliosauridae) from the Upper Cretaceous (Early Turonian) of the North American Western Interior” Kansas Academy of Science, Transactions 111(3-4):203-218. Serratos, D.J.; Druckenmiller, P.; Benson, R.B.J. (2017). "A new elasmosaurid (Sauropterygia, Plesiosauria) from the Bearpaw Shale (Late Cretaceous, Maastrichtian) of Montana demonstrates multiple evolutionary reductions of neck length within Elasmosauridae". Smith, E.A.; O'Keefe, F.R. (2023). "Occurrence of Styxosaurus (Sauropterygia: Plesiosauria) in the Cenomanian: Implications for relationships of elasmosaurids of the Western Interior Seaway". Journal of Systematic Palaeontology. 21 Storrs, G.W. (1999). “An examination of Plesiosauria (Diapsida: Sauropterygia) from the Niobrara Chalk (upper Cretaceous) of central North America”. The University of Kansas Paleontological Contributions, (N. S.), No. 11, 15 pp. Taylor, M. A. (1993), “Stomach stones for feeding or buoyancy? The occurrence and function of gastroliths in marine tetrapods”. Phil. Trans. Royal Society London. B 341:163-175. Zhao, R. J. (2026). "Body reconstruction and size estimation of plesiosaurs". PeerJ. 14

  • Placoderms | Prehistoric Midwest

    Placoderms Armored Devonian Fish Placoderms were a group of jawed fishes who were among the most abundant and diverse vertebrate lineages of the early Paleozoic era. The first placoderms appeared during the Silurian period and they would remain a common presence in the world's oceans up until the end of the Devonian period 358.9 million years ago. Placoderms are best known for the fossils of the hard bony armor which covered their heads and the areas in front of their dorsal fins. These plates may have functioned as a way to store useful minerals within the tissues of their bodies, as well as offering an extra layer of protection from predation. By the end of the Devonian period, the most common placoderms were those which are classified as part of the clade Arthrodira, also known as arthrodires. Many of these animals had powerful jaws and specialized bony plates which served the same function as large sets of slicing teeth. Classification Types of Placoderms Over the course of their 80 million year evolutionary history, placoderms came in many different shapes and sizes. Many earlier groups were benthic animals who fed close to the seafloor. Some of these benthic animals like the Early Devonian genus Gemuendina , tended to have large pectoral fins which gave them a silhouette which was superficially similar to a stingray or skate. Some of these benthic detritivores managed to survive all the way up until the end of the Devonian. Bothriolepis , a genus from North America, Europe, Asia and Australia, had a long oval-shaped body and a distinctive set of long, thin pectoral fins. Fossils found in the Cleveland Shale include the remains of some of the best known types of Devonian placoderms. This includes Dunkleosteus , which is well known for its powerful jaws which were surrounded by sharpened tooth-like bony plates. Many other types of placoderms filled the ecological niches of top marine predators during the Devonian, with some of their fossils having been found in association with the remains of smaller placoderms and sharks who seem to show signs of having been bitten by the larger placoderm. Some Cleveland Shale arthrodires, like the genus Titanichthys , are thought to have been filter-feeders based on the relatively small size of their jaw plates. (BELOW) Placoderms were a very diverse group and took on many different shapes depending on the roles they filled within the ecosystems of the Devonian and Silurian periods. These included large active carnivores, detritivores and filter-feeders Paraphyly For most of the history of the study of their fossils, placoderms were considered to form a natural grouping, which is to say that they were believed to have all descended from a common ancestor which was not shared by any other separate group. More recent scholarship seems to suggest that this is not in fact the case and that the group we call placoderms includes the common ancestor of cartilaginous fishes (sharks, stingrays, etc.) and all bony fish, including tetrapods. Although the term "placoderm" is still widely used in order to describe these ancient armored fishes, it is often more useful to refer to them based on where they fall within the jawed fish family tree. For instance, most of the placoderms found in deposits from the Cleveland shale are considered to be arthrodires. Since the term "Placoderm" is still used informally to refer to the armored fishes found in the Silurian and Devonian we will continue to use that term in this section. It should be noted, however, that our current understanding suggests that all cartilaginous and bony fishes are descended from the group previously known as placoderms and are still, in a cladistic sense, technically part of the placoderm group. (BELOW) A cladogram showing the organization of the jawed fish family tree. Groups which have historically been considered placoderms are shaded in orange, other jawed vertebrate groups are shown in yellow. Arthrodires are marked in red. Anatomy Skeletal Anatomy Placoderms are mostly known from the remains of the plates of bony armor which covered their skulls but we do also have some information about the structure of their post-cranial skeletons which are occasionally preserved alongside the cranial plates. The skeletons of the rear parts of the bodies of placoderms were composed of cartilage, similar to the materials which comprise the majority of the skeletons of living sharks and stingrays. A series of spinal cartilages supported most of the bodies of these fish while a separate set of cartilages formed the main structure of the dorsal fin. Two additional sets of cartilage were found near the point where the pelvic fins were connected to the trunk of the fish. The spinal cartilages of the tail angled upwards, supporting the fleshy dorsal caudal lobe which formed the upper part of the tail fluke. Placoderms generally did not have true teeth. Instead, the plates of bone around their jaws were used to slice apart and/or crush prey. The lower jaw held the infragnathal plates while the upper jaws held two pairs of supragnathal plates. In some genera these plates formed a single curved cutting surface while in others the cutting surfaces of the jaw plates were covered in serrations and/or cusps. The gills of these placoderms were found in the wide gap between the suborbital plate, near the cheek of the placoderm, and the anterior lateral plates. In arthrodires there is a space in the armor between the head shield and the median dorsal plates. This space is known as the nuchal gap and would have provided extra flexibility to the mouths and heads of these ancient fishes. (BELOW) The skeletal anatomy of the arthrodire Dunkleosteus from the Cleveland Shale of Ohio. This animal is mostly known from the plates of armor found around the skull. The post-cranial skeleton is based on known remains from other arthrodires. (BELOW) Cranial plate anatomies of a few notable arthrodire genera from the Cleveland Shale, including those of Selenosteus, Gymnotrachelus, Bungartius and Dunkleosteus . The differences in the sizes and shapes of their jaw plates are most likely a result of their specialization for the purposes of hunting different types of soft or hard-bodied prey. External Anatomy The external anatomical strucutres of placoderms were very mysterious up until only a few years ago. For many years it was conventional to restore these animals with long eel-like bodies. The armored plates of the skull were restored as structures which were entirely exposed without any sort of external skin covering. Thanks to the study of fossils of animals like Coccosteus and Amazichthys, in the last few decades paleontologists have been able to more accurately restore the bodies of these ancient fish. Soft tissue fossils of the tails of these animals suggest that many placoderms, including arthrodires, would have had a shark like profile with a dorsal fin, a forked tail fluke and smooth unarmored skin covering most of their bodies. The plates of the skull and jaws were likely covered in a layer of skin and protective soft tissue which would have appeared superficially similar to the skin of today's cartilaginous fishes. Some large placoderms which were previously restored as slender 20+ foot long eel-like animals are now thought to have had more stocky builds with short, deep bodies measuring around 11-13 feet in length (BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of the arthrodire Dunkleosteu s. Based on soft tissue fossils from related genera, these animals are now thought to have had short, robust bodies which outwardly resembled the forms of living sharks. Placoderms Bungartius Coccosteus Diplognathus Dunkleosteus Gorgonichthys Gymnotrachelus Heintzichthys Holdenius Mylostoma Paramylostoma Selenosteus Stenosteus Titancichthys Rare placoderms Bungartius Temporal Range: 362.6 – 360.1 million years ago Geographic Range: Cuyahoga County, Ohio Species: B. perissus Diet: Carnivore, possibly durophagous, placoderms Bungartiu s is a genus of placoderms which is considered to be a close relative of the filter-feeding arthrodire Titanichthys and the smaller selenosteids. It is classified as part of the superorder Dinichthyloidea. Bungartiu s had a long, narrow set of jaws with robust jaw plates which seem to have been adapted for dealing a shearing bite. The cutting surfaces of the lower jaws are smooth, without any cusps and the front part of the mandible features a prominent forward-facing chin projection. Based on the shapes of the fossils known from the area behind the skull of the animal, it seems that Bungartius was a more slender animal than some of its more distantly related contemporaries such as Dunkleosteus . The openings for its eyes were fairly small and were positioned along the sides of the skull. The dorsal armor of these animals also appears to cover a smaller area of the back in this genus, although the ventral plates are well built in a similar manner to other late Devonian placoderms. The slender build seen in Bungartius may be an indication that these animals were built to move quickly through the water while hunting or escaping from larger marine carnivores. (BELOW) The arrangement of the cranial plates on the head and neck of Bungartius . Compared with other Late Devonian arthrodires, Bungartius had a very long skull and jaw plates with no cusps or serrations. Based on Dunkle, 1947 Coccosteus Temporal Range: 393.3 – 359.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Ohio, New York, Scotland, Northern Ireland Species: C. canadensis, C. carbonarius, C. chamberlini, C. cuspidatus, C. cuyahogae, C . decipiens, C. disjectus, C. grossi, C. hercynius, C. macromus, C. markae, C. minor Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes Coccosteus is a fairly small placoderm classified as part of the family Coccosteidae. This genus is fairly unique among Devonian placoderms since these animals are known from some fairly complete postcranial material, in addition to the fossils of bony skull armor plates which constitute the majority of the material known from other placoderm genera. Coccosteus was a slender animal with a single long dorsal fin running along its back, positioned behind the animal’s dorsal armor. Their caudal flukes had a highly elongate dorsal lobe and a very small ventral lobe, similar to the tail shape seen in some types of sand tiger sharks. Fossils of animals belonging to this genus have been found in parts of Europe, particularly in Scotland. Their record in the Cleveland shale is somewhat contested and the remains assigned to this genus from the late Devonian of Ohio consist of only a few pieces of a jaw plate. (BELOW) A photo of a skeleton of Coccosteus cuspidatus (IVPP V19322) on display at the Paleozoological Museum of China. Photo by Wikimedia Commons user Morosaurus millenii, CC BY-SA 4.0 Diplognathus Temporal Range: 361 million years ago Geographic Range: Ohio, Michigan Species: D. mirabillis, D. larfargei Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes Diplognathus is a fairly large genus of placoderms and a possible member of the family Hadrosteidae. These animals had fairly slender tooth plates and the inferognathals of the lower jaws had a pair of particularly large jaw spines along the front of the mandible. Other sections of their upper and lower jaw plates were covered in large, recurved serrations. Their orbits were quite large and the skull of Diplognathus was relatively narrow. Their jaw elements seem to be weaker than those of some of the largest types of Cleveland shale placoderms but they are thought to have had a particularly wide gape. When their jaws were closed the lower jaw would have extended beyond the apex of the upper jaw. They seem to have been soft prey specialists who would have hunted for sharks and ray-finned fishes living in their marine habitat. (BELOW) The arrangement of the jaw plates of Diplognathus . Some species of these animals had long tooth-like spines at the front apexes of their mandibles. The rear parts of the mouth were covered in backwards-facing curved serrations Dunkleosteus Temporal Range: 382 – 358 million years ago Geographic Range: Ohio, New York, Missouri, Canada, Belgium, Russia, Morocco Species: D. amblyodoratus, D. denisoni, D. magnificus, D. marsaisi, D. missouriensis, D. newberryi , D. raveri, D. terrelli, D. tuderensis Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes Dunkleosteus is a very large genus of placoderms and the namesake of the wider family Dunkleosteidae. Like other arthrodires, Dunkleosteus would have lacked true teeth. Instead, the exposed bones along its upper and lower jaws would have formed sharp cutting edges. These self-sharpening blades closed together like a pair of bolt cutters and allowed these fish to break through the hardened exterior shells and bones of their prey. Dunkleosteus is primarily known from fossils of the armor which would have covered its head, parts of its back and the area around its pectoral fins. The exact shape of the rear portions of the body of this animal are not known from complete post-cranial fossils and as a result the un-armored portions of the body of Dunkleosteus have to be restored based on fossils of related animals. For most of the history of the study of this animal, Dunkleosteus was restored with a long, narrow body similar to the post-cranial anatomy seen in fossils of the placoderm genus Coccosteu s. Some body length estimates for Dunkleosteus based on the shapes of more gracile placoderms restored this large placoderm as an animal that could grow to be over 20 feet long, larger than a living great white shark. More analyses such as those by Engelman (2024) suggest that Dunkleosteids had fairly short and robust bodies, with Dunkelsoteus itself having an estimated body length of around 11-13 feet. (BELOW) The arrangement of the cranial plates on the head and neck of Dunkleosteus CMNH 7424 . The jaw plates of these huge placoderms were some of the largest and most robust of all the Cleveland Shale arthrodires. (BELOW) Photo of the fossil skull plates of a large Dunkleosteus terrelli on display at the Cleveland Museum of Natural History, photo by Tim Evanson, CC BY-SA 2.0. Anterior lateral and posterior dorsolaterial plates are placeholders (BELOW) Photo of the fossil skull plates of a small Dunkleosteus, most likely a juvenile animal, on display at the Cleveland Museum of Natural History, photo by Tim Evanson, CC BY-SA 2.0 Gorgonichthys Temporal Range: 371.1 – 359.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Ohio Species: G. clarki Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes Gorgonichthys was a large genus of placoderms represented by a single species, Gorgonichthys clarki . These animals had particularly large head shields which grew to be around 2 feet (70 cm) long. These plates are roughly similar in size to the same types of plates found on other large Cleveland Shale placoderms such as Dunkleosteus . Although the jaw elements of Gorgonichthys were roughly similar in shape to those of Dunkleosteus , Gorgonichthys is not considered a member of the Dunkleosteid family and is instead placed within the clade Aspinothoracidi. Recent research positions this genus as a relative of the selenosteid placoderms such as Heintzichthys . Based on post-cranial skeletal material known from selenosteids such as the Moroccan genus Amazichthys, we might expect Gorgonichthys to have had a more slender build than the more robust dunkleosteid placoderms. (BELOW) A photo of the infragnathals (lower jaw plates) of a Gorgonichthys showing the large tooth-like projections at the apex of the mandible, photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons. Original photo by user Paleeoguy, CC BY-SA 4.0 Gymnotrachelus Temporal Range: 371.1 – 359.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Ohio Species: G. hydei Diet: Active carnivore: small fish Gymnotrachelus is a genus of selenosteid placoderms which seem to be close relatives of animals like Heintzichthys and Stenosteus . These animals had a relatively wide, shallow wedge-like head and a broad mouth. Their eyes were relatively small for a selenosteid. The plates of its jaws were lightly built and vere covered in very fine and sharp tooth-like serrations which are particularly prominent on the animal’s lower jaw. The nuchal gap between the armor of the head and the back was fairly wide in this genus. (BELOW) The structure of the cranial armor of Gymnotrachelu s including the position of the sclerotic ring in the orbit. These animals had wide, wedge shape skulls which were separated from their dorsal armor by a fairly wide nuchal gap. Heintzichthys Temporal Range: 371.1 – 359.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Ohio, possible European record Species: H. gouldii Diet: Active carnivore: small fish Heintzichthys is a genus of selenosteid placoderms. This genus is known from fossils which preserve portions of the cheek and jaw plates, the parasphenoid of the palate, components of the shoulder girdle, paired fins, sections of the axial skeleton, and parts of the neurocranium. In some fossils of Heintzichthys the fossil skeletal elements remained partially connected which gives us a good sense of how these anatomical elements would have articulated in life. Heintzichthys was once classified within the family Dinichthyidae but it was later reassigned to the selenosteid family within the clade Aspinothoracidi, along with animals like Paramylostoma and Stenosteus . Holdenius Temporal Range: 371.1 – 359.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Northern Ohio Species: H. holdeni Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes Holdenius was a large placoderm in the clade Aspinothoracidi which is represented by a single species, Holdenius holden i. These animals are particularly well known for the fossils of their enormous bony gnathal plates which served the same purpose as conventional slicing teeth. The sharp cutting margins along the edges of these plates would have allowed their jaws to grasp prey animals and slice them into manageable portions. This feeding structure resembled that of Dunkleosteus , another armored placoderm from the same environment. As an arthrodire, Holdenius likely had articulated bony plates protecting its head and the front of its trunk. However, the fragmentary nature of its fossils makes a complete anatomical reconstruction impossible. One Holdeniu s fossil was found in association with the remains of a dorsal spine from a ctenacanth shark which was preserved piercing the palate and entering the placoderm’s braincase. This shows that the area behind the animal’s powerful jaws was fairly soft and would have remained vulnerable to injury. Although formerly placed within Dunkleosteidae, Holdenius is now thought to be more closely related to animals like Gorgonichthys and Heintzicthys , although its exact placement among the members of the clade Aspinothoracidi has not yet been conclusively determined Mylostoma Temporal Range: 361 million years ago Geographic Range: Ohio Species: M. variabile, M. terrelli Diet: Possibly durophagous, hard-shelled prey Mylostoma was a genus of possibly durophagous placoderms specialized for crushing the shells of other animals. The jaws of these animals were adapted to breaking down hard food instead of cutting flesh with sharpened jaw edges. These animals had broad dental plates that created powerful crushing surfaces, instead of individual teeth. Over the course of their lives the jaw plates of Mylostoma became increasingly fused. In fossils which seem to come from younger individuals, the front of the upper jaw contains two anterior palatopterygoid plates. As these animals grew, these paired structures joined at the center to form a single central jaw plate. The rear of the upper jaw was formed by a set of sturdy posterior palatopterygoid plates. When biting down on their prey, these fused components produced a more efficient apparatus for crushing smaller placoderms and/or hard-shelled invertebrates. Paramylostoma Temporal Range: 371.1 – 359.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Northern Ohio Species: P. arcualis Diet: Carnivore, possibly durophagous, hard-shelled prey Paramylostoma was a genus of shell-crushing selenosteid placoderms. Unlike other types of selenosteid, Paramylostoma did not have large cusps or serrations on its jaw plates. Their skulls also seem to have been slightly wider than those of their closest selenosteid relatives and their orbits were smaller than those seen in the skulls of animals like Selenosteus and Stenosteus . These characteristics have led Paramylostom a to be considered a shell-crushing animal. Fossils of hard-shelled invertebrates are fairly rare in the Cleveland shale but these jaws may have been useful for cracking open the shells of marine cephalopods and may have even been used to bite through the bony armor of smaller placoderms. Selenosteus Temporal Range: ~ 373 – 359.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Ohio, New York? Species: S. brevis Diet: Active carnivore: small fish Selenosteus was a medium-sized genus of placoderms and the namesake of the wider family Selenosteidae. Like most other Selenosteids, Selenosteus had very large orbits which likely would have held well-developed eyes. The lower jaws and the associated tooth-like plates of these animals were relatively thin and the portion of the skull in front of the eyes was short and sharply angled in the area around the nares. (BELOW) Structure of the cranial plates of Selenosteus based on a diagram from a redescription by Carr (1996). Note the very large orbits which are a feature that is often seen in the skulls of placoderms from the family selenosteidae. Stenosteus Temporal Range: 371.1 – 359.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Northern Ohio Species: S. glaber, S.pertenius, S. angustopectus Diet: Active carnivore: small fish Stenosteu s was a genus of relatively small selenosteid placoderms. Like many of its close relatives, Stenosteus would have had very large eyes and very thin and slender inferognathals (lower jaw plates) and the cutting surfaces of their jaws were covered in low cusps and fine serrations. The area in front of the eye sockets seen in the well-preserved skulls known from this genus would have been very short and angular. Titanichthys Temporal Range: 361 million years ago Geographic Range: Northern Ohio, Morocco, possibly Poland Species: T. agassizi , T. attenuatus, T. hussakofi, T. termieri Diet: Filter feeder: small aquatic organisms Titanichthys was a very large Late Devonian placoderm with very lightweight armor and very unique jaw plates. In contrast to Dunkleosteus , which used its sharpened jaw plates for slicing prey, Titanichthys had smaller, blunter plates along the edges of its mouth which lacked effective cutting surfaces. This, along with the proportionally large size of the mouths of these animals, suggests that Titanichthys was a filter feeder which scooped up small organisms suspended in the water. Despite its large size, the cranial and neck armor of TItanichthys covered fewer parts of its body than in other types of Late Devonian placoderms. The rostral plate which covered the animal’s snout was elliptical across its entire width and was completely separated from neighboring plates. Many of the upper jaw plates seen in fossils of these animals are also unusually reduced. One particularly complete articulated fossil from Ohio’s Cleveland Shale preserves parts of the snout, cheeks, jaws, nasal capsule, and body armor positioned in the same places they occupied when the animal was still alive, which gives us a better sense of the arrangement of these cranial bony plates. Placoderms known from fragmentary fossils Some placoderm genera found in the Cleveland shale are only known from a small number of very fragmentary fossils, or have otherwise convoluted taxonomic histories. These additional genera are listed below, along with our current understanding of their positions within the placoderm family tree. All of these animals seem to be arthrodires and have been distinguished from other Cleveland Shale genera by key differences in the shape and orientations of known fossils of their skull plates. (BELOW) A speculative life restoration of the genus Hussakofia, restored here as a dunkleosteid arthrodire with a stout body and powerful slicing jaws. This genus is only known from a few plate fragments from near the base of the skull Other Placoderms Callognathus : Classified as a selenosteid, known from a few gnathal plate fragments Glyptaspis : A placoderm known from fossils of four of its ventral plates, possibly a relative of animals like Tropidosteus and Holonema in the family Holonematidae Hlavinichthys : An aspinothoracid known from fossils of its skull roof, its cheek plates, the sclerotic rings around the eyes, and a few fragmentary jaw element fossils. Hussakofia : A small possible relative of Dunkleosteus Trachosteus: A selenosteid known from a few fragments of skull armor Suggested References: Placoderms Engelman, Russell K. (2023-02-21). "A Devonian Fish Tale: A New Method of Body Length Estimation Suggests Much Smaller Sizes for Dunkleosteus terrelli (Placodermi: Arthrodira)". Diversity. 15 (3): 318. Engelman, Russell K.; Carr, Robert K.; Trinajstic, K.; Johanson, Z.; Lebedev, Oleg A. (2025). "Functional anatomy, jaw mechanisms, and feeding behavior of Dunkleosteus terrelli (Placodermi, Arthrodira)". The Anatomical Record ar.70075. Carr, R, & G.L. Jackson. 2008. The Vertebrates fauna of the Cleveland member (Famennian) of the Ohio Shale. Society of Vertebrates Paleontology. 1–17. Anderson, P.S.L.; Westneat, M. (2009). "A biomechanical model of feeding kinematics for Dunkleosteus terrelli (Arthrodira, Placodermi)" (PDF). Paleobiology. 35 (2): 251–269 Carr, Robert (1994). "A redescription of Gymnotrachelus hydei (Placodermi : Arthrodira) from the Cleveland Shale (Famennian) of northern Ohio, U. S. A.". Kirtlandia (48): 3–21. Jobbins, Melina; Rücklin, Martin; Ferrón, Humberto G.; Klug, Christian (2022). "A new selenosteid placoderm from the Late Devonian of the eastern Anti-Atlas (Morocco) with preserved body outline and its ecomorphology". Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. 10. Carr, Robert (February 1996). "Stenosteus augustopectus sp. nov. from the Cleveland Shale (Famennian) of Northern Ohio with a Review of Selenosteid (Placodermi) Systematics". Kirtlandia. 49: 9–43. Hansen, Michael C. (2005). "Phylum Chordata—Vertebrate Fossils". In Feldmann, Rodney M.; Hackathorn, Merrianne (eds.). Fossils of Ohio. ODNR Bulletin 70. Columbus, Ohio: Ohio Department of Natural Resources.

