Search this site
53 results found with an empty search
- Ichthyosaurs | Prehistoric Midwest
Explore the types of Ichthyosaurs who lived in the Western Interior Sea, including animals like Athabascasaurus and Maiaspondylus Ichthyosauria Ichthyosaurs of the Western Interior Sea Ichthyosaurs were a group of marine reptiles whose streamlined bodies closely resembled those of modern dolphins. They had shark-like tail flukes, paddle-shaped limbs and often also had exceptionally large eyes that helped them to hunt effectively in low-light underwater environments. Unlike most reptiles, ichthyosaurs were viviparous, giving birth to live young in the ocean rather than laying eggs on land. During the Cretaceous Period, many of the surviving ichthyosaurs belonged to the platypterygiine lineage, a subgroup of ophthalmosaurid ichthyosaurs who managed to live on long after most other types of ichthyosaurs had long since gone extinct. Evolutionary History (BELOW) A group of large Ichthyosaurs has washed ashore during the late Triassic. During the mass extinction event at the end of this period, most of the larger types of ichthyosaurs would die out and vanish from the fossil record. An Ancient Group of Marine Reptiles Ichthyosaurs were one of the first major groups of reptiles to become fully adapted to life in the ocean. Their evolutionary history begins all the way back during the Early Triassic shortly after the end-Permian mass extinction. The terrestrial ancestors of this group gradually acquired a range of aquatic adaptations, first becoming semi-aquatic and then eventually fully marine animals. Throughout the middle and late Triassic period ichthyosaurs diversified dramatically. They developed their dolphin-like streamlined bodies and became important predators in marine ecosystems. Some species, including Shonisaurus, evolved enormous sizes and ranked among the largest marine reptiles of the era, growing to be larger than some of today’s sperm whales. Some of these ancient giants may have even evolved specialized jaw structures used for filter feeding. Ichthyosaur sizes reached their peak towards the end of the Triassic period but most of the larger groups of ichthyosaurs died out during the end-Triassic extinction event. The animals who made it through to the Jurassic period were generally smaller and more heavily built than the large, slender ichthyosaurs of the late Triassic period. They remained a key part of the ocean food web as generalists and even large macropredators all the way through the Jurassic, although they faced increased competition from other types of marine reptiles such as plesiosaurs. Although ichthyosaur diversity declined during the Cretaceous, the group continued to be represented by advanced members of the subfamily Platypterygiinae before they disappeared completely during the early part of the late Cretaceous. (BELOW) A fossil preserving the remains of the Cretaceous Ichthyosaur Maiaspondylus was found alongside the bones of two ichthyosaur embryos. These animals were unable to leave the water to lay eggs and so they instead gave live birth at sea. Platypterygiines (Platypterygiinae) The Last of the Ichthyosaurs Platypterygiines were a distinctive subgroup of ichthyosaurs that were some of the last Ichthyosaurs to exist before their extinction during the middle Cretaceous period. These animals are often grouped together based on the square-shaped tooth roots, specialized limb structures, and broad, powerful pectoral fins often seen in the members of the platypterigiine lineage. These adaptations likely helped them occupy a variety of predatory niches in Cretaceous marine ecosystems, msotly as soft-prey specialists. During the middle Cretaceous, North American seas were home to several platypterygiine taxa of various sizes, whose fossil remains are found in deposits located in Canada and Wyoming dating to a time before the two halves of the Interior Sea had fully joined together. Athabascasaurus Temporal Range: 112.6 million years ago - 109 million years ago Geographic Range: Alberta Species: A. bitumineus Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Athabascasaurus was an ichthyosaur that measured around 11 feet long which would have made it a medium-sized marine predator within the Cretaceous seas of North America. Its first fossils were found in 2000 at an oil sands mine near Fort McMurray, Alberta. The fossil included a nearly complete skull and most of an articulated skeleton which was enough material to tell that this animal should belong to a new genus. The name Athabascasaurus honors the Athabasca region where the specimen was discovered, while the species name bitumineus references its recovery from bitumen-rich oil sands deposits. Maiaspondylus Temporal Range: 113 million years ago - 94.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Northwest Territories, the UK, Russia Species: M. cantabrigiensis, M. lindoei Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Maiaspondylus is a platypterigiine ichthyosaur known from fossil material discovered in the Loon River Formation of northern Canada. It can be distinguished from other ichthyosaurs by its enlarged front flippers and widened upper arm bones which formed a large section of the point where its flippers articulated with the joints of its shoulders. The original material we now call Maiaspondylus was initially assigned to the genus Platypterygius , a genus which has since become considered a “wastebasket taxon” with many distantly related ichthyosaurs placed within this genus as new species. Many of these species have since been split into new genera of platypterigiines. Further study led to the fossil from the Loon River Formation being formally named Maiaspondylus in 2006. The genus name means “good mother vertebra”. This name was inspired by a fossil containing two embryos preserved alongside the remains of an adult individual. This specimen showed that Maiaspondylus, much like other ichthyosaurs, gave birth to live young at sea. Suggested References: Ichthyosauria Druckenmiller, P. S.; Maxwell, E. E. (2010). "A new Lower Cretaceous (lower Albian) ichthyosaur genus from the Clearwater Formation, Alberta, Canada". Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences. 47 (8): 1037–1053. Fischer, V; Maisch, M. W.; Naish, D ; Kosma, R.; Liston, J.; Joger, U.; Krüger, F.J.; Pérez J. P.; Tainsh, J; Appleby, R. M. (2012). "New Ophthalmosaurid Ichthyosaurs from the European Lower Cretaceous Demonstrate Extensive Ichthyosaur Survival across the Jurassic–Cretaceous Boundary". PLOS ONE. 7 (1) e29234. Naish, D. (2023). “Ancient Sea Reptiles: Plesiosaurs, Ichthyosaurs, Mosasaurs, and More. Washington, DC”: Smithsonian Books, 192 p Zverkov, N. G. ; Grigoriev, D. V. (2020). "An unrevealed lineage of platypterygiines (Ichthyosauria) with peculiar forefin structure and semiglobal distribution in the mid-Cretaceous (Albian–Cenomanian)". Cretaceous Research. 115 104550.
