top of page

Guide To The Cleveland Shale

Ancient fish from the Devonian of Ohio

pageheaderdimensions2_edited_edited.jpg

361 million years ago the Midwest was covered by a shallow sea. At this time in Earth's history the largest types of vertebrates were the giant fish who patrolled the world's oceans. One particular type of prehistoric fish, the arthrodires (a group of placoderms) reached the height of their diversity towards the end of the Devonian period. In the layers of shale beneath parts of north-eastern Ohio, fossils of some of these giant armored fishes have been found which once belonged to some of the most powerful marine carnivores of their day. Giants like Dunkleosteus used their bone-shattering jaws to crush through the reinforced plates of their prey. Some arthrodires also appear to have adapted to become massive filter feeders. For instance, Titanichthys has a relatively light set of cranial armor and its reduced jaw plates suggest that it was an animal that specialized in straining microscopic organic material out of the water. Fossils of shark-like cartilaginous fishes can also be found in the rock layers of the Cleveland Shale. The seas of the Late Devonian were home to the strange genus Stethacanthus which is famous for its anvil-shaped dorsal fins. The fossils found in the Cleveland Shale date back to only a few million years before the Devonian period would end in a major mass extinction event. Many of these unique groups of marine vertebrates found in the layers of rock beneath parts of northern Ohio would soon vanish. The Cleveland Shale therefore stands as one of the best places to look back at a window of time when giant armored fishes still ruled the seas.

cleavelandpageheader.jpg

Browse animals by taxonomic group

Or scroll to the bottom of the page to browse by genus

Cleveland Shale Fauna

Armored Fish

(Placodermi)

Dunkleosteoids, Selenosteids, etc.

dunkleosteusthumbnail.jpg

Cartilaginous Fish

(Chondrichthyes)

Ctenacanthiformes,

Holocephali

stethacanthusthumbnail.jpg

Bony Fish

(Osteichthyes)

Lungfishes, Palaeoniscoids

palaeoniscumdetail.jpg

About the Cleveland Shale

The Cleveland Shale is a member of the larger Ohio Shale Formation. The section of the Cleveland Shale which is best known for its fossils of large marine vertebrates has outcrops in north-eastern Ohio. These layers can also be found at a few other sites in the south-western portion of the state. Fossils found in the Cleveland Shale are particularly common in Cuyahoga county, near the shale’s namesake city of Cleveland. The Cleveland Shale Member is typically divided into two sections, a lower set of layers which are lighter gray-blue in color and a darker, oil rich upper layer. The member as a whole is separated from the underlying Chagrin Shale by a thin layer of pyrite.

ohiomap.jpg

(ABOVE) A map showing the areas where fossils are found in layers which fall within the Cleveland Shale (marked in orange). Most placoderm and shark fossils are found in the north-eastern part of the state but a few outcrops are also known from south-western Ohio. Most fossils are found in Cuyahoga County. 

The preservation quality of invertebrate remains at sites connected to the Cleveland Shale Member is generally rather poor. A few types of brachiopod fossils have been found in these layers but the most common fossils tend to be those of larger vertebrates, especially the harder parts of the skeletons of these aquatic animals. Remains of placoderms rarely preserve any material aside from the large bony plates which would have covered the heads and necks of these animals. Surprisingly the fossils of the bodies of ancient cartilaginous fishes tend to be rather complete. The entire outlines of the bodies of some of these ancient animals are visible as darker sections or areas within a flat section of rock. Most of these soft tissue fossils have been compressed or otherwise flattened by the fossilization process. In some parts of the Cleveland Shale, fragmentary fossils of woody plant material can also be found in the lower-most pyrite layer within the remains of what was once a shallow coastal region during the later part of the Devonian period.

devonianfishes.jpg

(ABOVE) Fauna known from the Cleveland Shale include (1) Palaeoniscoid bony fishes, (2,3,4) armored placoderms, and (5) cartilaginous fishes, usually those which are part of the lineage which includes today's Chimaeras, the Holocephali.

bottom of page