  • Coelacanths | Prehistoric Midwest

    Explore the different types of prehistoric coelacanths who lived in the Western Interior Sea during the Cretaceous period. Coelacanths Lobe-Finned Fishes of the Western Interior Sea Compared with earlier geological periods, coelacanth diversity had declined quite a lot by the Late Cretaceous. However, despite this they continued to occupy a role within marine ecosystems alongside other vertebrates inhabiting the Western Interior Sea. Fossil evidence indicates that one of the largest known coelacanths of all time, Megalocoelacanthus, was found in the Interior Sea at this time. These animals would have been fearsome, albeit fairly slow moving, predatory animals who preyed upon smaller fishes and even mid-sized marine reptiles. Anatomy Skeletal Anatomy Coelacanths have a series of strong bones at the bases of their fins which support the muscles of their fin lobes. Some of these bony structures contain the bones which are homologous with the bones in the arms and legs of tetrapods. Most coelacanths also keep a large spinal notochord throughout adulthood. Unlike the fully developed vertebral columns of most modern bony fishes, the coelacanth's notochord remains as a fluid-filled, supportive rod running along the body in place of a bony spine. At the front of their skulls they have a special rostral organ which allows these fishes to pick up electrical signals left by their prey. The outer parts of the bodies of coelacanths are covered in a coat of mineralized scales. Much of their skeleton consists of cartilage rather than dense bone, reducing weight while maintaining structural support. Their tails are tri-lobed and have a small central extension along the middle of the caudal fin set known as the epicaudal lobe. (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeleton of a coelacanth. Note the presence of a very large notochord running along the length of the animal in the place of a spine. This notochord is an unusual feature among members of the bony fish group Evolutionary History Lobe-finned fishes are a group of vertebrate animals with bony ossified skeletons and whose earliest members had/have fleshy, bone-supported paired fins. These fins each have a muscular lobe at their bases instead of having fins composed only of sets of long thin rays as in ray finned actinopterigian fishes. The main three groups of lobe-finned fishes are the coelacanths, the lungfishes, and the tetrapods, including most terrestrial vertebrates. Coelacanths are the best known type of lobe-finned fishes. Although they are only found in deep waters today, their predecessors lived in shallow water and riparian environments for millions of years. This lineage first showed up during the early Devonian but they suffered a massive drop in species diversity at the end of the Cretaceous period. Lungfishes are another type of lobe-finned fish. These animals are able to breathe air for short periods of time. Despite this air breathing ability these lungfishes are not ancestral to the other group of air-breathing lobe-finned fishes, the tetrapods. Tetrapods, including all reptiles, amphibians, birds and mammals, are all descended from aquatic lobe-finned fish ancestors. As such this group is by far the most abundant lineage of lobe-finned fish. (BELOW) The main living groups of lobe-finned fishes include coelacanths, lungfishes and tetrapods. This technically means that all terrestrial vertebrates are part of the lobe-finned fish clade. Megalocoelacanthus Temporal Range: 87 million years ago - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: M. dobei Diet: Carnivorous, fish, cephalopods, marine reptiles Megalocoelacanthus was a very large genus of coelacanths that lived in the Late Cretaceous seas of North America. It has been estimated to have grown to be up to 15 feet long, which would make it one of the largest coelacanths known from the fossil record. Fossils recovered from the Niobrara Formation of Kansas show that these animals had a narrow parietonasal shield bordered by unusually large openings on the sides of its head that housed parts of the supraorbital sensory canal system. A similar skull arrangement is seen only in a few closely related genera, including the genus Libys from the Jurassic period. Megalocoelacanthus also seems to have been largely edentulous, meaning that it probably had very few teeth. Some mawsoniid coelacanths also have this toothless feature but these two animals seem to be fairly distantly related to one another and Megalocoelacanthus is currently positioned as a closer relative of the living coelacanth genus Latimeria. Suggested References: Coelacanths Brito, Paulo M.; Meunier, François J.; Clément, Gael; Geffard-Kuriyama links, Didier (2010). "The histological structure of the calcified lung of the fossil coelacanth Axelrodichthys araripensis (Actinistia: Mawsoniidae)". Palaeontology. 53 (6): 1281–90. Dutel, H., Maisey, J., Schwimmer, D., Janvier, P. and Clément, G. (2011). “Giant coelacanth Megalocoelacanthus dobiei from the Upper Cretaceous of North America and its bearings on the phylogeny of Mesozoic coelacanths”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 31 Everhart, M.J. (2017). “Oceans of Kansas - A Natural History of the Western Interior Sea,” Second Edition. Indiana University Press, 460 pp. Fricke, H.; Plante, R. (1988). "Habitat requirements of the living coelacanth Latimeria chalumnae at grande comore, Indian Ocean". Naturwissenschaften. 75 (3): 149–51. Schwimmer, D. R., Stewart, J.D. and Williams, G.D. (1994). “Giant fossil coelacanths of the Late Cretaceous in the eastern United States”. Geology. 22:503-506.

  • Xenarthrans | Prehistoric Midwest

    Explore the different types of giant sloths and armadillos who lived in the Midwest region during the Pleistocene epoch, including animals like Megalonyx and Glyptotherium Xenarthra Sloths, Armadillos and Anteaters Xenarthra is a superorder of animals that originated in South America and includes anteaters, sloths and armadillos. During the Pleistocene Epoch, the Midwest was home to several types of xenarthrans. The most widespread varieties of these ancient animals were the giant ground sloths, huge extinct relatives of today’s tree sloths, some of which could weigh as much as a grizzly bear. In addition to these sloths, the Midwest was also home to different types of armadillos, including glyptodonts, giant plant-eaters protected by thick bony armor, as well as large pampatheres and relatives of the living nine-banded armadillos. These animals spread into North America from South America as part of the Great American Biotic Interchange after the two continents became joined by the Isthmus of Panama. Over time, unique lineages of xenarthrans began to evolve in their new homes, becoming new endemic species only found in certain parts of North America. Anatomy (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeletal anatomy of the ground sloth Northrotheriops . Drawing is based on a skeletal mount on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Skeletal Anatomy Xenarthrans are a group of animals whose earliest members were adapted for digging burrows. As a result, many features of their skeletons are connected to their fossorial past. One common feature seen in the skeletons of xenarthrans is the presence of specialized articulation points between the lumbar vertebrae which are sometimes called xenarthrous joints. These extra connections add extra strength to the spine during activities which put a lot of strain on this part of the body such as digging or climbing. In most xenarthrans the forelimbs of these animals are heavily built and their arm bones are covered in enlarged surfaces for muscle attachments. This allows these animals to impart a lot of force from their arms and hands when digging nests or reaching up into trees to grab ahold of leafy branches. In armadillos, the underlying skeleton supports a protective covering of bony dermal plates which together make up the animal’s shell segments. The teeth of xenarthrans can vary a lot as well. Megalonyx, for instance, has a set of four large incisors at the front of its mouth which is a feature not seen in most other types of sloths. Anteaters have no teeth at all and armadillos have somewhat pointed peg-shaped teeth. (BELOW) A labeled diagram showing the key bones and features of the skeletal anatomy of a nine-banded armadillo. For the purposes of this diagram the dorsal shell and cephalic shield are shown only in profile view as a cross-section Shell Anatomy Armadillos are a group defined by their shells. These keratinous plates are a form of body covering that serves as a line of defense against predators and environmental hazards. The shells of armadillos are made of hundreds of small bony plates called osteoderms, which are embedded within the skin and coated by a durable layer of keratin. This armor is organized into distinct sections, usually a set of rigid shields, one over the shoulder and the other over the pelvic region, connected by a series of flexible bands that run across the back. In some glyptodonts the bands along the middle of the shell are absent and the dorsal armor instead forms a single large dome covering the animal's entire back. The tails of armadillos are surrounded by a set of overlapping ring-shaped bands. Some giant South American armadillos like Doedicoerus had bony clubs at the ends of their tails which they could swing around when they felt threatened. An armadillo’s armor is completely attached to the animal's body and is supported by the underlying skeleton. In addition to helping to deter attacks from predators. (BELOW) The plates composing the shell of a nine-banded armadillo. The number of plates in between the pelvic and pectoral shield can vary a lot between genera and some armadillos lack these bands altogether Sloths (Folivora) Ancient giants with huge claws During the Pleistocene Epoch, North America was home to several species of giant ground sloths. Much like their tree-dwelling relatives, the giant ground sloths of the past had long claws on their hands and feet. These claws were used to pull leafy branches down from trees so that they were easier to reach, and possibly as defensive tools to ward off potential predators. The largest sloths of the Pleistocene, animals like the elephant-sized Megatherium and Eremotherium , did not make it far enough to the north to reach the Midwest, but even the relatively mid-sized sloths from this region like Megalonyx and Paramylodon could easily end up weighing half a ton or more. Jefferson's Ground Sloth Megalonyx jeffersonii Temporal Range: 5 million years ago to approximately 13,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, Alaska to Mexico Species: M. jeffersonii, M. leptostomus, M. matthisi, M. obtusidens, M. wheatleyi Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, twigs, buds Megalonyx , commonly known as Jefferson’s ground sloth, was an extinct ground sloth that lived in North America from the Pliocene epoch to the end of the Pleistocene epoch. It was one of the continent’s largest herbivores, reaching about 3 meters (10 feet) in length and weighing up to nearly 1,300 kilograms (2,900 pounds). Its most distinctive features were its powerful limbs and large curved claws, which it likely used to pull down branches and gather vegetation. Fossils of Megalonyx have been found across much of the United States and even as far north as Alaska during warmer periods, making it the most widely distributed North American ground sloth. Megalonyx is also unique in terms of the anatomy of its hind feet. In most ground sloths, the feet are positioned sideways such that the weight of the animal is supported by the sides of their feet, while the soles face towards one another. Megalonyx seems to have retained plantigrade feet, where the sole is placed on the ground. (BELOW) A cranium of the ground sloth Megalonyx on display at the KU Museum. These ground sloths had particularly unique enlarged tusk-like incisors on their upper and lower jaws used to take bites of leafy vegetation Nothrotheriops texanus Temporal Range: 2.5 million years ago to approximately 10,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found in the southern parts of North America Species: N. shastensis, N. texanus Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, fruits, roots, tubers, twigs, leaves Nothrotheriops was one of the most distinctive ground sloths of Ice Age North America. It was relatively small, about the size of a black bear, with a long, slender skull and a narrow mouth. Its powerful forelimbs carried large curved claws used to pull down branches, forage for food, and defend against predators. It had a narrower torso and a longer tail than those seen in most other North American ground sloths, giving it a more slender frame. The species commonly referred to as the “Shasta ground sloth” is Nothrotheriops shastensis , mostly known from the southwestern US. Another species, Nothrotheriops texanus , was found in parts of the southern Great Plains in Oklahoma and Texas. One of the most remarkable features of Nothrotheriops is the exceptional preservation of its soft tissues and integumentary remains. In dry caves of the American southwest, scientists have discovered not only bones but also preserved hair, skin, tendons, and even dung from these animals, providing rare insights into their appearances and diets. These finds show that it fed on a variety of desert plants, including yucca, cacti, and Joshua tree fruits. (BELOW) A Nothrotheriops skull from a mounted skeleton on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Note the shape of the cheekbones. The long lower flange of bone seen in this skull is a feature found in the skulls of many types of ground sloths. Paramylodon harlani Temporal Range: 4.9 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North America as far south as Guatemala Species: P. harlani Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Paramylodon was one of the largest ground sloths found in North America. It seems to have been a close relative of the South American sloth genus Glossotherium and its name means “near-Mylodon” , referring to its shared skeletal features with other mylodontid ground sloths. Like other mylodontids, Paramylodon had a long snout with well-developed chewing teeth at the back of its mouth and smaller somewhat sharpened teeth further forward. It is well represented in the tar pits at Rancho La Brea, with the remains of over 70 individual sloths known from this site alone. Mylodontids are suggested to have been better equipped for feeding on grasses than some of their contemporaries like Megalonyx , possibly also using their long claws to dig through the soil in search of roots or tubers. Footprint trackways from New Mexico at White Sand National Monument preserve tracks of a Paramylodon which overlapped with human footprints, possibly left behind by people following the sloth as it moved through the area. Armadillos (Cingulata) Armored hulks and flexible burrowers During the Pleistocene, North America was home to several extinct types of armadillos, including giant glyptodonts and pampatheres. These animals were relatives of modern armadillos but were far larger and more heavily built. Glyptodonts, such as Glyptotherium, were protected by a massive dome-shaped shell made of fused bony plates that covered nearly their entire body. Some species from South America also had heavily armored tails that could be used for defense. Pampatheres like Holmesina were smaller than glyptodonts with their armor formed into more flexible bands instead of rigid domes. Additionally, slightly larger relatives of today’s nine-banded armadillos were also found in the Midwest. Beautiful armadillo Dasypus bellus Temporal Range: 1.8 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America Species: D. bellus Diet: Omnivorous, insects, lizards, amphibians, tubers, roots Dasypus bellus , also known as the beautiful armadillo, was a larger relative of today’s nine banded armadillo, both falling within the genus Dasypus . Their shells were arranged with two large half-dome shaped plates, one behind their heads and one in front of their tails. In between these larger pieces of armor they had a set of bony rings which added a degree of flexibility to their shells. Like their modern relatives the tops of their skulls were covered in a thick layer of reinforced shell material, and the underside of Dasypus bellus was not covered in armor. Their tails were long and thin, surrounded by overlapping bony rings. Their feet were tipped with long claws, used for digging in the process of excavating their burrows and they had long thin snouts and peg-like teeth suggesting that they fed on small animal prey such as insects, mollusks and small vertebrates, as well as a small amount of plant matter. This sort of diet is also seen in the living members of their genus. Glyptotherium texanum Temporal Range: 3.9 million years ago to approximately 15,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found in parts of North and South America Species: G. texanum, G. cylindricum Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Glyptotherium was a glyptodont and was one of the largest armadillos ever to live in North America. Like all armadillos, glyptodonts were originally a South American group. The majority of their species diversity remained in the southern hemisphere even during the Pleistocene, but some intrepid populations of these animals managed to reach the southern parts of what would one day become the US. Glyptotherium was found much further north than many of its relatives with its fossils being found in parts of Texas, Oklahoma and Florida. It seems to have preferred living in warmer climates and its spread further north may have been limited by lower winter temperatures. The dome-like shell of Glyptotherium was composed of a huge number of small bony plates called osteoderms. These osteoderms displayed a characteristic rosette pattern with a central raised area surrounded by smaller peripheral elements. Their tails did not end in a tail club like those of some of their South American relatives but were instead surrounded by a series of 8-9 rings of armor which were further covered in short spines. Holmesina septentrionalis Temporal Range: 5 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Genus found in North and South America Species: H. septentrionalis, H. floridanus, H. major, H. occidentalis Diet: Omnivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves, some invertebrates Holmesina was a genus of pampathere, a type of large extinct armadillo who could grow to be around the same size as the living giant armadillo, with maximum lengths of around 6 feet. Their shells were divided into smaller plates instead of forming large rigid domes of armor like those seen in glyptodonts. Most pampatheres remained in South America where their fossil record is the most extensive, but animals like Holmesina were able to cross into North America where they became very successful in the Great Plains and the southern parts of what is now the US. Based on their teeth they are thought to have had a greater preference for plant matter as part of their diet than living omnivorous or insectivorous armadillos. Most of their teeth are fairly flat with broad chewing surfaces which were well developed for processing leaves or grass, unlike the peg-shaped teeth seen in nine-banded armadillos. Media Gallery Suggested References: Xenarthra De Iuliis, Gerardo; Bargo, María S.; Vizcaíno, Sergio F. (2001). "Variation in skull morphology and mastication in the fossil giant armadillos Pampatherium spp. and allied genera (Mammalia: Xenarthra: Pampatheriidae), with comments on their systematics and distribution". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 20 (4): 743–754. Delsuc, F.; Gibb, G.C.; Kuch, M.; Billet, G.; Hautier, L.; Southon, J.; Rouillard, J.-M.; Fernicola, J.C.; Vizcaíno, S.F.; MacPhee, R.D.E.; Poinar, H.N. (2016). "The phylogenetic affinities of the extinct glyptodonts". Current Biology. 26 (4): R155–R156. Fari a, R. A., & Vizcaíno, S. F. (1997). “Allometry of the bones of living and extinct armadillos (Xenarthra, Dasypoda).” Zeitschrift fur Saugetierkunde, 62, 65-70. Gillette, David D.; Carranza-Castañeda, Óscar; White, Richard S.; Morgan, Gary S.; Thrasher, Larry C.; McCord, Robert; McCullough, Gavin (2016). "Ontogeny and Sexual Dimorphism of Glyptotherium texanum (Xenarthra, Cingulata) from the Pliocene and Pleistocene (Blancan and Irvingtonian NALMA) of Arizona, New Mexico, and Mexico". Journal of Mammalian Evolution. 23 (2): 133–154. McDonald, H.G. (2022). "Paleoecology of the extinct Shasta ground sloth, Nothrotheriops shastensis, (Xenarthra, Nothrotheriidae): The physical environment". New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin. 88: 33–43. Naples, Virginia L. (1987), “Reconstruction of Cranial Morphology and Analysis of Function in the Pleistocene Ground Sloth Nothrotheriops shastense (Mammalia, Megatheriidae)”, Contributions in Science 389, October 1987, Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County Schubert, Blaine W.; Graham, Russell Wm.; McDonald, H. Gregory; Grimm, Eric C.; Stafford, Thomas W. (2004). "Latest Pleistocene paleoecology of Jefferson's ground sloth ( Megalonyx jeffersonii ) and elk-moose ( Cervalces scotti ) in northern Illinois". Quaternary Research. 61 (2): 231–240. Scillato-Yané, G. J.; Carlini, A. A.; Tonni, E. P.; Noriega, J. I. (2005). "Paleobiogeography of the late Pleistocene pampatheres of South America". Journal of South American Earth Sciences. Quaternary Paleontology and biostratigraphy of southern South Africa. 20 (1): 131–138. Semken, Holmes A.; McDonald, H. Gregory; Graham, Russell W.; Adrain, Tiffany; Artz, Joe Alan; Baker, Richard G.; Bryk, Alexander B.; Brenzel, David J.; Arthur Bettis, E.; Clack, Andrew A.; Grimm, Brittany L.; Haj, Adel; Horgen, Sarah E.; Mahoney, Meghann C.; Ray, Harold A. (2022). "Paleobiology of Jefferson's Ground Sloth ( Megalonyx jeffersonii ) derived from three contemporaneous, ontogenetically distinct individuals recovered from Southwestern Iowa, U.S.A." Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 42 (1) e2124115. Shockey, B. J. (2001). “Specialized knee joints in some extinct, endemic, South American herbivores”. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica, 46(2). Slaughter, B.H. (1959). "The First Noted Occurrence of Dasypus bellus in Texas". Field and Laboratory. 27 (2): 77–80. Web of Science. Stinnesbeck, Sarah (2020). "Mexican fossil ground sloths - A case study for Late Pleistocene megafaunal turnover in the Mexican Corridor". Hochschulschrift. 14: 29. Tomak, C.H. (1982). "Dasypus bellus and Other Extinct Mammals From the Prairie-Creek Site". Journal of Mammalogy. 63 (1): 158–160. doi:10.2307/1380686. JSTOR 1380686. Web of Science. Vizcaíno, S. F.; De Iuliis, G.; Bargo, M. S. (1998). "Skull Shape, Masticatory Apparatus, and Diet of Vassallia and Holmesina (Mammalia: Xenarthra: Pampatheriidae): When Anatomy Constrains Destiny". Journal of Mammalian Evolution. 5 (4): 291–322.

