Canidae

Ancient Dogs and Foxes
Canidae is the family which encompasses all of today’s wolves, foxes, dogs, jackals and their closest relatives. Fossil canids are well represented in the Ogallala Formation. Early on in their history, the canid family split into three subfamilies; Caninae, Hesperocyoninae and Borophaginae. Hesperocyonines were particularly common in North America during the Eocene and Oligocene epochs but they had disappeared and/or had given rise to the other two subfamilies of canids by the Middle Miocene epoch. The subfamily Caninae (canines) includes the line which leads towards all living canids.
The other family, Borophaginae (borophagines) was by far the more diverse group of canids during the Miocene in North America. Some of these animals grew to be the size of bears, while others were only about as large as a red fox. The borophagines are also sometimes called “bone-crushing dogs”, in reference to the well built skulls and cheek teeth seen in some members of this lineage. Animals like Borophagus, Epicyon and Aelurodon would likely have used their powerful molars to crush through the bones of their prey, possibly as a way to access nutritious bone marrow. Not all borophagines lived up to their bone crushing name, and some genera, such as Carpocyon, had fairly small teeth and seem to have been omnivorous. Borophagines would eventually dwindle and disappear as they faced increased pressure from cats during the Pliocene epoch. The canine subfamily on the other hand would survive and go on to spread to every continent except for Antarctica over the course of the Late Pliocene, Pleistocene and early Holocene epochs.
Anatomy
(BELOW) Coyotes (Canis latrans) are one of the most common wild canids found in North America today. These animals are medium-sized generalists who eat meat but will also supplement their diets with fruit insects and aquatic invertebrates. Like most living canids they have long legs, an elongated tail and a pronounced snout. Some extinct canine genera from the Ogallala Formation, such as the genus Eucyon, may have filled ecological niches similar to those of these living animals. Photo by Henry Weinberg, CC BY 2.0
.jpg)
Diagnostic Features
Canids all belong to an order of mammals called Carnivora. This order also includes animals like cats, bears, hyenas, otters and weasels. The name of the order Carnivora should not be confused with the word carnivore. Not all Carnivorans are meat eating carnivores and not all animals who eat meat are carnivorans. Fossils of dogs and other canids can be distinguished from other types of carnivoran fossils based on the characteristics they share with living dogs. In general, canids have long snouts, well-developed nasal passages, nonretractable claws, and relatively slender legs which they can use when running at high speeds. Their fingers and toes are less mobile than those of weasels or raccoons and are usually held rigidly in close proximity to the other toes of the front and hind feet. Canids are also digitigrade animals who walk on the foremost bones of their toes while keeping their ankles high off the ground. Most species have five toes on each forefoot and four functional toes on each hindfoot.
Canid teeth are distinctive enough that they can often be used to determine whether or not an animal belongs to the dog family. Their large upper and lower canine teeth are used to puncture through potential prey while the upper fourth premolar and lower first molar form a unit which is used to cut through flesh called the carnassial complex. In some extinct types of canids the cheek teeth around the carnassials are particularly large, seemingly as an adaptation for crushing through bone. Additional crushing surfaces behind these teeth allow some canids, such as jackals and coyotes to chew up tough parts of insects as well as plant matter.

(BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeletal anatomy of a canid (Canis dirus), based on a skeletal mount of bones from the La Brea Tar Pits which is on display at the KU Natural History Museum.
(BELOW) Features of the cranial and mandibular anatomy of a dire wolf. In many types of carnivorans a large set of teeth called the carnassial complex is positioned along the rear edges of the mouth in order to help with cutting through meat.

Canines and Borophagines
All of today’s living canids are members of the same subfamily, Caninae. During the Neogene period when the Ogallala Formation was in the process of being deposited across the Great Plains, the now extinct subfamily Borophaginae formed a separate, closely related branch that evolved entirely in North America. Borophagines from the Miocene and Pliocene seem to have had a more diverse array of feeding strategies than ancient canines. Some of these animals were small generalists, or may have even preferred to feed on fruits and tubers instead of hunting for live prey. The most well known borophagines are animals like Borophagus, Epicyon and Aelurodon. These larger animals were the “bone-crushers” of the family, with extremely well built cheek teeth used to break open the bones of their prey and to extract every possible source of food from an animal carcass.
(BELOW) Skulls of extant canids; a coyote on the left and a gray wolf on the right. Compared with the extinct borophagine canids, living dogs and wolves have longer and thinner snouts with less heavily built teeth. Photo taken at the KU Natural History Museum by Corbin Rainbolt
.jpg)
(BELOW) Photo of a skull of Borophagus secundus from Texas. The skulls of Borophagus have some of the shortest and deepest snouts of any borophagine genus. Although their first few premolars were fairly small, the teeth at the back of the moth on both the upper and lower jaws were extremely large, similar to those of living hyaenas. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo uploaded by user Bloopityboop, CC BY-SA 4.0
_(cropped).jpg)
Canids (Family Canidae)
Aelurodon

