top of page

Search this site

53 results found with an empty search

  • Further Reading | Prehistoric Midwest

    Learn more about Prehistoric life by visiting these other websites. Additional links to useful books are also provided on this webpage. Further Reading and Other Resources Further Reading: Websites Cretaceous Atlas of Ancient Life An online guide to the types of fossils found in deposits from the Western Interior Sea, with photographs of many types of invertebrate and vertebrate fossil material. Managed by the Paleontological Research Institution as part of the Digital Atlas of Ancient Life project. Cretaceousatlas.org Oceans of Kansas Paleontology One of the most extensive sources of online information about life in the Western Interior Sea. This website is run by Mike Everhart, Adjunct Curator of Paleontology at the Sternberg Museum of Natural History in Hays, Kansas. It features lots of excellent information about all types of extinct animals from the Cretaceous of Kansas. Oceansofkansas.com Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology An open-access 55 volume series from the University of Kansas Paleontological Institute detailing information about all known groups of prehistoric invertebrates. All volumes can be downloaded as pdf files from the Treatise website. Treatise on Invert Paleo website Animals of Ashfall, Nebraska Public Media Produced in collaboration with the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History. This website presents descriptions, illustrations and 3D models of some of the fossils of Miocene animals found at the Ashfall Fossil Beds in northern Nebraska. Animals of Ashfall Ammonites.org An online database with entries on hundreds of ammonoid and nautiloid species sorted by chronology and by their evolutionary relationships. Many entries have high quality photographs of cephalopod fossil specimens. Written in French. Ammonites.org Further Reading: Books Oceans of Kansas: Second Edition (2017) Written by Mike Everhart and published by Indiana University Press. This second edition builds on the original version of the book published in 2005. An excellent resource about the geology and paleontology of the entire Western Interior Sea Find this book Elephants and Their Fossil Relatives: A 60 Million Year Journey (2026) Written by Asier Larramendi and Marco P. Ferretti, illustrated by Shu-yu Hsu, published by Princeton University Press. A very comprehensive guide to all types of extinct proboscideans, featuring some excellent illustrations of these animals in their habitats. All of the proboscidean genera known from the Midwest are discussed in this book. A very good reference for anyone who wants to learn about the anatomy and ancient evolutionary history of extinct elephant relatives. Find this book Coloring Pages and Anatomical Diagrams We have produced a series of downloadable anatomical coloring pages for those who would like to learn more about the anatomies of prehistoric animals. Coloring pages featuring drawings of the animals themselves are also available. Learn more

  • Timeline of Prehistoric Life | Prehistoric Midwest

    The Western Interior Sea once spanned from the Gulf of Mexico to the Arctic Ocean and split North America in two during the Late Cretaceous period Timeline Of Prehistoric Life In The Midwest The Geologic Timescale When we look back at the entire history of the Earth, it is often useful to be able to divide the entire 4.56 billion year story of the planet into smaller increments. The geologic timescale divides Earth's history into a series of chronologically-ordered divisions which are themselves defined by major events in Earth's history. It is used by geologists and paleontologists to organize and date different rock layers and the fossils they hold. You may have heard of some of the geochronologic units found on the geologic timescale before; the Cretaceous and Jurassic periods are some well known examples. The boundaries between geochronologic units are defined by divisions between chronostratigraphic units. Chronostratigraphic units represent all of the rocks deposited over the course of a particular time interval. These units are based on the relative ages of different rock deposits. In cases where certain fossils are known to be very common in rocks from a particular chronostratigraphic unit, the appearance or disappearance of these index fossils can be used to define the start and end of a particular unit of time. For instance, the Jurassic system (a chronostratigraphic unit) contains all rocks deposited during the Jurassic period (a geochronologic unit) and the start of the Jurassic is defined by the first appearance in the fossil record of the ammonite Psiloceras spelae tirolicum. By looking at each of the units of time on the geologic timescale, we can get a general sense of what was happening on Earth at a particular time in the history of the planet. For example, rocks from the Campanian stage of the Cretaceous period found in Kansas preserve the remains of marine animals living in warm shallow waters. Similarly, rocks from the early Permian period in the eastern part of the state were formed 215 million years earlier, when that part of the world was covered in coastal rainforests filled with giant amphibians and millipedes. Jump To Section 1. The Cenozoic Era (66 million years ago - Present): After the extinction at the end of the Cretaceous period mammals become some of the largest animals found on Earth. The planet's climate slowly cools until large-scale glaciation covers many parts of the Midwest in ice sheets during the Pleistocene epoch. 3. The Paleozoic Era (538.8 - 252 million years ago): Life diversifies in the world's oceans and begins to move onto land. The first trees, insects, reptiles, amphibians and fish appear during this era. At various times during the Paleozoic the Midwest is covered in shallow seas or in huge rainforests filled with giant scale trees. 2. The Mesozoic Era (252 - 66 million years ago): Reptiles begin to take over new niches in the water, on land and in the skies. The first marine reptiles, pterosaurs, crocodylomorphs and dinosaurs appear during this era. Mammals and flowering plants also get their start during the Mesozoic. The Great Plains are covered in a shallow seaway during the second half of the Cretaceous period. 4. The Early Earth (4.56 billion years ago - 538.8 million years ago): The Earth and Moon are formed and the crust of the planet hardens into solid rock. The first oceans spread across the world and land is fairly rare. Life appears in the fossil record for the first time and by the end of the Proterozoic era, simple animals can be found living in the shallow seas of the Midwest. How To Read The Geologic Timescale The geologic timescale is composed of several different kinds units used to categorize spans of time. The largest units are eons, which usually span across billions of years or hundreds of millions of years. Each eon contains multiple eras, which are units of time lasting hundreds of millions or tens of millions of years. Eras are further broken down into periods, lasting tens of millions of years. Geologic periods are divided into units called epochs and ages which can last anywhere from millions of years to tens of thousands of years. Eons Eons are the largest units of geologic time. The history of the Earth is separated into four eons; the Hadean eon (4.65 billion years ago - 4 billion years ago), the Archaean eon (4 billion years ago - 2.5 billion years ago), the Proterozoic eon (2.5 billion years ago - 538.8 million years ago) and the Phanerozoic eon (538.8 million years ago - present). The Phanerozoic is the eon in which we are currently living. The name "Phanerozoic" means "visible life" since this era begins around the time that complex multicellular life began to proliferate. The entire evolutionary histories of mammals, reptiles, fish, insects, arachnids and land plants fall within the Phanerozoic eon. Eons are divided into smaller units called eras. Within the Phanerozoic eon there are three eras. The first of these is the Paleozoic era (538.8 - 252 million years ago) during which complex animal life diversified and the first vertebrates appeared and spread onto land. The Paleozoic contains six geologic periods; the Cambrian period, the Ordovician period, the Silurian period, the Devonian period, the Carboniferous period and the Permian period. The Paleozoic era was followed by the Mesozoic era (252 - 66 million years ago) which is often called the "age of reptiles". This is the span of time during which dinosaurs, birds, mammals and flowering plants appear in the fossil record. This era is divided into three periods; the Triassic period, the Jurassic period and the Cretaceous period. The Mesozoic era transitions over to the Cenozoic era at the end of the Cretaceous period 66 million years ago when an asteroid impact resulted in a mass extinction event. The Cenozoic era (66 million years ago - present) is the current era of geologic time. This span of time saw mammals move into many of the niches left behind after the extinction of the non-avian dinosaurs. It is divided into three periods; the Paleogene period, the Neogene period and the Quaternary period. The Quaternary period began 2.58 million years ago and is the time period which includes the present day. Eras and Periods Epochs, Ages and Stages Periods can further be divided into smaller units of time called epochs. An epoch usually lasts anywhere from tens of millions of years to tens of thousand of years. The current period of geologic time; the Quaternary period, is divided into the Pleistocene epoch (2.58 million years ago - 11,700 years ago) and the Holocene epoch (11,700 years ago - present). Mesozoic time periods are divided into "early", "middle" and "late" epochs, i.e. the Upper Cretaceous epoch or the Early Jurassic epoch. By putting all of this information together we can say that, for instance, we are currently in the Holocene epoch of the Quaternary period of the Cenozoic era of the Phanerozoic eon! Tyrannosaurus rex , on the other hand, lived in the Late Cretaceous epoch of the Cretaceous period of the Mesozoic era of the Phanerozoic eon. Some time periods and epochs are so long that it becomes useful to further divide them into units called ages. These ages are also often referred to using their chronostratigraphic equivalent unit term "stages". These ages often span a few million years. The Cretaceous period, for instance, is divided into two epochs; the Late Cretaceous and the Early Cretaceous. The Late Cretaceous is composed of six ages/stages; the Maastrichtian, the Campanian, the Santonian, the Coniacian, the Turonian and the Cenomanian. The Early Cretaceous epoch also has six ages/stages; the Albian, the Aptian, the Barremian, the Hauterivian, the Valanginian and the Berriasian. Many simplified representations of the geologic timescale like the one below will show the periods of the Phanerozoic (Cambrian- Quaternary) but will not show the periods of the previous three eons. The 12 phanerozoic periods can also be listed with their 1-2 letter abbreviations. These spans of time also have their own associated colors. Eons don't have universally accepted abbreviations so they are shown here as Had. (Hadean), Arch. (Archaean) and Prot. (Proterozoic). Abbreviations Cambrian period - Ꞓ Ordovician period - O Silurian period - S Devonian period - D Carboniferous period - C Permian period - P Triassic period - T Jurassic period - J Cretaceous period - K Paleogene period - Pg Neogene period - Ng Quaternary period - Q The Early Earth 4.56 billion years ago - 538.8 million years ago For the vast majority of Earth's history there were no plants, no animals, no fungi. For billions of years the entire planet was only home to simple single-celled organisms such as archaea. These first living things were closely tied to the presence of liquid water and may have gotten their start near hydrothermal vents or in warm mineral-rich geothermal springs. Plants first appeared as simple algae-like photosynthetic organisms sometime during the Proterozoic eon. It wouldn't be until the very end of the Proterozoic that organisms we might recognize as animals first appeared. The span of time previously known as the "Pre-Cambrian", now divided into the Hadean, Archaean and Proterozoic eons, comprises more than 70 percent of the history of the planet. It includes the earliest days of the Earth when our planet was still a ball of molten rock floating in space, as well as later periods of extreme cold when the planet would have nearly been covered in ice from pole to pole The Hadean eon is the first of four eons which make up the history of the Earth. This first span of around 750 million years saw the planet begin to coalesce from smaller pieces of metal and rock orbiting around the sun. Early on it its history, Earth is thought to have collided with another proto-planet called Theia, which resulted in the formation of the moon. The outer crust of the planet cooled into solid rock during the Hadean eon and the Earth developed its first atmosphere, which was composed of large amounts of methane, water vapor and ammonia. As The Earth cooled, some of this water vapor condensed to form the first oceans. Asteroids and comets rained down on the planet's surface bringing water, gasses, metals and other materials along with them. The end of the Hadean saw a particularly intense series of collisions during a time period called the Late Heavy Bombardment during which asteroid and comet impact became much more common. The first life forms on Earth may have appeared towards the end of the Hadean or during the first half of the next eon, the Archaean. During this eon the Earth was almost completely covered in a deep ocean, with only a few rare islands poking above the surface of the water. Cyanobacteria first appeared during this eon. Some of these ancient organisms are known from ancient fossils, known as stromatolites, which are formed from the cemented and layered remains of some types of microbial mats. The atmosphere was still oxygen-poor and was composed of large amounts of methane gas. The next eon, the Proterozoic, is the longest eon in the history of the Earth. Oxygen became an important component of the atmosphere and the world's oceans during the early part of this eon. A second oxygenation event later in the Proterozoic caused a series of glaciation events which may have covered nearly the entire planet in ice. Life became increasingly complex during the Proterozoic. The first microscopic plants appeared in the oceans during this eon, as did the first eukaryotic single-celled organisms. Some of the first groups of true animals appeared at the very end of the Proterozoic, including ancestors of sponges and jellyfishes. (ABOVE) A scene set during the late Archaean eon showing a cluster of stromatolites in the foreground. The rising levels of oxygen in the atmosphere have turned the sky a pale shade of blue while in the distance a few scattered volcanic islands stand in the middle of a vast global ocean Next Section The Paleozoic Era

  • Rodents | Prehistoric Midwest

    The Giant Beaver Castoroides was one of the largest rodents ever to live in North America and would have lived in freshwater environments during the Pleistocene epoch Rodentia Giant Pleistocene Rodents Rodents are mammals characterized primarily by a single pair of continuously growing incisors in both the upper and lower jaws. These incisors are large and chisel-shaped, well adapted for gnawing through tough materials. Rodents lack canine teeth and typically have a distinct gap called a diastema between their incisors and their cheek teeth. Rodents include all of today's mice, rats, gerbils, guinea pigs and porcupines, but during the Pleistocene epoch some North American rodents reached massive sizes. In particular the Giant Beaver Castoroides may have been the largest rodent to live in North America. Giant beaver Castoroides ohioensis Temporal Range: 1.9 million years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America from the Yukon to Florida Species: C. ohioensis, C. dilophidus Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, aquatic plants Castoroides , commonly known as the giant beaver, was one of the largest rodents ever to live in North America. This massive mammal inhabited lakes, marshes, and wetland habitats. Its fossils have been discovered across much of North America, with one species most often found in the Midwest (C. ohioensis ) and another species found in the southeastern US (C. dilophidus ) Unlike modern beavers, Castoroides was enormous, reaching lengths of about 7 feet and weighing about as much as a small bear. Its body was heavily built, with large hind feet that likely aided with swimming. Their tails may have been longer and less paddle-shaped than those of living beavers. One of Castoroides ' most notable features was the size of its incisors, which could grow to be over 6 inches long. These teeth had a textured enamel surface not seen in the chisel-like incisors of modern beavers. Evidence suggests that Castoroides fed primarily on aquatic vegetation rather than cutting down large trees. (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeletal anatomy of the giant beaver Castoroides . Drawing is based on a mounted skeleton on display at the Joseph Moore Museum in Richmond, Indiana. Note the extremely large size of the incisors. (BELOW) A partial cranium of Castoroides displayed alongside the cranium of an extant beaver. These huge rodents could easily weigh 20 times more than their smaller relatives. Media Gallery Suggested References: Rodentia Harington, C.R. (2007). "Giant Beaver, Castoroides ohioensis, remains in Canada and an overlooked report from Ontario". Canadian Field-Naturalist. 121 (3): 330–333. Korth, William W (1994). “The Tertiary record of rodents in North America”. Springer. p. 145. Parmalee P. W.; Graham R. W. (2002). "Additional records of the giant beaver, Castoroides, from the Mid-South: Alabama, Tennessee, and South Carolina". Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology. 93: 65–71. Plint, Tessa; Longstaffe, Fred J.; Zazula, Grant (2019). "Giant beaver palaeoecology inferred from stable isotopes". Scientific Reports. 9 (7179): 1–12. Swinehart, Anthony L., and Richards, Ronald L. (2001) "Palaeoecology of a Northeast Indiana Wetland Harboring Remains of the Pleistocene Giant Beaver (Castoroides Ohioensis)." Indiana Academy of Science.

