top of page

Placoderms

placodermsheader.jpg

Armored Devonian Fish

Placoderms were a group of jawed fishes who were among the most abundant and diverse vertebrate lineages of the early Paleozoic era. The first placoderms appeared during the Silurian period and they would remain a common presence in the world's oceans up until the end of the Devonian period 358.9 million years ago. Placoderms are best known for the fossils of the hard bony armor which covered their heads and the areas in front of their dorsal fins. These plates may have functioned as a way to store useful minerals within the tissues of their bodies, as well as offering an extra layer of protection from predation. By the end of the Devonian period, the most common placoderms were those which are classified as part of the clade Arthrodira, also known as arthrodires. Many of these animals had powerful jaws and specialized bony plates which served the same function as large sets of slicing teeth. 

Classification

Types of Placoderms

Over the course of their 80 million year evolutionary history, placoderms came in many different shapes and sizes. Many earlier groups were benthic animals who fed close to the seafloor. Some of these benthic animals like the Early Devonian genus Gemuendina, tended to have large pectoral fins which gave them a silhouette which was superficially similar to a stingray or skate. Some of these benthic detritivores managed to survive all the way up until the end of the Devonian. Bothriolepis, a genus from North America, Europe, Asia and Australia, had a long oval-shaped body and a distinctive set of long, thin pectoral fins.

​

Fossils found in the Cleveland Shale include the remains of some of the best known types of Devonian placoderms. This includes Dunkleosteus, which is well known for its powerful jaws which were surrounded by sharpened tooth-like bony plates. Many other types of placoderms filled the ecological niches of top marine predators during the Devonian, with some of their fossils having been found in association with the remains of smaller placoderms and sharks who seem to show signs of having been bitten by the larger placoderm. Some Cleveland Shale arthrodires, like the genus Titanichthys, are thought to have been filter-feeders based on the relatively small size of their jaw plates. 

(BELOW) Placoderms were a very diverse group and took on many different shapes depending on the roles they filled within the ecosystems of the Devonian and Silurian periods. These included large active carnivores, detritivores and filter-feeders

placodermtypes.jpg

Paraphyly

For most of the history of the study of their fossils, placoderms were considered to form a natural grouping, which is to say that they were believed to have all descended from a common ancestor which was not shared by any other separate group. More recent scholarship seems to suggest that this is not in fact the case and that the group we call placoderms includes the common ancestor of cartilaginous fishes (sharks, stingrays, etc.) and all bony fish, including tetrapods. Although the term "placoderm" is still widely used in order to describe these ancient armored fishes, it is often more useful to refer to them based on where they fall within the jawed fish family tree. For instance, most of the placoderms found in deposits from the Cleveland shale are considered to be arthrodires. 

​

Since the term "Placoderm" is still used informally to refer to the armored fishes found in the Silurian and Devonian we will continue to use that term in this section. It should be noted, however, that our current understanding suggests that all cartilaginous and bony fishes are descended from the group previously known as placoderms and are still, in a cladistic sense, technically part of the placoderm group.

(BELOW) A cladogram showing the organization of the jawed fish family tree. Groups which have historically been considered placoderms are shaded in orange, other jawed vertebrate groups are shown in yellow. Arthrodires are marked in red.

Anatomy

Skeletal Anatomy

Placoderms are mostly known from the remains of the plates of bony armor which covered their skulls but we do also have some information about the structure of their post-cranial skeletons which are occasionally preserved alongside the cranial plates. The skeletons of the rear parts of the bodies of placoderms were composed of cartilage, similar to the materials which comprise the majority of the skeletons of living sharks and stingrays. A series of spinal cartilages supported most of the bodies of these fish while a separate set of cartilages formed the main structure of the dorsal fin. Two additional sets of cartilage were found near the point where the pelvic fins were connected to the trunk of the fish. The spinal cartilages of the tail angled upwards, supporting the fleshy dorsal caudal lobe which formed the upper part of the tail fluke. 