Temporal Range: 15.97 - 5.3 million years ago
Geographic Range: Florida, western North America
Species: A. asthenostylus, A. ferox, A. mcgrewi, A. montanensis, A. stirtoni, A. taxoides
Diet: Carnivorous, meat, bone marrow
Aelurodon was an extinct genus of borophagine canids. Species in this genus dated to later in the Miocene seem to have become increasingly specialized for hunting larger mammalian prey over time. The carnassial teeth of these animals developed longer cutting edges, while the grinding surfaces of their molars became smaller. Some later species were also larger and more strongly built than their earlier ancestors. For instance, the species Aelurodon taxoides would have been one of the largest and most hypercarnivorously specialized members of its genus. They may have had a diet which was somewhat similar to the diets of today’s living wolves, although scientists have not yet been able to determine conclusively whether or not bone crushers like Aelurodon would have hunted in packs. Their adaptations towards carnivory would have made Aelurodon quite different from omnivorous Ogallala Formation canids such as Cynarctus and Carpocyon, which had broader teeth used for grinding up plant matter, and from animals like Eucyon, a smaller and more lightly built jackal-like canid with a more broad unspecialized generalist diet. Aelurodon seems to have been better adapted for breaking apart meat using a slicing bite, rather than crunching straight through the bones of their prey like their close relatives in the genus Borophagus.

(BELOW) Photo of an Aelurodon stirtoni skeleton on display at the Smithsonian's National Museum of Natural History. The proportions of these animals were fairly similar to those of some of today's largest living canids, albeit with shorter legs and a stockier skull. The feet of Aelurodon and other later borophagines were more similar to those of living dogs than to those of some of their oldest canid ancestors, some of which may have had much more flexible toes and possibly even retractable claws. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by Jonathan Chen, CC BY-SA 4.0

(BELOW) Photo of the skull of an Aelurodon taxoides. Note the size of the cheek teeth in these animals as well as the depth of the lower jaw. These features of the anatomy of their skulls would have allowed Aelurodon to break open the bones of its prey. Image accessed via Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain image


Borophagus
Temporal Range: 12 - 2 million years ago
Geographic Range: Found across North and Central America
Species: B. diversidens, B. dudleyi, B. hilli, B. littoralis, B. parvus, B. pugnator
Diet: Carnivorous, meat, bone marrow
Borophagus was an extinct genus of borophagine canid that is found in some of the upper layers of the Ogallala Formation. They were about as large as a subadult wolf but they would have had a shorter and deeper skull than any living dog species. Their premolars and other cheek teeth seem to be built similarly to those of hyaenas which would have given this genus the ability to break open and consume bones. They also had a reinforced, vaulted skull which allowed them to withstand the intense pressure generated while biting. Although Borophagus also ate flesh, its bone-crushing adaptations enabled it to use portions of carcasses unavailable to many other predators, such as the marrow found at the center of large limb bones. This would have allowed Borophagus to get more use out of a single carcass. This genus is the namesake of the subfamily Borophaginae, the bone-crushers. This group is now extinct but at the time of the deposition of the Ogallala formation this subfamily of dogs was far more diverse than the living canine subfamily. This genus is the synonym of another genus which also appears in older literature, Osteoborus, which is currently considered to be a junior synonym of Borophagus.


Carpocyon
Temporal Range: Middle - Late Miocene epoch
Geographic Range: Florida, the Great Plains, western North America
Species: C. compressus, C. limosus, C. robustus, C. webbi
Diet: Omnivorous generalist, meat, invertebrates, fruit
Carpocyon is an unusual canid genus which was part of the borophagine subfamily. Despite its relationship to powerful bone-crushing canids, Carpocyon had less heavily built jaws and comparatively small teeth. The shape of its cheek teeth tells us that it was probably an omnivore which would have eaten a mixture of animal prey and plant material. Their molars are unusually flat and somewhat similar to those of other types of omnivorous mammals such as peccaries. Other borophagine bone-crushing dog genera from the Ogallala Formation such as Aelurodon, Epicyon, and Borophagus had jaws which were somewhat similar to those of hyaenas with larger premolars, and dental adaptations that allowed them to eat more meat or process bones. It likely would have supplemented its diet with fruits, a dietary trend which is also seen in today’s coyotes. This presumed behavior is the namesake for the genus Carpocyon which roughly translates to “fruit dog”. The remains of this animal are found below the main ash layer at the Ashfall Fossil Beds site.