  • Cleveland Shale | Prehistoric Midwest

    Guide To The Cleveland Shale Ancient fish from the Devonian of Ohio 361 million years ago the Midwest was covered by a shallow sea. At this time in Earth's history the largest types of vertebrates were the giant fish who patrolled the world's oceans. One particular type of prehistoric fish, the arthrodires (a group of placoderms) reached the height of their diversity towards the end of the Devonian period. In the layers of shale beneath parts of north-eastern Ohio, fossils of some of these giant armored fishes have been found which once belonged to some of the most powerful marine carnivores of their day. Giants like Dunkleosteus used their bone-shattering jaws to crush through the reinforced plates of their prey. Some arthrodires also appear to have adapted to become massive filter feeders. For instance, Titanichthys has a relatively light set of cranial armor and its reduced jaw plates suggest that it was an animal that specialized in straining microscopic organic material out of the water. Fossils of shark-like cartilaginous fishes can also be found in the rock layers of the Cleveland Shale. The seas of the Late Devonian were home to the strange genus Stethacanthus which is famous for its anvil-shaped dorsal fins. The fossils found in the Cleveland Shale date back to only a few million years before the Devonian period would end in a major mass extinction event. Many of these unique groups of marine vertebrates found in the layers of rock beneath parts of northern Ohio would soon vanish. The Cleveland Shale therefore stands as one of the best places to look back at a window of time when giant armored fishes still ruled the seas. Browse animals by taxonomic group Or scroll to the bottom of the page to browse by genus Cleveland Shale Fauna Armored Fish (Placodermi) Dunkleosteoids, Selenosteids, etc. Explore Cartilaginous Fish (Chondrichthyes) Ctenacanthiformes, Holocephali Coming Soon Bony Fish (Osteichthyes) Lungfishes, Palaeoniscoids Coming Soon About the Cleveland Shale The Cleveland Shale is a member of the larger Ohio Shale Formation. The section of the Cleveland Shale which is best known for its fossils of large marine vertebrates has outcrops in north-eastern Ohio. These layers can also be found at a few other sites in the south-western portion of the state. Fossils found in the Cleveland Shale are particularly common in Cuyahoga county, near the shale’s namesake city of Cleveland. The Cleveland Shale Member is typically divided into two sections, a lower set of layers which are lighter gray-blue in color and a darker, oil rich upper layer. The member as a whole is separated from the underlying Chagrin Shale by a thin layer of pyrite. (ABOVE) A map showing the areas where fossils are found in layers which fall within the Cleveland Shale (marked in orange). Most placoderm and shark fossils are found in the north-eastern part of the state but a few outcrops are also known from south-western Ohio. Most fossils are found in Cuyahoga County. The preservation quality of invertebrate remains at sites connected to the Cleveland Shale Member is generally rather poor. A few types of brachiopod fossils have been found in these layers but the most common fossils tend to be those of larger vertebrates, especially the harder parts of the skeletons of these aquatic animals. Remains of placoderms rarely preserve any material aside from the large bony plates which would have covered the heads and necks of these animals. Surprisingly the fossils of the bodies of ancient cartilaginous fishes tend to be rather complete. The entire outlines of the bodies of some of these ancient animals are visible as darker sections or areas within a flat section of rock. Most of these soft tissue fossils have been compressed or otherwise flattened by the fossilization process. In some parts of the Cleveland Shale, fragmentary fossils of woody plant material can also be found in the lower-most pyrite layer within the remains of what was once a shallow coastal region during the later part of the Devonian period. (ABOVE) Fauna known from the Cleveland Shale include (1) Palaeoniscoid bony fishes, (2,3,4) armored placoderms, and (5) cartilaginous fishes, usually those which are part of the lineage which includes today's Chimaeras, the Holocephali. Placoderms Bungartius Coccosteus Diplognathus Dunkleosteus Gorgonichthys Gymnotrachelus Heintzichthys Holdenius Mylostoma Paramylostoma Selenosteus Stenosteus Titancichthys Rare placoderms

  • Pleistocene guide | Prehistoric Midwest

    An illustrated field guide to the extinct megafauna once found in the Midwest during the Pleistocene epoch including mammoths, mastodons, sabertooth cats, camels and ancient horses Guide To The Megafauna Of The Pleistocene Ice age giants in the Midwest The Pleistocene epoch began 2.58 million years ago and ended at the start of the Holocene epoch 11,700 years ago. This stretch of time saw the Midwest play host to many different types of giant ancient land mammals and reptiles, including members of groups which are entirely absent from the North American continent today. Relatives of today's elephants, including mammoths and mastodons, made their homes in the open plains and pine forests, while giant ground sloths browsed on woody vegetation. Parts of the southern plains in Oklahoma and Texas were even home to huge armadillos which could grow to be the size of a small car! Whether due to a changing climate or the arrival of humans, many of these ancient animals disappeared towards the end of the Pleistocene epoch, with most of the largest land mammals having vanished by around 10,000 years ago. Browse animals by taxonomic order/family Or scroll to the bottom of the page to browse by genus Extinct Pleistocene Mammals Elephant relatives (Proboscidea) Mastodons, Mammoths, Gomphotheres Explore Cats and Dogs (Carnivora) Pantherines, Saber-Toothed Cats, Wolves Explore Odd-Toed Ungulates (Perissodactyla) Horses, Tapirs Explore Even-Toed Ungulates (Artiodactyla) Deer, Bison, Camels, Peccaries Explore Sloths and Armadillos (Xenarthra) Giant Ground Sloths, Glyptodonts Explore Giant Beaver Explore Rodents (Rodentia) Extinct Pleistocene Reptiles Tortoises (Testudinidae) Western Giant Tortoise Explore The Pleistocene Landscape Glaciers, tundras and pine forests covered the corn belt The midwest as it was inhabited by the megafauna of the Pleistocene was very different from the land we known today. 700,000 years ago glaciers reached as far south as Kansas City and the area that would one day become the Great Lakes was covered by thousands of feet of ice. Explore the Pleistocene Landscape Browse all Pleistocene taxa Carnivorans Bears (Family Ursidae) Arctodus pristinus Arctodus simus Cats (Family Felidae) Homotherium Miracinonyx American Lion Giant Jaguar Smilodon Dogs and Wolves (Family Canidae) Aenocyon armbrusteri Dire wolf Canis edwardii Proboscidea Cuvieronius Mammuthus columbi Mammuthus primigenius Mammut americanum Stegomastodon Perissodactyla Horses (Family Equidae) Equus scotti Equus simplicidens Haringtonhippus Nannippus Tapirs (Family Tapiridae) Tapirus veroensis Artiodactyla Peccaries (Family Tayassuidae) Mylohyus Platygonus Deer (Family Cervidae) Bretzia Cervalces Camels (Family Camelidae) Camelops Hemiauchenia Palaeolama Titanotylopus Bison, Muskoxen (Family Bovidae) Bison antiquus Bison latifrons Bison occidentalis Bootherium Euceratherium Pronghorns (Family Antilocapridae) Capromeryx Stockoceros Tetrameryx Xenarthrans Sloths (Suborder Folivora) Megalonyx Nothrotheriops Paramylodon Armadillos (Order Cingulata) Dasypus bellus Glyptotherium Holmesina Rodents Castoroides Tortoises Hesperotestudo