  • Arthropods | Prehistoric Midwest

    Explore the different kinds of marine arthropods who lived in the Western Interior Sea during the Cretaceous period, including lobsters, barnacles, clam shrimp and crabs Arthropods Crustaceans and Horseshoe Crabs The fossils of aquatic arthropods, including crabs, lobsters, barnacles and horseshoe crabs, sometimes turn up in deposits left behind by the Western Interior Sea. These animals shared a few common arthropod characteristics, including segmented bodies, jointed limbs, and outer exoskeletons composed of a material called chitin. Decapods, the group containing crabs, lobsters, and similar ten-legged animals went through a diversification event during the Cretaceous period and many more familiar forms of these animals appear in the fossil record around this time. Some remains of horseshoe crabs which appear very similar to their living relatives are also found in layers of sedimentary stone formed in nearshore environments. Arthropod remains are sometimes incomplete because their exoskeletons could separate after death or be discarded during the molting process. Most arthropod groups are fully mobile animals but in the case of some crustaceans such as gooseneck barnacles, the adult forms of these organisms attach themselves to a hard surface such as a rock or a piece of driftwood. Arthropods (Browse by class, order) Horseshoe crabs (Order Xiphosura) Limulus Clam shrimp (Superorder Diplostraca) Cyzicus Seed shrimp (Class Ostracoda) Cytherella Barnacles (Subclass Ciripedia) Stramentum Decapods (Order Decapoda) Ghost shrimp (Familly Callianassidae) Protocallianassa Prawns (Suborder Dendrobranchiata) Penaeus Spiny lobsters (Infraorder Achelata) Linuparis Panulirus Rugafarius Lobsters (Infraorder Astacidae) Hoploparia True crabs (Infraorder Brachyura) Horseshoe Crabs (Xiphosura) Temporal Range: 480 million years ago - Present Diet: Benthic carnivore/scavenger, fish, invertebrates Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Limulus Horseshoe crabs are marine arthropods that are more closely related to other chelicerates like spiders and scorpions than they are to true crabs. A tough, horseshoe-like or crescent-shaped exoskeleton protects their bodies, which consist of three sections: the prosoma, opisthosoma, and telson. The prosoma holds the eyes, mouth, and legs, while the opisthosoma carries movable spines and five pairs of book gills used to breathe underwater. The long telson is a sharp spine on the rear part of the animal. This structure is not venomous or used for stinging. Instead it helps with steering and allows the animal to flip itself over when it ends up lying upside down. They spend most of their lives at sea but will come ashore in order to lay their eggs. (ABOVE) The genus Liumulus, the same genus as the extant horseshoe crab which is also found in Cretaceous deposits Crustaceans Crustaceans are a very diverse order of arthropods which includes animals like isopods, ostracods, lobsters and crabs. Their clearest diagnostic feature is the presence of two pairs of antennae, including one shorter set called the antenulles. A crustacean’s segmented body is generally divided into the head, thorax, and abdomen, similar to what is seen in insects. In some species the head and thorax unite to form a cephalothorax which is often protected by a shell or carapace. Their bodies are supported by a hard, chitinous exoskeleton that must be molted and shed as the animal grows. Aquatic crustaceans usually take in oxygen through their gills, but many forms of crustaceans have independently adapted to spend extended periods of time on land, and some groups have even become fully terrestrial. Clam Shrimp (Diplostraca) Temporal Range: ~410 million years ago - Present Diet: Microscopic filter feeder/carnivore, tiny plants and animals Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Cyzicus Clam shrimps are branchiopod crustaceans whose bodies are protected by a hinged shell made of two valves, giving them a clam-like appearance. Despite this feature and their resemblance to their namesake clams, clam shrimps are still crustaceans rather than bivalve mollusks. They have a series of feathery legs which stick out slightly from the edges of their shells. They also use a specialized set of antennae to push themselves forward when swimming. They are able to seal the valves of their shells closed when they feel threatened. Today these animals usually live in shallow freshwater ponds and temporary pools, although in the distant past these animals seem to have been able to live outside of ephemeral environments and may have survived as fully marine organisms. Many living species endure dry conditions by laying eggs which can stay dormant in the sediment until water returns. (ABOVE) The clam shrimp genus Cyzicus is a genus whose shells are found in Cretaceous deposits but which is also found living in ephemeral pool environments today Seed Shrimp (Ostracoda ) Temporal Range: ~460 million years ago - Present Diet: Detritivore, bacteria, algae, mold, other organic waste Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Cytherella Ostracods, often known as seed shrimp, are microscopic crustaceans whose bodies are surrounded by a hinged shell consisting of two valves. This carapace is mostly made of chitin reinforced with calcium carbonate. The presence of this layer of calcium carbonate allows these small animals to fossilize more easily than some other types of microinvertebrates. Although their shells resemble those of tiny clams, ostracods have jointed limbs like most other arthropods, as well as antennae which they use when they are swimming, crawling, and/or detecting their surroundings. (ABOVE) The ostracod genus Cytherella . These animals are generally quite small, less than 1/2 a millimeter long. Barnacles (Cirripedia ) Temporal Range: ~320 million years ago - Present Diet: FIlter feeder, Plankton Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Stramentum Cirripedia the subclass of crustaceans that contains barnacles. Most adult barnacles remain firmly attached to rocks, shells, or driftwood once they have fully matured. Their bodies are usually surrounded by a hard calcified mantle. Their feather-like limbs called cirri reach through the shell opening to collect plankton and suspended organic material as part of their suspension-feeding process. Although adults are stationary, their larvae swim freely before selecting a surface and becoming attached. Acorn barnacles fasten directly to surfaces, while goose barnacles attach themselves to surfaces along flexible stalks. Gooseneck barnacles, like the genus Stramentum, are the best represented group of barnacles known from deposits formed by the Western Interior Sea. (ABOVE) The genus Stramentum is the most common barnacle found fossilized in the Western Interior Sea. As a gooseneck barnacle it would have been connected to a hard surface by a tube of softer tissue which is rarely preserved. Decapods (Decapoda) Temporal Range: ~376 million years ago - Present Diet: Includes active predators, scavengers, detritivores Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Protocallianassa, Penaeus, Panulirus, Rugafarius, Linuparis, Hoploparia, Cenomanocarcinus, Dakoticancer, Necrocarcinus, Hoplitocarcinus, Zygastrocarcinus, Heus, Raninella, Dromiopsis, Dioratiopus, Xanthosia, Plagiophthalmus Decapods are a group of crustaceans who are named for their tendency to have ten legs. Many members of this group, including crabs, lobsters and ghost shrimp, have limbs which have transformed over time into chelae, or claws, of various sizes. In some other lineages, like the spiny lobsters, the five pairs of legs remain roughly the same size while their antennae grow to be quite large. The segmented bodies of decapods consist of a cephalothorax, formed by the fused head and thorax, and a rear, often segmented, section called an abdomen. A rigid carapace covers the cephalothorax and protects the organs and gills beneath. A series of smaller appendages called pleopods which can be found on the lower surfaces of the tails of some decapods are used to help these animals swim. In some forms of shrimp, spiny lobsters and true lobsters, the muscular sections of their abdomens end in tail fans formed by the telson and uropods. These structures are used to help these animals steer themselves through the water. In crabs, the abdomen is generally reduced and folded beneath the cephalothorax. This abdominal reduction is a feature found in true brachyuran crabs as well as several groups of anomuran “false crabs”. (ABOVE) The genus Protocallianassa from the Late Cretaceous. Note the asymmetrical claws (ABOVE) The genus Penaeus, an extant genus also known from the Late Cretaceous of Kansas. Like many types of prawns these animals have prominent pleopods on their ventral surfaces (ABOVE) Spiny lobsters of the Western Interior Sea: (A) Panulirus, (B) Linuparis, (C) Rugafarius (ABOVE) The genus Hoploparia , a Late Cretaceous lobster. These animals had a fairly wide geographic distribution and could grow to be as large as some extant lobsters. (ABOVE) Types of crabs found in the Western Interior Sea. Remains from these animals are fairly rare in deposits from central North America Crab Genera Family Dakoticancridae: Dakoticancer Family Cenomanocarcinidae : Cenomanocarcinus Family Homolidae: Hoplitocarcinus, Zygastrocarcinus, Plagiophthalmus? Family Raninidae: Heus, Raninella Family Longodromitidae: Dioratiopus Family Necrocarcinidae: Necrocarcinus Family Dromiidae: Dromiopsis Family Xanthidae: Xanthosia Suggested References: Arthropods Digital Atlas of Ancient Life. (n.d.). Maxillopoda. Cretaceous Atlas of Ancient Life | Maxillopoda. https://www.cretaceousatlas.org/classes/maxillopoda/ Digital Atlas of Ancient Life. (n.d.). Branchiopoda. Cretaceous Atlas of Ancient Life | Branchiopoda. https://www.cretaceousatlas.org/classes/branchiopoda/ Digital Atlas of Ancient Life. (n.d.). Malacostraca. Cretaceous Atlas of Ancient Life | Malacostraca. https://www.cretaceousatlas.org/classes/malacostraca/ Dunlop, J. A., Penney, D. & Jekel, D. (2013). “A summary list of fossil spiders and their relatives”. In Platnick, N. I. (ed.) The world spider catalog, version 14.0 Everhart, M.J. (2017). “Oceans of Kansas - A Natural History of the Western Interior Sea,” Second Edition. Indiana University Press, 460 pp. Newman, W. A. et al., 1969. Cirripedia in Moore, R. C., ed., “Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part R, Arthropoda 4(1), Volume 1”. The University of Kansas and Geological Society of America. 398 pp. Schweitzer, C.E.; Feldmann, R.M. (2001). "New Cretaceous and Tertiary decapod crustaceans from western North America". Bulletin of the Mizunami Fossil Museum. 28: 173–210. Sammy De Grave; N. Dean Pentcheff; Shane T. Ahyong; et al. (2009). "A classification of living and fossil genera of decapod crustaceans" (PDF). Raffles Bulletin of Zoology. Suppl. 21: 1–109.