- The Cenozoic Era | Prehistoric Midwest
The Western Interior Sea once spanned from the Gulf of Mexico to the Arctic Ocean and split North America in two during the Late Cretaceous period The Cenozoic Era 66 million years ago - Present The Cenozoic era is the span of time lasting from the end of the Cretaceous period 66 million years ago all the way up to the present day. Often this time period is referred to as the “Age of Mammals” since many of the new ecological niches which opened up after the extinction of the non-avian dinosaurs were taken over by mammals. Despite this, mammals were not the only animals to radiate into new roles over the course of the Cenozoic. Many types of crocodylomorphs, birds, snakes and turtles grew to gigantic sizes at various points during this era. Much like the Mesozoic era, the Cenozoic is divided into three periods; the Paleogene period, The Neogene period, and the Quaternary period. The Paleogene was the first period of the Cenozoic and this span of time saw the first appearances of many of the large mammal groups we are used to seeing today; including the first hoofed mammals and whales, the first primates, and the first carnivorans. The Paleogene period began as a very warm moment in geologic history but as this period gave way to the Neogene, the Earth had started to grow colder. The Neogene saw the expansion of grassland habitats. Much of the Midwest would have been covered in wide savannahs during the Neogene and rhinos, tapirs, camels and early horses would have been abundant in these new open environments. The Quaternary period is the last period in the Cenozoic and is the geologic period which includes the present day. This time period was characterized by the advance and retreat of huge continental ice sheets which at various times in the last 2.5 million years had managed to cover nearly the entire Midwest. Animals like mammoths, mastodons, giant sloths and bison would have been common in North America during this period. Humans arrived in the Midwest towards the end of the Quaternary and their arrival is thought to have been one of the reasons for the extinction of the large land mammals which used to be found in this region. Previous Section The Mesozoic Era Return to Home Home Page The Paleogene Period: 66 - 23 million years ago In the immediate aftermath of the end-Cretaceous mass extinction most of the animals who had managed to survive the effects of the asteroid impact were small generalists or seed eaters. With most of the large animals gone, mammals, crocodylomorphs, squamates and birds were able to move into new niches and grew rapidly to much larger sizes. Rocks which date back to the Paleogene period are found in parts of the upper Great Plains, particularly in North Dakota. Some of the earliest large Cenozoic animals to appear in the fossil record are found in these deposits, such as the strange pantodont mammal Titanoides . The Paleogene is divided into three epochs; the Paleocene, the Eocene and the Oligocene. For most of the Paleocene and Eocene epoch the climate of North America was generally warm and humid. Huge rainforests spanned across the entire continent and large crocodilians and other cold-sensitive reptiles were found at very high latitudes in the northern hemisphere. Over the course of the Eocene and Oligocene epochs the Earth’s climate began to cool and become more dry. By the end of the Paleogene period the large rainforests had fragmented and were increasingly divided by larger expanses of more open environments. Many different groups of animals crossed over repeatedly between Eurasia and North America during the Paleogene, including early horse ancestors and several groups of carnivorous hoofed mammals. Camels first appeared in North America during the Paleogene and they would become one of the most abundant and diverse mammal groups endemic to the continent during the next period in geologic time; the Neogene period. (ABOVE) A scene set in a dense rainforest during the Eocene epoch of the Paleogene period. A pair of large rhino-like uintatheres stand beside a small stream. These forest are home to many types of birds and hoofed carnivorous mammals. (ABOVE) A giant Megacerops titanothere with a forked nasal horn moves in to protect its young calf from a pair of cat-like sabertoothed nimravids. Fossils of Megacerops are often found in parts of the White River badlands in South Dakota Paleogene Animals Basilosaurus an ancient whale Archaeotherium an entelodont Dissacus a mesonychid Agriochoerus a hoofed mammal The Paleogene Period 23 million years ago The Neogene Period The Neogene Period: 23 - 2.58 million years ago The Neogene period is divided into two epochs; the Miocene epoch (23-5.3 million years ago) and the Pliocene epoch (5.3-2.58 million years ago). In many parts of North America, grasslands took over the landscape during the Neogene period. Although the first grasses found in the fossil record date all the way back to the Cretaceous period, these plants became much more abundant in the Neogene as forests began to retreat as a result of a cooling climate. In broad terms the Midwest was still warmer during the Neogene period than it is today. Many parts of the Great Plains were covered in savannah-like habitats which were home to relatives of elephants, ancient rhinos, horses, tapirs, dogs, camels and early cats. Some of the best preserved fossils from this time period are found within deposits linked to the Ogallala formation/group which today extends from Texas to South Dakota. The fossils found in these deposits show us that Neogene life in North America would have been just as diverse as the biotas of today’s African savannahs. A particularly notable series of sites in Nebraska, the Ashfall Fossil Beds, preserve the remains of an entire herd of Teleoceras rhinos, as well as the fossils of dozens of other types of animals, preserved in fine ash along the edge of what was once a watering hole. These animals were victims of the ash generated by an ancient eruption of the Yellowstone supervolcano which formed an ash plume extending across most of North America. The western parts of North America seem to have been very volcanically active over the course of much of the Cenozoic and many Neogene fossil localities in the western US are linked to the deposition of ash as a result of these catastrophic eruptions. Despite this, none of these volcanic events seem to have resulted in large-scale mass extinction events. Towards the end of the Neogene period, North and South America became connected by the isthmus of Panama. This allowed many types of animals to move between the continents. North America got its first armadillos and sloths, while South America would receive its first carnivorans, horses, proboscideans and deer. (ABOVE) A representation of the landscape of central North America during the Miocene epoch. The warmer climate which characterized this moment in the Neogene period, along