  • Artiodactyls | Prehistoric Midwest

    Explore the different species of prehistoric bison, muskoxen, deer, pronghorns and peccaries found in the Midwest during the Pleistocene epoch. Artiodactyla Even-Toed Ungulates Artiodactyla, a group also known as the even-toed ungulates, comprises the largest and most diverse living order of hoofed mammals. Members of this group typically hold their weight on their 3rd and 4th toes, unlike the odd-toed ungulates who walk on feet supported by 1, 3 or 5 toes. Artiodactyls include all of today’s sheep, goats, cattle, pigs, muskoxen, antelopes, pronghorns, giraffes, camels, deer and hippos. The group also includes all of today’s whales, dolphins and porpoises, since these aquatic animals descend from land-dwelling hoofed ancestors. During the Pleistocene epoch the Midwest was home to many types of artiodactyls which have since gone extinct, ranging from giant bison who were as big as rhinos to tiny pronghorns who were less than half as large as their living relatives. Anatomy Skeletal Anatomy Artiodactyls, or even-toed ungulates, are named for a key feature of their foot anatomy, where the third and fourth toes bear the majority of the body's weight. These digits are usually capped with keratinous hooves and serve as the main points of contact with the ground. In many species, the remaining digits have become reduced or vestigial and are only present as small nubs along the back of each foot. In some groups of artiodactyls, such as deer and cattle, the metacarpal and metatarsal bones are fused to form a cannon bone in the areas above the front and hind hooves. These bones give their limbs more stability when moving at high speeds. Their limbs are typically long and thin, although there are of course exceptions to this tendency, such as hippos. Most artiodactyls can move very quickly over short to medium distances. The skulls of these animals also show some specialized features and many types of artiodactyls have horns or antlers that help play a role in defense, communication with other members of their species, and/or competition for mates or territory. Their teeth are generally specialized for plant-based diets, with large grinding molars and, in many ruminants, a reduction or complete lack of upper incisors. (BELOW) Features of the skeletal anatomy of the long-snouted peccary Mylohyus. These animals had many of the traits which are commonly found in artiodactyls, including feet supported by hooves on two toes, tall spinous processes on the thoracic vertebrae and a short tail. These peccaries would have also had rather long tusks. (BELOW) In many large artiodactyls such as bison and camels the tall spinous processes behind the shoulder anchor extensive amounts of soft tissue in the form of a dorsal ridge or hump. These are often used to store fat and energy by animals who live in very harsh or strongly seasonal environments Peccaries (Tayassuidae) Peccaries in the Midwest Peccaries are a group of hoofed mammals in the order Artiodactyla (even-toed ungulates). Their closest relatives are pigs. There are three peccary genera alive today found in parts of North and South America: the white-lipped peccary (Tayassu ), the chacoan peccary (Catagonus ) and the collared peccary or javelina (Dicotyles). These extant peccaries are particularly common in semi-arid environments today but during the Pleistocene, several other types of peccaries were found all throughout the Americas, even reaching as far north as Michigan. Long-snouted peccary Mylohyus nasutus Temporal Range: 5 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Eastern and central North America , Nebraska, Texas, Florida Species: M. nasutus , M. elmorei, M. floridanus, M. fossilis, M. gildleyi Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Mylohyus was an extinct genus of peccary found throughout many parts of North America during the Pleistocene. These animals stood slightly taller than today’s peccaries. Their legs were relatively long and their skulls were particularly large for a peccary. Their canine teeth formed a set of sharpened tusks which they could use as defensive weapons or as tools used to dig in search of roots and edible tubers. The spinous processes on the vertebrae near the shoulder were quite long in these animals and would have been held off the ground at a higher position than the pelvis, giving Mylohyus ’s back a distinctive sloped posture. The genus first appears in the fossil record around the start of the Pliocene epoch and quickly spread across a large part of the southern and eastern areas of the North American continent. Knowledge about their social structure is somewhat murky but they seem to have lived in smaller groups than other Pleistocene peccaries like Platygonus. Flat-headed peccary Platygonus compressus Temporal Range: 10.3 million years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North and South America Species: P. compressus, P. brachirostris, P. chapadmalensis, P. cinctus, P. kraglievichi, P. marplatensis, P. narinoensis, P. oregonensis, P. pearcei, P. pollenae, P. scagliae, P. setiger, P. striatus, P. texanus, P. vetus Diet: Omnivorous, roots, tubers, leaves, invertebrates, carrion Platygonus was the most widespread genus of North American peccaries from the Pleistocene epoch. In terms of its general appearance, it was similar in size and shape to today’s collared peccaries. The name “flat-headed peccary” refers to the shape of the animal’s forehead, which was smooth with no sharp differences in the angles between the slope of the bones of the forehead and the slope of the nasal bones. Relative to their body sizes, Platygonus peccaries had smaller skulls than their contemporaries like Mylohyus . Fossil assemblages of the remains of large groups of Platygonus are often found in caves, suggesting that they may have used these areas as a source of shelter. They also seem to have been very social animals, with perhaps dozens of animals living together in herds. Peccaries in the genus Platygonus were particularly common in eastern North America, but ranged much further south as well, with other species of Platygonus known from fossils found as far away as Argentina. Deer (Cervidae) Horse-Sized Behemoths and Agile Runners Deer are a group of artiodactyls best known for their unique antlers. Unlike the true horns seen in other groups of animals, deer grow a new set of antlers every year and shed them during the fall. The largest type of deer found in North America today is the moose, which spread across the continent during the Pleistocene epoch. Some extinct deer species from the Pleistocene like the Stag-moose Cervalces rivaled today’s largest moose in terms of size, growing to be nearly as large as a draft horse. Other extinct deer genera from the Pleistocene, like the smaller genus Bretzia , more closely resembled today’s white-tailed deer and mule deer, with a smaller body size than today’s moose and elk, narrower snouts and thinner legs. Some of these extinct animals preferred to live in wetland habitats, while others tended to live in forests. Bretzia nebrascensis Temporal Range: 4.9 million years ago to approximately 10,000 years ago Geographic Range: Central North America, Nebraska, South Dakota Species: B. nebrascensis, B pseudalces Diet: Herbivorous, leaves, twigs, soft buds Bretzia is a genus of deer with two recognized species, Bretzia nebrascensis and Bretzia pseudalces . Bretzia pseudalces is known from fossils found in deposits from Washington state and had broad antlers similar to those of moose. Bretzia nebrascensis is known from fossils found in deposits from the Great Plains and had thinner tines on its antlers, more similar to those seen in the living white-tailed deer. The exact relationship between these two species of Bretzia is somewhat unclear and they may in fact be more distinct from one another than previously thought. Bretzia is classified as a member of the subfamily Capriolinae, along with animals like caribou, mule deer, white-tailed deer, Cervalces and moose. They are more closely related to these types of deer than they are to members of the “old world deer” subfamily such as elk. The genus includes some of the oldest types of deer known from the Americas. Bretzia likely had a long thin snout, thin legs and a gracile body plan. Like most of today’s species of deer, the females of this genus are thought to have lacked antlers. Stag-moose Cervalces scotti Temporal Range (C. scotti) : Middle Pleistocene to approximately 11,500 years ago Geographic Range: Genus found in North America, Europe, Asia Species: C. scotti, C. latifrons, C. carnutorum Diet: Herbivorous, leaves, sedges, aquatic plants The Stag moose, Cervalces , was a close relative to today’s moose. The genus Cervalces contains three species, two of which are only found in Eurasia, as well as the species C. scotti , the only species found in North America. Unlike today’s moose whose antlers each form a single palmate frond-like shape, Cervalces scotti had antlers with a flattened lower palmated section and an upper palmate area with sharper tines. The North American population of Cervalces seems to be descended from a group of Eurasian Cervalces , most likely Cervalces latifrons , which moved across the Bering land bridge into Alaska at some point during the Pleistocene. It seems to have preferred living in woodlands enviroments which sustained high level of rainfall, perhaps wading through shallow water in search of aquatic plants, a behavior often seen in today’s moose. Cervalces had a skull with a large nasal opening. In living moose, the rear parts of the nasal openings are positioned further back on their skulls, leaving room for a large fleshy nose which they can seal off when grazing underwater. In Cervalces , the nasal openings are positioned further forward than in moose but further back than in most other types of deer. This suggests that they may have had a less specialized nasal structure than today’s moose. (BELOW) An antler and skull fragment from a Cervalces on display at the KU Natural History Museum. These fossils were found along the Kaw river in eastern Kansas and date back to the late Pleistocene Camels (Camelidae) Giant Camels and Llama Relatives Camels from the family Camelidae form a group of hoofed mammals which includes all living old world camels, llamas, alpacas, vicunas, guanacos and all their closest extinct relatives. Although there are no living camels native to the Midwest, for most of their evolutionary history camels were most abundant in North America, only spreading to other continents within the last few million years. Camels are part of the suborder Tylopoda, named after the padded feet often seen in living camelids. Unlike true ruminant animals who have four stomach chambers, camels only have three-chambered stomachs making them less efficient at digesting tough plant material like grass. Most camels feed on a mixture of grasses and softer leaves. During the Pleistocene epoch, the Midwest was home to a wide variety of camel genera, including some very large animals like the elephant-sized Titanotylopus as well as smaller relatives of today’s South American camelids. Camelops hesternus Temporal Range: 3.2 million years ago to approximately 13,000 years ago Geographic Range: Western North America , Central America Species: C. hesternus Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Camelops , also known as the Western Camel or Yesterday’s Camel, was a Pleistocene camel which somewhat resembled today’s dromedary camels. The shape of the spinous processes over the vertebrae along this camel’s back might indicate that it had a low hump similar to those seen in living camels, although the shape and extent of this soft tissue structure has not yet been determined. These animals seem to be closely related to animals like Paracamelus who crossed over into Eurasia and were the direct ancestors of the camels found in parts of Asia and Africa today. Fossils of Camelops are found from southern Canada all the way to Honduras, indicating that these animals once had a very broad geographical range spreading across most of North America. Standing around 7 feet tall, Camelops would have been similar in size to today’s dromedary camels. It is assumed to have had a flexible lip split into two halves like modern camelids, an adaptation which would have allowed it to easily browse for vegetation and to pull leaves off of branches. Fossils showing many sets of Camelops footprints laid down in the same area show us that these camels were animals who preferred to live in herds. Based on the discovery of Camelops remains found in association with stone tools and showing signs of cut marks on their bones, it seems as though these camels were also hunted by humans who had crossed over into the Americas Hemiauchenia macrocephala Temporal Range: 10.3 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found in parts of North and South America Species: H. macrocephala, H. minima, H. blancoensis, H. vera, H. paradoxa, H. seymourensis, H. edensis, H. mirim Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Hemiauchenia is a genus of camels in the tribe lamini which seems to have been the direct ancestor of today’s South American camelids like llamas and alpacas. The genus first appeared during the Miocene in North America with fossils of these early animals uncovered in Texas, Kansas, Nebraska and Florida as well as parts of Central America. The genus further expanded into South America once the isthmus of Panama joined the Americas around 2-2.5 million years ago. Species like Hemiauchenia paradoxa appear in South America during the middle Pleistocene. Like many other lamine camelids, Hemiauchenia had a long neck habitually held in a posture which would have positioned most of the cervical vertebrae above the shoulder blades. Their torsos were relatively narrow and they would have lacked the tall spinous processes which could have anchored fleshy humps like those seen in dromedary and bactrian camels. Some species of Hemiauchenia had proportionally larger heads than their living relatives. Hemiauchenia was widespread in North America for much of the Pleistocene but disappeared in North America at the very end of the epoch around 12,000 years ago. The descendants of Hemiauchenia paradoxa diversified in South America during the later part of the Pleistocene. Giant Camel Titanotylopus nebraskensis Temporal Range: 10.3 million years ago to approximately 300,000 years ago Geographic Range: Central and western North America, California, Nebraska Species: T. nebraskensis Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Titanotylopus was by far the largest camel found in Ice Age North America. Standing as tall as a small elephant, these animals filled ecological roles similar to those occupied by giraffes on other continents. Thanks to their height and their extremely long necks, they were able to browse for leafy vegetation which was off limits to nearly every other type of Ice Age herbivore. Titanotylopus did not survive long enough to reach the end of the Pleistocene epoch. This genus first appeared during the Miocene epoch and lived up until around 300,000 years ago. In its habitat throughout much of what would one day become the Great Plains it would have been one of the largest hoofed mammals around at the time. Like many of today’s camelids, Titanotylopus camels had very long canine teeth which they may have used as defensive weapons when fighting against potential predators and/or against other Titanotylopus in fights over mates, food or territory. Some paleontologists consider the camels once classified as a separate genus, Gigantocamelus , to be part of the genus Titanotylopus , while others consider these to be two separate genera. (BELOW) A skeleton of Titanotylopus on display at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History (BELOW) A Titanotylopus skull on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Note the large size of the canine teeth. These long teeth were used to fight with other camels over territory, food and water. Male dromedary and bactrian camels still have very large canine teeth today. Palaeolama mirifica Temporal Range: 1.9 million years ago to approximately 3,400 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North and South America Species: P. aequatorialis, P. brevirostris, P. crassa, P. crequii, P. hoffstetteri, P. leptognata, P. major, P. niedae, P. paradoxa, P. promesolithica, P. reissi, P. weddeli, P. mirifica Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Palaeolama , also known as the Stout-Legged Llama, was a lamine camel related to today’s South American camelids as well as the extinct genus Hemiauchenia . Its remains are found in parts of both North and South America. Unlike most of the other hoofed animals included in this section, Palaeolama did not go extinct at the end of the Pleistocene epoch. The most recent remains of these animals seem to be around 4,200 years old. The genus Palaeolama first appeared in Florida during the middle Pleistocene but these animals would soon move to new habitats, eventually reaching far away Chile and Argentina. In terms of their anatomy and proportions they were roughly similar in appearance to today’s llamas, albeit with slightly shorter legs and a larger maximum body size. Their remains are found in areas which would have been open grasslands, forests and mountainous regions. They seem to have fed on a mixture of grasses, sedges, leaves and softer leaf buds. Bison and Muskoxen (Bovidae) Ancient Relatives of Cattle and Goats Bovids are a family of mammals with four-chambered stomachs and cloven hooves which includes today’s cows, goats, sheep, muskoxen and antelopes. These animals first appeared in Eurasia and by the Pleistocene, North American bovids were still fairly recent arrivals on the continent. During the Pleistocene, the bovid family was represented in North America by members of the Bovinae subfamily (Bison, cattle) as well as members of the subfamily Caprinae (Muskoxen, sheep, etc.). Some of these ancient species seem to have been the direct ancestors of species still found in North America today, while others became extinct towards the end of the Pleistocene or the start of the Holocene. One species from the Pleistocene, the Giant Bison, may have been the largest bovid ever to live in North America. Ancient bison Bison antiquus Temporal Range: 60,000 years ago to approximately 10,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North America Species: B. antiquus, desendents of this species evolved into B. bison Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Bison antiquus , also known as the ancient bison, was a large extinct species of bison which is thought to be the ancestor of the western bison and the species of bison found in North America today. Compared with today’s bison, Bison antiquus was considerably larger and had a taller hump over its shoulder. The presence of this hump is determined based on the presence of extremely long spinous processes on vertebrae near the animal’s shoulders. Patterns of wear on their teeth suggest that they were better suited for feeding on a mixture of soft leaves and tough grasses, spending their lives living in mixed forest-grassland habitats, instead of being grassland specialists. Like today’s bison, these animals are presumed to have lived in large herds, offering them protection from animals like saber-toothed cats, pantherines and large canids which are known from fossil evidence of kill sites to have preyed upon ancient bison fairly regularly. Humans also seem to have hunted these bison, as they were still present when the first people arrived in North America. (BELOW) The skull of an ancient bison on display at the KU Natural History Museum. This particular skull was found in a late Pleistocene deposit in north-eastern Kansas. Giant bison Bison latifrons Temporal Range: 120,000 years ago to approximately 13,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, from Canada to Mexico Species: B. latifrons Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Bison latifrons was the largest bison species to appear in North America during the Pleistocene epoch. It is best known for its gigantic horns which could span 7 feet from tip to tip, much larger than the horn spans of today’s bison. The shape of the rest of the body of Bison latifrons remains something of a mystery as most material known from this animal is composed of fragmentary skulls and horns, but if scaled based on other bison species, these animals would have been truly enormous, reaching masses comparable to those of adult white rhinos. Like all North American bison species, Bison latifrons is thought to have descended from a population of steppe bison who crossed over the Bering land bridge into Alaska and from there spread throughout the rest of North America, diversifying as they entered new habitats. There is some evidence to suggest that Bison latifrons may have given rise to Bison antiquus which was the ancestor of today’s American bison. As a side note, animals of the genus “Bison ” are sometimes considered to be part of the same genus as cattle, the genus “Bos ”. This would make the giant bison Bos latifrons but since this group is more commonly known by the genus name “Bison ” we will continue to use this genus name for our entries about prehistoric bison species. (BELOW) A partial skull and horns of a giant bison (top of the image) on display at the KU Natural History Museum. These remains are much larger than the skulls of other bison species visible on the lower row of this display Western bison Bison occidentalis Temporal Range: 13,000 years ago to approximately 1,700 years ago Geographic Range: Found in Alaska and central North America Species: B. occidentalis, possibly intermediate between B. antiquus and B. bison Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Bison occidentalis , also known as the western bison is a type of bison which is sometimes considered its own species or alternatively considered to be a subspecies of American bison. These animals managed to survive up until very recently, with the youngest Bison occidentalis remains having been found at a site dated to be less than 2,000 years old. In terms of their appearance, they were roughly similar to today’s American bison, smaller than their possible ancestor, the much larger Bison antiquus . They had medium-sized horns which pointed up and slightly forwards. Fossils of these animals are found far to the north where they likely would have needed very thick fur in order to survive frigid arctic winters. At various times, different authors have suggested these animals to have constituted their own genus, or to have formed a subspecies of either Bison priscus, Bison antiquus or Bison bison. (BELOW) A skull of a western bison on display at the KU Natural History Museum. The skulls of these bison are very similar to those of the living bison subspecies still found in North America today. Woodland muskox Bootherium bombifrons Temporal Range: 780,000 years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North America Species: B. bombifrons Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Bootherium bombifrons , the woodland muskox, was an extinct species of muskox adapted for life in forested habitats. These animals are sometimes called helmeted muskoxen, since their horns are fused together over their foreheads instead of being separated by a deep gap as in living muskoxen. Bootherium remains are found in sites which represent temperate environments, suggesting that these ancient animals preferred to live in dense woodlands instead of the open tundras where their living relatives can be found today. In order to remain comfortable while living in these warmer habitats, they may have been covered in a lighter coat of fur, especially during the summer months. Although muskoxen superficially resemble cows, they are actually part of the subfamily Caprinae, which also includes today’s sheep and goats. The name for the genus of the living muskox, “Ovibos ”, translates to “sheep-cow” because of this resemblance. Like their living kin, the woodland muskox would have had wide feet well adapted for walking over muddy, snowy or otherwise unstable ground. (BELOW) A skeleton of Bootherium on display at the KU Natural History Museum. This is a particularly complete skeleton which was recovered from the Natural Trap Cave system in Wyoming which has yielded the bones of many types of animals from the late Pleistocene epoch. (BELOW) The top of a skull of Bootherium . The horns of these animals were fused together along the top of the animal's skull, unlike the horns of living muskoxen which are separated from one another by a deep groove (BELOW) The skull of a living muskox (Ovibos ) at the KU Museum. Note the unfused area between the horns in this genus Shrub ox Euceratherium collinum Temporal Range: 1.1 million years ago to approximately 13,000 years ago Geographic Range: Genus is found in Asia and North America Species: E. collinum, E. bizzelli Diet: Herbivorous, soft buds, twigs, leaves Euceratherium, the shrub-ox, was a genus of muskox whose remains are found in parts of Central America, the southern and western parts of the US and parts of China. Fossils of Euceratherium have been found as far south as Guatemala, giving it one of the southern-most ranges of any muskox species. The remains in eastern Asia seem to be the oldest remains of Euceratherium and these animals most likely first appeared in Eurasia before later moving over to North America at some point during the middle Pleistocene. Euceratherium seems to have preferred living in hilly areas where these animals would have fed upon leafy vegetation instead of grass. They are thought to have filled an ecological role similar to that of the living takin, another species of caprine bovid found today in parts of the Himalayas. Like other muskox species, Euceratherium had large horns, although their horns tended to curve sharply forwards instead of upwards as is seen in those of living muskoxen and those of the extinct woodland muskox Bootherium . Pronghorns (Antilocapridae) North America's Endemic Ruminants Antilocaprids are a group of hoofed ruminant mammals native to North America. Although they are often called “antelopes” their closest relatives are giraffes and okapis. Many types of prehistoric antilocaprids can be distinguished from one another based on the shapes of their horns. These horns have some features unique to this group. Although they superficially resemble the true horns found in bovids, antilocaprids are able to shed their horns similarly to the way that deer shed their antlers. Extinct antilocaprids, like today’s pronghorns, were typically grassland specialists and fed on a diet primarily composed of grass, although some ancient antilocaprid varieties may have had a greater preference for browsing on leaves. Capromeryx furcifer Temporal Range: 5 million years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North and South America Species: C. arizonensis, C. furcifer, C. gidleyi, C. mexicanus, C. minor Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Capromeryx , also known as the dwarf pronghorn, was the smallest known antilocaprid genus. It lived in North America from the start of the Pliocene to the late Pleistocene epoch, with its fossils having been found from Nebraska to as far south as central Mexico. The smallest species of Capromeryx had estimated adult body weights in the area of around 25 pounds, making them much smaller that today’s pronghorns. The horns of Capromeryx were arranged into four points. Unlike in Stockoceros or Tetrameryx where their horns point in opposite directions, forwards and backwards, in Capromeryx the horn cores seem to be positioned parallel to one another on each side of the skull. In the remains of some individuals the front and rear horns are of roughly equal length while in others the front horns are considerably shorter than the rear horns. In general it seems as though later species of Capromeryx had smaller horns than their relatives in the Pliocene. Stockoceros conklingi Temporal Range: 1.8 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Southern North America, as far as central Mexico Species: S. conklingi, S. onusrosagris Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Stockoceros was a genus of extinct pronghorns whose fossils are found in the southern parts of North America. Their fossils are found as far north as Texas and as far south as central Mexico, with populations also reaching the Pacific coast in parts of California. Stockoceros had two horns on top of its head and each of these horns was split into two halves of roughly equal length and size. The tips of the horn cores from these animals are slightly rounded instead of pointed, but keratin horn extensions may have meant that their horns grew into a different shape in life in some individuals. Stockoceros was initially considered to be part of the genus Tetrameryx , another larger pronghorn found in Pleistocene deposits, however most workers currently consider it to be a valid separate genus. Most remains of Stockoceros represent animals who are slightly smaller than today’s pronghorns but larger than the dwarf pronghorn Capromeryx . Tetrameryx shuleri Temporal Range: 1.8 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout western North America Species: T. irvingtonensis, T. knoxensis, T. mooseri, T. shuleri, T. tacubayensis Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Tetrameryx is an extinct genus of pronghorns known from fossils found in the southern and western parts of North America. Many species are classified within this genus, distinguished from one another based on subtle differences in the shapes of their horns. In the best represented species, Tetrameryx shuleri , there is a considerable difference between the sizes of the front and rear horns. In this species, a shorter set of anterior horns sits at the front of the skull with two larger horns behind them. These rear horns could extend to lengths of over 2 feet, making them far larger than the horns of living pronghorns. Tetrameryx appears to have been a more heavily built animal than many of its relatives. As with other antilocaprids, the structure of its leg bones are unique, with the lower legs composed of only the cannon bones without any additional lateral toes. The most recent Tetrameryx populations seem to have died out around 12,000 years ago Media Gallery Suggested References: Artiodactyla Baskin, J., R. Walls, and R. Thomas. (2022). “Bison antiquus and B. latifrons from the latest Rancholabrean (latest Pleistocene), Nueces River Valley, South Texas”. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin 88: 213. Bover, Pere; Llamas, Bastien; Thomson, Vicki A.; Pons, Joan; Cooper, Alan; Mitchell, Kieren J. (2018). "Molecular resolution to a morphological controversy: The case of North American fossil muskoxen Bootherium and Symbos". Dalquest, W. W. (1974). "A New Species of Four-Horned Antilocaprid from Mexico". Journal of Mammalogy. 55 (1): 96–101 Hoganson, JW (2002). "Occurrence of the Giant Ice Age Bison, Bison latifrons, in North Dakota" (PDF). NDGS Newsletter. 29 (2): 1–3. McDonald, J. N., & Lammers, G. E. (2002). “Bison antiquus from Kenora, Ontario, and notes on the evolution of North American Holocene bison”. Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology, 93, 83–97. McDonald, H. Gregory; Dyer, David L.; Shane, Linda C. K.; Haskell, Brian J.; Stafford, Jr., Thomas W. (2024). "The Woodland Muskox Bootherium bombifrons (Artiodactyla, Bovidae) from Hebron, Licking County, Ohio, USA and its Paleoecology in the Great Lakes Region". The Ohio Journal of Science. 123 (2): 44–61. McDonald, H. Gregory. (1989) "New Records of the Elk-moose Cervalces scotti from Ohio". American Midland Naturalist 122.2 : 349-356. Richards, R. L.; McDonald, J. N. (1991). "New Records of Harlan's Muskox (Bootherium bombifrons) and an Associated Fauna from the Late Pleistocene of Indiana". Proceedings of the Indiana Academy of Science. 99 (2–4): 211–228. Spencer, Lillian M.; Scott, Eric (2023). "Resource partitioning among late Pleistocene herbivores of Natural Trap Cave, Wyoming". Quaternary International. 647–648: 88–93. Wilson, M.C.; Hills, L.V.; Shapiro, B. (2008). "Late Pleistocene northward-dispersing Bison antiquus from the Bighill Creek Formation, Gallelli Gravel Pit, Alberta, Canada, and the fate of Bison occidentalis". Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences. 45 (7): 827–859. Zver, Lars; Toškan, Borut; Bužan, Elena (2021). "Phylogeny of Late Pleistocene and Holocene Bison species in Europe and North America". Quaternary International. 595: 30–38.