​

Placoderms generally did not have true teeth. Instead, the plates of bone around their jaws were used to slice apart and/or crush prey. The lower jaw held the infragnathal plates while the upper jaws held two pairs of supragnathal plates. In some genera these plates formed a single curved cutting surface while in others the cutting surfaces of the jaw plates were covered in serrations and/or cusps. The gills of these placoderms were found in the wide gap between the suborbital plate, near the cheek of the placoderm, and the anterior lateral plates. In arthrodires there is a space in the armor between the head shield and the median dorsal plates. This space is known as the nuchal gap and would have provided extra flexibility to the mouths and heads of these ancient fishes.

(BELOW) The skeletal anatomy of the arthrodire Dunkleosteus from the Cleveland Shale of Ohio. This animal is mostly known from the plates of armor found around the skull. The post-cranial skeleton is based on known remains from other arthrodires.

placodermskeletalanatomy.jpg

(BELOW) Cranial plate anatomies of a few notable arthrodire genera from the Cleveland Shale, including those of Selenosteus, Gymnotrachelus, Bungartius and Dunkleosteus. The differences in the sizes and shapes of their jaw plates are most likely a result of their specialization for the purposes of hunting different types of soft or hard-bodied prey.

placodermheads2.jpg

External Anatomy

The external anatomical strucutres of placoderms were very mysterious up until only a few years ago. For many years it was conventional to restore these animals with long eel-like bodies. The armored plates of the skull were restored as structures which were entirely exposed without any sort of external skin covering. Thanks to the study of fossils of animals like Coccosteus and Amazichthys, in the last few decades paleontologists have been able to more accurately restore the bodies of these ancient fish. Soft tissue fossils of the tails of these animals suggest that many placoderms, including arthrodires, would have had a shark like profile with a dorsal fin, a forked tail fluke and smooth unarmored skin covering most of their bodies. The plates of the skull and jaws were likely covered in a layer of skin and protective soft tissue which would have appeared superficially similar to the skin of today's cartilaginous fishes. Some large placoderms which were previously restored as slender 20+ foot long eel-like animals are now thought to have had more stocky builds with short, deep bodies measuring around 11-13 feet in length

(BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of the arthrodire Dunkleosteus. Based on soft tissue fossils from related genera, these animals are now thought to have had short, robust bodies which outwardly resembled the forms of living sharks.

bungartiusforwebsite.jpg

Bungartius

 Temporal Range:  362.6 – 360.1 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Cuyahoga County, Ohio

 Species: B. perissus

 Diet: Carnivore, possibly durophagous, placoderms

Bungartius is a genus of placoderms which is considered to be a close relative of the filter-feeding arthrodire Titanichthys and the smaller selenosteids. It is classified as part of the superorder Dinichthyloidea. Bungartius had a long, narrow set of jaws with robust jaw plates which seem to have been adapted for dealing a shearing bite. The cutting surfaces of the lower jaws are smooth, without any cusps and the front part of the mandible features a prominent forward-facing chin projection. Based on the shapes of the fossils known from the area behind the skull of the animal, it seems that Bungartius was a more slender animal than some of its more distantly related contemporaries such as Dunkleosteus. The openings for its eyes were fairly small and were positioned along the sides of the skull. The dorsal armor of these animals also appears to cover a smaller area of the back in this genus, although the ventral plates are well built in a similar manner to other late Devonian placoderms. The slender build seen in Bungartius may be an indication that these animals were built to move quickly through the water while hunting or escaping from larger marine carnivores.

devonianhab.jpg
bungartiuscranialarmor.jpg

(BELOW) The arrangement of the cranial plates on the head and neck of Bungartius. Compared with other Late Devonian arthrodires, Bungartius had a very long skull and jaw plates with no cusps or serrations. Based on Dunkle, 1947

coccosteusforwebsite.jpg

Coccosteus

 Temporal Range:  393.3 – 359.3 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Ohio, New York, Scotland, Northern Ireland

 Species: C. canadensis, C. carbonarius, C. chamberlini, C. cuspidatus, C. cuyahogae, C . decipiens, C. disjectus, C. grossi, C. hercynius, C. macromus, C. markae, C. minor

 Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes

Coccosteus is a fairly small placoderm classified as part of the family Coccosteidae. This genus is fairly unique among Devonian placoderms since these animals are known from some fairly complete postcranial material, in addition to the fossils of bony skull armor plates which constitute the majority of the material known from other placoderm genera. Coccosteus was a slender animal with a single long dorsal fin running along its back, positioned behind the animal’s dorsal armor. Their caudal flukes had a highly elongate dorsal lobe and a very small ventral lobe, similar to the tail shape seen in some types of sand tiger sharks. Fossils of animals belonging to this genus have been found in parts of Europe, particularly in Scotland. Their record in the Cleveland shale is somewhat contested and the remains assigned to this genus from the late Devonian of Ohio consist of only a few pieces of a jaw plate. 

devonianhab.jpg
Coccosteus-Paleozoological_Museum_of_China.jpg

(BELOW) A photo of a skeleton of Coccosteus cuspidatus (IVPP V19322) on display at the Paleozoological Museum of China. Photo by Wikimedia Commons user Morosaurus millenii, CC BY-SA 4.0

diplognathusforwebsite.jpg

Diplognathus

 Temporal Range:  361 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Ohio, Michigan

 Species: D. mirabillis, D. larfargei

 Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes

Diplognathus is a fairly large genus of placoderms and a possible member of the family Hadrosteidae. These animals had fairly slender tooth plates and the inferognathals of the lower jaws had a pair of particularly large jaw spines along the front of the mandible. Other sections of their upper and lower jaw plates were covered in large, recurved serrations. Their orbits were quite large and the skull of Diplognathus was relatively narrow. Their jaw elements seem to be weaker than those of some of the largest types of Cleveland shale placoderms but they are thought to have had a particularly wide gape. When their jaws were closed the lower jaw would have extended beyond the apex of the upper jaw. They seem to have been soft prey specialists who would have hunted for sharks and ray-finned fishes living in their marine habitat.

devonianhab.jpg

(BELOW) The arrangement of the jaw plates of Diplognathus. Some species of these animals had long tooth-like spines at the front apexes of their mandibles. The rear parts of the mouth were covered in backwards-facing curved serrations

dunkleosteusforwebsite.jpg

Dunkleosteus

 Temporal Range:  382 – 358 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Ohio, New York, Missouri, Canada, Belgium, Russia, Morocco

 Species: D. amblyodoratus, D. denisoni, D. magnificus, D. marsaisi, D. missouriensis, D. newberryi , D. raveri, D. terrelli, D. tuderensis

 Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes

Dunkleosteus is a very large genus of placoderms and the namesake of the wider family Dunkleosteidae. Like other arthrodires, Dunkleosteus would have lacked true teeth. Instead, the exposed bones along its upper and lower jaws would have formed sharp cutting edges. These self-sharpening blades closed together like a pair of bolt cutters and allowed these fish to break through the hardened exterior shells and bones of their prey.

 

 Dunkleosteus is primarily known from fossils of the armor which would have covered its head, parts of its back and the area around its pectoral fins. The exact shape of the rear portions of the body of this animal are not known from complete post-cranial fossils and as a result the un-armored portions of the body of Dunkleosteus have to be restored based on fossils of related animals. For most of the history of the study of this animal, Dunkleosteus was restored with a long, narrow body similar to the post-cranial anatomy seen in fossils of the placoderm genus Coccosteus. Some body length estimates for Dunkleosteus based on the shapes of more gracile placoderms restored this large placoderm as an animal that could grow to be over 20 feet long, larger than a living great white shark. More analyses such as those by Engelman (2024) suggest that Dunkleosteids had fairly short and robust bodies, with Dunkelsoteus itself having an estimated body length of around 11-13 feet. 

devonianhab.jpg

(BELOW) The arrangement of the cranial plates on the head and neck of Dunkleosteus CMNH 7424. The jaw plates of these huge placoderms were some of the largest and most robust of all the Cleveland Shale arthrodires.