with the spread of prairie grasses, led to the formation of savannah-like grassland environments in parts of Kansas, Nebraska, Oklahoma, South Dakota and Texas. Neogene Animals Andrias a giant salamander Alligator mefferdi an alligatorid Balearica a crowned crane Harrisonsaurus an iguana Ceratogaulus a mylagaulid rodent Teleoceras a rhinoceros Synthetoceras a protoceratid Ischyrocyon a bear-dog Borophagus a borophagine dog Gomphotherium a proboscidean Aepycamelus a camel Daeodon an entelodont The Neogene Period 2.58 million years ago The Quaternary Period The Quaternary Period: 2.58 million years ago - Present The Quaternary period is the final and shortest period of the Cenozoic era. It is also the period of geologic time which includes the present day. The span of time within the Quaternary period between 2.58 million years ago and 11,700 is known as the Pleistocene epoch, while the length of time from 11,700 years ago to the present is known as the Holocene epoch. The Pleistocene saw large ice sheets advance and retreat across the Midwest over the course of many successive warm and cold cycles lasting tens of thousands of years. At their largest extent, these ice sheets extended as far south as Kansas City. The presence of such large volumes of ice had huge impacts on the world’s geography. Sea levels were very low during much of the Pleistocene and many parts of the world which are currently covered by shallow seas would have been coastal lowlands at various times throughout this epoch. The movement of ice sheets also reshaped the landscape of the Midwest, scouring the surface of the land, changing the drainage patterns of rivers, and even creating the conditions necessary to form the Great Lakes. North America was also home to many unique forms of large animals during the Pleistocene. These extinct Pleistocene animals, often collectively known as “ice age megafauna”, included mammoths, mastodons, deer, bison, ground sloths, camels and tortoises. Many of these large land animals became extinct towards the end of the Pleistocene, possibly as a result of increased hunting from humans who arrived in North America towards the end of the Pleistocene epoch. Our Pleistocene Field Guide (ABOVE) Forest and wetland animals found in the Midwest during the Pleistocene epoch; (1) Cervalce s, (2) Castoroides , (3) a Mastodon We have an online field guide about all the different kinds of animals who lived in the Midwest during the Pleistocene epoch! Click the link to learn more! Learn More Extinct Pleistocene Animals American Mastodon Mammut americanum Giant Bison Bison latifrons Western Tortoise Hesperotestudo Giant Beaver Castoroides ohioensis Scott's Horse Equus scotti Stag Moose Cervalces latifrons Giant camel Titanotylopus nebrascensis Saber-toothed Cat Smilodon fatalis (BELOW) The skyline of Kansas City as it appears today at the meeting point of the Kansas and Missouri rivers. The path followed by the Missouri River today was shaped by the presence of large ice sheets in this region around 700,000 years ago which pushed the river further south. The advance of these ice sheets also caused many rivers in the area to flow from east to west instead of north to south. Previous Section The Mesozoic Era Return to Home Home Page
- Proboscideans | Prehistoric Midwest
Extinct proboscideans - Mammoths, mastodons and other elephant relatives from the Pleistocene epoch of the Midwest Proboscidea Midwestern Elephant Relatives During the Pleistocene Epoch, the Midwest was home to several large proboscideans, the group of mammals that includes modern elephants. These animals represented many different forms of elephant-like mammals, including mammoths, mastodons and gomphotheres. Mastodons preferred forested environments, where they browsed on leaves, twigs, and shrubs, while mammoths were more adapted to open grasslands and fed primarily on grasses. Gomphotheres formed a group with a convoluted taxonomic history, possibly even including the direct ancestors of mammoths and living elephantids, as well as a diverse array of strange four-tusked extinct proboscideans. In the Pleistocene epoch, the last members of the gomphothere group were animals like the spiral-tusked Cuvieronius . Fossil discoveries across Midwestern states such as Kansas, Missouri, Iowa, Illinois, and Indiana show that these giant mammals were important members of Pleistocene ecosystems until their extinction near the end of the Ice Age. Anatomy (BELOW) Features of the skulls of proboscideans, in this case the gomphothere Cuvieronius. The large tusks found in many types of proboscideans are composed of a pair of enlarged incisors. Some proboscideans had lower jaw tusks as well. Skull and Dentition One of the defining features of proboscideans both living and extinct is their large, highly modified skulls. In many proboscideans, the skull is saturated with air-filled cavities that make the bones more lightweight without losing the strength needed to hold the mass of the trunk and tusks. Living elephants have a tall, sometimes domed skull with enlarged nasal openings situated high on the face. This position is linked to the shape of the base of the trunk. Extinct proboscidean groups each had their own special suites of skull features which ranged from the longer, lower-profile skulls of amebelodontids which often held long tusks on their lower jaws, as well as the more familiar skull shapes seen in animals like mammoths. The teeth of proboscideans changed quite a bit over the course of their evolutionary history as well. Early members of the group had a larger number of teeth than their modern relatives and had relatively simple molars with low crowns. Over time molar structure became increasingly specialized. Mastodons had molars with tall cusps suited for browsing on woody vegetation, while mammoths and modern elephants evolved large flattened grinding teeth characterized by multiple enamel ridges which are perfect for chewing up grasses and other tough silicate-rich plant matter. In many species the upper incisors eventually turned into tusks which, depending on the genus, could be straight, curved or even spiral-shaped. (BELOW) Lower jaws of two types of extinct proboscideans on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Mammoth jaw on the left side of the image, mastodon lower jaw on the right. Note the differences in the shapes of the molars. Postcranial Skeletal Anatomy Most proboscideans were/are rather large animals. As a result of their size, most of their skeletal anatomy is adapted for holding up extreme amounts of weight. These animals have massive, pillar-like limbs which are thick and heavily reinforced. Their nearly vertical orientation beneath the body helps to reduce mechanical stress as these animals move. Compared with many other mammals, the lower limb joints of proboscideans are quite inflexible and are supported by a cushioned pad beneath each foot. Their vertebral columns and rib cages