Cynarctus
Temporal Range: ~ 16.0 - 10.3 million years ago
Geographic Range: Colorado, California, Maryland, Nebraska, Texas
Species: C. saxatilis, C. crucidens, C. galushai, C. marylandica, C. voorhiesi, C. wangi
Diet: Omnivorous generalist, meat, invertebrates, fruit
Cynarctus was a genus of borophagine canids whose fossils are found in deposits dating back to the Middle and Late Miocene epoch. Its fossils have been discovered in western Nebraska and some parts of northern Texas. They are mostly known from fossil fragments of their jaws and from the remains of their teeth. Despite belonging to the group of canids commonly called “bone-crushing dogs,” Cynarctus did not have the highly specialized bone-cracking features of later borophagines. Instead, it had more lightly-built teeth and a unique set of comb-shaped incisors which have been theorized to be an adaptation for catching slippery aquatic animals such as frogs and salamanders. This dental structure suggests that Cynarctus ate an omnivorous diet which would have been composed of fruit, vegetation, fish, aquatic invertebrates and even insects. They were smaller than animals like Carpocyon, which is another type of omnivorous borophagine found in Ogallala deposits.. Early studies of the remains of these animals which seemed well adapted for an omnivorous diet led paleontologists to tentatively assign them to the raccoon family Procyonidae before eventually being moved over to the borophagine subfamily of Canidae. The structure of the teeth in some species, with deep, rounded molars with well-developed cusps, may be an indication that certain Cynarctus species fed primarily on fruit and other types of plant matter such as tubers.


Epicyon
Temporal Range: ~ 12 - 5 million years ago
Geographic Range: Florida, Alabama, central and western North America
Species: E. haydeni, E. aelurodontoides, E. saevus
Diet: Carnivorous, meat, bone marrow
Epicyon was an extinct genus of giant borophagine canids. The genus is composed of three recognized species. One of these species, E. haydeni, was the largest canid species of all time and could have weighed over 300 pounds. Like most other borophagines they would have had a suite of cranial adaptations which would have been useful for breaking apart bones, including a tall sagittal crest and wide, enlarged cheekbones. Other genera such as Aelurodon also have these features but they are even more pronounced in Epicyon. Its wide and durable cheek teeth could tolerate powerful biting forces and break bones and would have allowed these dogs to reach the nutrient-rich marrow inside, a food source which would not have been available to many other types of Ogallala macropredators. These animals would have filled a similar role to today’s hyaenas, although their size would have meant that they could have actively hunted for very large prey and may not have relied as heavily on carrion as living mid-sized bone-crushing carnivorans. Many types of borophagines would lose their status as top predators in their ecosystems as cats began to spread into North America, diversifying into newer and larger forms over the course of the Neogene period.

(BELOW) Photo of an Epicyon haydeni skeleton on display at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles. This particular species could have grown to be larger than some living bear species and is the largest currently known canid species. It is unclear whether or not they would have hunted in packs like today's wolves. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by Eric Polk, CC BY-SA 4.0

(BELOW) Photo of a replica of the jawbone from the Epicyon haydeni skeleton in the photo above showing the size and width of the animal's cheek teeth. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by Eric Polk, CC BY-SA 4.0


Eucyon
Temporal Range: ~ 10.3 - 3.6 million years ago
Geographic Range: Western North America, Eurasia
Species: E. davisi, E. ferox, E. intrepidus, E. khoikhoi, E. kuta, E. marinae, E. minor, E. monticinensis, E. skinneri, E. wokari, E. zhoui
Diet: Omnivorous; meat, invertebrates, plant matter
Eucyon was a small- to medium-sized canid genus and a member of the canine subfamily. These animals had relatively generalized teeth and lightly built skulls, the shape of which would suggest to us that it may have had a diet and feeding strategy similar to those of living jackals. It likely would have hunted for smaller mammals and occasionally fed on plant matter. This makes Eucyon somewhat different from several other canids found in Ogallala deposits. Large borophagine bone-crushers had more heavily built skulls and enlarged premolars used for processing meat or crushing through bones. Eucyon would not have had these heavy feeding adaptations. It shared some features in common with the genus Carpocyon, which also would have had a slender skull, long snout and teeth which were less well adapted for crushing though tough bony material. This is in spite of the fact that Carpocyon was only a distant relative of Eucyon and would have been a member of the older borophagine lineage. The genus Eucyon survived for over 7 million years. Their fossils are found in North America, and possibly some sites in Eurasia and Africa. They may be the direct ancestors of all living dogs and wolves in the genus Canis which would eventually move into many of the niches left behind after the extinction of the borophagine dogs.