  • Miocene Proboscideans | Prehistoric Midwest

    Proboscidea Ancient Elephant Relatives Proboscidea is the order of mammals which includes all of today’s elephants as well as their closest extinct relatives. Today North America is not home to any wild proboscideans but this was not always the case. During the Miocene and Pliocene epoch the Great Plains were home to at least ten proboscidean genera which can generally be grouped into three categories, the amebelodontids, the gomphotheriids, and the mammutids. These ancient elephant relatives had some features in common with their living relatives; they had trunks and long tusks on their upper jaws formed from a set of extended incisors. Unlike today’s elephants however, most Neogene proboscideans had relatively short legs, stocky torsos and many genera had a second set of tusks set along the front edges of their elongated lower jaws. The exact shapes of these mandibular tusks varied between different groups. Members of the family Amebelodontidae had spoon-shaped lower jaws tipped with broad and flattened tusks. Gomphotheriids on the other hand often had pointed tusks on their lower jaws, although some genera like Gnathabelodon had no tusks on their lower jaws while still having very long mandibles. Mammutids were the ancestors of later animals like the American mastodon. Earlier mammutids still had tusks in their lower jaws but they were much smaller than in most other contemporary Amebelodontids and Gomphthotheriids. It should be noted that although we refer to the family Gomphotheriidae as a separate group in this section, it is likely that Gomphotheriidae is not a natural grouping of animals and that some members of this family were in fact the direct ancestors of all mammoths and all three living elephant species. Anatomy Skull and Dentition Many well known North American gomphotheres and amebelodontids had longer jaws and lower foreheads than today's living elephants. The heights of the foreheads of the extinct genera does vary by region to some extent; Platybelodon from Asia have low foreheads while the North American members of this genus have taller skulls. In many genera from the Miocene epoch, the upper incisors developed into tusks that curved downward and outward. These animals also tended to have a distinctive lateral band of enamel running along the outsides of their upper tusks. Amebelodontids had very specialized lower jaws which sometimes widened towards the opening of the mouth. It some genera, such as Platybelodon, the base of the lower jaw was wide enough to form a spoon-like structure. Most of these proboscideans had a second set of tusks set at the front apex of their lower jaws, which seems to be the ancestral condition for all proboscideans. This feature seems to have been lost independently at least five separate times by different groups of proboscideans. The genera Megabelodon, Eubelodon and Gnathabelodon , for instance, had long lower jaws but with no mandibular tusks. The fossilized molars of these animals are covered in unique patterns of cusps and ridges which can be used to distinguish between different groups of ancient proboscideans. Gomphotheres and amebelodontids had tooth surfaces which were covered in rounded cusps which allowed them to feed on many different types of plants, including grasses, sedges and soft leaves. On the other hand, Mammutids, the group which would later include animals like the American mastodon, had sharper, conical cusps adapted for a more specialized diet composed primarily of woody vegetation. (BELOW) Tooth shape is one of the easiest ways to distinguish between different groups of extinct proboscideans. (A) An "Amebelodon" tooth at the KU Museum with smooth cusps (the Rhino Hill "Amebelodon" material may instead belong to the genus Torynobelodon ) , (B) a mastodon tooth at KU with more angular chewing surfaces (BELOW) Many Miocene proboscideans had fairly short upper tusks which pointed downwards. (A) A skull of a "Gomphotherium " at the KU Museum, (B) A Megabelodon skull at the Denver Museum of Nature and Science (BELOW) A Tetralophodon longirostris mandible from Spain. These animals are considered to be "tetralophodont gomphotheres" since their first and second molar teeth each have four sets of cusps. Most North American gomphotheres are "trilophodont gomphotheres" who only have three sets of cusps on these same teeth. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, uploaded by user PePeEfe, CC BY-SA 4.0 Postcranial Skeletal Anatomy Proboscideans have to hold up the weight of their bulky bodies while moving around. As a result, these animals have columnar limbs and wide pads on their feet. Living elephants have long legs but many of the proboscidean genera known from deposits from the Miocene and Pliocene epochs had fairly short limbs and very stocky torsos. This feature is especially pronounced in genera such as Gomphotherium . (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeletal anatomy of a Megabelodon , based on the skeletal mount from the Denver Museum of Nature and Science. External Anatomy Little is known about the external appearances of proboscideans from the Miocene and Pliocene epochs. Modern elephants have relatively sparse body hair and large ears that help regulate body temperature by releasing heat from circulating blood. Woolly mammoths, and perhaps some mastodons,may have had different strategies for managing the temperatures of their bodies. Their thick fur and insulating undercoat helped them survive in cold environments. Proboscideans adapted to colder climates probably also had smaller ears, which would have reduced heat loss. By contrast, mammoths and other extinct proboscideans from warmer regions may have had mostly hairless skin similar to that of modern elephants. Because the Great Plains were warmer during the Miocene and Pliocene than they are today, the proboscideans that lived there may have had a light covering of hair, but probably not the dense, shaggy coats associated with woolly mammoths. (BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of the a Miocene proboscidean, Tatabelodon Proboscideans Amebelodon Eubelodon Gnathabelodon "Gomphotherium" osborni Megabelodon Platybelodon Serbelodon Tatabelodon Torynobelodon Zygolophodon Amebelodon Temporal Range: Late Miocene, 9 - 6.7 million years ago Geographic Range: Florida, Kansas, Nebraska, Oklahoma, Texas, Oregon Species: A. fricki, A. hicksi, A. floridanus Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Amebelodon is a genus of proboscideans which is the namesake for the family Amebelodontidae, also known as the “shovel tuskers”. These animals had long lower jaws which curved slightly downwards and would have had a pair of long, flattened tusks at the apex of their mandibles. Fossils of the genus Amebelodon are known from sites in the central Great Plains and along the southern Gulf coast. These animals seem to have been browsers who preferred to feed on woody browse instead of grasses. The shapes of their molars support this feeding strategy. Like many types of Miocene proboscideans, Amebelodon would have had molars which were covered in rounded lobes. This is an example of bunodont detention, a feature often seen in animals who feed on leaves, unlike the flattened molars seen in mammoths and other grazing proboscideans. Many hypotheses have been proposed to explain the function of the shovel-shaped tusks found on the lower jaws of Amebelodon . Earlier artistic depictions of these animals tend to show Amebelodo n living in wetlands and using its long jaws to scoop up aquatic vegetation. This interpretation is no longer particularly popular and they are now thought to have lived in drier environments, potentially using their long mandibular tusks to scrape bark off of trees. (BELOW) The lower jaw of an amebelodontid on display in the vertebrate paleontology collections at the Sternberg Museum of Natural History in Hays, Kansas. The tusks on the mandibles of amebelodontids were particularly broad and flattened. Eubelodon Temporal Range: Middle - Late Miocene, 12 - 5.9 million years ago Geographic Range: Nebraska, South Dakota Species: E. morrilli Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Eubelodon was a large trilophodont gomphothere which is known from Miocene deposits from the Great Plains. Like many types of gomphotheres, Eubelodon would have had proportionally shorter legs than those of living elephantids. This genus is also known as the “Perfect tusker”. These animals are thought to have been midbrowsers with somewhat longer trunks than some other types of early gomphotheres. Their lower jaws were rather long but would have lacked the distinctive tusks found along the mandibular symphysis at the front of the lower jaw. The lower jaw remains quite long, similar to the condition seen in many other longirostrine (long jawed) gomphotheres with a slight downward curve along the front edges of the jaw. The genus Eubelodon has had a fairly convoluted taxonomic history since its description as a unique genus in 1914. In some studies Eubelodon is considered to be a member of the Amebelodontid family as a close relative of animals like Protanancus and Megabelodon . It was previously considered to be a synonym of the genus Gomphotherium and was later considered to be a Rhynchotheriine. Their fossils are known from sites in northern Nebraska and south-central South Dakota and their fossils are found in the deposits which underlie the main ash layer at the Ashfall Fossil Beds. (BELOW) A Eubelodon skeleton on display in the hall of proboscideans at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. The lower jaws of these animals were longer than those of living elephants but shorter than the lower jaws of most longirostrine gomphotheres. Gnathabelodon Temporal Range: Clarendonian land mammal age, age of type specimen is uncertain Geographic Range: Kansas, Nebraska Species: G. thorpei Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Gnathabelodon was a close relative of the brevirostrine (short jawed) gomphotheres. Despite having an extremely long mandible, this genus had an unusual lack of tusks at the symphysis of its lower jaws, a feature which is only seen in a few other genera such as Eubelodon . The tip of the lower jaw was wide and would have flared outwards, giving it a spoon-like appearance. This feature has led to the animal occasionally being referred to as the “spoon jawed mastodon” although it should be noted that these animals were only distantly related to the true mastodons of the genus Mammut. The genus is generally considered to be a part of the Gomphotheriid family but it has also been suggested to have been a relative of the family Choerolophodontidae, a group which is otherwise only known from fossils found in Europe, Africa and Asia. "Gomphotherium" osborni Temporal Range: ~14 - 11.3 million years ago Geographic Range: North America Species in the Ogallala formation: G. osborni, G. productum? Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Gomphotherium is one of the best known Neogene proboscideans and the namesake for the family Gomphotheriidae. Its fossils are known from deposits in Europe, Asia, Africa and North America dating from a time span lasting from the early Miocene to the start of the Pliocene. Unlike the superficially similar members of the Amebelodontid family, Gomphotherium would not have had a wide spoon-shaped lower jaw. Its mandible would have been long and pointed. Its mandibular tusks were less broad than those of some of other contemporary proboscidean genera.Its skull was long and would have lacked the forehead dome seen in living asian elephants and the extinct mammoths. Its upper set of tusks curved gently downwards, bracing the trunk and the sides of the mandible when the mouth of the animal was closed. Like many other types of gomphotheres it would have had relatively short legs and a stocky build when compared with living elephants. They are considered to be a part of the trilophodont gomphothere group which is distinguished from other gomphotheres (tetralophodonts) by the three ridges found on their fourth premolars and their first two molars. The genus includes over a dozen species. The last members of the genus Gomphotherium seem to have lived in North America for millions of years after their relatives in Africa, Asia and Europe had become extinct. It is likely that one of the Afro-Eurasian Gomphotherium species, Gomphotherium steinheimense , is the direct ancestor of today’s living elephants. (BELOW) A Gomphotherium skeleton on display in the main hall of the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. These animals had very short legs compared with those of living elephants. Megabelodon Temporal Range: Miocene and Pliocene epochs Geographic Range: Nebraska, South Dakota, Colorado Species: M. lulli, M. cruziensis, M. joraki, M. minor, M. phippsi Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Megabelodon is a genus of long-jawed (longirostrine) gomphotheres known from fossil material found in Nebraska, South Dakota and Colorado. These animals are known from more complete remains than many other types of Neogene proboscideans from North America. Megabelodo n would have had a long lower jaw but the end of the mandible would have been tuskless. This condition is similar to the appearances of the jawbones known from genera such as Gnathabelodon . The tusks of Megabelodon curved downwards slightly but were fairly straight. These upper tusks were also particularly thick in cross-section and restored skeletons from these animals show their tusks as ending in a blunt or squared-off tip instead of ending in a sharp point. The bones of the foreheads of some skeletons of Megabelodon are quite tall, although they were narrower than the skull domes of today’s Asian elephants when viewed from the front. Platybelodon Temporal Range: Middle Miocene, 15 - 10 million years ago Geographic Range: North America, Eurasia, Africa Species: P. grangeri, P. barnumbrownii, P. tongxinensis, P. dangheensis, P. tetralophus Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Platybelodon is an Amebelodontid which is known from fossils found at sites in Europe, Asia and possibly North America. Like many of its close relatives, Platybelodon would have had a spoon-shaped lower jaw ending in a flattened set of mandibular tusks. Their upper tusks were long, straight and pointed slightly outwards away from the position of the trunk. Many of these animals had historically been restored with broad, shortened trunks but it is likely that Amebelodontids would have had fairly long trunks which were more similar to those of living elephantids than was previously thought. They may have used their trunks to grab ahold of vegetation while using their lower tusks to cut the plant material into bite-sized pieces or to uproot it from the ground. Based on measurements of fossil materials ascribed to this genus, it seems as though Platybelodo n would have been a somewhat smaller animal than some of its close relatives like Amebelodon . Their fossils are found in areas which would have been composed of open grassland environments interspersed with patches of trees, similar to today’s savannahs. The species of Platybelodon found in the Ogallala formation, P. barnumbrownii , has also been suggested to be a member of a separate amebelodontid genus; Protanancus. Serbelodon Temporal Range: 11.3 - 9 million years ago Geographic Range: Nebraska Species: S. barbourensis, S. burnhami? Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Serbelodon was a genus of Amebelodontid proboscideans which lived in parts of central and southern North America during the middle Miocene epoch. Studies examining microwear patterns along the outer surfaces of Serbelodon mandibular tusks suggest that these animals would have used their elongated lower jaws to dig and/or to scrape bark from trees. Based on isotopic data collected from the dental enamel of these proboscideans, Serbelodon seems to have fed on a mixed diet of grasses, leaves and woody browse. Fossils from earlier in the Miocene show evidence of a diet largely composed of C3 plants while younger tooth fossils show traces of a diet composed of both C3 and C4 plants. Tatabelodon Temporal Range: Middle Miocene, Barstovian stage Geographic Range: New Mexico, Nebraska Species: T. gregorii, T. riograndensis Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Tatabelodon is a genus of proboscideans known from two species whose fossils are found in New Mexico and Nebraska. Despite being one of the oldest proboscideans known from remains found in the Great Plains, their teeth closely resemble those of animals who lived millions of years later. Their remains share many characteristics in common with fossils which have been assigned to the wastebasket taxon Gomphotherium over the years, with a few unique factors which make Tatabelodon a distinct genus. The lower jaw of Tatabelodon curves downwards at a sharper angle than the mandibles of animals assigned to the species “Gomphotherium” osborni. Tatabelodon also had tusks set in their lower jaws that are thick and pear-shaped in cross-section. Their upper tusks point straight out and are very large. Torynobelodon Temporal Range: Middle Miocene, 15 - 10 million years ago Geographic Range: Asia, North America Species: T. loomisi Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Torynobelodon was an extinct proboscidean genus which is currently classified as a member of the Amebelodontid family. Its fossils are found in Asia and North America. The North American species is classified as the species Torynobelodon loomisi . The first remains of these animals were found in the early 20th century near the town of Freedom in Frontier County, Nebraska. The fossil was found close to the location where Amebelodon fricki had been discovered the previous year. Paleontologist Erwin H. Barbour formally named the new animal Torynobelodon loomisi in 1929. Like many other members of the amebelodontid family of proboscideans, Torynobelodon would have had wide, flattened tusks along the front of the animal’s mandible. "Zygolophodon" (Miomastodon) Temporal Range: Early Miocene - Late Miocene Geographic Range: North America, Eurasia, Africa Species in the Ogallala formation: Z?. proavus, Miomastodon merriami Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves, grasses Zygolophodon was a genus of mammutid proboscideans who seem to have been the ancestors of the American Mastodon. This genus had a wide distribution with species of Zygolophodon turning up in North America, Europe, Africa and Asia. The genus is likely to be a wastebasket taxon for mammutids with long lower jaws and it may be more appropriate to place the North American Zygolophodon species into the genera Miomastodon and Pliomastodon . The most well represented North American species is "Zygolophodon" proavus . Despite being members of the mastodon family, Zygolophodon still had many of the features we associate with earlier branches of the proboscidean family tree. These animals had long lower jaws which, although they were shorter than those of most Ambebelodontids and gomphotheres, still had a set of small tusks at the front-most part of the mandible. Their cusped teeth were very similar to those of later mastodons, with angular surfaces which were well adapted for processing woody vegetation. Other Proboscidean Genera Protanancus : Platybelodon barnumbrownii has been suggested to belong to this genus which is otherwise found in parts of Eurasia Pediolophodon: A genus from Nebraska and Kansas which was either a Gomphotheriid or an Amebelodontid. Possibly synonymous with the genus Torynobelodon and/or the genus Amebelodon Media Gallery Suggested References: Proboscidea Tobien H. (1973) On the Evolution of Mastodonts (Proboscidea, Mammalia); Part 1, The bunodont trilophodont Groups, Notizblatt des Hessischen Landesamtes fuer Bodenforschung zu Wiesbaden 101, 202-276 Spencer LG 2022. The last North American gomphotheres. N Mex Mus Nat Hist Sci. 88:45–58. Larramendi, Asier (2023-12-10). "Estimating tusk masses in proboscideans: a comprehensive analysis and predictive model". Historical Biology: 1–14. Lambert, W.D (1992). "The feeding habits of the shovel-tusked gomphotheres: evidence from tusk wear patterns". Paleobiology. 18 (2): 132–147. Larramendi, A., & Ferretti, M. P. (2026). Elephants and Their Fossil Relatives: A 60 Million Year Journey. Princeton University Press. Princeton University Press Larramendi, A. (2015). "Shoulder height, body mass and shape of proboscideans". Acta Palaeontologica Polonica. 60. doi:10.4202/app.00136.2014. Tassy, Pascal. (1987). A Hypothesis on the Homology of Proboscidean Tusks Based on Paleontological Data. Vol. 2895. New York, N.Y: American Museum of Natural History Barbour, E.H. and Sternberg, G. (1935). Gnathabelodon thorpei, gen. et sp. nov. A new mud-grubbing mastodon. Bulletin of the Nebraska State Museum, 42: 395-404. Steven R. May (2019). The Lapara Creek Fauna: Early Clarendonian of south Texas, USA. Palaeontologia Electronica 22 (1): Article number 22.1.15. doi:10.26879/929. Osborn, Henry Fairfield (1933). "Serbelodon Burnhami, a new Shovel-Tusker from California" (PDF). American Museum Novitates (639): 1–5. Mothé, Dimila; Ferretti, Marco P.; Avilla, Leonardo S. (2016). "The Dance of Tusks: Rediscovery of Lower Incisors in the Pan-American Proboscidean Cuvieronius hyodon Revises Incisor Evolution in Elephantimorpha". PLOS ONE. 11 Sanders, William J. (2018). "Horizontal tooth displacement and premolar occurrence in elephants and other elephantiform proboscideans". Historical Biology. 30 (1–2): 137–156.