are similarly sturdy and often very wide. (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeletal anatomy of a Columbian mammoth, based on the skeletal mount from the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History. External Anatomy Modern elephants have relatively little body hair and, in many species, they additionally have large ears that they can use to cool down by flushing them with blood. In contrast, woolly mammoths and possibly some mastodons were covered by a thick coat of fur and an insulating underlayer, adaptations for survival in cold environments. Proboscideans living in colder climates also likely had smaller ears in order to keep their body heat from escaping. Mammoths and other Pleistocene proboscideans living in warmer climates may have had mostly hairless skin like that seen in living elephants. (BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of the proboscidean Stegomastodon from the early Pleistocene epoch Cuvieronius hyodon Temporal Range: 10 million years ago to approximately 10,700 years ago Geographic Range: Found across North and South America Species: C. hyodon, C. tropicus, C. oligobunis, C. priestleyi Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Cuvieronius was an elephant-like proboscidean belonging to the trilophodont gomphothere group. It was one of the last surviving gomphotheres and ranged from the southern regions of North America through Central America before eventually spreading into South America. Unlike mammoths and mastodons, Cuvieronius had distinctive tusks that twisted in a gentle spiral. Its lower tusks were greatly reduced or absent in adults. Fossil evidence indicates that it would have lived in a variety of environments, including open grasslands, woodlands, and subtropical habitats. Its flexible diet allowed it to consume a wide range of vegetation rather than specializing on either grasses or browse. A few sites seem to show the remains of Cuvieronius preserved alongside stone tools, suggesting that the first humans to arrive in the Americas hunted these gomphotheres. Columbian mammoth Mammuthus columbi Temporal Range: 1.5 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Genus across North America, Central America Species: M. columbi Diet: Herbivorous grazer, grasses The Columbian mammoth was the largest land mammal found in the Midwest during the Pleistocene. Up until around 12,000 years ago mammoths would have been a common sight all throughout North America. Their range extended from North Dakota all the way down to central Mexico and their remains are found along both the Atlantic and Pacific coasts. Mammoths were at home in grassland habitats where they would have lived alongside giant bison, camels and wild horses. The average adult Columbian mammoth would have stood around 12 feet tall at the shoulder, although some very large individuals may have reached heights of 14 feet making them much larger than any elephant species alive today. A particularly large example of a Columbian mammoth skeleton, nicknamed Archie, is on display at the Nebraska State Natural History Museum in Lincoln. This particular specimen is one of the largest mounted mammoth skeletons in the world. (ABOVE) A skeleton of a Columbian mammoth, nicknamed "Archie" on display the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. Woolly mammoth skeleton in the background on the right. (ABOVE) An adult mammoth tooth (left) compared with a tooth from a juvenile (right). Mammoths and other proboscideans lost their teeth as they got older and new sets moved in to take their place. Teeth are on display at the KU Natural History Museum in Lawrence, KS. Woolly mammoth Mammuthus primigenius Temporal Range: 400,000 years ago to approximately 4,000 years ago Geographic Range: northern latitudes of North America, Eurasia Species: M. primigenius Diet: Herbivorous grazer, grasses Woolly mammoths were fairly rare in the Midwest. They were almost entirely absent in the southern parts of the Plains and even in parts of South Dakota they seem to have been outnumbered by their larger relatives, the Columbian mammoths. At the Mammoth Site in Hot Springs, South Dakota, a Pleistocene bone bed preserves the remains of dozens of Columbian mammoths but only three woolly mammoths. Woolly mammoths are well known for their thick coats of fur which would have offered them a great deal of protection from the cold. Some mammoth mummies have even been found with some of their fur coats still intact. Mammoths had longer legs than most of today's elephants and had a distinctive dome on top of their foreheads. The last of the woolly mammoths disappeared from a small island in the Arctic called Wrangel Island around 4,000 years ago, although by then they had been extinct on the mainland for thousands of years. American mastodon Mammut americanum Temporal Range: 8 million years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Genus is found across North America Species: M. americanum, M. pacificum, M. nevadanum Diet: Herbivorous browser, leaves American mastodons were some of the first large animals whose fossils were recorded as having been found in North America. Their bones were likely found across the continent for thousands of years but the first recorded find of one of their fossils is likely a piece of a tooth surface found sometime around 1705. Early in their history of study, in the 19th century, the large cusps on the teeth of these animals were interpreted as a sign that they were carnivorous, although this idea was soon dismissed. We now know that these large cusped teeth were likely an adaptation for feeding on woody plant material. Mastodons were found all across North America, from Alaska to central Mexico. These animals could be differentiated from mammoths by their stockier builds, straighter tusks, unique tooth surface shapes, and the lack of a large bony dome over their foreheads. They preferred to live in forest habitats. Although these animals are typically reconstructed with a thick coat of fur, some researchers have suggested that they might not have been very hairy after all, with their stockier build keeping them warm even in colder areas. This is still an unresolved question and future finds may give us more information about the life appearance of these ancient animals. The American mastodon also has an important cultural presence in the US and has been designated the official fossil of the states of Michigan and Indiana! (ABOVE) A mastodon tooth on display at the KU Natural History Museum. The tall cusps on these teeth were well adapted for processing woody browse. Worn teeth of this size are found in older individuals. (ABOVE) A mastodon skeleton on display the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. Unlike mammoths, these mastodons did not have a prominent dome on their foreheads. Stegomastodon nebrascensis Temporal Range: 4 million years ago to 1.2 million years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North