(BELOW) Photo of a skeleton of Eucyon davisi from the Miocene of Arizona. The teeth and general shapes of the skulls of these animals are far more similar to those of living canines than to those of the extinct Neogene borophagines. Thiss, along with their widespread distribution across both North America and Eurasia, points to these animals being the ancestors of living dogs, wolves, jackals and coyotes. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo by Skye McDavid, CC BY-SA 4.0


Leptocyon
Temporal Range: 30.8 - 10.3 million years ago
Geographic Range: Found across North America
Species: L. delicatus, L. gregorii, L. vafer, L. vulpinus
Diet: Omnivore: small vertebrates, invertebrates, fruit
Leptocyon was a genus of small, fox-like canids that lived in North America throughout much of the Oligocene and Miocene. This makes them one of the oldest dog genera known from the Americas. Species living during the interval represented by the Ogallala Formation were generally comparable in size to the living red fox. Leptocyon is considered to be a member of the subfamily Caninae which also includes today’s living wolves, coyotes, and dogs. It had a narrow skull with a long, thin shout. Its teeth seem to have been fairly unspecialized and it most likely had a diet similar to those of today’s skunks, feeding on small vertebrates, invertebrates and possibly even plant material. These animals were some of the smallest canids found in deposits from the Miocene epoch of the Great Plains, usually growing to be around half the size of a housecat. One species, Leptocyon delicatus, may be the smallest canid species known to science. Instead of competing with the larger bone crushing canids or the mid-sized omnivorous genera such as Carpocyon, it may have instead competed with some of the mustelid genera known from the Ogallala Formation. The long, narrow bodies of Leptocyon may have even allowed them to pursue rodents underground, although their forelimb anatomy tells us that they were not capable diggers.

(BELOW) Photo of a skull of Leptocyon vafer from California. The skulls of these animals are narrow and not very large, around the same size as the skulls of living foxes, although some Leptocyon species seem to have been even smaller. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo uploaded by user Bloopityboop, CC BY-SA 4.0
_skull_compared_to_Leptocyon_vafer_skull_cast_(bottom)_edite.jpg)

Metalopex
Temporal Range: ~10.3 - 4.9 million years ago
Geographic Range: Nebraska, Texas, Arizona, Nevada, California, Oregon
Species: M. bakeri, M. macconnelli, M. merriami
Diet: Omnivore: small vertebrates, invertebrates, fruit
Metalopex was a genus of foxes found in western North America during the later part of the Miocene epoch. Based on the structure of its teeth, Metalopex seems to have been an omnivorous animal and meat only formed a relatively limited part of its diet. It would have had larger grinding surfaces on its molars which allowed it to chew up a lot of different kinds of tougher foods. It seems to have been a close relative of the living gray fox genus Urocyon. The genus is primarily known from fossils of a partial skull, jaw fragments and teeth but we can assume that, like many types of living foxes, Metalopex would have had a long, slender tail, possibly covered in a long coat of fur, as well as short legs and a long, narrow snout.

Metatomarctus

Temporal Range: ~23 – 16 million years ago
Geographic Range: Delaware, Florida, western North America
Species: M. canavus
Diet: Carnivorous, small and mid-sized vertebrate prey
Metatomarctus was a genus of mid-sized borophagine dogs which lived earlier in the Miocene than many of the other types of canids known from deposits in the Ogallala Formation, disappearing by around 16 million years ago. Its fossils occasionally turn up in the lowermost member of the formation, the Valentine Member. They had fairly narrow snouts when compared with later bone crushing dogs like Aelurodon and Epicyon but their cheek teeth show some early adaptations for breaking apart bones and are more heavily built than those of most living canids. Their fossils are found across North America as far south as parts of Florida. They would have hunted medium-sized mammals such as ancient horses and camelids


Paratomarctus
Temporal Range: ~ 16.3 – 5.3 million years ago
Geographic Range: Western parts of North America from Texas to Oregon
Species: P. temerarius
Diet: Carnivorous, small and mid-sized vertebrate prey
Paratomarctus was one of the later genera of borophagine dogs which managed to make it into the very start of the Pliocene epoch, surviving up until around 5 million years ago. Its fossils are found exclusively in western North America and it appears to have been a mid-sized generalist, often compared to coyotes and jackals in terms of both their presumed dietary preferences for a wide range of different types of foods, as well as their overall body sizes.