  • Miocene artiodactyls part 1 | Prehistoric Midwest

    Artiodactyla Even-Toed Ungulates Fossils preserved in the Ogallala Formation preserve the remains of several groups of artiodactyls, or even-toed hoofed ungulates, that lived in the Great Plains during the Miocene and Pliocene epochs. These included members of the family Camelidae (camels) Antilocapridae (pronghorns) and Tayassuidae (peccaries), along with the extinct protoceratid and dromomerycid families. The family Camelidae, which comprises all of today’s camels, llamas, alpacas and their relatives, is a family which originated in North America and is known from fossils of large and small animals such as Megatylopus and Aepycamelus. These extinct camels were often large, with long legs and, in some species, elongated necks that helped them browse and travel efficiently across open landscapes. Some smaller camelid genera, such as Protolabis , are also found in these deposits. The family Tayassuidae (peccaries) includes several extinct Miocene genera, some of which had ong flanges of bone along the edges of their cheekbones. Their teeth and long snouts were useful for rooting through soil in search of food. The family Antilocapridae is the pronghorn family and includes animals with long palmate horns and shorter horns with rounded tips. Other now extinct families of artiodactyls are also found in these deposits, including the dromomermerycids and protoceratids. Some of these animals had paired structures above their eyes and in some genera a third projection is found further back, towards the base of the skull. The order artiodactyla was one of the most diverse orders of large mammals found in North American Neogene deposits. Some groups found in North America are absent from the fossil record of the Miocene and Early Pliocene. These include deer, bison, sheep and goats, which would later arrive from Eurasia during the late Pliocene and Early Pleistocene. Anatomy Skeletal Anatomy Even-toed ungulates take their name from the structure of their feet. In most members of the group, the animal’s weight is concentrated on the third and fourth toes which are protected by keratinous hooves. A second pair of reduced hooves are present in some types of artiodactyls, conserved as small dewclaws behind the main hooves. Many fast-running artiodactyls such as protoceratids, antilocaprids and dromomerycids also have very long legs and fused metacarpal and metatarsal bones called cannon bones, features which help to limit unnecessary sideways movement, and allowing these animals such as deer, pronghorns, and cattle to move quickly over open ground. On the other hand, some types of artiodactyls, such as large Miocene camels, hippos, pigs and oreodonts for example, are much more heavily built. The skulls of artiodactyls are equally diverse. Some have horns or antlers used for display, defense, or competition, while their teeth reflect diets ranging from mixed feeding to specialized grazing and browsing. They often have broad molars which are well-adapted for grinding, although some omnivorous groups have molars which are covered in tooth lobes or angular cusps. Many types of artiodactyls, such as musk deer, early protoceratids, peccaries, pigs, hippos and camels, have long canine teeth which are used for defense or when competing with other members of their own species. (BELOW) Features of the skeletal anatomy of the long-snouted peccary Mylohyus. These animals had many of the traits which are commonly found in artiodactyls, including feet supported by hooves on two toes, tall spinous processes on the thoracic vertebrae and a short tail. These peccaries would have also had rather long tusks. (BELOW) The hooves of artiodactyls are quite different from those of odd-toed ungulates such as horses and rhinos. Like most even-toed ungulates, The hooves of roe deer (A) are cloven, with two hooves contacting the ground and two smaller dew claws positioned off the ground further up on the leg. These dew claws are not found in odd-toed ungulates. Horses (B) support their weight on a single hoof while rhinos and tapirs walk on multiple toes supported by a thick pad. Photo A, Public Domain image, Photo B accessed via Wikipedia Commons, uploaded by user Montanabw, CC BY-SA 3.0 Artiodactyls have a huge range of different types of adornments on their crania. The best known of these structures are horns and antlers. True horns, such as those of cattle, goats, sheep, and antelopes, are composed of permanent bony cores surrounded by keratin sheaths. These structures generally grow throughout an animal’s life and are rarely shed. The exceptions to this trend are pronghorns and other types of antilocaprids which will shed the outer sheaths of their horns. Deer on the other hand have antlers, which are branching structures formed entirely from bone. Developing antlers are initially covered by a sensitive, blood-rich layer of skin known as velvet. After they are finished growing, the velvet is removed as the animals scrape them along rocks and trees, and later the antlers are eventually shed and replaced. This typically happens over the course of an annual cycle. Giraffes, okapis, and several extinct groups, such as protoceratids and dromomerycids from the Miocene and Pliocene of the Great Plains, have ossicones, which are skin-covered bony projections that develop separately before fusing with the skull. In many dromomerycids these ossicones sit over the eyes and, in some groups, at the back of the skull over the neck. Some of the last members of the family Protoceratidae the skulls of these animals show a combination of features, with a pair of true horns along the back of the head and fused ossicone-like protrusions sitting along the upper portions of their muzzles. Cranial Ornamentation (BELOW) Horns of a pronghorn. Like many other types of horned artiodactyls the bony cores of the horns of antilocaprids are sheathed in a thick layer of keratin. Unlike horned ruminants however, pronghorns are able to shed and regrow their horn sheaths. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by James St. John, CC BY 2.0 (BELOW) Ossicones are another type of cranial projection found in some types of artiodactyls. In the skull of a giraffe, the ossicones are the horn-like features at the rear of the head. These structures are covered in skin and fur. Similar ossicones seem to have been present in dromomerycids and on the noses of protoceratids. Photo was taken at the KU Natural History Museum by Corbin Rainbolt Artiodactyls Not all artiodactyls are listed on this page. See the list below for the order in which entries are listed Next page This page Family Dromomerycidae Bouromeryx Cranioceras Dromomeryx Procranioceras Yumaceras Pediomeryx Family Camelidae Aepycamelus Vampyrocamelus Alforjas Floridatragulus Megatylopus Oxydactylus Pleiolama Procamelus Protolabis Gigantocamelus Homocamelus Megacamelus Titanotylopus Family Tayassuidae Mckennahyus Mylohyus Platygonus Prosthennops Protherohyus Skinnerhyus Stirtonhyus Family Moschidae Blastomeryx Longirostromeryx Superfamily Merycoidodontoidea Merychyus Ticholeptus Ustatochoerus Family Protoceratidae Lambdoceras Prosynthetoceras Synthetoceras Family Antilocapridae Capromeryx Cosoryx Merycodus Proantilocapra Ramoceros Texoceros Sphenophalos Paracosoryx Next Page Dromomerycids (Dromomerycidae) Ruminants With Elaborate Headgear Dromomerycids were an ancient group of artiodactyls who superficially resembled deer or antelopes, despite not being particularly closely related to either group. The males of many dromomerycid genera had long projections called ossicones on their skulls. Unlike antlers, these structures were usually unbranched and were not shed each year. Most groups of dromomerycids had paired ossicones above their eyes, while some genera also had a central projection at the back of their skulls. Over the course of the Miocene epoch several dromomerycid genera underwent a gradual transition towards a grazing diet, developing high-crowned molars which could resist more wear and tear from silica-rich grasses. Bouromeryx Temporal Range: 17 - 11 million years ago Geographic Range: Parts of the Great Plains, Florida, Saskatchewan Species: B. americanus, B. submilleri, B. trigonocorneus Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Bouromeryx was a North American dromomerycid ruminant which was a relative of animals like Cranioceras and Pediomeryx . Like other dromomerycids, it carried tall cranial appendages on the top of its head. They would not have shed these projections and instead they would have grown over the course of the lives of these animals. The ossicones over their eyes were medium-sized for a dromomerycid while the rear appendage was noticeably smaller than the elongated occipital ossicones of later related genera such as Cranioceras . Bouromeryx also would not have had any upper canines and had only a short diastema, a gap separating the teeth at the front of the mouth from the cheek teeth. It would have had comparatively large premolars and low-crowned teeth which were probably more useful for browsing on leaves than for grinding up tough grasses. Cranioceras Temporal Range: 15.97 - 5.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across parts of central and western North America Species: C. unicornis, C. clarendonensis, C. pawniensis, C. teres Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Cranioceras was a North American dromomerycid ruminant that survived from the Miocene into the early Pliocene and the namesake of the tribe Cranioceratini. Like most other types of dromomerycids, Cranioceras had large giraffe-like ossicones over its eyes. Like its closest relatives it also would have had a third smaller projection issuing from the back of its skull just over the uppermost portion of the neck. These ossicones were likely covered in fur instead of a keratinous outer sheath and are associated with the remains of animals who are thought to have been male individuals. They would not have been shed like the antlers of deer. The postcranial remains of these animals resemble those of deer and antelopes and Cranioceras was likely an able runner, living in both wooded and open environments. Dromomeryx Temporal Range: 13.6 to 10 million years ago Geographic Range: Western North America from Nebraska to California Species: D. borealis Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Dromomeryx was a Miocene artiodactyl native to North America and the namesake of the family Dromomerycidae. Unlike some other types of dromomerycids, Dromomeryx only had two projections on its skull instead of the three projections usually seen in cranioceratini such as Cranioceras and Pediomeryx . They also would have lacked the long canine teeth which we see in some groups of earlier dromomerycids. Based on the wear patterns on their teeth and their low crowned molars it seems as though Dromomeryx preferred to live in wooded environments and browsed mainly on leaves and other soft plants, although later species may have consumed tougher vegetation as conditions became cooler and drier. Like many other members of its family, it would have had very long legs and was likely an efficient runner. (BELOW) Cranial projections and limb bones of Dromomeryx borealis at the University of California Museum of Paleontology. Unlike the projections of most dromomerycids, those of some Dromomeryx species are branched into a large upper tine and a short rounded lower tine. Photo by Ted Fremd, Public Domain Procranioceras Temporal Range: 16 - 13.6 million years ago Geographic Range: Nebraska, Florida, Saskatchewan Species: P. skinneri Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Procranioceras was a dromomerycid that lived during the Middle Miocene epoch and whose fossils are known from parts of Nebraska, Florida, and Saskatchewan. In addition to paired hornlike projections above its eyes, Procranioceras would have had the long third horn-like projection arising from the occipital region at the rear of the skull seen among members of the tribe cranioceratini. This feature tells us that these animals were close relatives of genera such as Cranioceras and its kin. These animals differed from the members of the tribe dromomerycini, which only had a single pair of supraorbital appendages and from the members of the subfamily aletomerycinae which often had enlarged canine teeth similar to those of musk deer. Compared with later cranioceratini such as the genus Pediomeryx, Procranioceras had shorter cranial appendages and lower-crowned teeth which were better suited for browsing on soft leaves instead of grass. (BELOW) Skull of "Cranioceras " (Procranioceras ) skinneri from Nebraska at the Museum für Naturkunde, Berlin. Note the size of the cranial projections over the eyes, which are longer than the projection at the base of the skull. Image accessed via Wikimedia Commons, uploaded by user FunkMonk, CC BY-SA 3.0 Yumaceras and Pediomeryx Temporal Range: ~13 - 4.9 million years ago Geographic Range: Found in the Great Plains, Florida, California Species: Y. figginsi, P. hamiltoni, P. hemphillensis, P. ruminalis Diet: Herbivorous, some species are browsers, later species seem to have grazed on grass as mixed browsers. Yumaceras Yumaceras was a large North American dromomerycid genus. This animal is sometimes considered to be a subgenus or synonym of Pediomeryx rather than an independent genus. As in other cranioceratin dromomerycids, males of this genus had large paired frontal ossicones above their eyes and a single median occipital ossicone extending from the back of the skull just above the neck. These appendages were especially elongated in Yumaceras , and it had more elaborate cranial ornamentation than earlier genera such as Bouromeryx , which had shorter, more rounded projections. Compared with animals in the genus Pediomeryx , specimens assigned to the genus Yumaceras are generally larger and have longer premolar rows and lower-crowned molars. Like many types of artiodactyls, these animals seem to have become smaller over the course of the Miocene epoch and these later forms evolved more high-crowned teeth better suited to grazing on abrasive plants. Pediomeryx Pediomeryx was an extinct North American dromomerycid that lived from the Late Miocene epoch to the Early Pliocene epoch. Like many of its relatives, it would have had tall cranial projections over its eyes, similar to the ossicones of giraffes. Fossil skeletons which are thought to have belonged to male individuals of this genus have two elongated frontal ossicones above the eyes and a third ossicone extending from the back of the skull. Each of these projections tends to grow to be around 9-10 inches tall (around 25 cm). Their ossicones were longer on average than those of related genera such as Cranioceras . Later species in the genus Pediomeryx became smaller than their earlier ancestors and developed higher-crowned molars and even shorter premolar rows. In most animals who go through these sorts of transitions, it seems as though the development of taller crowns reflects a preference for grass as a part of their diets and a switch over to a grazing feeding style. Microwear patterns on their teeth also suggest that some of these species were mixed feeders, unlike many earlier dromomerycids, which primarily browsed on leaves. Pediomeryx was one of the last surviving dromomerycid genera during the Pliocene epoch. (BELOW) A drawing of the head of Pediomeryx , one of the last dromomerycid genera and one of the few to survive into the Early Pliocene epoch. The ossicones of these animals were longer than those of related genera and may have been covered in a layer of skin and fur. Camels (Camelidae) Ancient Camels in North America Camelids are a family of hoofed mammals which includes today’s Old World camels, South American llamas, alpacas, vicunas, and guanacos, along with their extinct relatives. Camelids spent most of their evolutionary history in North America. Some of the first camels found in the Great Plains were small animals who lived in forests during the Paleogene period. Over the course of the Miocene, several groups of camels independently developed larger body sizes, with some even having long giraffe-like necks used to browse along tall branches. Camelids only spread to other continents within the past few million years. They are split into two living lineages; the cameline subfamily, which include all camels found in Asia and Africa, and the lamine subfamily , which includes South America’s native camelids such as llamas and alpacas. The camelid family is part of Tylopoda, a suborder named for the distinctive padded feet found in later members of the camelid family. Unlike true ruminants, which have four stomach chambers, camels have three and digest tough grasses less efficiently. Aepycamelus and Vampyrocamelus Temporal Range: 16 - 2 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across southern and western North America Species: A. bradyi, A. giraffinus, A. major Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Aepycamelus Aepycamelus was a very strange genus of camelids which would have had a giraffe-like body shape unlike those of their relatives. Aepycemelus had a very small head which was supported by a very long neck. As with all long-necked mammals, this neck length was achieved thanks to the lengthened shape of its cervical vertebrae, not from an increased number of neck bones. The limbs of these animals were also very long and thin which gave it an elevated, stilt-legged build in which the knees and elbows were positioned at similar heights relative to the feet and torso. In some individuals, the head would have managed to reach around 10 feet, or three meters, up above the ground, which gave these animals more room to browse along the tops of trees. Compared with earlier camelids, Aepycamelus had more derived feet similar to those of living camels. It walked on its toes and would have had cushioned foot pads comparable to those of modern camels. They do not seem to have been primarily adapted for running based their proportionally long and very thin legs. Vampyrocamelus The genus Vampyrocamelus was named in 2026 based on material which appears to be very similar to the genus Aepycamelu s. The name of the genus, which translates to “vampire camel” refers to the enlarged upper canines and first premolars found in the skulls of these animals. Fossils of this animal are known from parts of Nebraska in the Ash Hollow Member of the Ogallala Formation as well as the Clarendon Beds in Texas and Oklahoma. Most Aepycamelines had very large upper canines but the teeth found in Vampyrocamelus are particularly large compared with all known camelids. Female members of this genus had reduced canines compared with the teeth of skeletons which are presumed to be from males. (BELOW) A restoration of the life appearance of the head and neck of Vampyrocamelus . Like Aepycamelus this genus would have had a very long neck and a rather slender snout. Skull drawing is adapted from "The Evolution of North American Camels", New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 104 (2026), Figure 10.1 (BELOW) Bones of the neck and leg bones of an Aepycamelus (right) alongside the skeleton of a Procamelus on display at the American Museum of Natural History. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by Ryan Somma, CC BY-SA 2.0 Alforjas Temporal Range: 10.3 - 5.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found from Oregon to central Mexico Species: A. taylori Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Alforjas was a medium-sized genus of North American camelids which was a member of the lamine tribe, along with today’s South American camelids such as llamas and alpacas. Their range would have extended across parts of central and southern North America, as far south as central Mexico. They seem to have been somewhat larger animals than living lamines, growing to be around 20 percent larger than today’s llamas. They also would have had longer snouts than most of their relatives such as the genus Pleiolama. Floridatragulus Temporal Range: 20.6 - 15.9 million years ago Geographic Range: Florida, Texas, Nebraska Species: F. dolichanthereus, F. hesperus, F. nanus, F. texanus Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Floridatragulus was an extinct North American camelid with a long, slender, tube-shaped muzzle. The snouts of these animals would have been almost uniform in their width toward the front but expanded considerably around the cheek teeth, which gave the skull proportions unlike those of most other camelids. The lower jaw was similarly long and narrow and it would have had an extended fused symphysis and several prominent gaps between the teeth. One particular gap which distinguishes this genus from other types of camelids was the rather large space which separated the second and third lower premolars. The incisors of these animals were large and somewhat canine-like, while the cheek teeth were low-crowned and adapted for slicing and grinding softer vegetation. When fossils of these animals were first found, paleontologists initially mistook Floridatragulu s for an ancient type of ruminant because of its unusual skull and tooth structure. In terms of its body size it seems to have been a mid-sized genus of camelid, around the same size as a living guanaco. Hemiauchenia Temporal Range: 10.3 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found in parts of North and South America Species: H. macrocephala, H. minima, H. blancoensis, H. vera, H. paradoxa, H. seymourensis, H. edensis, H. mirim Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Hemiauchenia is a genus of camels in the tribe lamini which seems to have been the direct ancestor of today’s South American camelids like llamas and alpacas. The genus first appeared during the Miocene in North America with fossils of these early animals uncovered in Texas, Kansas, Nebraska and Florida as well as parts of Central America. The genus further expanded into South America once the isthmus of Panama joined the Americas around 2-2.5 million years ago. Species like Hemiauchenia paradoxa appear in South America during the middle Pleistocene. Like many other lamine camelids, Hemiauchenia had a long neck habitually held in a posture which would have positioned most of the cervical vertebrae above the shoulder blades. Their torsos were relatively narrow and they would have lacked the tall spinous processes which could have anchored fleshy humps like those seen in dromedary and bactrian camels. Some species of Hemiauchenia had proportionally larger heads than their living relatives. Megatylopus Temporal Range: 10.3 - 2.58 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across southern, central North America Species: M. gigas, M. cochrani, M. matthewi, M. primaevus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Megatylopus was among the largest camelids known to have lived in North America, with some individuals reaching estimated shoulder heights of around 14 feet (4.2 meters). Their size would have given these animals access to leafy browse growing on higher branches of trees and would have extended its feeding envelope when grazing along the ground. As a result of seemingly forming part of the cameline branch of the camelid family tree, the genus Megatylopus would have appeared quite similar to living bactrian camels and the bones of its limbs and feet are fairly similar to corresponding bones of later Pleistocene North American camels such as the genus Camelops . Megatylopus seems to have been closely related to animals like Gigantocamelus and to the lineage containing modern Camelus. Their size meant that they could have reached sizes comparable to those of some of the proboscidean elephant relatives and large rhinos who shared their habitats. Oxydactylus Temporal Range: 28.4 - 13.7 million years ago Geographic Range: Florida, Nebraska, Texas, Wyoming, California, Idaho Species: O. longipes, O. lacota, O. wyomingensis Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Oxydactylus was a genus of North American camelids which would have appeared somewhat similar to the genus Aepycamelus. The genus is known for its long neck and limbs, as well as its narrow, pointed toes. As is the case with Aepycamelus and the living giraffe, its neck was formed from seven elongated vertebrae instead of being composed of many smaller vertebrae like the necks of sauropod dinosaurs and long-necked birds. Its limbs were very lightly built. Unlike modern camels, llamas, and alpacas, Oxydactylus lacked the specialized surfaces on its toe bones which support broad foot pads. Instead, the phalanges at the ends of each of its toes were tall, narrow, and pointed, which would suggest that Oxydactylu s walked on hoof-like structures rather than cushioned soles. The animal also had a relatively small skull and still had several dental characteristics associated with earlier branches of the camelid family tree. Its cheek teeth had low crowns while its upper incisors were only slightly reduced (living camels lack upper incisors), and its premolars remained fully developed. Later camelids generally had more reduced incisors and premolars. (BELOW) Skeleton of an Oxydactylus wyomingensis . Note the lengthening of the cervical vertebrae of the neck. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 2.0 (BELOW) Detail of the skull from the skeleton in the photo above, on display at the University of Wyoming Geological Museum. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 2.0 Pleiolama Temporal Range: ~10.3 - 5 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North and Central America Species: P. mckennai, P. vera Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Pleiolama was an extinct North American member of the lamine tribe, part of the camelid group that also includes modern llamas, alpacas, guanacos, and vicuñas. Unlike the tall, well built skulls of dromedary and bactrian camels, Pleiolama and its relatives had relatively slender skulls. Like many other types of lamines Pleiolama had a set of reduced premolars. Their limbs were long and slender, which gave this genus a lighter, taller build than more heavily constructed, short-legged camelids. It probably resembled a large, swift-moving llama moreso than a heavy-bodied camel. There is some anatomical evidence which suggests that this genus may be a paraphyletic grouping of different North American lamines which may be more distantly related to one another than was originally thought, although this possibility has not yet been proven conclusively. Procamelus Temporal Range: ~16.3 - 5.