America Species: S. nebrascensis, S. mirificus, S. aftonae, S. primitivus Diet: Herbivorous mixed diet, grasses, leaves Stegomastodon was an extinct proboscidean belonging to a group called the trilophodont gomphotheres. These were extinct elephant relatives that had flourished in North America during the Neogene period but became increasingly rare during the Pleistocene. Stegomastodon lived in North America from the Pliocene into the early Pleistocene. Unlike earlier gomphotheres, which often had elongated jaws with a second set of lower symphysial tusks, Stegomastodon had a short lower jaw and only a pair of upper tusks, giving it a more elephant-like appearance than some of its ancestors. Its tusks curved upward and could reach impressive lengths. Fossils of Stegomastodon have been discovered across much of North America, indicating that it occupied a wide range of habitats. These animals were once thought to have lived in South America but those southern species have since been folded into the genus Notiomastodon . (ABOVE) A skeleton of Stegomastodon on display the University of Nebraska State Museum of Natural History, Morrill Hall. Note the length of the tusks in this animal and the width of the bones of the ribcage and pelvis Media Gallery Suggested References: Proboscidea Bader, Camille; Delapré, Arnaud; Göhlich, Ursula B.; Houssaye, Alexandra (2024). "Diversity of limb long bone morphology among proboscideans: how to be the biggest one in the family". Papers in Palaeontology. 10 (6) e1597. Dooley Jr., Alton C.; Scott, Eric; Green, Jeremy; Springer, Kathleen B.; Dooley, Brett S.; Smith, Gregory James (2019). "Mammut pacificus sp. nov., a newly recognized species of mastodon from the Pleistocene of western North America". PeerJ. 7 e6614 Louguet-Lefebvre, Sophie (2013). "The Columbian mammoths from the Upper Pleistocene of Hot Springs (South Dakota, United States)". Paléo. 24 (24): 149–171. Pérez-crespo, V. A.; Prado, J. L.; Alberdi, M. T.; Arroyo-cabrales, J.; Johnson, E. (2016). "Diet and habitat for six American Pleistocene proboscidean species using carbon and oxygen stable isotopes". Ameghiniana. 53 (1): 39–51. Lucas, Spencer G.; Aguilar, Ricardo H.; Speilmann, Justin A. (2011). "Stegomastodon (Mammalia, Proboscidea) from the Pliocene of Jalisco, Mexico and the species-level taxonomy of Stegomastodon". New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin. 53: 517–553. Mothé, Dimila; Avilla, Leonardo S.; Cozzuol, Mário; Winck, Gisele R. (2012). "Taxonomic revision of the Quaternary gomphotheres (Mammalia: Proboscidea: Gomphotheriidae) from the South American lowlands". Quaternary International. 276–277: 2–7. Mead, Jim I.; Arroyo-Cabrales, Joaquin; Swift, Sandra L. (2019). "Late Pleistocene Mammuthus and Cuvieronius (proboscidea) from Térapa, Sonora, Mexico". Quaternary Science Reviews. 223 105949. Mothé, Dimila; Avilla, Leonardo S.; Cozzuol, Mario A. (2012). "The South American Gomphotheres (Mammalia, Proboscidea, Gomphotheriidae): Taxonomy, Phylogeny, and Biogeography". Journal of Mammalian Evolution. 20: 23–32. Nabavizadeh, Ali (2024). "Of tusks and trunks: A review of craniofacial evolutionary anatomy in elephants and extinct Proboscidea". The Anatomical Record. 308 (11) ar.25578. Sanders, William J. (2023). "Chapter 3:Late Paleogene: First Major Diversification and Adaptive Radiation of Proboscideans". Evolution and Fossil Record of African Proboscidea. CRC Press. pp. 45–99. Sanders, William J. (2017). "Horizontal tooth displacement and premolar occurrence in elephants and other elephantiform proboscideans". Historical Biology. 30 (1–2): 137–156. Smith, Gregory James; DeSantis, Larisa R. G. (2020). "Extinction of North American Cuvieronius (Mammalia: Proboscidea: Gomphotheriidae) driven by dietary resource competition with sympatric mammoths and mastodons". Paleobiology. 46 (1): 41–57.
- Archosaurs | Prehistoric Midwest
Cretaceous archosaurs found in the Western Interior Sea included pterosaurs, seabirds, giant crocs and dinosaurs who had been washed out to sea. Learn more about animals like Pteranodon, Deinosuchus and Hesperornis Archosauria Dinosaurs, Crocs and Pterosaurs Archosauria is a diverse group of reptiles that includes dinosaurs, pterosaurs, crocodilians, and modern birds. Members of this clade share several key characteristics, such as openings in the skull located in front of their orbits, teeth anchored within sockets, and an upright limb posture. These features improved the mobility and efficiency of these reptiles and helped archosaurs become one of the most successful vertebrate groups of the Mesozoic era. The first Archosaurs showed up during the Triassic period and they quickly evolved into a wide variety of forms adapted to life on land, in the air and in aquatic environments. During the Cretaceous Period, the Western Interior Sea was home to a wide variety of Archosaurs. Pterosaurs flew over the seaway, while birds occupied coastal and marine habitats. Dinosaurs, including hadrosaurs and tyrannosaurs, lived along nearby shorelines and floodplains and crocodyliforms were common in rivers, estuaries, marshes and coastal regions connected to the seaway. Anatomy (ABOVE) A labeled diagram of the skull of the tyrannosauroid Gorgosaurus showing the placement of bones and key openings General Characteristics Archosaurs are a very diverse group of reptiles and as a result of the range of forms taken by the members of this group it can be difficult to find shared anatomical traits found in many living and extinct archosaurian lineages. Despite this, by looking back into the fossil record, we see that one of the key traits of the archosaurs as a group is the antorbital fenestra, an opening located in between the eye socket and nostril which helped lighten the skull. In some groups of archosaurs, such as crocodilians and birds, this fenestra was later lost. Many types of archosaurs also had a mandibular fenestra in their lower jaws, which reduced bone mass and provided additional space for jaw muscles. Their teeth are also anchored within deep sockets in the jaw. Early archosaurs also had very mobile ankles and reinforced pelvic bones which allowed them to hold themselves off the ground instead of holding a sprawled posture. (BELOW) The bones of the forelimbs of different types of archosaurs. Archosaurs ancestrally had five fingers on each hand, although only the front three fingers would have had a claw/nail. Some groups of archosaurs lost digits over time. Dinosaurs Many of the major distinguishing features which separate different groups of dinosaurs are related to the skeletal anatomies of these extinct animals. There are generally considered to be two main groups of dinosaurs; saurischians and ornithischians, which differ primarily in the arrangement of their pelvic bones. Saurischians, including theropods and sauropodomorphs, had a forward-directed pubis bone, while ornithischians evolved a pelvis in which