Dunkleosteus_terrelli_-_Cleveland_Museum_of_Natural_History_-_2014-12-26_(21137540331).jpg

(BELOW) Photo of the fossil skull plates of a large Dunkleosteus terrelli on display at the Cleveland Museum of Natural History, photo by Tim Evanson, CC BY-SA 2.0. Anterior lateral and posterior dorsolaterial plates are placeholders

(BELOW) Photo of the fossil skull plates of a small Dunkleosteus, most likely a juvenile animal, on display at the Cleveland Museum of Natural History, photo by Tim Evanson, CC BY-SA 2.0

gorgonichthysforwebsite.jpg

Gorgonichthys

 Temporal Range:  371.1 – 359.3 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Ohio

 Species: G. clarki

 Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes

Gorgonichthys was a large genus of placoderms represented by a single species, Gorgonichthys clarki. These animals had particularly large head shields which grew to be around 2 feet (70 cm) long. These plates are roughly similar in size to the same types of plates found on other large Cleveland Shale placoderms such as Dunkleosteus. Although the jaw elements of Gorgonichthys were roughly similar in shape to those of Dunkleosteus, Gorgonichthys is not considered a member of the Dunkleosteid family and is instead placed within the clade Aspinothoracidi. Recent research positions this genus as a relative of the selenosteid placoderms such as Heintzichthys. Based on post-cranial skeletal material known from selenosteids such as the Moroccan genus Amazichthys, we might expect Gorgonichthys to have had a more slender build than the more robust dunkleosteid placoderms.

devonianhab.jpg

(BELOW) A photo of the infragnathals (lower jaw plates) of a Gorgonichthys showing the large tooth-like projections at the apex of the mandible, photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons. Original photo by user Paleeoguy, CC BY-SA 4.0

Gorgonichthys_infragnathals.jpg
gymnotrachelusforwebsite.jpg

Gymnotrachelus

 Temporal Range:  371.1 – 359.3 million years ago

 Geographic Range: Ohio

 Species: G. hydei

 Diet: Active carnivore: small fish

Gymnotrachelus is a genus of selenosteid placoderms which seem to be close relatives of animals like Heintzichthys and Stenosteus. These animals had a relatively wide, shallow wedge-like head and a broad mouth. Their eyes were relatively small for a selenosteid. The plates of its jaws were lightly built and vere covered in very fine and sharp tooth-like serrations which are particularly prominent on the animal’s lower jaw. The nuchal gap between the armor of the head and the back was fairly wide in this genus.

devonianhab.jpg

(BELOW) The structure of the cranial armor of Gymnotrachelus including the position of the sclerotic ring in the orbit. These animals had wide, wedge shape skulls which were separated from their dorsal armor by a fairly wide nuchal gap.

heintzichthysforwebsite.jpg

Heintzichthys

 Temporal Range:  371.1 – 359.3 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Ohio, possible European record

 Species: H. gouldii

 Diet: Active carnivore: small fish

Heintzichthys is a genus of selenosteid placoderms. This genus is known from fossils which preserve portions of the cheek and jaw plates, the parasphenoid of the palate, components of the shoulder girdle, paired fins, sections of the axial skeleton, and parts of the neurocranium. In some fossils of Heintzichthys the fossil skeletal elements remained partially connected which gives us a good sense of how these anatomical elements would have articulated in life. Heintzichthys was once classified within the family Dinichthyidae but it was later reassigned to the selenosteid family within the clade Aspinothoracidi, along with animals like Paramylostoma and Stenosteus.

devonianhab.jpg
Holdeniusforwebsite.jpg

Holdenius

 Temporal Range:  371.1 – 359.3 million years ago

 Geographic Range: Northern Ohio

 Species: H. holdeni

 Diet: Active carnivore: smaller placoderms, cartilaginous fishes

Holdenius was a large placoderm in the clade Aspinothoracidi which is represented by a single species, Holdenius holdeni. These animals are particularly well known for the fossils of their enormous bony gnathal plates which served the same purpose as conventional slicing teeth. The sharp cutting margins along the edges of these plates would have allowed their jaws to grasp prey animals and slice them into manageable portions. This feeding structure resembled that of Dunkleosteus, another armored placoderm from the same environment. As an arthrodire, Holdenius likely had articulated bony plates protecting its head and the front of its trunk. However, the fragmentary nature of its fossils makes a complete anatomical reconstruction impossible. One Holdenius fossil was found in association with the remains of a dorsal spine from a ctenacanth shark which was preserved piercing the palate and entering the placoderm’s braincase. This shows that the area behind the animal’s powerful jaws was fairly soft and would have remained vulnerable to injury. Although formerly placed within Dunkleosteidae, Holdenius is now thought to be more closely related to animals like Gorgonichthys and Heintzicthys, although its exact placement among the members of the clade Aspinothoracidi has not yet been conclusively determined