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America from Virginia to California Species: P. occidentalis, P. coconinensis, P. grandis, P. leptocolon, P. leptognathus, P. minor, P. gracilis Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Procamelus was a North American camelid which more closely resembled living dromedary camels than the lamine camelids, despite only growing to be slightly larger than today’s llamas. The animals of this genus had long, slender limbs which were likely well suited to sustained high speed trotting. Its neck was relatively straight unlike the elongated or curved necks of Oxydactylus and Aepycamelus . The feet of Procamelus show some features which were important to the development of the distinctive foot pads seen in many living camelids. Evidence from the bones of the toes of Procemelus would suggest that they supported broad, cushioned pads similar to those of living camels, unlike most earlier camelids which had more hoof-like feet similar to those of other artiodactyls. These pads would have distributed the animal’s weight across soft ground and would have allowed these animals to move efficiently across unstable surfaces. The spinous processes on their thoracic vertebrae were also rather long and may have helped to anchor the neck muscles and/or fatty tissue, although they likely did not have a full camel-like hump. (BELOW) Skeleton of Procamelus grandis on display at the American Museum of Natural History. Note the height of the spinous processes over the thoracic vertebrae along the back of the animal. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by Ryan Somma, CC BY-SA 2.0 Protolabis Temporal Range: 20.4 – 5.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found central America and western North America Species: P. barstowensis, P. coartatus, P. heterodontus, P. saxeus, P. inaequidens Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Protolabis was a small genus of early North American camelids, typically only growing to be less than 3 feet tall at the shoulder. The genus name of these animals means “primitive lips” in reference to the unusual anatomical features seen in the structures of the upper and lower jaws of these ancient camels. The muzzles of these animals were particularly narrow while the front portion of the nasal openings would have widened toward the sides. These features created a facial shape that differed from the broad spacious nasal openings seen in many other types of camelids. The first two upper premolars in Protolabis ’ mouth were also greatly reduced and occasionally absent which seems to represent a trend toward dental simplification, while the upper jaws still held incisor teeth which is a feature which is not present in living camels. They seem to be one of the smallest camel genera found in Middle-Late Miocene North America and despite their superficial similarities to llamas and alpacas, they do not seem to be closely related to today’s South American camelids. Gigantocamelus Temporal Range: 10.3 million years ago to approximately 300,000 years ago Geographic Range: Central and western North America, California, Nebraska Species: G. spatulus Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Gigantocamelus was one of the largest camel genera ever to live in North America. Standing as tall as a small elephant, these animals filled ecological roles similar to those occupied by giraffes on other continents. Thanks to their height and their extremely long necks, they were able to browse for leafy vegetation which was off limits to nearly every other type of Ice Age herbivore. Gigantocamelus did not survive long enough to reach the end of the Pleistocene epoch. This genus first appeared during the Miocene epoch and lived up until around 300,000 years ago. In its habitat throughout much of what would one day become the Great Plains it would have been one of the largest hoofed mammals around at the time. Like many of today’s camelids, Gigantocamelus camels had very long canine teeth which they may have used as defensive weapons when fighting against potential predators and/or against other Gigantocamelus in fights over mates, food or territory. This animal was once considered to be a junior synonym of the genus Titanotylopu s but more recent work suggests that these animals are distinct enough to be considered separate genera. (BELOW) A skeleton of Gigantocamelus on display at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History (BELOW) A Gigantocamelus skull on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Note the large size of the canine teeth. These long teeth were used to fight with other camels over territory, food and water. Male dromedary and bactrian camels still have very large canine teeth today. Additional Camelid Genera Genera: Homocamelus, Megacamelus, Titanotylopus Homocamelus Once thought to be a synonym of the genus Procamelus based on the shape of the teeth found in the jaws of this genus. Later analyses based on more complete skeletal material now suggest that the genus is, in fact, valid and is considered to be part of the Miolabine camels and a close relative of the Early Miocene genus Nothotylopus. Megacamelus A genus of large camelids closely related to animals like Gigantocamelus , growing to be over 10 feet tall. Known from fossils found in parts of Nebraska and South Dakota. Found in deposits from the Middle Miocene epoch to the Early Pliocene epoch. Titanotylopus A very large camelid known from relatively fragmentary material found in Webster County, Nebraska. Additional material from this genus may also have been found in California, Arizona and South Dakota. This animal is known from a single species, T. nebrascensis . This genus has occasionally been considered to be a synonym of the genus Gigantocamelus but more recent analyses support these genera being separate groups of animals. Peccaries (Tayassuidae) North America's Pig-Like Omnivores Peccaries are a group of pig-like hoofed mammals who form the family Tayassuidae. These animals have a long evolutionary history in North America dating back all the way to the Early Miocene epoch. The Ogallala Formation contains the fossils of several types of peccaries, many of which display unique types of anatomical features which are not found in any living peccary genera. Among the most striking of these features are the large wing-like flanges of bone seen on the cheeks of some Miocene genera such as Mckennahyus and Skinnerhyus . In some extreme cases the distance between the apexes of these flanges can exceed the total length of the animal’s skull. The exact function of these unusual cheekbones remains a mystery but they were almost certainly display features. Some Ogallala Formation peccaries, such as the genus Mylohyus , would survive all the way up until the late Pleistocene epoch. Mckennahyus Temporal Range: Late Miocene epoch Geographic Range: Nebraska Species: M. parisidutrai Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Mckennahyus was an extinct peccary genus known for its particularly large cheekbones. The only recognized species in this genus, Mckennahyus parisidutra i, had zygomatic arches that projected outward to form broad, spoon-like flanges. Although strong cheek arches are a feature seen in many types of peccaries, those of Mckennahyus were so greatly expanded that they led scientists to assign these remains to a separate newly named genus. These projections produced an unusually wide skull that contrasted sharply with the narrower facial structure of other members of the peccary family. Their exact purpose is unknown, although they may have functioned as visual display and/or communication structures associated with age, sex, or social status. This interpretation remains speculative because the genus is known mainly from incomplete skull material. The genus was first described relatively recently, in 2021, based on fossils recovered from the Merritt Dam Beds of the Ash Hollow Member in Nebraska. Long-snouted peccary Mylohyus nasutus Temporal Range: 5 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Eastern and central North America , Nebraska, Texas, Florida Species: M. nasutus , M. elmorei, M. floridanus, M. fossilis, M. gildleyi Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Mylohyus was an extinct genus of peccary found throughout many parts of North America From the Pliocene to the Late Pleistocene. These animals stood slightly taller than today’s peccaries. Their legs were relatively long and their skulls were particularly large for a peccary. Their canine teeth formed a set of sharpened tusks which they could use as defensive weapons or as tools used to dig in search of roots and edible tubers. The spinous processes on the vertebrae near the shoulder were quite long in these animals and would have been held off the ground at a higher position than the pelvis, giving Mylohyus ’s back a distinctive sloped posture. The genus first appears in the fossil record around the start of the Pliocene epoch and quickly spread across a large part of the southern and eastern areas of the North American continent. Knowledge about their social structure is somewhat murky but they seem to have lived in smaller groups than other ancient peccaries like Platygonus. (BELOW) Skeleton of Mylohyus naustus. The long front legs of these animals and their tall spinous processes gave their backs a distinctive sloped appearance. Their skulls were also very long compared with those of other types of peccaries. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo uploaded by user Reynosa Blogs, CC BY-SA 2.0 (BELOW) Photo of the lower jaw of a Pleistocene specimen of Mylohyus nasutus showing the shape and orientation of the canine tusks as well as the distinctive shapes of the molars of these peccaries. Fossil collected in Allegany County, Maryland by J. W. Gidley. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain Image. Flat-headed peccary Platygonus compressus Temporal Range: 10.3 million years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North and South America Species: P. compressus, P. brachirostris, P. chapadmalensis, P. cinctus, P. kraglievichi, P. marplatensis, P. narinoensis, P. oregonensis, P. pearcei, P. pollenae, P. scagliae, P. setiger, P. striatus, P. texanus, P. vetus Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Platygonus was the most widespread genus of North American peccaries from the Pleistocene epoch but its evolutionary history goes back all the way to the Miocene. In terms of its general appearance, it was similar in size and shape to today’s collared peccaries. The name “flat-headed peccary” refers to the shape of the animal’s forehead, which was smooth with no sharp differences in the angles between the slope of the bones of the forehead and the slope of the nasal bones. Relative to their body sizes, Platygonus peccaries had smaller skulls than their contemporaries like Mylohyus . Fossil assemblages of the remains of large groups of Platygonus are often found in caves, suggesting that they may have used these areas as a source of shelter. They also seem to have been very social animals, with perhaps dozens of animals living together in herds. Peccaries in the genus Platygonus were particularly common in eastern North America, but ranged much further south as well, with other species of Platygonus known from fossils found as far away as Argentina. (BELOW) Skeleton of Platygonus compressus. N ote that the skulls of these animals are much shorter and deeper than those of Mylohyus peccaries. Fossil is on display at the Harvard Museum of Natural History. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by David Starner, CC BY-SA 3.0 Prosthennops Temporal Range: 15 - 5 million years ago Geographic Range: Southern US, Central America Species: P. condoni, P. haroldcooki, P. kernensis, P. niobrarensis, P. rex, P. serus, P. xiphodonticus, P. ziegleri Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Prosthennop s was a medium-sized genus of peccaries. The skulls of these animals show that they had flattened muzzles and skulls with eye sockets positioned toward the rear of their heads. The front of the upper jaws of these animals held two pairs of incisors, although the second pair seem to have been reduced in many specimens. Their large canines on both the upper and lower jaws had an elliptical cross-section and pointed downward rather than forward while the premolars of these animals were highly molarized, meaning they had developed shapes similar to the grinding teeth found at the back of the mouths of many mammals. The true molars at the very back of the mouth were low-crowned and were coated in a thick protective layer of enamel. The chewing surfaces of these molars were covered in simple, rounded cusps suited to crushing food, and not built for grinding up grassy vegetation. Compared with living peccaries, Prosthennops would have had a more heavily reinforced skull and much larger cheek projections. Its snout was also shorter than that of long-faced fossil peccaries such as the genus Mylohyus . Unlike extinct peccaries with sharply ridged teeth, Prosthennops had relatively simple, rounded grinding chewing surfaces. Some fossils historically placed within the genus also show slender lower jaws and remarkably long, blade-like canines. However, some paleontologists have questioned whether all these specimens belong to the genus Prosthennops. Protherohyus Temporal Range: Late Miocene Geographic Range: Great Plains, Florida, Indiana, Mexico, Costa Rica Species: P. brachydontus Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Protherohyus was an extinct North American peccary from the Neogene period. These animals had the same kinds of heavily-built pig like bodies seen in most types of peccaries, although the structure of the cheek teeth seen in the skulls of animals in this genus would have been somewhat unusual. Instead of the simple, rounded cusps which we find in many related peccaries, Protherohyus would have had molars and premolars with pronounced ridges connecting their cusps. Together, these ridges created grinding surfaces which were well suited to breaking down tough and fibrous plants. Fossils from Florida suggest that these animals ate a comparatively high proportion of C4 vegetation, probably including grasses as well as softer leaves. This diet differed from that of the contemporary long-snouted peccary Mylohyus , which consumed more hard, woody browse. The dental anatomy of Protherohyus is also one of the features which can be used to differentiate between these animals and closely related peccaries in the genus Prosthennops . The latter had low-crowned molars with simpler, rounded cusps, along with premolars that closely resembled molars. Some types of living peccaries generally feed on food items which they find in forest environments, but Protherohyus appears to preferred to eat vegetation from more open habitats, somewhat similar to the diet of the living javelina. Skinnerhyus Temporal Range: 13.6 - 10.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Nebraska Species: S. shermerorum Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Skinnerhyus was an extinct genus of peccaries with long wing-shaped growths positioned along the outer edges of their cheekbones. These flanges of bone are somewhat shorter than those of animals like Mckennahyus but still quite large. These flanges of bone were one of the key anatomical features which was used to separate this genus from other types of Neogene peccaries such as the genera and living peccaries, none of which would have had such large flange-like projections. The biological purpose of these enlarged structures remains unknown. The textures on the outsides of the bones may indicate that they supported or could have been covered over by layers of additional soft tissues and/or functioned as visual display structures, but currently available fossils cannot confirm either explanation. The genus was described in 2013 based on Miocene fossils found in Nebraska. Stirtonhyus Temporal Range: Middle Miocene Geographic Range: Nebraska Species: S. xiphodonticus Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Stirtonhyus was an extinct North American peccary closely related to animals like Prosthennops . These animals had lower jaws which were unusually narrow and lightly built compared with the deep, powerful mandibles seen in many other fossil peccaries. Their lower canines were relatively long and thin. Their swordlike appearance inspired the species name “xiphodonticus” (sword-toothed). There was also a small gap in front of each of their canines, and the gap between the canines and the rear chewing teeth, known as the diastema, was very long in the skulls of animals in the genus Stirtonhyus. Musk Deer (Moschidae) Deer-Like Artiodactyls With Long Canine Teeth Musk deer are small even-toed hoofed mammals who are only distantly related to true deer in the family Cervidae. These animals do not grow antlers and instead, male musk deer have very long upper canine teeth that extend downward like tusks. These canines look similar to the saber teeth seen in some types of carnivorous mammals but in musk deer they are used as display structures rather than as tools for hunting. North American fossil musk deer from the Ogallala formation belong to an extinct group called the blastomerycines, which were common in many Miocene mammal communities. Some of these animals had much longer muzzles than their living relatives. The fossils of these animals are found in the main ash layer at the Ashfall Fossil Beds. Blastomeryx Temporal Range: 20.4 - 10.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across the Great Plains, Florida Species: B. cursor, B. gemmifer, B. vigoratus Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Blastomeryx was a small genus of Miocene musk deer and the namesake of the family Blastomerycinae. Their bodies were gracile and lightly built when compared with the more sturdy and well-built frames associated with true deer. Its upper canine teeth were very large as is the case for most musk deer, and would have formed prominent tusks that may have served as defensive weapons and/or as displays of fitness, maturity and health. One particularly unique feature found in these animals is that some Blastomery x fossils have small bony projections on their skulls. These knobs have been interpreted as early hornlike structures and is an unusual characteristic for musk deer, which generally do not have any sort of antlers. Longirostromeryx Temporal Range: Miocene - Late Pliocene Geographic Range: Nebraska, Kansas, Texas, New Mexico Species: L. wellsi, L. clarendoniensis, L. novomexicanus Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Longirostromeryx was an extinct genus of musk deer named for its elongated snout. The name of the genus translates roughly to “long-faced deer”. This long skull shape was quite different from the shorter muzzle seen in many other musk deer, including the living members of this family. Like other members of the moschid family Longirostromeryx would not have had any antlers. They had mouths with saber-shaped canine teeth and these canines were longer and more curved in males than in females. Research on the well-preserved species L. wellsi tells us that its forelimbs and upper hind limbs were not specialized entirely for rapid running. Most other types of musk deer which tend/tended to be adapted exclusively to either open environments or dense vegetation have proportionally longer legs relative to the sizes of their bodies. Anatomical comparisons suggest that Longirostromeryx most closely resembled other closely related members of the extinct musk deer subfamily Blastomerycidae. Oreodonts (Merycoidodontoidea) Sheep-Like Artiodactyls With Short Snouts Oreodonts are a now extinct group of hoofed mammals which were common in North America during the Oligocene and Miocene epochs. These animals had pig-like bodies and tall skulls with short snouts. Many of these animals also had long tails. Over the course of their evolutionary history oreodonts occupied many types of ecological niches. Some earlier animals were capable tree-climbers, while others would have spent a lot of time in the water like miniature hippos. The Oreodont fossils found in the Ogallala Formation come from animals who were terrestrial generalists who had teeth which seem to have been adapted to feeding on woody browse. Merychyus Temporal Range: 20.4 - 10.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Texas, California, Oregon, Nebraska, South Dakota, North Dakota, Idaho, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Wyoming, Saskatchewan Species: M. elegans, M. arenarum, M. calaminthus, M. minimus, M. relictus Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Merychyus was a mid-sized genus of oreodonts with fairly short faces. They would have had reinforced tusklike canine teeth and broad cheek teeth that were low and flattened for grinding vegetation. Like other oreodonts, Merychyus walked on four-toed hooves, but its legs were short, which would have given it a torso which sat relatively close to the ground when compared with other oreodonts. Like many of their relatives, this genus would have had a long tail. Species of Merychyu s could vary quite a bit in size: Merychyus calaminthus was small-bodied, whereas forms historically assigned to Merychyus major were much larger. (BELOW) Skeleton of Merychyus elegans collected from the Miocene of Nebraska, on display at the Royal Ontario Museum. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain. Ticholeptus Temporal Range: 16.0 - 13.6 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America Species: T. zygomaticus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Ticholeptu s was a North American oreodont genus from the Middle Miocene. Like most other oreodonts, it had a heavy, piglike body, four functional toes, fang-like canines, and cheek teeth with crescent-shaped ridges used for grinding up plant matter. Its premolars and molars were closely packed together and increased in size toward the rear of the jaw. The cheek teeth were somewhat high-crowned which would have allowed them to sustain more wear than the lower-crowned teeth of earlier browsing oreodonts, although they were still less specialized than the extremely tall teeth developed by animals like Ustatochoerus . Some skulls also show partial retraction of the nasal bones, which may be a sign that these animals had a flexible muscular upper lip. Ustatochoerus Temporal Range: 23 - 7.2 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across the Great Plains and western North America Species: U. calaminthus, U. californicus, U. leptoscelus, U. major, U. medius, U. profundus, U. tedfordi. Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Ustatochoerus was one of the last surviving North American oreodonts. It would have been built along the same lines as the typical oreodont body plan, with a short muzzle, enlarged canines, a heavy torso, a long tail, compact feet, and four functional toes. However, successive species of this genus became considerably larger over time. The occipital region at the rear of the skull also became increasingly flared, which would have given these animals a broader head than those seen in many earlier types of oreodonts. Over the course of the Miocene, some species of Ustatochoerus developed increasingly high-crowned cheek teeth. The taller molars of later species were able to withstand greater wear. In some specimens of U. major, the unworn crown of the third lower molar measured approximately three and a half times its width, the highest degree of hypsodonty (crown-height) recorded among oreodonts. The premolars of these animals also became more molar-like over time, which would have increased the number of chewing surfaces available for grinding up vegetation. Most other oreodonts had lower-crowned, less specialized teeth with crescent-shaped ridges. Their unique tooth structure may be a sign that oreodonts of the genus Ustatochoerus were increasingly adapting to feed more on grass as the Miocene progressed and forest habitats covered less area in central North America. See the rest of our entries about Ogallala artiodactyls by continuing to the next page Next Page Suggested References: Artiodactyls Chen, Katheryn. (2015). Ecology and Morphology of the Late Miocene Musk Deer, Longirostromeryx wellsi (Artiodactyla: Moschidae: Blastomerycinae). Frick, C. (1937). "Horned ruminants of North America". Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History. 69: 1–669. Janis, Christine M.; Theodor, Jessica M.; Boisvert, Bethany (2002). "Locomotor evolution in camels revisited: a quantitative analysis of pedal anatomy and the acquisition of the pacing gait". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 22 (1): 110–121 Marriott, Katherine; Prothero, Donald R.; Lukowski, Stephanie M.; Forcellati, Meghan R. (2026). "CHAPTER 10: VAMPYROCAMELUS WELSHI, A NEW GENUS AND SPECIES OF GIRAFFE-LIKE CAMEL (ARTIODACTYLA: CAMELIDAE)". New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin. 104: 221–233. Lander, B. (1998). "Oreodontoidea". In Janis, C.M.; Scott, K.M.; Jacobs, L.L. (eds.). Evolution of Tertiary mammals of North America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 402–425 Prothero, Donald (2007). The Evolution of Artiodactyls. Johns Hopkins University Press. Sánchez, Israel M.; Cantalapiedra, Juan L.; Ríos, María; Quiralte, Victoria (2015). "Systematics and Evolution of the Miocene Three-Horned Palaeomerycid Ruminants (Mammalia, Cetartiodactyla)". PLoS One. 10 (12) Semprebon, Gina; Janis, Christine; Solounias, Nikos (2004). "The Diets of the Dromomerycidae (Mammalia: Artiodactyla) and Their Response to Miocene Vegetational Change". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 24 (2): 427–444 Semprebon, G.M.; Rivals, F. (September 2007). "Was grass more prevalent in the pronghorn past? An assessment of the dietary adaptations of Miocene to Recent Antilocapridae (Mammalia: Artiodactyla)". Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 253 (3–4): 332–347. Sowls, Lyle K. (1997). Javelinas and Other Peccaries: Their Biology, Management, and Use (2nd ed.). Texas A&M University Press . pp. 67–68. Stevens, M.S.; Stevens, J.B. (1996). "Merycoidodontinae and Miniochoerinae". In Prothero, D.R.; Emry, R.J. (eds.). The terrestrial Eocene-Oligocene transition in North America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 498–573.