the pubis pointed backward. Many saurischians also had hollow, lightweight bones, three-toed hind feet, and sharp teeth suited for catching and consuming prey. Some members of this group, like the sauropods, had long necks, relatively small heads, sturdy pillar-like limbs, and robust vertebrae adapted to support their immense bodies. Many saurischians seem to have had large air sacs inside of their bodies which would have helped them grow to giant sizes while remaining fairly light relative to their immense volume. It seems as though these saurischian air sacs also played a role in giving these animals more efficient ways to breathe. Ornithischians on the other hand developed several features associated with specializing in plant-eating diets, including specialized grinding teeth and in some groups an extra predentary bone at the front of the lower jaw. Some groups, such as ceratopsians, evolved horns and large frills around their skulls, whereas stegosaurs and ankylosaurs would have had protective armor and defensive skeletal structures along the length of their bodies. (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeletal anatomy of Gorgosaurus . The furcula, or wishbone, was present in many types of derived theropod dinosaurs by the Late Cretaceous, even in lineages which were not able to fly. Adaptations For Flight (ABOVE) Dinosaurs are usually classified as ornithischians or saurischians based on the arrangement and shape of their hip bones. Birds, which are part of the saurischian theropod group, independently developed a hip with a retroverted pubis. Various different archosaur groups independently evolved specialized skeletal features that helped them achieve powered flight. Pterosaurs, the earliest known vertebrates capable of powered flight, had wings formed by a set of membranes called patagia which stretched along an exceptionally elongated fourth finger and which were supported by thin rods called actinofibrils. Their skeletons were highly adapted for aerial locomotion, with hollow lightweight bones that minimized body weight without sacrificing structural strength. Birds, descendants of maniraptoran theropod dinosaurs, developed an alternative wing design in which feathers attached to modified bones in their forelimbs. Over time they evolved several new flight-related adaptations, including a fused clavicle, or furcula (the wishbone), and a large keeled sternum that anchored large flight muscles developed from the pectoral muscles around the chest. Fusing different bones was a common strategy in different types of flying archosaurs. In pterosaurs for instance, many of the thoracic vertebrae became linked together into a rigid bony structure called a notarium. Many of these animals also had fused synsacra composed of their fused or semi-fused sacral vertebrae. (BELOW) In order to deal with the skeletal stresses required for a bird to develop powered flight, these animals evolved a suite of anatomical characteristics which gave them more support for their flight muscles. This includes the extra large sternal keel. Some ancient seabirds would have had some unique anatomical features not seen in today's birds. For instance, many Cretaceous seabirds would have had teeth lining their bills, similar to the serrations seen on the beaks of living mergansers, likely an adaptation for catching slippery prey. (BELOW) A series of diagrams with labels showing the skeletal anatomy of the pterosaur Pteranodon sternbergi . Note the fusion of the thoracic vertebrae into a notarium and the fused sacral vertebrae which have formed a synsacrum. (BELOW) The bones of the wings of Pteranodon and their corresponding equivalents in the bones of a human arm. The second half of a pterosaur's wing is built from the bones of the 4th finger. The wing membranes of these animals were held in place by a series of strong soft tissue structures called actinofibrils which became more densely packed towards the wingtip Aquatic Adaptations Ancient archosaurs didn't just take over the land and manage to evolve powered flight, some groups also became partially or fully aquatic. Many crocodylomorph groups evolved streamlined body shapes that reduced water resistance and enhanced swimming ability. Long, narrow jaws lined with sharp teeth were particularly effective for capturing fish and other aquatic prey. The placement of the eyes and nostrils high on the skull allowed these animals to remain largely submerged while still being able to see and breathe at the water’s surface. Adaptations of the limbs also played an important role in the transition to the water, and some forms developed paddle-like appendages that gave them extra propulsion while swimming, although most of these animals depended primarily on their tails to push themselves forward. Among the most specialized marine crocodylomorphs, such as metriorhynchids, further modifications included flipper-like limbs, reduced osteoderms, and powerful tail fins adapted for sustained swimming in open seas. Some groups even developed specialized salt glands which allowed these animals to process saltwater, a trait which is also found in many of today’s living crocodiles. (ABOVE) The crocodylomorph Terminonaris is an example of a type of archosaur which became adapted to spending life at sea. Many anatomical features associated with today's crocodilians appeared independently at many points during the evolutionary history of crocodylomorphs as different lineages of these animals repeatedly moved into aquatic niches Archosaurs Non-avian dinosaurs Claosaurus Niobrarasaurus Birds (Class Aves) Apatornis Baptornis Fumicollis Guildavis Hesperornis Iaceornis Ichthyornis Parahesperornis Pasquiaornis Pterosaurs (Order Pterosauria) Aetodactylus Alamodactylus Cimoliopterus Nyctosaurus Pteranodon Clade Crocodylomorpha Deinosuchus Terminonaris Non-Avian Dinosaurs (Dinosauria) Dinosaurs Preserved at Sea The term “non-avian dinosaurs” is used to refer to all dinosaurs except for the group which includes today’s birds and their closest extinct bird relatives. Most non-avian dinosaur fossils found in rocks left behind by the Western Interior Sea are the remains of animals that were washed out to sea. Two of the most notable cases of this type of fossilization are the fossils of Niobrarasaurus and Claosaurus . Niobrarasaurus was a nodosaurid ankylosaur, a heavily built, four-legged herbivore protected by rows of bony armor plates called osteoderms. Unlike some other ankylosaurs, it lacked a tail club and likely relied on its thick armor and defensive shoulder spines for protection. Claosaurus , in contrast, was a slender early hadrosauromorph closely related to the duck-billed dinosaurs. It had small forelimbs, an elongated tail, long hind limbs, and a lightweight body adapted for efficient movement. Claosaurus did not have any dermal armor covering its skin and would have had simpler teeth than more advanced hadrosaurs. Claosaurus Temporal Range: 87 million