  • Echinoderms | Prehistoric Midwest

    Explore the different types of crinoids, sea urchins, brittle stars and starfishes who lived in the Western Interior Sea during the Cretaceous period Echinoderms Starfishes, Sea Urchins and Brittle Stars Echinodermata is a group of marine invertebrates which includes animals like sea stars, brittle stars, sea urchins, sand dollars, sea cucumbers, and feather stars. The name “echinoderm” means “spiny skin,” which refers to rough surfaces or spines commonly present on their bodies. Adult echinoderms usually have bodies organized radially with five symmetrical sections arranged around a central point, while their larvae are bilaterally symmetrical. Echinoderms have a skeleton which is built from calcium carbonate structures known as ossicles. They also have an internal system which pumps water through their bodies in order to fill small fluid-filled canals and, in some groups, mobile tube feet. Changes in fluid pressure can make these tube feet stretch out, working together to produce a sort of walking motion. Some echinoderms are fully mobile while others attach themselves to a hard surface or to the loose substrate of the ocean floor. Echinoderm fossils, particularly those of crinoids, are common in deposits from the Paleozoic era but turn up less often in deposits from the Western Interior Sea. Most extant groups of echinoderms had already appeared on the scene by the Late Cretaceous and the most common echinoderm group known from these rock layers are the echinoids, or sea urchins. Echinoderms (Browse by class) Sea Urchins (Class Echinoidea) Codiopsis Cottaldia Goniopygus Cassidulus Echinobrissus Nucleolites Globator Tetragramma Crassiholaster Holaster Anorthopygus Holectypus Gauthiera Phymosoma Goniophorus Salenia Hemiaster Sea Urchins (continued) Heteraster Holanthus Mecaster Micraster Sea Lilies (Class Crinoidea) Dunnicrinus Lakotacrinus Uintacrinus Starfishes (Class Asteroidea) Astrocratis Betelgeusia Coulonia Brittle Stars (Class Ophiuroidea) Brezinacantha Sea Lilies (Crinoidea) Temporal Range: ~480 million years ago - Present Diet: Filter feeders: plankton Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Lakotacrinus, Uintacrinus, Dunnicrinus Crinoids are marine echinoderms structured with a cup-shaped central body, known as the calyx, surrounded by flexible arms bearing many smaller filament-like branches called pinnules. These feather-like structures trap plankton and other suspended food particles before moving them through feeding grooves toward their mouths. Sea lilies are anchored to the ocean floor by a structure called a column. Some types of crinoids, like the extinct Cretaceous genus Uintacrinus or the living feather stars, are free-swimming and are not connected to the seafloor. (ABOVE) Crinoid genera of the Western Interior sea: (A) Lakotacrinus, (B) Uintacrinus, (C) Dunnicrinus (ABOVE) Detail of a slab containing many fossils of Uintacrinus on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Two crinoids have been shaded in order to show their constituent elements Starfishes (Asteroidea) Temporal Range: ~450 million years ago - Present Diet: Active predator, small fish, invertebrates Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Coulonia, Astrocratis, Betelgeusia Starfishes are a type of benthic echinoderm whose bodies are structured as a central disc surrounded by five or more arms. Rows of tube feet line the underside of the body of the starfish and can move the body of the animal by changing the pressure of the seawater passing through an attached vascular system. These tube-feet help the starfish travel, grip surfaces, detect its surroundings, and handle food. Most sea stars hunt invertebrates living on the ocean floor. Some species digest prey by extending their stomach outside their bodies. They also have an internal calcium-based skeleton and can usually regrow injured or missing arms. (ABOVE) Starfish genera found in the Western Interior Sea: (A) Coulonia, (B) Astrocratis, (C) Betelgeusia Brittle Stars (Ophiuroidea ) Temporal Range: ~488 million years ago - Present Diet: Scavengers, carrion, organic detritus Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Brezinacantha Brittle stars, or Ophiuroids, are echinoderms who have five narrow, highly flexible arms extending from a distinct central disc. By twisting and sweeping these segmented arms, they can travel rapidly across the ocean floor. Their tube feet do not have suckers and are mostly used to detect the animal’s surroundings and to gather food. Brittle stars feed on plankton and any type of organic detritus they find on the seafloor. They have longer and more flexible arms than sea stars. (ABOVE) The genus Brezinacantha known from deposits found in the Western Interior Sea. (ABOVE) A collection of Ophiura brittle star fossils found in the early Cenomanian Grayson Formation of Texas, fossils collected and image taken by Jared Cooke/ jcookepaleo (ABOVE) A version of the photo of the brittle star deathbed with the fossils outlined in red. Fossils collected and image taken by Jared Cooke/ jcookepaleo Sea Urchins (echinoids ) Temporal Range: ~465 million years ago - Present Diet: Algae, small slow-moving or stationary invertebrates Order in the Western Interior Sea: Arbacioida, Cassiduloida, Echinoneoida, Euechinoida, Holasteroida, Holectypoida, Phymosomatoida, Salenioida, Spatangoida Sea urchins are marine members of the echinoderm class Echinoidea. Their rounded bodies are protected by a hard internal shell known as a test, which is built from a series of fused calcium carbonate plates. This structure is covered with spines which help to defend the animal and support its movement. The sea urchin’s tube feet can move in and out of small pores in the test to allow the animal to move slowly over the seafloor. The mouth of the sea urchin is found on the lower side of the body and holds a special organ called an Aristotle’s lantern which is used to scrape food off of rocks. Most of the fossils of sea urchins known from areas which were once covered by the Western Interior Sea are fossils of the tests of these ancient echinoids. (ABOVE) Cretaceous echinoids of the order Arbacoida: (A) Codiopsis, (B) Cottaldia, (C) Goniopygus (ABOVE) Cretaceous echinoids of the order Cassiduloida: (A) Cassidulus, (B) Echinobrissus, (C) Nucleolites (ABOVE) The genus Globator, an echinoid from the early and Late Cretaceous of Texas and New Mexico (ABOVE) The genus Tetragramma from the Late Cretaceous of Texas (ABOVE) Cretaceous echinoids of the order Holasteroida: (A) Holaster, (B) Crassiholaster (ABOVE) Cretaceous echinoids of the order Holectypoida: (A) Anorthopygus, (B) Holectypus (ABOVE) Cretaceous echinoids of the order Phymosomatoida: (A) Gauthiera, (B) Phymosoma (ABOVE) Cretaceous echinoids of the order Salenioida: (A) Goniophorus, (B) Salenia (ABOVE) Cretaceous echinoids of the order Spatangoida: (A) Heteraster, (B) Micraster, (C) Mecaster, (D) Hemiaster, (E) Holanthus Gallery: Sea Urchin Fossils Suggested References: Echinoderms Everhart, M. J. "Notes on Uintacrinus socialis Grinnell" https://www.oceansofkansas.com/Uintacrinus.html Williston, S. W. (1894). “Notes on Uintacrinus socialis Grinnell”. Kansas University Quarterly, 3(1):19-21 (includes note by B. H. Hill). Everhart, M.J. (2017). “Oceans of Kansas - A Natural History of the Western Interior Sea, Second Edition”. Indiana University Press, 460 pp. Voultsiadou, Eleni; Chintiroglou, Chariton (2008). "Aristotle's lantern in echinoderms: an ancient riddle" (PDF). Cahiers de Biologie Marine. 49 (3). Station Biologique de Roscoff: 299–302. Aaron W. Hunter, Neal L. Larson, Neil H. Landman, Tatsuo Oji; Lakotacrinus brezinai n. gen. n. sp., a new stalked crinoid from cold methane seeps in the Upper Cretaceous (Campanian) Pierre Shale, South Dakota, United States. Journal of Paleontology 2016;; 90 (3): 506–524.

  • Coloring pages | Prehistoric Midwest

    Coloring pages featuring prehistoric animals from the Midwest which can all be downloaded as pdf files! Browse this section for anatomical coloring pages to learn more about the skeletal structures of ancient animals. We also have coloring pages made from drawings of prehistoric animals in their natural habitats. Coloring Pages Free downloadable coloring pages featuring prehistoric life known from fossils found in the Midwest. The lower section of this page also features some anatomical diagrams which can be colored in to learn about the skeletal features of these ancient animals. Click on the links below to download these coloring pages as printable pdf files. Tylosaurus A giant mosasaur that once swam in the seas which covered the Great Plains during the late Cretaceous period. Tylosaurus is also the state ocean fossil of Kansas! Download pdf file Columbian mammoth One of the largest land animals to live in North America during the Pleistocene epoch. Download pdf file Pteranodon These huge flying reptiles were part of a group of animals called the pterosaurs who were some of the most abundant flying animals of the Mesozoic era, the time of the dinosaurs. Download pdf file American mastodon A type of elephant relative (proboscidean) known from fossils found across North America. They had cusped teeth used to chew up woody plants. Download pdf file Carboniferous period Invertebrates A selection of ocean invertebrates whose fossils are found in parts of eastern Kansas Download pdf file Cooperoceras A strange spiky nautiloid whose fossils are found in Texas, Oklahoma and Texas Download pdf file Giant bison Bison latifrons , the giant bison, was one of the largest bovids of all time, weighing about as much as a large rhino! Download pdf file Carboniferous period fishes Prehistoric fishes whose fossils are found in marine deposits in parts of the Midwest which were covered by shallow seas during the Carboniferous period Download pdf file Anatomical coloring pages Add color to these labeled diagrams to learn more about the unique skeletal features of prehistoric animals Nothrotheriops skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of the Shasta ground sloth from the Pleistocene of the southwestern US. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Protostega skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of the sea turtle Protostega from the Cretaceous of Kansas. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Batomorph skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of an eagle ray, Myliobatis . Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Tortoise skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy a tortoise showing the placement of the bones beneath the shell. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Mammoth skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of a Columbian mammoth h from the Pleistocene of North America. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Theropod cranial anatomy A coloring page of the anatomy of the skull of a Tyrannosaurid meat-eating dinosaur. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Theropod skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of a meat-eating theropod dinosaur, Gorgosauru s. Click below to download the file Download pdf file Platecarpus skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of the mosasaur Platecarpus from the Cretaceous of Kansas. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Ray-finned fish skeleton A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy a Pycnodont ray-finned fish from the Cretaceous period. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Armadillo skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of the a nine-banded armadillo, showing the bones of the animal as they appear beneath the shell. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Plesiosaur skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of a polycotylid plesiosaur and an elasmosaurid from the Cretaceous of Kansas. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Dire wolf skeletal anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of the a dire wolf from the Pleistocene of North America. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Shark jaw anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of the jaw cartilages of a shark. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Ammonoid shell anatomy A coloring page of the shell anatomy of an ammonoid. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Placoderm anatomy A coloring page of the skeletal anatomy of the placoderm fish Dunkleosteus from the Devonian period. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file Tortoise shell anatomy A coloring page of the different types of scutes found on the shells of turtles and tortoises. Click below to download the file. Download pdf file