  • Western Interior Sea guide | Prehistoric Midwest

    An online guide to the animals found in the Western Interior Sea, including mosasaurs, plesiosaurs, pterosaurs and giant Cretaceous sharks Guide To The Western Interior Sea An ancient seaway once covered the Great Plains Between 100 and 70 million years ago during the Cretaceous period, the part of North America we now call the Great Plains was in the process of sinking while sea levels rose to some of the highest levels ever seen in Earth’s history. The result of these two processes working in tandem was the slow ingression of the waters of the Arctic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico into the American midcontinental region, with inland seas forming over the continental shelf in the North and South. Eventually these northern and southern seas joined together, forming a long narrow body of water we now call the Western Interior Sea. At its height, this sea spanned from southern Texas to the Canadian Arctic, splitting the continent in two. The waters of this seaway were warm and shallow, estimated to have been no more than 3,000 feet deep. Today we find the fossils of the ancient denizens of these prehistoric waters in the layers of limestone and shale located beneath much of the Great Plains, including the remains of mosasaurs, plesiosaurs, giant fish, sharks and even some rare fossils of dinosaurs whose bodies were washed out to sea. Browse animals by taxonomic group Or scroll to the bottom of the page to browse by genus Vertebrate fauna Mosasaurs and kin (Squamata) Mosasaurs, Dolichosaurids Explore Plesiosaurs (Plesiosauria) Elasmosaurids, Polycotylids, Pliosaurs Explore Ichthyosaurs (Ichthyosauria) Fish-Shaped Marine Reptiles Explore Archosaurs (Archosauria) Dinosaurs, Pterosaurs, Crocs, Seabirds Explore Turtles (Testudines) Protostegids And Other Sea Turtles Explore Shallow Water Coelacanths Explore Latimiriid Coelacanths (Latimiriidae) Explore Lamniform Sharks, Carpet Sharks, etc. Sharks (Selachii) Other Cartilaginous Fishes Rays, Sawskates, Guitarfish Explore Explore Gars and Teleost Fishes Ray-Finned Fishes (Actinopterygii) Invertebrate fauna Ammonoids (Ammonoidea) Monomorph and Heteromorph Ammonites Explore Coleoids and Nautiloids Octopods, Belemnites, Nautilids Explore Snails (Gastropoda) Marine And Estuarine Aquatic Snails Explore Bivalves (Bivalvia) Rudists, Clams, Mussels, Oysters Explore Arthropods (Arthropoda) Crabs, Horseshoe Crabs, Barnacles, Shrimp Explore Sea Lilies, Starfishes, Brittle Stars, Urchins Explore Crinoids, Sea Urchins (Echinodermata) Explore Misc. Invertebrates: Bryozoa, Sponges, Brachiopods, Corals The Geography of the Western Interior Sea Although the Western Interior Sea spanned all the way from the Arctic circle to the Caribbean, the waters of the ocean were very shallow. The ocean floor wasn't covered in corals in the same way as today’s tropical coastal waters. It was instead composed of a thick layer of ooze and slime, home to many different species of large bivalves. Explore the Interior Sea Browse vertebrates by genus Squamates Clade Mosasauria Clidastes Dallasaurus Ectenosaurus Eonatator Globidens Gnathomortis Jormungandr Latoplatecarpus Mosasaurus Clade Mosasauria (continued) Platecarpus Plesioplatecarpus Plioplatecarpus Prognathodon Russellosaurus Selmasaurus Tylosaurus Family Dolichosauridae Coniasaurus Plesiosaurs Pliosaurs (Suborder Pliosauroidea) Brachauchenius Megacephalosaurus Elasmosaurs (Family Elasmosauridae) Albertonectes Elasmosaurus Libonectes Nakonanectes Plesioelasmosaurus Styxosaurus Terminonatator Thalassomedon Wapuskanectes Leptocleidids (Family Leptocleididae) Nichollssaura Polycotylids (Family Polycotylidae) Dolichorhynchops Edgarosaurus Martinectes Pahasapasaurus Plesiopleurodon Polycotylus Serpentisuchops Trinacromerum Unktaheela Ichthyosaurs Athabascasaurus Maiaspondylus Archosaurs Non-avian dinosaurs Claosaurus Niobrarasaurus Birds (Class Aves) Apatornis Baptornis Fumicollis Guildavis Hesperornis Iaceornis Ichthyornis Parahesperornis Pasquiaornis Pterosaurs (Order Pterosauria) Aetodactylus Alamodactylus Cimoliopterus Nyctosaurus Pteranodon Clade Crocodylomorpha Deinosuchus Terminonaris Sea Turtles Archelon Chelosphargis Ctenochelys Desmatochelys Kansastega Lophochelys Porthochelys Prionochelys Protostega Toxochelys Coelacanths Megalocoelacanthus Sharks Order Orectolobiformes Chiloscyllium Cretorectolobus Orectoloboides Plicatoscyllium Order Lamniformes Archaeolamna “Carcharias” Cardabiodon Cretolamna/Cretalamna Cretodus Cretoxyrhina Dallasiella Johnlongia Leptostyrax Odontaspis Paranomotodon Protolamna Pseudocorax Pseudomegachasma Ptychodus Scapanorhynchus Squalicorax Order Carcharininiformes Archaeotriakis Galeorhinus Palaeogaleus Squatigaleus Order Synechodontiformes Paraorthacodus Synechodus Order Squatiniformes Squatina Order Heterodontiformes Heterodontus Order Squaliformes Squalus Order Hexanchiformes Hexanchus Unclear Affinities Aquilolamna Rays, Hybodonts and Batomorphs Stingrays (Order Myliobatiformes) Dasyatis Myliobatis Rhombodus Skates (Order Rajiformes) Ischyrhiza Onchopristis Ptychotrygon Texatrygon Walteraja Chimaeras (Order Chimaeriformes) Edaphodon Ischyodus Hybodonts (Order Hybodontiformes) Lonchidion Meristodonoides Guitarfishes (Rhinopristiformes) Pseudohypolophus Rhinobatos Myledaphus Proplatyrhina Ray-Finned Fishes Order Ichthyodectiformes Gillicus Ichthyodectes Prosaurodon Saurocephalus Saurodon Xiphactinus Order Pycnodontiformes Anomoeodus Coelodus Gyrodus Micropycnodon Palaeobalistum Order Semionotiformes Hadrodus Order Crossognathiformes Apsopelix Elopopsis Pachyrhizodus Order Elopiformes Laminospondylus Family Pachycormidae Bonnerichthys Protosphyraena Order Aulopiformes Apateodus Cimolichthys Enchodus Leptecodon Stratodus Order Beryciformes Caproberyx Kansius Order Tselfatiiformes Bananogmius Enischnorhynchus Ferrifrons Luxilites Martinichthys Niobrara Pentanogmius Pseudanogmius Syntegmodus Thryptodus Zanclites Order Polymixiiformes Omosoma Order Albuliformes Paralbula Pollerspoeckia Family Apogonidae Apogonidarum Order Amiiformes Cyclurus Paraliodesmus? Order Anguiliformes Anguilavus Urenchelys Family Ariidae Vorhisia Order Aspidorhynchiformes Belonostomus Family Lepisosteidae Atractosteus Lepisosteus Browse invertebrates by family, order or class Ammonoids (Browse by family) Family Acanthoceratidae Acanthoceras Burroceras Calycoceras Conlinoceras Cunningtoniceras Dunveganoceras Eucalycoceras Mammites Morrowites Neocardioceras Paraconlinoceras Plesiacanthoceras Plesiacanthaceratoides Pseudaspidoceras Spathites Tarrantoceras Watinoceras Family Anisoceratidae Allocrioceras Family Baculitidae Baculites Sciponoceras Family Binneyitidae Borissiakoceras Family Brancoceratidae Mortoniceras Oxytropidoceras Family Coilopoceratidae Coilopoceras Family Collignoniceratidae Collignoniceras Menabites Prionocyclus Texanites Family Desmoceratidae Moremanoceras Parapuzosia Family Dipoloceratidae Hystoceras Family Engonoceratidae Engonoceras Metengonoceras Family Forbesiceratidae Forbesiceras Family Gaudryceratidae Anagaudryceras Family Hamitidae Stomohamites Hamites Family Muniericeratidae Tragodesmoceras Family Nostoceratidae Cirroceras Didymoceras Exiteloceras Eubostrychoceras Family Pachydiscidae Eopachydiscus Pachydiscus Family Placenticeratidae Placenticeras Proplacenticeras Family Scaphitidae Clioscaphites Desmoscaphites Discoscaphites Haresiceras Hoploscaphites Jeletzkytes Scaphites Trachyscaphites Yezoites Family Schloenbachiidae Schloenbachia Family Sphenodiscidae Sphenodiscus Family Turrilitidae Mariella Ostlingoceras Turrilites Family Vascoceratidae Vascoceras Coleoids and Nautiloids (Browse by subclass) Subclass Coleoidea Belemnites Enchoteuthis Muensterella Niobrarateuthis Subclass Nautiloidea Stenzeloceras Eutrephoceras Cymatoceras Gastropods (Browse by subclass) Subclass Caenogastropoda Family Aporrhaidae Anchura Drepanochilus Lispodesthes Family Buccinidae Aliofusus Family Cancellariidae Caveola Family Capulidae Trichotropis Family Cassiopidae Gymnentome Family Cerithiidae Cerithium Hemicerithium Levicerithium Macrocerithium Voysa Vascellum Family Cerithopsidae Monroea Family Epitoniidae Epitonium Family Fasciolariidae Bellifusus Fasciolaria Fusinus Graphidula Paleosephaea Piestochilus Family Gyrotropidae Lirpsa Family Naticidae Euspira Gyrodes Lunatia Natica Family Pseudomelaniidae Psedomelania Family Sarganidae Hillites Family Thiaridae Pyrgulifera Family Turritellidae Cragina Mesalia Turritella Caenogastropoda (continued) Family Tylostomatidae Tylostoma Family Vanikoridae Vanikoropsis Family Viviparidae Campeloma Family Volutidae Parvivoluta Tovula Subclass Heterobranchia Family Acteonidae Fictoacteon Pirsila Family Pyramidellidae Turbonilla Family Ringiculidae Cinulia Ringicula Family Siphonariidae Anisomyon Subclass Neritimorpha Family Neritidae Nerita Subclass Patellogastropoda Family Acmaeidae Acmaea Subclass Vetigastropoda Family Eucyclidae Amberleya Family Fissurelidae Diadora Family Pleurotomariidae Pleurotomaria Family Turbinidae Turbo Bivalves (Browse by order) Order Adapedonta Leptosolen Panope Panopea Siliqua Superorder Anomalodesmata Anatyma Cuspidaria Geniomya Laternula Pholadomya Psilomya Order Arcida Breviarca Cuculea Idonearca Limopsis Parallelodon Protarca Order Cardiida Callistina Cardium Cyclorisma Nelltia Protocardia Protodonax Solyma Tancredia Tellina Tellinimera Trachycardium Order Carditida Crassatella Opis Venericardia Order Hippuritida Durania Eoradiolites Hippurites Proradiolites Sauvagesia Order Lucinida Clissocolus Ctena Lucina Nympholucina Sexta Order Myalinida Cremnoceramus Inoceramus Myalinida Mylitoides Volviceramus Order Myida Caryocorbula Corbula Opertochasma Parmicorbula Pholas Ursirivus Order Mylitida Brachidontes Botula Crenella Lithophaga Modiolus Volsella Order Nuculanida Malletia Nuculana Yoldia Order Nuculida Acila Nucula Order Ostreida Crassostrea Exogyra Gervilliopsis Gryphaea Lopha Nanostrea Pseudoperna Pycnodonte Tenuipteria Texigryphaea Order Pteriida Phelopteria Pteria Order Pectinida Anomia Lima Pecten Plicautula Neithea Syncyclonema Order Solemyida Solemya Order Trigoniida Trigonia Order Venerida Arctica Callistina Corbicula Cyclorisma Cyprimeria Dentonia Flaventia Legumen Arthropods (Browse by class, order) Horseshoe crabs (Order Xiphosura) Limulus Clam shrimp (Superorder Diplostraca) Cyzicus Seed shrimp (Class Ostracoda) Cytherella Barnacles (Subclass Ciripedia) Stramentum Decapods (Order Decapoda) Ghost shrimp (Familly Callianassidae) Protocallianassa Prawns (Suborder Dendrobranchiata) Penaeus Spiny lobsters (Infraorder Achelata) Linuparis Panulirus Rugafarius Lobsters (Infraorder Astacidae) Hoploparia True crabs (Infraorder Brachyura) Echinoderms (Browse by class) Sea Urchins (Class Echinoidea) Codiopsis Cottaldia Goniopygus Cassidulus Echinobrissus Nucleolites Globator Tetragramma Crassiholaster Holaster Anorthopygus Holectypus Gauthiera Phymosoma Goniophorus Salenia Hemiaster Sea Urchins (continued) Heteraster Holanthus Mecaster Micraster Sea Lilies (Class Crinoidea) Dunnicrinus Lakotacrinus Uintacrinus Starfishes (Class Asteroidea) Astrocratis Betelgeusia Coulonia Brittle Stars (Class Ophiuroidea) Brezinacantha Misc. Invertebrates (Browse by phylum) Brachiopods (Phylum Brachiopoda) Lingula Terebratulida Bryozoans (Phylum Bryozoa) Membranipora Pyripora Sponges (Phylum Porifera) Actinostromaria Cliona Stony Corals (Order Scleractinia) Astrangia Thamnasteria Updates - Our Blog Visit our Updates blog for more information about future additions to our website. You can access our blog by clicking the link below: Visit Our Blog Page