devonianhab.jpg
hlavinichthysforwebsite.jpg

Mylostoma

 Temporal Range:  361 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Ohio

 Species: M. variabile, M. terrelli 

 Diet: Possibly durophagous, hard-shelled prey

Mylostoma was a genus of possibly durophagous placoderms specialized for crushing the shells of other animals. The jaws of these animals were adapted to breaking down hard food instead of cutting flesh with sharpened jaw edges. These animals had broad dental plates that created powerful crushing surfaces, instead of individual teeth. Over the course of their lives the jaw plates of Mylostoma became increasingly fused. In fossils which seem to come from younger individuals, the front of the upper jaw contains two anterior palatopterygoid plates. As these animals grew, these paired structures joined at the center to form a single central jaw plate. The rear of the upper jaw was formed by a set of sturdy posterior palatopterygoid plates. When biting down on their prey, these fused components produced a more efficient apparatus for crushing smaller placoderms and/or hard-shelled invertebrates.

devonianhab.jpg
paramylostomaforwebsite.jpg

Paramylostoma

 Temporal Range:  371.1 – 359.3 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Northern Ohio

 Species: P. arcualis

 Diet: Carnivore, possibly durophagous, hard-shelled prey

Paramylostoma was a genus of shell-crushing selenosteid placoderms. Unlike other types of selenosteid, Paramylostoma did not have large cusps or serrations on its jaw plates. Their skulls also seem to have been slightly wider than those of their closest selenosteid relatives and their orbits were smaller than those seen in the skulls of animals like Selenosteus and Stenosteus. These characteristics have led Paramylostoma to be considered a shell-crushing animal. Fossils of hard-shelled invertebrates are fairly rare in the Cleveland shale but these jaws may have been useful for cracking open the shells of marine cephalopods and may have even been used to bite through the bony armor of smaller placoderms. 

devonianhab.jpg
selenosteusforwebsite.jpg

Selenosteus

 Temporal Range:  ~373 – 359.3 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Ohio, New York?

 Species: S. brevis

 Diet: Active carnivore: small fish

Selenosteus was a medium-sized genus of placoderms and the namesake of the wider family Selenosteidae. Like most other Selenosteids, Selenosteus had very large orbits which likely would have held well-developed eyes. The lower jaws and the associated tooth-like plates of these animals were relatively thin and the portion of the skull in front of the eyes was short and sharply angled in the area around the nares.

devonianhab.jpg

(BELOW) Structure of the cranial plates of Selenosteus based on a diagram from a redescription by Carr (1996). Note the very large orbits which are a feature that is often seen in the skulls of placoderms from the family selenosteidae.

stenosteusforwebsite.jpg

Stenosteus

 Temporal Range:  371.1 – 359.3 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Northern Ohio

 Species: S. glaber, S.pertenius, S. angustopectus

 Diet: Active carnivore: small fish

Stenosteus was a genus of relatively small selenosteid placoderms. Like many of its close relatives, Stenosteus would have had very large eyes and very thin and slender inferognathals (lower jaw plates) and the cutting surfaces of their jaws were covered in low cusps and fine serrations. The area in front of the eye sockets seen in the well-preserved skulls known from this genus would have been very short and angular. 

devonianhab.jpg
titanichthysforwebsite.jpg

Titanichthys

 Temporal Range:  361 million years ago

 Geographic Range:  Northern Ohio, Morocco, possibly Poland

 Species: T. agassizi , T. attenuatus, T. hussakofi, T. termieri

 Diet: Filter feeder: small aquatic organisms

Titanichthys was a very large Late Devonian placoderm with very lightweight armor and very unique jaw plates. In contrast to Dunkleosteus, which used its sharpened jaw plates for slicing prey, Titanichthys had smaller, blunter plates along the edges of its mouth which lacked effective cutting surfaces. This, along with the proportionally large size of the mouths of these animals, suggests that Titanichthys was a filter feeder which scooped up small organisms suspended in the water. 