  • Miocene Perissodactyla | Prehistoric Midwest

    Perissodactyla Rhinos, Horses and Tapirs Perissodactyls are hoofed herbivorous mammals who are also known as “odd-toed ungulates”. This group includes horses, rhinos, tapirs and their closest extinct relatives. Perissodactyl feet are organized around an enlarged third digit. With this arrangement, the main axis of each limb runs through the middle toe, which in turn bears most or all of the animal’s weight. Some species retain three functional toes, while horses support themselves on a single central hoof. In tapirs the front feet each have four toes while their hind feet have three. Many perissodactyls also tend to have long skulls and mouths with broad, flattened cheek teeth used for grinding vegetation. Compared with ruminant even-toed ungulates these animals have simple stomachs and they use specialized microorganisms to ferment and break down the tough cellulose found in plants. Grazing species generally have high-crowned teeth, while browsing forms usually have lower-crowned teeth. Fossils of perissodactyls from the Ogallala Formation include the remains of horses, rhinos, and tapirs. Equids are particularly diverse and include both one-toed and three-toed genera. Anatomy Skeletal Anatomy Perissodactyls are animals who tend to walk on one, three, or five toes. Living horses of the genus Equus have the most specialized arrangement, with one functional toe per foot, while tapirs and rhinos retain several toes for stability and weight distribution. Horses also have elongated lower limbs, reduced or fused bones, and a set of cannon bones which are helpful for rapid running across open grasslands. Rhinos by contrast have robust skeletons that help to support the weight of their bulky bodies. Their short, thick limb bones are adapted to bearing heavy loads, and each foot has three weight-bearing toes and a thick foot pad. Most rhinos also have a particularly broad rib cage, a reinforced vertebral column and large shoulder and pelvic girdles. Their skulls are long and heavily built, with thick nasal bones beneath the horn area, although the keratin horn itself has no large bony core. Most North American rhino genera were hornless, although some species of Teleoceras rhinos include males who seem to have had a single short horn on their noses. Like other perissodactyls, rhinos and tapirs have broad grinding teeth, often with high-crowned molars, adapted to processing tough and abrasive plant material. (BELOW) Titanotheres were distant relatives of horses and rhinos who were some of the largest animals found in North America during the Paleogene period. (A) Megacerops skull on display at the Sternberg Museum, (B) Palaeosyops cranium at the KU Natural History Museum (BELOW) Skulls of ancient North American rhinos at the Sternberg Museum of Natural History (C) Hyracodon, a hyracodontid rhino relative, (D) Teleoceras , a wide-bodied Miocene rhino. (BELOW) Skulls of ancient horse relatives at the KU Natural History Museum. (E) Hyracotherium , a palaeotheriid, (F) A Mesohippus skull from an anchitheriine three-toed horse (BELOW) Horse skulls at the KU Natural History Museum. (G) Merychippus from the Miocene epoch (H), A skull from the modern horse genus Equus. Foot Structure Extinct horses developed many different types of foot structures throughout their evolutionary history. Early horse relatives like the genus Hyracotherium had four hoofed toes on their front feet and three on their hind feet. Their toes splayed outwards and gave them extra traction when moving across soft forest floors. Later forms such as Mesohippus had three toes on each foot. Over time the middle digit became larger and increasingly bore more weight. By the Miocene epoch, the side toes of some horses became shorter and were often raised above the ground. Eventually, some extinct horses evolved a single weight-bearing toe, while remnants of the reduced outer digits remained as splint-like bones alongside the central cannon bone. (BELOW) Arrangements of foot bones in horses and palaeotheriids. Earlier members of the lineages that led towards horses had additional toes but as these animals adapted to living in open environments such as grasslands they began to support their weight on a single hoofed toe. Browsers and Grazers Perissodactyls can generally be grouped into two categories based on their tooth structures and their preferred feeding strategies. These two groups are the high-crowned perissodactyls and the low-crowned perissodactyls. High-crowned hypsodont animals have tall cheek teeth with distinctive enamel patterns on their chewing surfaces that resist extensive wear. This tooth morphology is particularly common among grazers that consume abrasive grasses or vegetation covered in soil and grit, with horses providing the clearest living example. Short-crowned brachydont perissodactyls have shorter crowns, longer roots, and less material to withstand wear. Their teeth are better adapted for browsing on softer foods such as leaves, and plant shoots. Tapirs and most types of extinct North American rhinos were brachydont browsers. (BELOW) Perissodactyls with low-crowned teeth tended to be animals who browsed on soft leaves. Some early groups of horses also fell within this group and filled ecological niches similar to those of today's deer. (BELOW) High crowned horses have/had teeth which were well adapted to processing abrasive grasses. These animals include today's horses, zebras and donkeys as well as their closest extinct relatives such as the genus Dinohippus. Perissodactyla Rhinos (Superfamily Rhinocerotoidea) Aphelops Peraceras Teleoceras Horses (Family Equidae) Anchitherium Archaeohippus Astrohippus Calippus Cormohipparion Dinohippus Hypohippus Megahippus Horses, Continued (Family Equidae) Merychippus Nannippus Neohipparion Parahippus Pliohippus Protohippus Pseudhipparion Tapirs (Family Tapiridae) Tapirus johnsoni Rhinos (Rhinocerotoidea ) Rhinos with long tusks The largest perissodactyls found in the Great Plains during the Miocene and Pliocene epochs were the rhinos. These animals are known from fossil sites where many individuals were found preserved together after passing away at the same time. This pattern of preservation provides evidence that some Miocene rhino genera spent their lives in large herds. Although some species of rhinos in the genus Teleoceras are known from fossils which preserve short nasal horns, most rhinos known from the Ogallala Formation were hornless. Instead these animals had long tusks on their lower jaws which were formed from an enlarged pair of lower incisors. The skulls of these North American rhinos were proportionally shorter and more heavily built than those of today’s extant rhinos. Aphelops Temporal Range: Middle Miocene – Early Pliocene, 17.5–4.5 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America Species: A. malacorhinus, A megalodus, A mutilus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Aphelops was the largest genus of rhinos found in Miocene deposits from North America. These animals were hornless rhinos with large tusks at the front of their lower jaws. The spinous processes over the thoracic vertebrae of their shoulders were particularly long in these animals, indicating that they would have had a shoulder hump in life. These tall processes also anchored the rhino’s powerful neck muscles. Aphelop s had longer legs and a more slender torso than some of its contemporaries like the rhinos of the genus Teleoceras . Their proportions are similar to those of the living Sumatran rhino. Wear patterns on their teeth seem to indicate that these animals had a mixed diet composed of both grasses and woody browse. Its longer legs may have given it greater stamina to cover long distances in search of food. (BELOW) An Aphelops skeleton on display at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. Note the tall spinous processed over the shoulder which would have anchored the animal's powerful neck muscles. (BELOW) A photo of the skull of the Aphelops skeleton in the image above. Most Miocene rhinos found in North America had long tusks along the forward apex of their lower jaws. Photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 4.0 Peraceras Temporal Range: Middle Miocene Geographic Range: Found across central and western North America Species: P. hessei, P. profectum, P. supercilisosus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Peraceras is a genus of rhino with similar proportions to Aphelops , although the largest animals in this genus were smaller than the largest Aphelops mutilus . It would have lacked a horn on its head and its nasal openings were positioned fairly far back on the animal’s skull. This suggests that Peraceras would have had a large and very sensitive nose. Fossils of the external tissues of Miocene rhinos are not available to tell us much about the soft tissues of these animals, yet based on the shapes of the skulls of Peraceras compared with those of living rhinos, we would expect these ancient rhinos to have had a flexible set of muscular lips which they could use to manipulate and strip plant material while feeding. These animals were some of the most abundant rhinos in the western parts of North America during the Miocene epoch but in the Great Plains their fossils are somewhat rare. Teleoceras Temporal Range: Middle Miocene – Early Pliocene, 15.97 – 4.5 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North and Central America Species: T. aepysoma, T. aginense, T. americanum, T. brachyrhinum, T. hicksi. T. fossiger, T. guymonense, T. major, T. medicornutum, T. meridianum, T. proterum Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Teleoceras is the best represented genus of rhinos found in deposits within the Ogallala formation. At the Ashfall fossil beds in northern Nebraska, a herd of over 40 individual Teleoceras are preserved where they died at the edge of a watering hole roughly 12.5 million years ago. The animals at this site were the victims of a large ash cloud produced by a major eruption of the Yellowstone supervolcano during the later part of the Miocene epoch. Their bones are preserved within a layer of fine ash, alongside the remains of over a dozen other types of mammals, birds and reptiles. The Ashfall layer contains the skeletons of dozens of Teleoceras of many different ages, including both male and female individuals. This particularly extensive degree of preservation allows scientists to learn a lot more about the herd structures of these animals than might otherwise be possible. Their herd sizes were apparently larger than those of living rhinos, which tend to include only a handful of individuals. Males also seem to have lived as part of these herds. Teleoceras had an unusually stocky form for a rhino, with a barrel-like chest and short legs which gave it proportions similar to those of living hippos. The shapes of their bodies initially led researchers to assume that these were semi-aquatic animals. However, in recent years further examination of the bones and the isotopic contents of the teeth of these ancient rhinos has produced more evidence that these animals fed and spent most of their lives outside of the water. Many of these animals are found with large tusks at the front of their lower jaws and the males of some species have a single short horn on their noses. (BELOW) A Teleoceras skeleton on display at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. These animals had very short legs and wide, barrel-like torsos. (BELOW) A skull of Teleoceras in the vertebrate paleontology collections at the Sternberg Museum of Natural history. Note the large tusks projecting forward from the apex of the mandible. These teeth may have been used to dig for roots. (BELOW) A close-up view of the teeth in the jaws of the Teleoceras skull above. These rhinos had teeth which were suited to a mixed diet composed of both grasses and woody vegetation. Horses (Equidae ) One and Three-Toed Horses Horses were by far the most abundant and diverse group of odd-toed ungulates found in deposits from the Ogallala formation. Some of these animals were small deer-like animals who had low crowned teeth similar to those found in other types of perissodactyls who prefer to feed on leaves. On the other hand, horses with high-crowned teeth seem to have been better adapted for living in open spaces and feeding on grasses and other abrasive plants. Although the fossils of the horse genera found in the oldest layers of the Ogallala formation all had three toes on each of their feet, deposits from later in the Miocene and the early Pliocene epoch have yielded the remains of Pliohippus and Dinohippus individuals who had only a single toe on each of their feet, although this single-hoofed condition is not universal among all fossils assigned to those genera. The loss of the outer digits in horses seems to have been an adaptation for running on solid open ground. As horses continued to adapt to the spread of grassland environments, the side toes of several horse groups independently became smaller over the course of millions of years and began to bear less and less of the horse’s body weight. (BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of a horse Anchitherium Temporal Range: Oligocene - Middle Miocene Geographic Range: Found in North America, Europe, Asia Species:A. alberdiae, A. aurelianense, A. australis, A. castellanum, A. clarencei, A. corcolense, A. cursor, A. ezquerrae, A. gobiense, A. hippoides, A. matritense, A. navasotae, A. parequinum, A. procerum Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Anchitherium was a genus of three-toed horses which were found in parts of North America, Central America and even parts of Eurasia during the Miocene epoch. This genus is the namesake for the subfamily Anchitherinae, a group of horses with low-crowned teeth who retained many of the characteristic features of earlier horse genera. Like many other types of Anchitherines, Anchitherium was a browsing horse which seems to have preferred living in forested areas where it would have browsed for leaves, a niche which was much more similar to living deer than the grazing diet of today’s horses and donkeys. They were fairly small horses, around the size of a large dog at around 2 feet in height at the shoulder. Relative to the sizes of their bodies Anchitherium had a small head, a short muzzle and a long neck. (BELOW) Skull of Anchitherium at the Harvard Museum of Natural History. Note the short snout and the low-crowned teeth adapted for browsing on leaves Photo by Jonathan Chen, CC BY-SA 4.0 (BELOW) A photo of the lower jaws of an Anchitherium aurelianense showing the unique pattern of enamel ridges on the surfaces of the molars. This specimen is from an early Miocene european species Photo-Didier Descouens, CC BY-SA 4.0 Archaeohippus Temporal Range: Early Oligocene - Middle Miocene, 30.8 – 13.6 million years ago Geographic Range: Found from Alberta to Panama Species: A. blackbergi, A. mannulus, A. mourningi, A. penultimus, A. ultimus Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Archaeohippus is one of the older three-toed horse genera known from sites associated with the Ogallala formation. The first fossils of animals belonging to this genus date all the way back to the early Oligocene epoch and the last members of this genus seem to have disappeared during the middle of the Miocene epoch. Archaeohippu s had a very long snout when compared with other anchitherine horses such as Anchitherium and Hypohippu s. It was also much smaller than many of its close relatives, reaching sizes comparable to a medium-sized dog. This genus could be found across much of North America and they were particularly common in the western part of the continent. Their closest relative appears to be Parahippus . (BELOW) An Archaeohippus blackbergi skull (AMNH 56610) on display at the American Museum of Natural History. The nasal opening on this skull has been filled in but the outlines of the surrounding bones are still visible. Photo by Jonathan Chen, CC BY-SA 4.0 Astrohippus Temporal Range: Middle Miocene - Early Pliocene, 16.3 – 4.9 million years ago Geographic Range: Nebraska, Florida, Texas, Northern Mexico Species: A. ansae, A. stockii Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Astrohippus was a genus of equine horse whose fossils are found in parts of the Great Plains, Florida and Mexico in deposits dating back to the later part of the Miocene epoch and the early part of the Pliocene epoch. These animals were close relatives of living horses in the genus Equus but are not thought to be the direct ancestors of living horses. Isotopic and microwear analyses of Astrohippus teeth show that they seem to have had different diets in different parts of their range in southern North America. In some areas they appear to have preferred feeding almost exclusively on grasses and very abrasive plant material, while in other areas they seem to have supplemented their diet with softer leaves. Calippus Temporal Range: Middle Miocene - Early Pliocene, 16 – 1.8 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, Nebraska to Costa Rica Species: C. martini, C. regulus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Calippus was a genus of horses which existed in parts of southern North America for over 14 million years, from the Middle Miocene epoch to the Early Pliocene. These animals are considered to be members of the tribe Equini, which includes animals like Astrohippus , Pliohippus , Protohippus and the extant genus Equus which includes all living horses. Calippus was a fairly small equine, growing to be about the size of a large sheep. The fossils belonging to this genus are common in sites from Texas and the Gulf coast but are more rare in parts of Nebraska and South Dakota. Compared with other Neogene equines, Calippus had a relatively wide muzzle. (BELOW) A Calippus placidus skull (AMNH 60437) on display at the American Museum of Natural History. Photo by Jonathan Chen, CC BY-SA 4.0 Cormohipparion Temporal Range: Middle Miocene - Early Pliocene, 15.97 – 3.6 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North and Central America Species: C. cappadocium , C. fricki, C. goorisi , C. johnsoni, C. matthewi, C. merriami , C. occidentale, C. sofularensis, C. quinni, C. skinneri Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Cormohipparion was an extinct genus of three toed horses which seems to have been an earlier ancestor of animals like Hipparion which later spread into parts of Europe and Asia. These animals had long faces and their skulls featured a set of facial fossae which were relatively shallow compared with those of other contemporary horse genera. They seem to have had chewing surfaces on their teeth which would have been well suited for processing grassy vegetation, although some microwear analyses have pointed to the possibility of these animals being mixed grazers of both grass and soft leaves. Fossils of animals belonging to this genus are particularly common in sites from Florida and their remains are also found in the ash layer at the Ashfall Fossil Beds in northern Nebraska. (BELOW) A skeleton of Cormohipparion occidentale found at the Ashfall Fossil Beds in northern Nebraska. The fossils of this animal were found preserved in a thick layer of volcanic tuff. Photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 4.0 (BELOW) A replica of a fossil skull of Cormohipparion occidentale from the Ashfall site. Note the shallow facial fossa in front of the animal's orbit. Their fairly high-crowned teeth would have been useful for processing grass and other types of tougher silica-rich plants. Photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 4.0 Dinohippus Temporal Range: Middle Miocene-Late Pliocene, 10.3 – 3.6 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, Alberta to Panama Species: D. edensis, D. interpolatus, D. leardi, D. leidyanus, D. mexicanus, D. osborni, D. pachyops, D. subvenus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Dinohippus was a North American horse that lived from the late Miocene to the early Pliocene epoch. It resembled modern horses more closely than earlier equids and is considered a close relative of the genus Equus , which contains all living species of horses, donkeys, and zebras. It had very shallow facial fossae, unlike living horses which entirely lack this depression in front of their eye sockets. Dinohippus is unique among Neogene horses because it had a very basic stay apparatus; a system of tendons built into the animal’s limb bones which helped Dinohippus stand for long periods while using less energy. Dinohippus is the earliest horse known to display this feature, which became much more developed in modern equids. Fossils of Dinohippus also show an unusual degree of variation in the structure of their feet. Although Dinohippus was once considered to be a genus of exclusively single-toed horses, fossils from sites in Nebraska seem to show that some individuals retained the ancestral three toed condition, while others had only one toe on each foot. A similar trend is seen in fossils of the genus Pliohippus . This variation records the continuing reduction of the side toes in some of the later horse genera during the late Miocene and Pliocene epochs. (BELOW) A Dinohippus skeleton. This particular fossil is the holotype specimen for the species Dinohippus leidyanus on display at the American Museum of Natural History (AMNH 17224). Photo by Jonathan Chen, CC BY-SA 4.0 Hypohippus Temporal Range: Middle Miocene, 15.97 – 10.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America Species: H. affinis, H. osborni Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Hypohippus was a genus of browsing Achitherine three-toed horse which was a distant relative of animals like Anchitherium and Archaeohippus. The skulls of these animals were long and had a prominent fossa in front of their eyes. These animals had three distinct hoofed toes on each foot. In some species of Hypohippus the side toes were reduced and do not seem to have sustained any weight. They seem to have stood taller than related animals like Anchitherium ; around 3 feet tall at the shoulder. Their muzzles were tall and relatively short and their eyes were positioned further forward on the skull than in living horses and zebras. They preferred to live in forest habitats and would have fed on soft leaves instead of grazing on grass. (BELOW) A Hypohippus skeleton. This particular fossil is of the species Hypohippus osborni on display at the American Museum of Natural History. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, Original Photo by user PrimalMustelid, CC BY-SA 4.0 Megahippus Temporal Range: Middle Miocene, 16.3 – 10.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, Montana to Florida Species: M. matthewi, M. mckennai Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Megahippus was a particularly large Miocene three-toed horse. While many lineages of Miocene horses developed adaptations for grazing, Megahippus remained a highly specialized forest browser. Its incisors formed a curved U-shaped row rather than the broad, straight dental arrangement commonly found in grazing horses that use their teeth to graze and crop grasses. It also had the characteristic low-crowned cheek teeth seen in other types of browsing horses. These low-crowned teeth were very useful for processing soft leafy foliage but vulnerable to wear from abrasive grasses. Megahippus was also a particularly large browsing horse, estimated to have weighed nearly 600 pounds. Each of its feet had three functional toes. It should be noted, however, that the bones of Megahippus ’ limbs and its fetlock joints had convergently developed to become similar to those of modern horses, most likely as a way to help support its large body size. Merychippus Temporal Range: Middle - Late Miocene, 15.9 – 5.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America from Montana to central Mexico Species: M. brevidontus, M. calamarius, M. californicus, M. coalingensis, M. coloradense, M. eohipparion, M. eoplacidus, M. gunteri, M. insignis, M. labrosus, M. missouriensis, M. patrusus, M. primus, M. proparvulus, M. quartus, M. quintus, M. relictus, M. republicanus, M. secundus , M. sejunctus, M. seversus, M. stevensi Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Merychippus was a North American three-toed horse that lived during the middle part of the Miocene. Despite retaining three toes on each foot, it would have appeared much more similar to modern horses than most of its contemporaries. Like most three-toed horses, Merychippus kept most of its weight resting on an enlarged central toe, while the two outer toes were reduced and provided less support. Its long legs were adapted for rapid movement across the open grassland landscapes which were becoming increasingly common in North America over the course of the Miocene. Compared with other horses from the middle Miocene, Merychippus would have had a very long face and the high-crowned teeth commonly found in the mouths of grazing horses, as opposed to the shorter-crowned teeth seen in earlier browsing horses which were better suited to processing softer leaves. The complex ridges on its teeth resembled those of ruminant mammals (cows, sheep, etc.), leading to its name, which roughly translates to “ruminant horse.” However it is likely that Merychippus digested its food using hindgut fermentation like living horses, rather than by chewing cud. (BELOW) A Merychippus skeleton on display at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. Note the deep facial fossae seen in front of the orbits of this animal, as well as the small toes bracing the sides of each foot. Nannippus Temporal Range: Late Miocene - Early Pleistocene Geographic Range: Found across North America Species: N. lenticularis, N. peninsulatus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Nannippus lenticularis was a small species of three-toed horse that lived in North America from the late Miocene to the start of the Pleistocene epoch. It belonged to an older group of horses that had been widespread across the continent before the evolution of the larger, one-toed horses such as those of the genus Equus. Fossils of Nannippus have been discovered in Kansas, Nebraska, Alabama, North Carolina, Texas, and Alberta, indicating that it was well adapted to a variety of environments. Unlike modern horses, Nannippus lenticularis retained three functional toes on each foot. The enlarged middle toe bore most of the animal's weight, while the two smaller side toes were positioned higher up and braced the middle toe from each side. Members of the genus Nannippus were relatively small, growing to be around the size of a sheep or a large dog. Dental evidence suggests that Nannippus species were primarily browsers who fed on leaves, shrubs, and other softer vegetation rather than relying exclusively on grasses like today’s horses. This diet allowed them to thrive in woodland and savanna habitats that were common across North America during the late Miocene, although as grasslands began to spread they faced increased competition from other horses who had become specialist grazers. Neohipparion Temporal Range: Middle Miocene - Early Pliocene Geographic Range: Found across North and Central America Species: N. affine, N. eurystyle, N. gidleyi, N. leptode, N. trampasense Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves The extinct horse genus Neohipparion lived in the Americas between about 16 and 5 million years ago. Unlike today’s one-toed horses, it had three toes: a strong central toe and two smaller toes positioned on either side. Neohipparion belonged to a group known as the Hipparion horses. These animals had distinctive upper cheek teeth, particularly a structure called the protocone ridge that was usually separated from the other ridges on their teeth. The genus included several species and appears to have adapted successfully to the spread of open habitats. Its fossils have even been found in parts of Central America. (BELOW) A Neohipparion skeleton on display at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall Parahippus Temporal Range: Early - Middle Miocene, 24 – 17 Million years ago Geographic Range: Found in Florida, Texas, Nebraska, California, Oregon Species: P. cognatus, P. coloradoensis, P. leonensis, P. pawniensis Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Parahippus was a genus of extinct horses which lived during the early part of the Miocene epoch. Although it had three toes on each foot, its anatomy differed from that of many other three-toed horses. Most of its body weight rested on an enlarged central toe, while the two lateral toes were smaller and played a reduced role in locomotion. Most earlier three-toed horses distributed their weight more evenly across all three toes. Parahippu s also would have had a set of elongated, partially fused leg bones that restricted sideways movement and produced a more efficient forward stride. These adaptations would have made Parahippus better suited to running through open environments. In terms of its cranial anatomy, Parahippus had a long head with eye sockets located behind the midpoint of the skull, superficially similar to the skulls of living horses. Some species developed high-crowned cheek teeth coated with a layer of protective cementum which was deposited along with permanent ridges on their molars. These would have reduced dental wear and allowed the animal to consume abrasive grasses as well as softer leaves. Earlier three-toed horses generally had lower-crowned teeth adapted primarily for browsing. Pliohippus Temporal Range: Middle Miocene - Pliocene, 15.97 – 4.9 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America Species: P. castilli, P. fossulatus, P. mirabilis, P. nobilis, P. pernix, P. tantalus, P. tehonensis Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Pliohippus was a North American horse that was found all across the continent during the late Miocene, approximately 12 to 6 million years ago. This genus seems to be a group of animals which independently bridged the gap between three-toed and one-toed horses. Pliohippu s had slender legs and an enlarged middle hoof that gave it a more modern appearance. While some individuals retained two small, nonfunctional side toes, others seem to have only had a single toe on each foot. Some Pliohippus skulls also have very prominent facial fossae, which were deep hollows positioned in front of the eyes. These fossae are one of the features which can be used to distinguish Pliohippus from the related genus Dinohippu s, which had smaller fossae, and from Equus, which lacks them entirely. Pliohippus also had teeth which were more curved than those of living horses and donkeys. Pliohippus was once considered a direct ancestor of living horses but these unique features found on the skulls and teeth of these extinct horses has led them to be considered part of an offshoot lineage of equines with no direct living descendants. (BELOW) A Pliohippus skeleton on display at the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. These animals were quite similar to living horses, although some of their skeletons still have three toes and hooves on each foot. (BELOW) A Pliohippus skull on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Foot bones are visible on the left side of the photo Protohippus Temporal Range: Late Miocene, 13.6 – 5.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, Montana to Panama Species: P. vetus, P. perditus, P. supremus, P. gidleyi Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Protohippus was a three-toed horse, comparable in size to a modern donkey. These animals would have lived in North America during the late Miocene. Its body was more similar to that of later horses than those of earlier forest-dwelling equids, particularly because of its long limbs adapted for movement through open habitats. The genus Protohippus had high-crowned cheek teeth that were resistant to wear caused by abrasive vegetation, a feature which was commonly found in horses which had begun to adapt to grazing diets composed primarily of tough grasses. Details of the skull and teeth suggest that Protohippus was a close relative of the genus Calippus . These genera formed their own branch of the horse family and were not direct ancestors of Pliohippus, Dinohippus , or the modern Equus genus. Pseudhipparion Temporal Range: Middle - Late Miocene, 15.97 – 5.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, Montana to Florida Species: P. curtivallum, P. gratum, P. hessei , P. retrusum, P. simpsoni, P. skinneri Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Pseudhippario n was a genus of small, three-toed horses that lived in North America during the middle and later parts of the Miocene epoch. These animals were relatively lightly built with certain species only weighing around 85 pounds. The genus also underwent a notable trend toward dwarfism, and later species seem to have generally had smaller teeth than their earlier relatives. Dental anatomy is among the most useful features for identifying Pseudhipparion . Its cheek teeth had high crowns which were well adapted for breaking down plant material. This feature seems to be especially prominent among the younger species in the Pseudhipparion genus which developed especially tall crowns. Isotopic analyses of fossils of their teeth suggest that these horses mainly ate C3 vegetation. As members of the hipparionine horse group, Pseudhipparion has no surviving descendants. Its fossils have been found throughout the Great Plains and the Gulf Coastal Plain Tapirs (Tapiridae ) Ancient Tapirs in the Great Plains Tapirs have a fossil record in North America which goes back to before the start of the Miocene epoch. Earlier North American tapirs seem to have been fairly small animals but over the course of the Miocene they increased in size until they reached masses comparable to today’s extant tapirs. Tapir fossils are fairly rare in the Ogallala formation. The best known species is Tapirus johnsoni, which seems to have been around the same size as today’s Malaysian tapir. These animals were browsers who lived in forested habitats and fed on a diet primarily composed of leaves. The shape of the nasal openings seen in the holotype skull of T. johnsoni suggest that they would have had a short trunk, much like the trunks seen in living tapir species. Tapirus johnsoni Temporal Range: Pliocene Geographic Range: Nebraska Species: T. johnsoni Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves Tapirus johnsoni was an extinct North American tapir whose fossils were found within the Ash Hollow Formation. It is known from fossils of a skull and teeth from Cherry County, Nebraska. Compared with the earlier tapir species Tapirus polkensis , T. johnsoni seems to be a considerably larger animal, similar in size to living tapirs found today in parts of Central and South America. Like other Tapirs, Tapirus johnsoni had teeth which were built for browsing on leaves and a nasal opening which is positioned further back on the animal’s skull. This feature is what allows tapirs to support the soft tissues of their nasal probosces. The ranges of extinct tapirs once extended much further into North America than they do today and tapirs were found in parts of the Midwest all the way up until the end of the Pleistocene epoch. Suggested References: Perissodactyla Mead, Alfred J. (2000). "Sexual dimorphism and paleoecology in Teleoceras, a North American Miocene rhinoceros". Paleobiology. 26 (4): 689–706. Wang, Bian; Secord, Ross (2020). "Paleoecology of Aphelops and Teleoceras (Rhinocerotidae) through an interval of changing climate and vegetation in the Neogene of the Great Plains, central United States". Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 542 Tucker, S.T.; Otto, R.E.; Joeckel, R.M.; Voorhies, M.R. (2014), "The geology and paleontology of Ashfall Fossil Beds, a late Miocene (Clarendonian) mass-death assemblage, Antelope County and adjacent Knox County, Nebraska, USA", Geologic Field Trips along the Boundary between the Central Lowlands and Great Plains: 2014 Meeting of the GSA North-Central Section, Geological Society of America, pp. 1–22 Tanner, L.G. (1967). "A New Species of Rhinoceros, Aphelops kimballensis, from the Latest Pliocene of Nebraska". Bulletin of the University of Nebraska State Museum. 6 (1). Janis, Christine M. (2023), "Asymmetry of Evolutionary Patterns Between New World and Old World Equids and Among New World Equine Tribes", in Casanovas-Vilar, Isaac; van den Hoek Ostende, Lars W.; Janis, Christine M.; Saarinen, Juha (eds.), Evolution of Cenozoic Land Mammal Faunas and Ecosystems, Vertebrate Paleobiology and Paleoanthropology, Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp. 143–164 Leidy, Joseph (1858). "Notice of Remains of Extinct Vertebrata, from the Valley of the Niobrara River, collected during the Exploring Expedition of 1857, in Nebraska, under the command of Lieut. G. K. Warren, U. S. Top. Eng., by Dr. F. V. Hayden, Geologist to the Expedition". Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia. 10: 20–29. Leidy, Joseph (1869). "The Extinct Mammalian Fauna of Dakota and Nebraska: Including an Account of Some Allied Forms from Other Localities, Together with a Synopsis of the Mammalian Remains of North America". Journal of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia. Ser. 2. 7: 275–279, 401. MacFadden, Bruce J.; Dobie, James L. (1998). "Late Miocene Three-Toed Horse Protohippus (Mammalia, Equidae) from Southern Alabama". Journal of Paleontology. 72 (1): 149–152. MacFadden, Bruce J. (1986). "Fossil horses from "Eohippus" (Hyracotherium) to Equus: scaling, Cope's Law, and the evolution of body size". Paleobiology. 12 (4): 355–369. Hulbert, Richard C. (1993). "Taxonomic evolution in North American Neogene horses (subfamily Equinae): the rise and fall of an adaptive radiation". Paleobiology. 19 (2): 216–234. Janis, C. M.; Damuth, J.; Theodor, J. M. (2002). "The origins and evolution of the North American grassland biome: The story from the hoofed mammals". Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 177 (1–2): 183–198.