years ago - 82 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: C. agilis Diet: Herbivorous browser, ferns, leaves, leaf buds Claosaurus was among the first dinosaur genera to be discovered in the Niobrara Formation of western Kansas. The fossil remains were collected by Othniel Charles Marsh in 1871 near the Smoky Hill River and were originally described in 1872 as Hadrosaurus agilis . As additional material became available and the specimen was studied more closely, Marsh determined that it differed significantly from Hadrosaurus and established the new genus Claosaurus in 1890. Fossils attributed to Claosaurus include portions of the skull, vertebral column, ribs, limb bones, and pelvic elements. These remains have made the genus an important subject in studies of hadrosauromorph evolution because it represents an early relative of the more specialized duck-billed dinosaurs that also lived during the Cretaceous. The occurrence of Claosaurus fossils in marine chalk deposits is particularly noteworthy because the animal lived on land. During the Late Cretaceous, much of present-day Kansas was submerged beneath the Western Interior Seaway. After this particular Claosaurus died its remains were likely transported from a nearby coastal region into the seaway, where they settled on the sea floor and became buried in fine carbonate sediments. Over millions of years, these sediments lithified into the chalk deposits of the Smoky Hill Member, preserving the remains of this terrestrial dinosaur in an otherwise marine environment. (BELOW) A photo of the mounted remains of Claosaurus agilis at the Yale Peabody Museum. Photo credit: user Greygirlbeast, accessed via Wikimedia Commons, distributed under a CC BY-SA 3.0 license (BELOW) Most of the skull is missing from the holotype specimen of Claosaurus . It is usually restored with a skull shape similar to that of animals like Eotrachodon , with a wide beak at the front of the mouth and large chewing tooth batteries Niobrarasaurus Temporal Range: 87 million years ago - 82 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: N. coleii Diet: Herbivorous browser, ferns, leaves, leaf buds Niobrarasaurus was an armored herbivorous dinosaur belonging to the nodosaurid branch of the ankylosaurs. Its body was covered with osteoderms, or bony plates, embedded within the skin, which formed a protective shield against predators. Unlike ankylosaurids such as Ankylosaurus , Niobrarasaurus did not have a tail club. Instead, it likely depended on its heavy body armor and on the enlarged defensive spines along its shoulders and the sides of the body for protection. The dinosaur walked on four sturdy legs and was adapted for a life spent browsing on low-growing vegetation. Scientific study of Niobrarasaurus began in 1930 when geologist Virgil Cole discovered a collection of fossil remains in western Kansas. The specimen was formally described in 1936, and was named Hierosaurus coleii. Decades later, paleontologists reexamined the fossils and concluded that they represented a distinct genus, later named Niobrarasaurus in 1995. (BELOW) The skeleton of Niobrarasaurus, MU 650 VP, on display at the Sternberg Museum of Natural History in Hays, Kansas. These fossils were found in Gove County, Kansas and are one of only a few non-avian dinosaur remains to have been found in the state. This image shows the reconstructed skull, forelimb bones and the osteoderms of the front of the body, (BELOW) The skeleton of Niobrarasaurus, MU 650 VP, middle section showing the ribs, osteoderms of the middle of the trunk (BELOW) The skeleton of Niobrarasaurus, MU 650 VP, this photo is of the rear section of the skeleton and shows the pelvis, hind limbs, rear osteoderms and caudal vertebrae of the animal Birds (Aves) Cretaceous Toothed Seabirds The Western Interior Sea was home to many types of marine birds. Unlike many of today’s birds, most birds from the Western Interior Sea still had small teeth lining their bills. These teeth would have been useful as tools for holding on to slippery fish, which are thought to have been the main source of food for many of these prehistoric animals. These Cretaceous birds were part of groups which were not directly ancestral to today’s birds and many of these ancient lineages would go extinct, along with the non-avian dinosaurs, at the end of the Cretaceous period. Apatornis Temporal Range: 83 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: A. celer Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Apatornis was a small ornithuran bird that lived during the Late Cretaceous and is known from fossils recovered in the Smoky Hill Chalk of Kansas. Although only limited skeletal material has been discovered, the preserved remains reveal several features that distinguish it from other contemporary birds. The most important fossil consists of a synsacrum, the fused vertebrae associated with the pelvic region. Comparisons with related birds indicate that Apatorni s had at least one more sacral rib than Ichthyornis and lacked the bony tendons that reinforced the sacral region in other genera. A study of some of the material known from Apatornis published in 2004 showed that the specimen could not be confidently linked to the original material and it was reassigned to the separate genus Iaceornis. As a result our current understanding of Apatornis is based largely on a single very incomplete original fossil, and many aspects of its biology and evolutionary relationships remain uncertain. Baptornis Temporal Range: 83 million years ago - 80 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Sweden Species: B. advenus Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Baptornis was possibly the most specialized marine diver of all the hesperornitheans. It had a long, slender neck, heavy bones that reduced buoyancy, and extremely large and strong hind limbs that it used as its main propulsion tool while swimming underwater. Although it wasn't able to fly, its skeletal remains still preserved small, reduced wing bones. Its elongated toes and powerful legs suggest that it was an efficient swimmer that relied on underwater pursuit rather than aerial hunting. Fossils of Baptornis were found fairly early on in the history of Kansas paleontology. Their remains were described In 1877. Because it was among the earliest fossil birds discovered from the Mesozoic Era, Baptornis became an important animal in studies of avian evolution. Additional specimens collected throughout the twentieth century revealed much more of its skeleton and allowed researchers to reconstruct its aquatic lifestyle, anatomy, and evolutionary relationships. Fumicollis Temporal Range: 85 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: F. hoffmani Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Fumicollis belonged to the group of flightless diving birds known as hesperornitheans. Its fossil remains were first collected in 1937 from the Smoky Hill Member