Tomarctus
Temporal Range: ~ 20.43 – 13.6 million years ago
Geographic Range: Florida, Texas, Nebraska, Oregon
Species: T. brevirostris, T. hippophaga
Diet: Carnivorous, small and mid-sized vertebrate prey
Tomarctus was a medium-sized canid belonging to the bone crushing dog family Borphaginae. It would have had a compact, muscular body and a short, broad skull. Its wide cheek bones and the tall sagittal crest along the back of the forehead would have provided lots of room for muscle attachment points for the jaw muscles. Like many of its borophagine relatives it would have had large and proportionally large premolars which were useful for both slicing and crushing and would have allowed it to eat a range of food including meat and bone marrow. Like today’s canids, Tomarctus walked on its toes and could grasp struggling prey effectively. However, its heavy build and relatively short legs would have made it better at ambush hunting rather than high-speed chases. These animals seem to have been close relatives of the larger genus Aelurodon, although Tomarctus species rarely got to be larger than a coyote. They would have scavenged for food as well as hunting for food as active predators of small-medium sized mammals and birds.

(BELOW) Photo of a skull of Tomarctus brevirostris from Nebraska. These were one of the older borophagine genera and showed many of the early characteristics which would be the hallmarks of later members of their subfamily, including wide cheekbones and enlarged molars. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, photo uploaded by user Bloopityboop, CC BY-SA 4.0
_(cropped).jpg)

Vulpes stenognathus
Temporal Range: Late Miocene - Early Pliocene
Geographic Range: Western North America
Species: V. stenognathus
Diet: Omnivore: small vertebrates, invertebrates, fruit
Vulpes stenognathus is an extinct species of true fox known from fossils found in deposits associated with the Ogallala Formation. It appears to have had a greater preference for eating meat than other Miocene Ogallala foxes such as Metalopex and its cheek teeth are larger than those of other members of the genus Vulpes. Today, living members of the Vulpes genus include the red fox, fennec fox, arctic fox and the swift fox. In the environment of the savannahs which once covered the central US and the Great Plains, Vulpes stenognathus would have hunted small and medium-sized rodents as well as prehistoric lagomorphs, relatives of today’s rabbits and pikas.

Suggested References: Canids
Wang, Xiaoming; Richard Tedford; Beryl Taylor (1999-11-17). "Phylogenetic systematics of the Borophaginae" (PDF). Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History. 243.
Silvestro, D.; Antonelli, A.; Salamin, N.; Quental, T. B. (2015). "The role of clade competition in the diversification of North American canids". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 112 (28): 8684–8689.
Wang, Xiaoming; White, Stuart C.; Balisi, Mairin; Biewer, Jacob; Sankey, Julia; Garber, Dennis; Tseng, Z Jack (2018). "First bone-cracking dog coprolites provide new insight into bone consumption in Borophagus and their unique ecological niche"
Van Valkenburgh, B.; Sacco, T.; Wang, X. (2003). "Pack hunting in Miocene borophagine dogs: evidence from craniodental morphology and body size". Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History. 279: 147–162.
Van Valkenburgh, B.; Wang, X.; Damuth, J. (October 2004). "Cope's Rule, Hypercarnivory, and Extinction in North American Canids". Science. 306 (#5693): 101–104.
Hall, E. Raymond; Dalquest, Walter W. (1962). "A New Doglike Carnivore, Genus Cynarctus, Pliocene, of Texas". University of Kansas Publications Museum of Natural History. 14: 135–138.
Barbour, Erwin; Cook, Harold (1 January 1914). "Two New Fossil Dogs of The Genus Cynarctus from Nebraska". Conservation and Survey Division. 4.
Pagnac, Darrin (2012). "Additions to the Vertebrate Faunal Assemblage of the Middle Miocene Fort Randall Formation in the Vicinity of South Bijou Hill, South Dakota, U.S.A." The Mountain Geologist. 49 (1): 19–34.
Wang, Xiaoming (1993). Transformation from plantigrady to digitigrady : functional morphology of locomotion in Hesperocyon (Canidae, Carnivora). American Museum of Natural History Library. New York, N.Y. : American Museum of Natural History.