  • Ogallala geography | Prehistoric Midwest

    The Ogallala Formation During the Miocene and Pliocene epochs, many parts of the Great Plains were covered in open grasslands interspersed with smaller patches of forests. Fossils of large reptiles and palm trees suggest that the climate in this region was much warmer than it is today. The Remains of an Ancient Savannah The Ogallala Formation comprises a vast region of deposition dating back to the Miocene and Pliocene epochs of the Neogene period. These deposits extend from western Texas and southeastern New Mexico northward through the Great Plains to South Dakota and forms North America’s largest nearly continuous exposure of nonmarine Neogene deposits. The Ogallala Formation is broken up into many distinct layers, some of which seem to have been formed by rivers, while others are composed of volcanic ash which can be tied to large eruptions which took place during the Neogene within the western interior of the North American continent as far west as Idaho. These deposits are very rich in fossils, particularly the remains of vertebrates. These include the remains of large mammals, birds, turtles, fish, crocodilians, lizards and amphibians. Plant fossils, including the remains of seeds and leaves, are also common in some parts of the Ogallala and are often used to differentiate between different layers of rock and sediment. Invertebrate fossils are rare, mostly represented by the trace fossils left behind by ancient ant nests and a few types of snail shell fossils. Stratigraphy Earlier geologists often referred to the deposits we now group together as part of the Ogallala Formation using names like the "Mortar beds", "Tertiary grit", or "Magnesia beds". The Ogallala is currently considered to be a large single unit, composed of three main zones, Kimball (youngest zone), Ash Hollow and Valentine (the oldest zone). The Ogallala is sometimes considered to be a formation comprising three members, or a geologic group comprising three formations. For the sake of this field guide, the Ogallala is considered to be a formation divided into three members; the Kimball Member, the Ash Hollow Member and the Valentine Member. (ABOVE) The distribution of deposits connected to the Ogallala Formation are marked in orange on this map of the central US. The Ogallala Formation covers hundreds of thousands of square miles of land from South Dakota to New Mexico The Valentine Member The Valentine Member is composed primarily of layers of sandstone which outcrop primarily in parts of Nebraska and South Dakota although deposits linked to the Valentine appear to a lesser extent in parts of Kansas and Colorado. This is the oldest of the three members of the Ogallala Formation. The layers of this member are mostly composed of crumbly stone formed from sand and silt which eroded away from the Rocky Mountains further to the west before being carried and deposited in the Great Plains by eastward-flowing rivers. The Valentine Member preserves the fossils of many types of vertebrates, including a dozen canid genera, proboscideans, horses, tapirs and bats. Fossils of some of the last oreodont genera known from the Miocene of North America are also preserved in the Valentine Member. (BELOW) Selected taxa known from fossils found within deposits linked to the Valentine Member of the Ogallala Formation Cormohipparion Mycteria Ustatochoerus Calippus Ceratogaulus Alilepus Leptocyon Aelurodon Andrias Amia The Ash Hollow Member The Ash Hollow Member is the most famous zone of the Ogallala Formation since it includes the fossils found at the Ashfall Fossil Beds site. This member is exposed across many parts of Kansas and Nebraska in places where the thinner overlying Kimball Member has worn away. This member is primarily formed from very compressed layers of sand, along with some layers formed from deposits of fine volcanic ash. Many types of fossils from proboscideans, bear-dogs, hoofed mammals, birds, cats and dogs are found in the Ash Hollow Member. The best known animals from these deposits are the rhinos, especially the genus Teoloceras which is known from hundreds of examples of extremely complete fossilized skeletons. (BELOW) Selected taxa known from fossils found within the rock layers of the Ash Hollow Member of the Ogallala Formation Teleoceras Epicyon Barbourofelis Tapirus johnsoni Skinnerhyus The Kimball Member The Kimball Member is the uppermost and youngest member of the Ogallala Formation. The layers assigned to this member are fairly thin and are capped with a layer of solid rock which is usually referred to as the “Algal Limestone” layer. This caprock layer was long thought to have been formed from the remains of layers of algae building up at the bottom of an ancient lake. Our current understanding of this uppermost rock layer instead suggests that these layers are formed from the hardened remains of ancient soils, which produced a type of rock called caliche as the climate of the Great Plains became increasingly dry during the Pliocene epoch. (BELOW) An example of a caliche deposit in Meade County, Kansas. This particular deposit dates back to the Pleistocene. Photo by Grace Muilenburg/KGS Ashfall Fossil Beds The Ashfall Fossil Beds are found at a site in north-central Nebraska (Antelope County) which formed around 12 million years ago. The deposits at the site fall within the Ash Hollow Member of the Ogallala Formation. Most of the fossils found at the site were preserved within a layer of fine volcanic ash which is linked to the eruption of a supervolcano in what is now Idaho known as the Bruneau-Jarbidge eruption. Despite being located over 1000 miles away from these sites in Nebraska, the eruption of this supervolcano was so massive that huge volumes of ash were carried eastward by the wind, covering parts of the Great Plains in several feet of ash. (ABOVE) A map showing the location of the eruption of the volcano at the Bruneau-Jarbidge caldera (A) and the Ashfall Fossil Beds (B). Volcanic ash clouds produced by this eruption were carried for thousands of miles by prevailing westerly winds Prior to the eruption, the site that would one day become the Ashfall Fossil Beds was a watering hole nestled within a low-lying area within a larger warm, arid grassland. The climate in Nebraska during the Miocene epoch would have been similar to the climate found in parts of south-eastern Africa today and animals would have come from miles around in order to get a drink. Animals who were near the watering hole at the time when the ash cloud moved in from the west would have died as a result of inhaling small ash particles. It seems as though smaller animals were more vulnerable to the impacts of the ash in the air and most likely would have died in the first few days after the arrival of the ash cloud. Larger animals, such as rhinos, may have lasted for weeks or even months before succumbing to the effects of ash inhalation. Fossils of the rhino genus Teleoceras are some of the best known remains from the Ashfall site. The Hubbard Rhino Barn, which is open to the public during the summer season, displays the remains of an entire herd of these rhinos, with dozens of individuals preserved together as fully articulated skeletons. (ABOVE) A smothering cloud of ash descended on the plains of northern Nebraska 12 million years ago. In some places the layers associated with this ash cloud are over 10 feet thick. (ABOVE) The interior of the Hubbard Rhino Barn as it appeared in 2008. The taller sections in this photo are parts of the ash left undisturbed in order to preserve the positions of the bones found in those areas. Photo accessed via Wikimedia Commons, uploaded by Greg Goebel, CC BY-SA 2.0 (ABOVE) Photo of the skeleton of a three-toed horse, Cormohipparion occidentale , at the Ashfall site. Most of the fossils found at Ashfall are preserved with the bones arranged as they would have been positioned when the animal was alive. A few fossils seems to have been partially disarticulated by scavengers but these are comparatively rare. Photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 2.0 (ABOVE) Photo of several skeletons of Teleoceras major rhinos preserved together at the Hubbard Rhino Barn. More than three dozen full skeletons from this rhino species have been found at the Ashfall site, likely representing an entire herd which died a few months after the arrival of the ash cloud. Photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 2.0 (ABOVE) Photo of a skull of Teleoceras major . The lower jaw of this animal shows signs of abnormal bone growth caused by the animal's diseased lungs. Long term damage from ash inhalation can result in a condition known as Marie's disease, where bone is deposited unevenly or in large growths. These marks are one of the key pieces of evidence showing us that these animals survived for quite some time after the initial arrival of the ash cloud. Photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 2.0 (ABOVE) Photo of the hip bones of a female Teleoceras major rhino which encompass the remains of a fetal rhino. Photo by James St. John, CC BY-SA 2.0 Other Ash Layers Calvert Ash Bed: The thickest ash layer associated with the Ogallala Formation, over 20 feet deep. Sits above the Valentine Member in parts of Kansas and Nebraska Rawlins Ash Bed: Part of the lower part of the Ash Hollow Member. Appears in parts of Kansas and Nebraska Fort Wallace Ash Bed: Outcrops in parts of Wallace County, Kansas Dellvale Ash Bed: Outcrops in Norton County, Kansas Reamsville Ash Bed: One of the younger layers of Ash in the Ogallala Formation. Deposits dating back to the Pliocene epoch also contain the fossils of seeds from grasses and trees. Reager Ash Bed: Outcrops in Norton County, Decatur County, Rawlins County, Kansas (ABOVE) Photo of a deposit from the Reager Ash Beds. Photo taken in 1970 in Norton County, Kansas. Photo by Grace Muilenburg/KGS (ABOVE) Some ash deposits in the Ogallala Formation are incredibly thick. The band of volcanic ash seen in this photo, taken in Lincoln County, Kansas, shows their scale in comparison to the height of an adult human. Photo by John Charlton/KGS Ancient Environments The climate of the Great Plains during the Miocene and Pliocene epoch was considerably warmer than it is today. Fossils of plants and animals who depend on warmer weather such as palm trees, alligators and giant tortoises are found in Ogallala deposits in Kansas and Nebraska. Nevertheless, over the course of the Miocene and Pliocene the central part of North America became increasingly cool and dry. Many areas which had previously been covered in dense forests were suddenly converted into vast stretches of open grassland, similar to the savannahs found today in parts of south-eastern Africa. Patches of forest persisted within this landscape but only in small pockets where there was enough water to sustain large trees, and where they were protected from the high winds and storms which repeatedly passed over these Miocene savannahs. Open Grasslands (ABOVE) Over the course of the Miocene and Pliocene, open grasslands began to replace dense forests as the dominant environment found in the central parts of North America. Many of the characteristic fauna of the Ogallala Formation show anatomical features which indicate that they were adapting to living in more open, grassy environments. One of the most important developments in the evolution of herbivorous mammals was taking place at this time, with many groups of animals independently acquiring features which allowed them to break down and chew tougher grasses. Grass has a much higher silica content than the leaves of woody plants and chewing through large amounts of grass can wear down the teeth of plant-eating animals like sandpaper. As a result, many grazing animals developed tougher layers of enamel on their molars, or gained teeth which grew continuously over the course of the life of an animal so that their chewing surfaces would never be worn down. Some ancient animals also modified the anatomies of their legs in order to move more efficiently in open spaces. Early members of the horse family walked on three-toed feet but over the course of the Miocene, more and more horse genera began to support their weight on the middle toe on each foot. Older horse lineages had needed to support their body weight on three-toed feet which could give their feet more surface area while walking on the soft, unstable ground of a forest floor. In open, dry grasslands on the other hand, having a single toe allowed horses to more more quickly and with greater agility as they fled potential predators. By the middle of the Pliocene epoch, horses with only a single toe on each foot, similar to the foot structure seen in living horses and donkeys, had already appeared. Around the Watering Hole (ABOVE) Watering holes and rivers were the main sources of water for animals living in these ancient grasslands and would have also sustained nearby trees and bushes. Many of the open environments found in the grasslands of the Ogallala Formation were fairly dry and water was hard to find. As such, animals would travel across many miles to gather around small ponds, lakes and watering holes. These areas also tended to support woodier vegetation such as trees and bushes, which in turn provided food for browsing animals and mixed grazers/browsers. As a result of all these animals gathering in such close proximity, many of the most extensive fossil deposits known from the Ogallala Formation are those which appear to be associated with rivers, small wetlands and/or watering holes. Find out more about Miocene and Pliocene savannahs by exploring our Ogallala Formation field guide! Learn More