 

Despite its large size, the cranial and neck armor of TItanichthys covered fewer parts of its body than in other types of Late Devonian placoderms. The rostral plate which covered the animal’s snout was elliptical across its entire width and was completely separated from neighboring plates.  Many of the upper jaw plates seen in fossils of these animals are also unusually reduced. One particularly complete articulated fossil from Ohio’s Cleveland Shale preserves parts of the snout, cheeks, jaws, nasal capsule, and body armor positioned in the same places they occupied when the animal was still alive, which gives us a better sense of the arrangement of these cranial bony plates.

devonianhab.jpg

Placoderms known from fragmentary fossils

Some placoderm genera found in the Cleveland shale are only known from a small number of very fragmentary fossils, or have otherwise convoluted taxonomic histories. These additional genera are listed below, along with our current understanding of their positions within the placoderm family tree. All of these animals seem to be arthrodires and have been distinguished from other Cleveland Shale genera by key differences in the shape and orientations of known fossils of their skull plates.

hussakofiaforwebsite.jpg

(BELOW) A speculative life restoration of the genus Hussakofia, restored here as a dunkleosteid arthrodire with a stout body and powerful slicing jaws. This genus is only known from a few plate fragments from near the base of the skull

Other Placoderms

Callognathus: Classified as a selenosteid, known from a few gnathal plate fragments

Glyptaspis: A placoderm known from fossils of four of its ventral plates, possibly a relative of animals like Tropidosteus and Holonema in the family Holonematidae

Trachosteus: A selenosteid known from a few fragments of skull armor

Suggested References: Placoderms

Engelman, Russell K. (2023-02-21). "A Devonian Fish Tale: A New Method of Body Length Estimation Suggests Much Smaller Sizes for Dunkleosteus terrelli (Placodermi: Arthrodira)". Diversity. 15 (3): 318.

 

Engelman, Russell K.; Carr, Robert K.; Trinajstic, K.; Johanson, Z.; Lebedev, Oleg A. (2025). "Functional anatomy, jaw mechanisms, and feeding behavior of Dunkleosteus terrelli (Placodermi, Arthrodira)". The Anatomical Record ar.70075.

 

Carr, R, & G.L. Jackson. 2008. The Vertebrates fauna of the Cleveland member (Famennian) of the Ohio Shale. Society of Vertebrates Paleontology. 1–17.

 

Anderson, P.S.L.; Westneat, M. (2009). "A biomechanical model of feeding kinematics for Dunkleosteus terrelli (Arthrodira, Placodermi)" (PDF). Paleobiology. 35 (2): 251–269

 

Carr, Robert (1994). "A redescription of Gymnotrachelus hydei (Placodermi : Arthrodira) from the Cleveland Shale (Famennian) of northern Ohio, U. S. A.". Kirtlandia (48): 3–21.

 

Jobbins, Melina; Rücklin, Martin; Ferrón, Humberto G.; Klug, Christian (2022). "A new selenosteid placoderm from the Late Devonian of the eastern Anti-Atlas (Morocco) with preserved body outline and its ecomorphology". Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. 10.

 

Carr, Robert (February 1996). "Stenosteus augustopectus sp. nov. from the Cleveland Shale (Famennian) of Northern Ohio with a Review of Selenosteid (Placodermi) Systematics". Kirtlandia. 49: 9–43.

 

Hansen, Michael C. (2005). "Phylum Chordata—Vertebrate Fossils". In Feldmann, Rodney M.; Hackathorn, Merrianne (eds.). Fossils of Ohio. ODNR Bulletin 70. Columbus, Ohio: Ohio Department of Natural Resources.

bottom of page