  • The Paleozoic Era | Prehistoric Midwest

    The Western Interior Sea once spanned from the Gulf of Mexico to the Arctic Ocean and split North America in two during the Late Cretaceous period The Paleozoic Era 538.8 million years ago - 252 million years ago The Paleozoic era is the span of time lasting from the start of the Cambrian period 538.8 million years ago and lasting up until the end of the Permian period around 252 million years ago. This era lasted longer than the entire lengths of the Mesozoic and Cenozoic eras combined and saw life on Earth move into many of the familiar niches we associate with living things found all around us today. Fossils of Paleozoic organisms preserve the remains of the first carnivorous animals, the first arthropods, the first land plants, the first trees, the first vertebrates and the first animals to move out of the water and onto the land. Many deposits dating back to periods of time during the Paleozoic are found in the Midwest. Some of the best known of these fossil bearing rock exposures are the late Devonian Cleveland Shale from Ohio which contains the fossils of giant arthrodires like Dunkleosteus, and the exceptionally preserved Carboniferous-aged Mazon Creek Formation in Illinois, where fossils of hundreds of types of small aquatic soft-bodied organisms are preserved pressed within small rocky nodules. In deposits from the Great Plains, such as those at the Hamilton quarry and Elmo quarry sites in Kansas, we find fossils of a huge variety of insects, as well as the skeletons of some of the oldest members of the reptile family tree. Previous Section The Early Earth Next Section The Mesozoic Era The Cambrian Period: 538.8 - 486 million years ago The Cambrian is a time period lasting from 538 to 486 million years ago and is the first time period of the Paleozoic era. Most Cambrian fossils come from marine deposits, although some rarer localities occasionally preserve the remains of animals which were deposited along the edges of beaches. At the Blackberry Hill site in Wisconsin, for example, traces of ancient jellyfishes who happened to wash to shore during the middle-late Cambrian period are preserved as circular ridge-like marks formed on top of the wavy patterns left behind by the movement of tidal waters. Small sand stromatolites are also found in these areas, as are traces of what seem to be trackways left behind by a scuttling arthropod, most likely an aquatic myriapod, and the slip marks deposited by the movement of a snail-like mollusk. These trackways seem to have been laid down outside of the water and are some of the first known traces in the fossil record of complex animals leaving the ocean to crawl out onto land. Other types of Cambrian fossils are found in other parts of the upper Midwest, with the remains of corals, trilobites, sponges, brachiopods, jellyfishes, graptolites and mollusks turning up in parts of Michigan, Wisconsin, Illinois and Iowa. Much of the Midwest would have been outside of the water on top of the ancient paleocontinent of Laurentia during the early part of the Cambrian period. These terrestrial areas would have been nearly devoid of all complex life, covered in vast featureless deserts with the only organisms found in these areas being hardy bacteria and archaea. By the later part of the Cambrian however, the seas to the south of Laurentia expanded and covered many of the low-lying parts of the ancient landmass, bringing shallow water reef ecosystems into a vast embayment stretching across the area between what is now Ohio and central Minnesota. (ABOVE) Opabinia was one of the strangest animals known from fossils dated to the Cambrian period. These animals had five eyes, a long trunk-like proboscis, and a series of paddle-like appendages running along the sides of their bodies. Their fossils are found in the Burgess Shale in British Columbia. (ABOVE) An extant brachiopod in the genus Lingula . The first brachiopods appeared during the Cambrian period. Although they seem superficially similar to bivalves like clams and oysters they are actually part of their own separate phylum. The Cambrian Period 486 million years ago The Ordovician Period The Ordovician Period: 486 - 443.1 million years ago Fossils of marine life dating back to the Ordovician period are commonly found across much of the northern and eastern Midwest. Fossils of bryozoans, rugose corals and brachiopods are among the most common remains dated to this time period but some deposits also preserve the remains of new types of trilobites which were going through a diversification event during the Ordovician as they moved into new niches and developed new external features such as elaborate tubercles and spines. One of the best known Ordovician trilobites is the genus Flexicalimene, which is notable for having been able to fully roll itself up into a ball, similarly to a modern woodlouse. Its remains are particularly common in parts of western Ohio and eastern Indiana. These animals lived in some of the largest reef ecosystems ever to exist in the history of the Earth, although most of these reefs were composed of colonies of rugose corals. Modern stony corals would not appear until much later during the Triassic period. The first simple land plants also appeared during the Ordovician. These were small low-lying organisms who were well-adapted for spending their lives in the rocky, nutrient-poor sun-baked terrestrial landscape. The world’s climate at the start of the Ordovician was fairly warm and much of the Midwest was initially covered in ocean. Over the course of the Ordovician, a series of ice ages would lock up large amounts of water at the poles. These ice sheets caused sea levels to fluctuate wildly over the course of the Ordovician. Around 470 million years ago most of the Midwest was above water once again but over the course of the rest of the Ordovician the oceans would slowly encroach over the Laurentian landmass until by around 450 million years ago the entire region was once again covered in a shallow sea. Glaciation events at the end of the Ordovician would, however, see the water retreat from areas around Wisconsin and Minnesota. (ABOVE) Conodont animals were some of the most common chordates found in the Paleozoic seas, becoming very abundant during the Ordovician period. They are mostly known from fossils of their jaw elements which look like small serrated blades. Most of these animals were only a few inches long. (ABOVE) Giant cephalopods were some of the largest carnivores found in the Ordovician seas. Animals like Cameroceras and Endoceras had long cone-shaped shells which could grow to be over 12 feet long in some cases! The Ordovician Period 443.1 million years ago The Silurian Period The Silurian Period: 443.1 - 419.3 million years ago The Silurian period is known from layers of sedimentary rocks found all across the Midwest, including in parts of Indiana, Illinois, Wisconsin and Iowa. These deposits were typically formed in marine or coastal environments, with layers linked to deep ocean waters, shallow reefs and beach environments. The Silurian period saw many major milestones in the history of life. On land, some of the first vascular plants appeared during the middle Silurian. Fungi also began to diversify around this time and some of these ancient organisms grew to be the size of small trees. Several groups of arthropods managed to fully transition over to terrestrial life, and some of the first land-dwelling members of the millipede group appeared in the Silurian. Vertebrates were very common at this time as well, although they were still confined to the water. The first jawed vertebrates appeared during the Silurian, including early members of the cartilaginous fish group, distant ancestors of sharks and stingrays. Eurypterid sea scorpions were at the peak of their diversity during the Silurian. These animals were distantly related to horseshoe crabs, although some of these chelicerates were powerful carnivores who could grow to be well over 8 feet long. Sea levels were highly variable during the Silurian and cycles of rising and falling water levels took place over millions of years as global temperatures rose and fell. Shallow ocean waters would have covered many of the low-lying areas across the Midwest, leading to the development of some of the largest reef systems ever to form in this region. Further to the east the Caledonian Orogeny, a collision between the European continental plates and the North American landmass, resulted in the continuation of a period of mountain building in parts of eastern North America, the Scottish highlands, Greenland and Norway. (ABOVE) Some sea scorpions like Carcinosoma had long grabbing appendages lined with sharp spines instead of the crab-like claws seen in some of their relatives. These ancient arthropods could grow to be very large and some genera would have been over 8 feet long. (ABOVE) Trilobites continued to be very successful during the Silurian period. Some of these animals even developed large spines, tubercles and tall eye stalks. The Silurian Period 419.3 million years ago The Devonian Period The Devonian Period: 419.3 - 358.8 million years ago The Devonian period is sometimes called the “Age of Fishes” and for good reason. Fossils of ancient armored placoderms and sharks are some of the most distinctive fossils found in Devonian rock layers. The Cleveland Shale in Ohio, for instance, preserves the remains of several dozen ancient fish species, including the famous arthrodire Dunkleosteus terrelli. These armored fishes did not have actual teeth in their mouths. They would have instead used extensions of their bony cranial armor to shear through prey or to crush hard-shelled animals. Ammonoids also appeared for the first time during the Devonian. These early ammonoids had much more simple suture patterns than their later relatives from the Mesozoic era. These early ammonoids had spiral-shaped shells and soft bodies with long, complex arms similar to those of octopi or cuttlefish. One of the major steps taken by vertebrate life during the Devonian was the start of the tetrapod transition onto land. These tetrapods were lobe-finned fishes who developed over time into animals who were able to spend more and more time outside of the water. Many of the earliest tetrapodomorphs still had fins but later members of this group would develop fully functional limbs and feet able to support the weight of their bodies outside of the water for extended periods of time. Land plants also went through a major diversification event during the Devonian. By the middle of this period large forests of tree-like Archaeopteris and Wattezia plants were found all around the world. These tall vascular plants were some of the first plants to develop a structure resembling a tree trunk. Devonian Animals Ctenacanthus a ctenacanthiform cartilaginous fish Stethacanthus a symmoriiform cartilaginous fish Bungartius an arthrodire Cladoselache a cladoselachiform chimaera relative The Devonian Period 358.8 million years ago The Carboniferous Period The Carboniferous Period: 358.8 - 298.9 million years ago The Carboniferous period lasted from 358.8 million years ago to 298.9 million years ago. In North America the period is often split into an earlier Mississippian subperiod (358.8 - 323 million years ago) and the later Pennsylvanian subperiod (323 - 298.9 million years ago). Rocks from the Carboniferous period are particularly common in the midcontinental region of the Midwest, especially rocks deposited in marine deposits from the Pennsylvanian which outcrop in eastern Kansas, northern Missouri and parts of Iowa, Illinois and Indiana. Older rocks from the Mississippian are also present in parts of southeastern Kansas and southern Missouri. Within these rock layers the most common fossils are those of brachiopods, bryozoans and crinoid columnals. Rocks from coastal wetland environments are also present in the Midwest. Sites like the Mazon Creek fossil beds in Illinois and Hamilton Quarry in Kansas preserve the remains of a wide variety of small freshwater and brackish invertebrates, lungfishes, cartilaginous fishes and insects. Tetrapod fossils are also known from this period. Temnospondyl amphibians were some of the largest animals found on land, usually occupying the niche of aquatic ambush hunters although some of these animals seem to have been almost completely terrestrial. Amniotes also show up during the Carboniferous and early on in their evolution they split into two lines; the sauropsids and the synapsids. The sauropsid group contains all true reptiles and their closest relatives while synapsids include all of today’s mammals as well as a wide variety of superficially reptile-like stem mammals. Early members of these groups were fairly similar to one another and would have had rather lizard-like body plans. Despite this even the fossils of these most basal forms can be distinguished from one another by the shapes of the openings at the back of their skulls. During the Carboniferous period many of the Earth’s continents had begun the process of moving together to form the supercontinent Pangaea. Parts of western North America were covered in water at this time and many parts of the Midwest would have been covered in shallow water reef ecosystems or tropical coastal forests. Sea levels rose and fell many times, particularly during the later part of the Carboniferous as the climate cooled and large ice sheets around the South Pole advanced and retreated over the course of tens of thousands of years. In many areas with Carboniferous rocks in the Midcontinent region the effects of these changes in sea level can be seen in the rock layers themselves, with bands of marine limestone separated by layers of shale and other mudstones which formed on land or in freshwater environments. Fossils of plants are quite common in terrestrial Carboniferous deposits, including the remains of scale trees, giant horsetails, clubmosses, early conifers and seed ferns. Although scale tree forests were very common during the early and middle Carboniferous, by the end of the period these rainforests became increasingly fragmented and were replaced in many areas with more open environments. Carboniferous Life Calamites a giant horsetail Cordaites an early conifer relative Actiobates a trematopid amphibian Arthropleura a giant millipede Iniopteryx a flying shark Tullimonstrum a mysterious animal from Mazon Creek Whatcheeria a tetrapodomorph Listracanthus a cartilaginous fish The Carboniferous Period 298.9 million years ago The Permian Period The Permian Period: 298.9 - 252 million years ago The Carboniferous period did not end in a major extinction event and the lifeforms found at the start of the Permian period were fairly similar to the kinds of organisms whose fossils are found in rocks from the late Carboniferous. Over the course of the Permian the Earth’s climate generally became cooler and drier, with large deserts expanding across the interior regions of the Pangean supercontinent. Volcanic activity seems to have intensified towards the end of the Permian with a particularly intense series of eruptions taking place in Siberia at the very end of the period. The volcanic activity around the Siberian traps is usually seen as the main driver of the end-Permian mass extinction event which wiped out over 90% of marine species and 70% of terrestrial species. Most Permian deposits in the Midwest date back to the first half of the Permian period. At this time much of what is now central North America was still close to the equator and was very warm and humid all year round despite the cooler global temperatures. The lycopsid rainforests which had dominated much of the Carboniferous period still existed in small pockets during the early Permian but they faced increased competition from conifers which were better adapted to cooler, drier climates.The giant lycopsids had completely vanished by the middle of the Permian period. Amniotes continued to radiate into new forms with the largest animals on land being members of the synapsid branch. Pelycosaurs were particularly successful during the early part of the Permian, with many animals like Dimetrodon and Edaphosaurus developing large sails along their backs. These pelycosaurs were replaced by the more derived therapsids later on in the Permian which occupied both carnivorous and herbivorous ecological niches. Temnospondyls also continued to be very successful, with some animals, like the genus Prionosuchus from Brazil, growing to be as large as saltwater crocodiles. This would likely make them the largest amphibians of all time. Flying insects also diversified quite a lot during the Permian, and the first members of the beetle order Coleoptera show up in the fossil record around 299 million years ago. Permian Life Adelophthalmus a eurypterid Diplocaulus a nectridean amphibian Labidosaurikos a captorhinid Fadenia a eugeneodontid Meganeuropsis a griffinfly Dimetrodon a pelycosaur Psaronius a tree fern Noeggerathia an extinct spore-bearing plant Previous Section The Early Earth Next Section The Mesozoic Era

  • Miocene Feliformes | Prehistoric Midwest

    Feliformes Cats and Barbourofelids Feliformes is the branch of the carnivoran family tree which today includes cats, hyenas, mongooses, civets, and their closest relatives. These animals can be distinguished from other carnivorans by their auditory bullae, a set of bony structures surrounding the middle ear, which are divided into two chambers by a septum. Most feliforms also tend to have short snouts, prominent canine teeth, specialized carnassials that function like blades for cutting flesh, and fewer teeth than caniform carnivorans. Many of these animals have retractable or partly retractable claws. During the Miocene and Pliocene epoch true cats had only recently arrived in North America. Fossils from deposits linked to the Ogallala formation preserve the remains of several early types of saber-toothed cats like Amphimachairodus , a possible ancestor of later animals like the famous genus Homotherium . Other feliforms from this time period included the barbourofelids, a group of false saber-toothed cats who had stocky bear-like bodies and large bony bars underneath their chins. Anatomy Skeletal Anatomy The best known types of feliformes are the members of the family Felidae. These animals have short faces, cutting teeth at the back of their mouths and retractable claws. A few other types of extinct feliform groups also would have had these same features. Barbourofelids and Nimravids were both extremely similar in shape to saber-toothed cats, although they also had their own suites of unique skeletal features. Barbourofelids, for instance, had taller foreheads than true cats. Their cheek teeth were also wider and more heavily built than those of felids. Other feliform mammals diverge from the cat-like body shapes which are usually associated with this group. Hyaenas superficially resemble dogs more so than cats thanks to their long, thin legs and pronounced snouts. Civets also have long muzzles, although their bodies are much more foxlike than the dog-like bodies of hyaenas and they tend to have short legs and long flexible torsos. (BELOW) Skulls of various types of feliform mammals. (A) A Barbourofelis skull on display at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, (B) A cast of a Smilodon skull at the Joseph Moore Museum. Note the similarities in the shapes of the skulls of these animals. (C) A spotted hyaena skull on display at the Field Museum. These animals have longer snouts than cats. Their cheek teeth are also very wide and ideally suited to cracking open bones. External Anatomy Many of the saber-toothed cats whose fossils are found in deposits from the Ogallala Formation share common anatomical features seen in their later relatives such as Smilodon and Homotherium . These animals had tall shoulders, front legs which were taller than their hindlimbs and wide, padded feet. The tails of some Miocene and Pliocene felids were somewhat longer than the bobtails of Pleistocene saber-tooths. Barbourofelids were more heavily built than true saber-toothed cats. The largest species of Barbourofelis could grow to be as large as today's lions, but their bodies were built more like those of bears, with short, robust limbs and stocky torsos. (BELOW) External anatomical features of the saber-toothed cat genus Amphimachairodus. These animals had taller shoulders and shorter tails than today's pantherine big cats. (BELOW) External features of the false saber-toothed cat genus Barbourofelis . These animals had a distinctive bony bar underneath their chins and a stockier frame than most true cats. Feliformes Cats (Family Felidae) Adelphailurus Amphimachairodus Hyperailurictis Nimravides False Sabertooths (Family Barbourofelidae) Barbourofelis Cats (Felidae) Neogene Sabertooth Cats Felids are members of the cat family, Felidae. All members of this group are hypercarnivorous. Their skulls have short snouts, large eye sockets, and strong jaw muscles. They use their long canines to puncture and grip prey and their blade-like carnassial teeth are used to slice meat. Most felids have flexible bodies and padded digitigrade feet. They often have retractable or partly retractable claws which they can keep off the ground when not in use so that they can remain sharp. Their forward-facing eyes provide overlapping fields of vision and give them a much greater degree of depth perception which is very useful when hunting or climbing. Ogallala Formation deposits preserve several fossil felids, particularly in the Ash Hollow Member. The lower Ash Hollow Wray fauna includes the remains of Ampimachairodus coloradensis , a saber-toothed cat. Fossils of Nimravides and Adelphailurus also show up at sites in the Ogallala formation. The presence of this range of cat fossils tells us that the Ogallala supported multiple feline predators living side by side, including saber-toothed cats and other, less specialized forms. They would have hunted many of the other types of animals found at these Neogene sites including ancient horses, camels and rhinos. Adelphailurus Temporal Range: 6.8 – 4.75 million years ago Geographic Range: Western North America from Kansas to southern California Species: A. kansensis Diet: Active carnivore, small to mid-sized mammals Adelphailurus was an extinct saber-toothed cat genus whose fossils are found in western North America in deposits dating back from the middle Miocene to the early Pliocene epoch. The only recognized species in this genus, Adelphailurus kansensis , was a medium-sized predator for its time roughly comparable in size to a modern mountain lion. These animals had some features in common with later sabertooth cats, including a somewhat tall shoulder and elongated face. Unlike the enormous fangs found in later predators such as Smilodon, its upper canines were relatively short, flattened on the sides, and lined with serrated edges. These blade-shaped teeth were adapted for cutting flesh, although they lacked the extreme length of later saber teeth. The animals of this genus also had relatively narrow skulls. Amphimachairodus Temporal Range: 9.8 – 4.4 million years ago Geographic Range: Parts of North America, Eurasia, Africa Species: A. palanderi, A. coloradensis, A. alvarezi , A. giganteus, A. horribilis Diet: Active carnivore, large mammals and other vertebrates The saber-toothed cat genus Amphimachairodu s is known from fossils found in Eurasia, North America, and possibly Africa dating back to the Miocene and early Pliocene. It was part of the homotherine branch of the sabertooth family tree and may have been closely related to the ancestors of later scimitar-toothed cats such as Homotherium itself. These animals had longer saber-shaped canine teeth than most other contemporary Miocene sabertooths, though they were not as enormous as the sabers of later genera such as Smilodon. Amphimachairodus also had a broad forehead and a relatively long muzzle. Many Amphimachairodu s species reached very large sizes and would have had muscular bodies capable of subduing large prey such as horses, camels, rhinos and tapirs. A healed injury found in the bones of the front paws of an Amphimachairodus may be evidence that these animals lived in social groups and that an injured animal may have been cared for by another Amphimachairodus while it was healing. (BELOW) A skull of the possible Amphimachairodus species A.? giganteus showing its large saber-like canines. Image accessed via Wikimedia Commons, uploaded by user Ghedoghedo, CC BY-SA 3.0 Hyperailurictis Temporal Range: 17.5 – 12.7 million years ago Geographic Range: Western North America Species: H. intrepidus, H. marshi, H. skinneri, H. stouti, H. validus Diet: Active carnivore, small to mid-sized mammals Hyperailurictis was a Pseudailurus -grade genus of cats from the Miocene epoch. Different Hyperailurictis species varied considerably in size. Some were similar in size to domestic cats or lynxes, whereas others grew to be nearly as large as leopards. Their jaw and tooth anatomy is one of the key characteristics used to distinguish these animals from other cats. The rear surfaces of their lower first molars were fairly small which would have helped these teeth slice flesh. Hyperailurictis also had a very defined and well-built chin. In some fossils the upper canines seem to be somewhat elongated. Although less extreme than the teeth of later saber-toothed cats, these canines may may be an early stage towards the development of such features. Hyperailurictis is particularly important because it was among the earliest known true cats to arrive in the Americas. Its fossils are found in parts of western and central North America. Nimravides Temporal Range: 11 – 6.5 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America Species: N. thinobates, N. catocopis, N. pedionomus, N. hibbardi, N. galiani Diet: Active carnivore, large mammals and other vertebrates Nimravide s was a genus of sabertooth cats found in Miocene deposits in North America. Although its name is similar to the name of the “false sabertooth cat” family Nimravidae, Nimravides was actually a true member of the cat family. It had fairly short saber teeth, although they were still longer than those of living big cats. Nimravides also had specialized teeth used for cutting meat. Their lower premolars had a distinctive blade-like structure and their carnassial cutting teeth were large and well developed. Based on fossils of postcranial remains assigned to this genus, Nimravides seems to have been a powerfully built, large-bodied hunter whose limbs had proportions resembling those of modern pantherine big cats more so than those of later sabertooth cats. Their limb bones were long and would have allowed these animals to move very quickly while hunting. (BELOW) A skull from a Nimravides galiani on display at the Florida Museum of Natural History. Image accessed via Wikimedia Commons, uploaded by user Geekgecko, CC BY 4.0 Barbourofelids (Barbourofelidae) False Sabertooth Cats Barbourofelids were a family of extinct cat-like carnivorans famous for developing saber teeth independently from true saber-toothed cats. These long, blade-like canine teeth extended far enough down as to protrude below the lower jaw. Their skulls were short and powerfully constructed with strong attachment areas for head and neck muscles and many genera had a wide section of bone at the front apex of their lower jaws. Behind their canines barbourofelids had reduced premolars and blade-like carnassial teeth used to slice through meat. Despite their catlike appearance, barbourofelids were not true members of the cat family. Their classification remains debated, with studies placing them just outside of the family Felidae or within a separate family called Nimravidae. Barbourofelis Temporal Range: 12 – 7 million years ago Geographic Range: Found in parts of North America and Eurasia Species: B. fricki, B. loveorum, B. morrisi, B. oregonensis, B. piveteaui Diet: Active carnivore, large mammals and other vertebrates The genus Barbourofelis was a false saber-toothed cat that lived in North America during the Miocene epoch. Despite its feline appearance, it was not part of the same lineage as true saber-toothed cats. Instead, its saber teeth seem to have developed independently, providing an interesting example of convergent evolution within the feliform group. Its most recognizable adaptations were its enormous, blade-like upper canine teeth, which extended well below the jaw and could be used to inflect deep wounds upon their prey while hunting. Barbourofelis also would have had a sturdy skeleton and powerful forelimbs which suggest that these animals depended on physical power to act as ambush hunters rather than relying on sustained speed to capture prey. The genus included species of different sizes with some reaching sizes comparable to those of living big cats. They may have preferred to live in more forested areas as opposed to open grasslands. Having more places to hide would have allowed them to ambush their preferred prey more easily. (BELOW) A skeleton of a Barbourofelis loveorum on display at the Florida Museum of Natural History. Image accessed via Wikimedia Commons, Photo by Dallas Krentzel, CC BY 4.0 (BELOW) A Hoplophoneus skull on display at the Sternberg Museum of Natural History. Note the large bony chin bar underneath the animal's upper canine teeth. These animals were part of the "false saber-tooth cat" family Nimravidae, which may be close relatives of animals like Barbourofelis . Suggested References: Feliformes Leidy, Joseph (1858). "Notice of Remains of Extinct Vertebrata, from the Valley of the Niobrara River, Collected during the Exploring Expedition of 1857, in Nebraska, under the Command of Lieut. G. K. Warren, U. S. Top. Eng., by Dr. F. V. Hayden, Geologist to the Expedition". Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia. 10: 15–89. Kitt, David B. (1958). "Nimravides, a New Genus of Felidae from the Pliocene of California, Texas and Oklahoma". Journal of Mammalogy. 39 (3): 368–375. Rothwell, Tom (2001). "A partial skeleton of Pseudaelurus (Carnivora, Felidae) from the Nambé Member of the Tesuque Formation, Española Basin, New Mexico" (PDF). American Museum Novitates (3342): 1–31. Chatar, N.; Tseng, Z. J. (2026). "New material of Adelphailurus kansensis sheds light on the cranial anatomy of an early-diverging machairodontine felid". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology e2667939. Turner, Alan; Antón, Mauricio (1997). The Big Cats and their fossil relatives. New York: Columbia University Press. ISBN 0-231-10228-3. Antón, Mauricio (2013). Sabertooth. Bloomington, Indiana: University of Indiana Press. Jiangzuo, Qigao; Li, Shijie; Deng, Tao (2022). "Parallelism and lineage replacement of the late Miocene scimitar-toothed cats from the old and New World". iScience. 25 (12)