  • 3D Models | Prehistoric Midwest

    Learn more about the fossils of prehistoric animals by seeing them in 3D. These scans of Midwestern fossilized animal bones, including those of mammoths, dire wolves and sabertoothed cats, can be viewed from all angles to get a better idea of the forms of these fossils View fossils in 3D Scans and models of the remains of prehistoric life The models presented below are a series of scans taken of many different types of fossils which were generously provided by Bernard Means and the Virtual Curation Laboratory at Virginia Commonwealth University. To open these 3D scans, click on the model previews. You will then be able to click and drag in order to rotate and view the models from different angles. You can also find more models or further information about the VCL project by visiting the VCL website and Sketchfab page VCL Homepage VCL on Sketchfab American Mastodon (Mammut americanum) The American Mastodon was a large proboscidean found in North America from the end of the Miocene epoch to the end of the Pleistocene epoch. These animals tended to be shorter and stockier than mammoths and would have had cusped teeth used to break down woody vegetation. They also lack the domed forehead seen in the skulls of most mammoths. Learn more about Mastodons by visiting our entry about these animal in our Pleistocene Field Guide Mastodon Field Guide Entry Mastodon Right Molar 3 Description - (VCU_3D_2895): This mastodon molar was 3D scanned with a NextEngine Desktop 3D scanner at the Western Science Center’s Valley of the Mastodons workshop and conference in August 2017. The molar is from the Yukon and was brought from the Yukon Beringia Interpretative Center by Yukon Paleontonologist Grant Zazula. Specimen number YG 26.1. Courtesy of the Yukon Beringia Interpretative Center. Cohoes Mastodon Tusk Description - (VCU_3D_3634): This tusk of the Cohoes Mastodon was 3D scanned on May 31, 2018 with a Go!Scan 50 at the New York State Museum. Museum Specimen Number VP101. Courtesy of the New York State Museum. Cohoes Mastodon Skull Description - (VCU_3D_3632): This skull of the Cohoes Mastodon was 3D scanned on May 30 and May 31, 2018 with a Go!Scan 50 at the New York State Museum. Portions of the interior of the maxilla and mandible and the back of the skull could not be fully scanned because of the support structure for the skeletal mount. As the tusks were replicas, due to the fragile nature of the real tusks, these replica tusks were not 3D scanned. A planned return visit to the New York State Museum will attempt to capture additional 3D data from the skull. Museum Specimen Number VP101. Courtesy of the New York State Museum. Baby Mastodon Mandible Description - (VCU_3D_3209): This baby mastodon (Mammut americanum) mandible is from the Carter Bog site in Darke County, Ohio. It was 3D scanned with GoScan 50 at the Boonshoft Museum of Discovery. Courtesy of the Dayton Society of Natural History. Mammoths (M. columbi, M. primigenius) During the Pleistocene epoch North America would have been home to both Columbian mammoths and woolly mammoths. Woolly mammoths were found further north and Columbian mammoths were found as far south as southern Mexico. Separating the to can sometimes be complicated since populations of these species often interbred with one another Learn more about Mammoths by visiting our entries about these animals in our Pleistocene Field Guide Mammoth Field Guide Entries Mammoth Tusk Description - (VCU_3D_7852): The Randolph mammoth was discovered in May 1934 in Cattaraugus County, New York, near the town of Randolph. This tusk from a Colombian mammoth was 3-D scanned at the New York State Museum in May 2023 using a Go!Scan 50 3-D scanner. Courtesy of the New York State Museum. Randolph Mammoth Skull Description - (VCU_3D_3629): This mammoth skull is currently part of the Ice Ages exhibit at the New York State Museum. Because of this, the skull could only be 3D scanned with a Go!Scan 50 from the top and sides. A subsequent visit is anticipated to 3D scan the remainder of the fossil. Museum specimen number VP95. Courtesy of the New York State Museum. Mammoth molar Description - (VCU_3D_7842): This fossil was captured 11 May 2023 using a Go!Scan 50 at the New York State Museum. Courtesy of the New York State Museum which makes this model freely downloadable for non-commercial research, educational, and public outreach purposes. Dire Wolf (Aenocyon dirus) For most of the history of the study of their fossils, dire wolves were classified as members of the same genus as living wolves and dogs. More recent research seems to indicate that they were descended from their own line of canids who separately diversified in the Americas, leading to these animals being placed in a new genus, Aenocyon. Learn more about dire wolves by visiting our entry about these animals in our Pleistocene Field Guide Dire Wolf Field Guide Entry Dire Wolf Skull Description - (VCU_3D_3214): This dire wolf (Aenocyon dirus) wolf skull is from the La Brea tar pits but is in the collection of the Boonshoft Museum of Discovery. It was 3D scanned with a GoScan 50. The mandible is wired to the skull, which meant that portions of the skull could not be 3D scanned. Courtesy of the Dayton Society of Natural History. Smilodon fatalis Smilodon was a genus of saber-toothed cats once found in parts of North and South America. Among their closest relatives, Smilodon had some of the longest saber teeth, reaching over 10 inches long in some cases, including the root. These sabers seem to have been relatively fragile and fossils evidence shows that these delicate teeth sometimes broke while hunting. Learn more about Smilodon by visiting our entry about these animals in our Pleistocene Field Guide Smilodon Field Guide Entry Smilodon Skull Description - (VCU_3D_3615): This saber-toothed cat fossil is from the La Brea Tar Pits. It was originally cataloged as Smilodon californicus, a type usually subsumed today into Smilodon fatalis. The fossil was 3D scanned with a Go!Scan 50 at the Boonshoft Museum of Discovery on May 24, 2018. The mandible is wired to the cranium so not all aspects of the fossil could be properly 3D scanned. The fossil is real except for the canines, which are casts. Museum specimen G-28039. Courtesy of the Dayton Society of Natural History. Platygonus compressus Platygonus was an extinct type of peccary that was found in the Americas from the Miocene to the late Pleistocene epoch. These animals are sometimes called "flat-headed peccaries", a name which refers to the relatively uniform slopes of their nasal bones and the bones of their foreheads. Learn more about Platygonus by visiting our entry about these animals in our Pleistocene Field Guide Platygonus Field Guide Entry Platygonus Skull Description - (VCU_3D_3628): This skull of the extinct peccary (Platygonus compressus) was 3D scanned with a Go!Scan 50 at the New York State Museum on May 30, 2018. This skull is currently part of the Ice Ages exhibition. Museum specimen number VP46. Courtesy of the New York State Museum. Bison latifrons Bison latifrons , also known as the giant bison, was the largest bovid found in Pleistocene North America. Its horns could span over 7 feet across from tip to tip and they stood taller than an adult human at the shoulder. Weight estimates for these animals suggest that they could have grown to be as big as today's rhinos. Learn more about Bison latifrons by visiting our entry about these animals in our Pleistocene Field Guide Giant Bison Field Guide Entry Bison latifrons Skull Description - (VCU_3D_3937): This skull was found during construction of the Diamond Valley Lake near Hemet, California. It is currently on exhibit at the Western Science Center in Hemet. The skull was removed from its exhibit on September 10, 2018 for 3D scanning with a Go!Scan 50 and is associated with a horn. Courtesy of the Western Science Center. Bison latifrons Horn Description - (VCU_3D_3936): This horn was found during construction of the Diamond Valley Lake near Hemet, California. It is currently on exhibit at the Western Science Center in Hemet. The horn was removed from its exhibit on September 10, 2018 for 3D scanning with a Go!Scan 50 and is associated with a skull. Courtesy of the Western Science Center. Bootherium bombifrons The woodland muskox, Bootherium bombifrons, was a type of muskox that once lived in parts of the Midwest and the Great Plains. Although they look very similar to bison or cows, the closest relatives of muskoxen are actually sheep and goats. The horns over their foreheads were joined together along the middle of the skull instead of being separated by an open gap. Learn more about Bootherium by visiting our entry about these animals in our Pleistocene Field Guide Bootherium Field Guide Entry Bootherium Skull Description - (VCU_3D_4139): This skull of a Bootherium bombifrons is the holotype and was collected by William Clark and George Rogers Clark from Big Bone Lick, Kentucky for Thomas Jefferson. It was 3-D scanned with a Go!Scan 50 at the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelpha on December 10, 2018 with funding from a Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) Seed Grant entitled “3-D Digital Ice Age Mastodon and Mammoth Skeletal Remains.” Specimen number 12994. Courtesy of the Academy of Natural Sciences. Castoroides ohioensis Castoroides, also known as the giant beaver, was possibly the largest rodent ever to live in North America. It could probably have grown to be as heavy as a black bear and each of its incisors was over five inches long. These animals do not seem to have been adapted for cutting down trees and instead would have browsed on aquatic vegetation in ponds and lakes. Learn more about Castoroides by visiting our entry about these animals in our Pleistocene Field Guide Castoroides Field Guide Entry Castoroides Skull Description - (VCU_3D_3639): This giant beaver skull was 3D scanned with a Go!Scan 50 at the New York State Museum on May 31, 2018. It was found in Wayne County, New York. Museum Specimen Number VP 47. Courtesy of the New York State Museum. Megalonyx jeffersonii Megalonyx was a type of ground sloth once found across most of North America all the way up until the very end of the Pleistocene epoch. Unlike many other types of ground sloths, who often walked on the sides of their feet, Megalonyx would have walked with the soles of its feet planted on the ground. It had a short snout and distinctive tusk-like insisors Learn more about Megalonyx by visiting our entry about this sloth in our Pleistocene Field Guide Megalonyx Field Guide Entry Megalonyx Skull Reconstruction Description - (VCU_3D_3996): Reconstructed skull of a Megalonyx by Ray Voden of the Virginia Museum of Natural History based on a fossil found at the Carter Bog site in Ohio and held at the Boonshoft Museum of Discovery. The red portions are reconstructed while the non-red portions are a cast of the original fossil. It was 3-D scanned with a GoScan! 50 on October 19, 2018. Courtesy of the Dayton Society of Natural History and the Virginia Museum of Natural History. Megalonyx Claw With Nail Description - (VCU_3D_5214): This giant ground sloth (Megalonyx jeffersonii) with intact finger nail was recovered from Big Bone Cave, Tennessee. It was 3-D scanned with a NextEngine Desktop 3-D scanner on March 11, 2020 at the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia. Repository specimen number ANSP 12487. Courtesy of the Academy of Natural Sciences. The Virginia Commonwealth University Humanities Research Center supported the research trip that made this scanning effort possible. Megalonyx Mandible Descritption - (VCU_3D_3943): This giant ground sloth mandible is currently on exhibit at the Western Science Center. It was removed from the exhibt for 3D scanning on September 10, 2018 and was 3D scanned with a Go!Scan 50. Courtesy of the Western Science Center. Paramylodon harlani Paramylodon harlani, also known as Harlan's ground sloth, was a large terrestrial sloth native to North America. It had a fairly long snout and is well represented by dozens of skeletons found at the Rancho La Brea Tar Pits in Los Angeles. Footprints of a Paramylodon were also found in associated with human tracks at White Sands National Monument. Learn more about Paramylodon by visiting our entry about this sloth in our Pleistocene Field Guide Paramylodon Field Guide Entry Paramylodon Osteoderm Description - (VCU_3D_8386): This fossil was 3-D scanned with a NextEngine Desktop scanner on 10 December 2024. Courtesy of Kevin Jones who has agreed to make this 3-D scan freely downloadable for non-commercial educational, outreach, and research purposes. A small plate of bony armor which would have been embedded in the skin of the sloth in life. Paramylodon Claw Description - (VCU_3D_3090): This fossil was 3D scanned at the Western Science Center on December 14, 2017 using a NextEngine Desktop 3D scanner. Courtesy of the Western Science Center. Find out more about ice age animals in the Midwest by exploring our Pleistocene field guide Learn More

bottom of page