  • Ray-finned fishes pt. 2 | Prehistoric Midwest

    Explore the different kinds of ray-finned fishes found in the Western Interior Sea, including animals like Xiphactinus, Enchodus and Pachyrhizodus Ray-finned fishes (continued) Ray-Finned Fishes Order Ichthyodectiformes Gillicus Ichthyodectes Prosaurodon Saurocephalus Saurodon Xiphactinus Order Pycnodontiformes Anomoeodus Coelodus Gyrodus Micropycnodon Palaeobalistum Order Semionotiformes Hadrodus Order Crossognathiformes Apsopelix Elopopsis Pachyrhizodus Order Elopiformes Laminospondylus Family Pachycormidae Bonnerichthys Protosphyraena Order Aulopiformes Apateodus Cimolichthys Enchodus Leptecodon Stratodus Order Beryciformes Caproberyx Kansius Order Tselfatiiformes Bananogmius Enischnorhynchus Ferrifrons Luxilites Martinichthys Niobrara Pentanogmius Pseudanogmius Syntegmodus Thryptodus Zanclites Order Polymixiiformes Omosoma Order Albuliformes Paralbula Pollerspoeckia Family Apogonidae Apogonidarum Order Amiiformes Cyclurus Paraliodesmus? Order Anguiliformes Anguilavus Urenchelys Family Ariidae Vorhisia Order Aspidorhynchiformes Belonostomus Family Lepisosteidae Atractosteus Lepisosteus Previous Page Tselfatiiform Fishes Plethodids of the Western Interior Sea Temporal Range: 113 million years ago - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: North America, Africa, Europe Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Pentanogmius, Bananogmius, Thryptodus, Ferrifrons, Zanclites, Niobrara, Martinichthys, Syntegmodus, Luxilites, Pseudanogmius Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, invertebrates Tselfatiiform fishes were an extinct group of marine bony fishes from the Cretaceous period. They are known for their roughly diamond-shaped bodies that were flattened from side to side. These fishes had reinforced head bones and many species had long, tall dorsal fins and small pelvic fins. The Tselfatiiform fishes of the Western Interior Sea were all part of the family Plethodidae. Most of these animals were fairly small fishes, only a few feet long at most, although a few genera are known to have grown to be more than 5 feet long in some parts of the world. The best known plethodids are animals like Bananogmius and Pentanogmius who would have appeared somewhat similar to today’s angelfishes. Some plethodids had their own unique structures found on their skulls. Martinichthys had a long-spine-like projection issuing from the front of its upper jaw while Thryptodus had a reinforced nasal area which has given it the nickname “battering ram fish”. These animals seem to have been either plankton-eating filter feeders or animals who ate smaller fish. (BELOW) Plethodid genera included some genera with long rostral bones and others with very tall dorsal fins. Some genera like Pentanogmius had significant differences between their different species such as P. evolutus and P. fristchi (BELOW) The plethodid genus Enischnorhynchus has an upermost size estimate which might make it quite a bit larger than many of the other types of plethodids found in the Western Interior Sea. (BELOW) A plethodid tooth plate from the Cenomanian of Texas. Fossil collected and original photo taken by Jared Cooke/ jcookepaleo Squirrelfish Relatives Beryciformes Temporal Range: 100 million years ago - Present day Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Kansius, Caproberyx Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, invertebrates Beryciform fishes are an order of ray-finned fishes which contains today’s squirrelfishes, soldierfishes and their closest relatives. They have large eyes, deep bodies, and long spines supporting their dorsal fins. In the Western Interior Sea, beryciform fishes were mainly represented by members of the family Holocentridae, the same family that includes modern squirrelfishes. One of the best-known genera from this region is Kansius , particularly the species Kansius sternbergi , which has been found in Late Cretaceous chalk formations in Kansas. Fossils show that Kansius was a rather small fish, only a few inches long. Most living and extinct beryciforms also had large mouths and rough scales that helped protect them from predators. Their body shape made them quick and agile swimmers in marine environments. The large eyes may have helped them see better in deeper or dimly lit waters. Beardfishes Polymixiiformes Temporal Range: 93 million years ago - Present day Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Omosoma Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, invertebrates Polymixiiformes (Beardfishes) are a type of fish who are named for the long sensory barbels, or whisker-like structures, located beneath their lower jaws. These barbels were used to help detect food in the water or along the seafloor. Beardfishes also have very large eyes used to see in low light conditions. The best represented genus of beardfishes in the Western Interior Sea is Omosoma . It measured only a few inches long and its fossils are sometimes found inside the shells of large inoceramid clams. They seem to have preferred to live near the seafloor, feeding on small benthic animals. Bonefishes Albuliformes Temporal Range: 147 million years ago - Present day Geographic Range: North America Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Paralbula, Pollerspoeckia Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, crustaceans Albuliformes is an order of ray-finned fishes which contains today’s bonefishes. Cretaceous albuliform fishes look fairly similar to their modern relatives and they are mostly found in deposits formed by shallow water environments in Texas and Montana. They would have had long, streamlined bodies and forked tails with rounded tips. Today’s bonefish are carnivorous animals who hunt for small fishes and invertebrates in near-shore shallow water environments close to the surface. It’s likely that their prehistoric relatives would have occupied similar ecological niches. Some extinct albuliform fish like Paralbula are known from rocks formed in freshwater and brackish habitats. Cardinalfish Apogonidae Temporal Range: ~73 million years ago - Present day Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Apogonidarum Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, invertebrates Cardinalfishes are a group of small ray-finned fishes that belong to the family Apogonidae who have large eyes, relatively large mouths, two separate dorsal fins, and surprisingly strong jaws adapted for feeding on small fish and crustaceans. Modern cardinalfishes are commonly found in reef environments, and fossil species like Apogonidarum show many of the same characteristics as their living kin. Bowfins Amiiformes Temporal Range: ~240 million years ago - Present Geographic Range: North America Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Cyclurus, Paraliodesmus? Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, invertebrates Bowfins belong to the order Amiiformes, a very old group of ray-finned fishes that has been around since the Mesozoic era and are still found today living in freshwater habitats. They have slender bodies and a dorsal fin that extends along much of their back. This long fin helps them swim smoothly and make quick movements while searching for food. Bowfins also have strong jaws lined with sharp teeth which allow them to catch and eat a variety of prey animals. In the Western Interior Seaway, bowfin fossils include the remains of animals like Cyclurus , especially the species Cyclurus fragosus . Fossils of Cyclurus show the classic bowfin features but their presence in chalk deposits from the ancient seaway is good evidence that some ancient bowfins were able to live outside the freshwater habitats which are home to all living species of bowfins. Another genus, Paraliodesmus, may also be a type of bowfin and is known from fossils found in parts of Kansas. Eels Anguilliformes Temporal Range: ~95 million years ago - Present day Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Urenchelys , Anguilavus Diet: Carnivorous, small fish Some early eels were present in the Western Interior Seaway, namely two genera, Urenchelys and Anguillavus . Both of these ancient fishes show the classic elongated body shape we are used to seeing in today’s eels. Some of these genera are known from fairly complete body fossils, some of which seem to show that animals like Urenchelys still had fairly large and deeply forked caudal fins, a feature which is not seen in today’s eels. Saltwater Catfishes Ariidae Temporal Range: ~75 million years ago - Present day Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Vorhisia Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, invertebrates Ariid catfishes, commonly known as sea catfishes, are members of the family Ariidae, a group of catfishes named for their tendency to live in marine environments. They are one of the oldest groups of catfishes and they are easy to recognize with their tall pointed dorsal fins and flattened body shapes. In the Western Interior Seaway, ariid catfishes are known from fossils of a genus called Vorhisia . Most evidence for the presence of Vorhisia in this region comes from fossil otoliths, or ear bones, which are found preserved in marine sediments in parts of the Great Plains. False Needlefishes Aspidorhynchidae Temporal Range: 170 million years ago - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Belonostomus Diet: Carnivorous, small fish Aspidorhynchiform fishes were an extinct group of ray-finned fishes that lived during the Mesozoic Era whose members are often compared to the living needlefishes, although the two groups do not seem to be particularly closely related to one another. In the Western Interior Seaway, the most common and well-known member of the Aspidorhynchiformes was Belonostomus , a fish with a long, narrow snout and a slender spear-like body. They had very large eye openings, deeply forked tails and a very flexible spinal cord. They seem to have been small predatory fishes adapted for hunting in the sunlit waters near the surface. Gars Lepisosteidae Temporal Range: ~150 million years ago - Present day Geographic Range: North America Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Atractosteus, Lepisosteus Diet: Carnivorous, smaller fish Gars are an ancient group of fishes whose fossil record from the Late Cretaceous is very extensive. This record includes genera like Lepisosteus , a genus which is still around today and includes longnose and shortnose gars. Fossils of gars who seem to share some characteristics in common with the larger Alligator gars (Atractosteu s) are also known from this area but they are not as common as the remains of Lepisosteus . The most common gar fossils are the remains of their distinctive diamond-shaped scales, which form a thick layer of defensive armor around the animal in life. See the rest of our entries about Cretaceous ray-finned fishes by returning to the previous page Previous Page Media Gallery Suggested References: Ray-Finned Fishes Alvarado-Ortega, Jesús; Porras- Múzquiz, Héctor ( 2009). "On the occurrence of Gillicus arcuatus (Cope, 1875) (Pisces, Ichthyodectiformes) in Mexico". Boletín de la Sociedad Geológica Mexicana. 61 (2): 215–224. Bardack, D. (1965). "Anatomy and evolution of chirocentrid fishes". The University of Kansas Paleontological Contributions. 10: 1–88. Bell, G. L., Jr. (1986). “A pycnodont fish from the upper Cretaceous of Alabama”. Journal of Paleontology 60(5):1120-1126, 2 figs. Bice, K. N.; Shimada, K.; Kirkland, J. I. (2013). "Late Cretaceous Marine Fishes from the Upper Greenhorn Limestone in Southeastern Nebraska". Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science. 116 (1–2): 22–26. Cope, E. D, (1872), “On the families of fishes of the Cretaceous Formation of Kansas”: Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, v. 12, p. 327-357. Everhart, M. J. (2007). “Remains of a pycnodont fish (Actinopterygii: Pycnodontiformes) in a coprolite; An upper record of Micropycnodon kansasensis in the Smoky Hill Chalk, western Kansas”. Kansas Academy of Science, Transactions 110(1/2): 35-43. Everhart, M. J. (2010). “Bonnerichthys gladius – The largest bony fish and first known planktivore from the Late Cretaceous”. Kansas Academy of Science, Transactions 113(1-2):123-124. Fielitz, C.; Stewart, J. D.; & Wiffen, J. (1999). “Aethocephalichthys hyainarhinos gen. et sp. nov., a new and enigmatic Late Cretaceous actinopterygian from North America and New Zealand”. Mesozoic Fishes 2 – Systematics and Fossil Record, G. Arratia & H.-P. Schultze (eds.): pp. 95-106, 7 figs. Fielitz, Christopher; González-Rodríguez, Katia A. (2010). "A New Species of Enchodus (aulopiformes: Enchodontidae) from the Cretaceous (albian to Cenomanian) of Zimapán, Hidalgo, México". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 30 (5): 1343–1351. Bibcode:2010JVPal..30.1343F. Fielitz C, Shimada K. (1999).”A new species of Bananogmius (Teleostei; Tselfatiformes) from the Upper Cretaceous Carlile Shale of western Kansas”. Journal of Paleontology 73(3): 504-511. Friedman, Matt; Beckett, Hermione T.; Close, Roger A.; Johanson, Zerina (2016). "The English Chalk and London Clay: two remarkable British bony fish Lagerstätten". Geological Society, London, Special Publications. 430 (1): 165–200. Grande, Lance; Bemis, William E. (1998). "A Comprehensive Phylogenetic Study of Amiid Fishes (Amiidae) Based on Comparative Skeletal Anatomy. an Empirical Search for Interconnected Patterns of Natural History". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 18 (sup1): 1–696. Kanarkina, A.; Zverkov, N.; Polyakova, I. (2024). "New evidence of the global distribution of the swordfish-like pachycormid Protosphyraena in the late Early Cretaceous and a review of global records of the genus". Cretaceous Research. 166. Lucas, Spencer G.; Sullivan, Robert M. (2006). “Late Cretaceous Vertebrates from the Western Interior: Bulletin 35”. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. Maisey, J. G., (1996). “Discovering Fossil Fishes”. Henry Holt and Company, New York. McIntosh, A. P.; Shimada, K.; Everhart, M. J. (2016). "Late Cretaceous marine vertebrate fauna from the Fairport Chalk Member of the Carlile Shale in southern Ellis County, Kansas, U.S.A." Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science. Near, Thomas J.; Thacker, Christine E. (2024). "Phylogenetic Classification of Living and Fossil Ray-Finned Fishes (Actinopterygii)". Bulletin of the Peabody Museum of Natural History. 65 (1): 3–302. Nelson, Luke E.; Murray, Alison M.; Sims, Megan E. (2026). "A new species of Enchodus from the Western Interior Seaway of North America and a taxonomic revision of Enchodus dirus, Leidy, 1857". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. Russell, D. A. (1988). “A check list of North American marine Cretaceous vertebrates including freshwater fishes”. Royal Tyrrell Museum Shimada, Kenshu (2016). "A new species of the Late Cretaceous 'sail-finned' bony fish, Pentanogmius (Actinopterygii: Tselfatiiformes), from Texas, USA". Cretaceous Research. 61: 188–198. Shimada, K. and M. J. Everhart. (2004). “Shark-bitten Xiphactinus audax (Teleostei: Ichthyodectiformes) from the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Cretaceous) of Kansas”. The Mosasaur 7, p. 35-39. Shimada, K. (2015). “Body form and paleoecology of the large Late Cretaceous bony fish, Pachyrhizodus caninus”. Cretaceous Research, 52, 286-291. Stewart, A. (1899). “Pachyrhizodus minimus, a new species of fish from the Cretaceous of Kansas”. Kansas University Quarterly, 8(1), 37-38. Taverne, Louis (2001). "Révision du genre Bananogmius (Teleostei, Tselfatiiformes), poisson marin du Crétacé supérieur d'Amérique du Nord et d'Europe". Geodiversitas. 23 (1): 17–40. Vavrek, Matthew J.; Murray, Alison M.; Bell, Phil R. (2016). "Xiphactinus audax Leidy 1870 from the Puskwaskau Formation (Santonian to Campanian) of northwestern Alberta, Canada and the distribution of Xiphactinus in North America". Vertebrate Anatomy Morphology Palaeontology. 1: 89.

bottom of page