of the Niobrara Chalk in Kansas by Harold Shepherd and George Sternberg. For many years, the specimen was classified as belonging to the diving bird genus Baptornis. Subsequent research determined that these fossils displayed some unique features, including enlarged processes on the vertebrae and unusually elongated pelvis, which suggested that the animal was distinct from Baptornis and other known hesperornitheans. Following a detailed reexamination of the material, paleontologists Alyssa Bell and Luis Chiappe named the new genus and species Fumicollis hoffmani in 2015. Guildavis Temporal Range: 83 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: G. tener Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Guildavis was a small bird that lived during the Late Cretaceous and is known from fossils recovered from the Niobrara Chalk Formation of Kansas. Although the available fossil material is limited, the genus appears to represent a distinct lineage of early ornithuran birds, the group that includes modern birds and their close relatives. The most important fossils consist of portions of the synsacrum, the fused vertebrae that support the pelvic region. It has at various times been considered to be a synonym of Ichthyornis. Hesperornis Temporal Range: 83 million years ago - 72 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, South Dakota, Alberta, parts of Russia Species: H. regalis, H. crassipes, H. gracilis, H. altus, H. rossicus, H. montana, H. bairdi, H. macdonaldi, H. mengeli Diet: Carnivorous, small prey, fish Hesperornis was a highly specialized marine bird which had completely lost its ability to fly. Its wings were greatly reduced, while its powerful paddle-like hind limbs were adapted for efficient swimming and underwater pursuit of prey. Unlike modern birds Hesperornis also had sharp teeth set within grooves in its jaws. Its streamlined body and strong legs made it an effective diver, and its lifestyle has often been compared to those of modern loons and grebes. Research on Hesperornis began in the late nineteenth century when Othniel Charles Marsh described fossils from the marine deposits of Kansas in 1872. The discovery was especially important because it revealed a bird with both avian characteristics and teeth, which in turn provided key evidence for the evolutionary connection between birds and their reptilian ancestors. Iaceornis Temporal Range: 83 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: I. marshi Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Iaceornis was a small bird once considered part of the genus Apatornis . The shape of its skeleton has resulted in this genus being placed in a position in between earlier birds such as Ichthyornis and the ancestors of modern birds. Its wing bones have more in common with wings of living birds than the wing anatomies seen in many of its contemporary Late Cretaceous species. For many decades the specimen now considered the holotype of Iaceronis was assigned to the species Apatornis celer and was widely used in descriptions of that genus. A revision of many types of Cretaceous seabirds published in 2004 determined that the wing bones of this particular specimen differed significantly from those seen in the Apatornis holotype which established Iaceornis as a new genus. Ichthyornis Temporal Range: 83 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Texas, Alabama, Alberta, Saskatchewan Species: I. dispar Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Ichthyornis was a seabird from the Cretaceous period that was superficially similar to a small seagull. It had sharp teeth embedded within its jaws, while the front portions of the jaws were covered by a beak. This unusual combination makes Ichthyornis one of the most important transitional birds known from the fossil record. It had a lightweight skeleton, powerful wings, and was well adapted for sustained flight over the waters of the Western Interior Sea. Othniel Charles Marsh formally described this genus in the early 1870s based on fossils found in Kansas, and the fossils quickly attracted scientific attention because they combined avian features with toothed jaws. Parahesperornis Temporal Range: 85 million years ago - 82 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: P. alexi Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Parahesperornis was a flightless, toothed seabird that used its powerful hind limbs to propel itself through the water while hunting for fish. It is named for its similarities with Hesperornis and other hesperornithean birds. Fossils of the bird were first collected from the Smoky Hill Chalk of Kansas in 1894, but their significance was not immediately recognized. For many years, these remains were grouped with other hesperornithean specimens, leading to confusion about their classification. It was classified as its own genus and species in 1984. Pasquiaornis Temporal Range: 94 million years ago Geographic Range: Saskatchewan Species: P. hardiei, P. tankei Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Pasquiaornis was an early member of the Hesperornithes whose remains show a combination of features that link it to both more advanced diving birds and their less specialized flying ancestors. Its limb bones and foot anatomy were adapted for swimming, but many skeletal characteristics retained a more ancestral condition than those seen in later hesperornitheans. It was originally thought to be a close relative of Baptornis but it has since been moved closer to the base of the hesperornithean family tree. There is some evidence that they might have spent time in groups since some of the original fossils found from this animal were found with many individuals located in a small area where they seem to have been deposited at around the same time. Pterosaurs (Pterosauria) Pterosaurs of the Western Interior Sea Pterosaurs were a group of Mesozoic flying reptiles and the first vertebrates to master true powered flight. They were characterized by lightweight, hollow bones, large wings made of skin membranes, and an elongated fourth finger that supported a large part of the membrane on each wing. Unlike birds, pterosaurs had wings composed of flaps of skin called patagia, superficially similar to the wing membranes of bats. Many species also displayed prominent head crests. By the end of the Cretaceous, the only remaining pterosaurs were animals with long hind legs and short tails. Many of these animals had large display crests or elaborate bill shapes. Some of the earlier Cretaceous pterosaurs of the Western Interior Sea still had teeth in their bills. Aetodactylus Temporal Range: 95 million years ago Geographic Range: Texas Species: A. halli Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Aetodactylu s is a small toothy pterosaur known from sites in Texas. It was discovered when a fossil lower jaw was found in 2006 near Mansfield, Texas in rocks belonging to the Tarrant Formation. In 2010, paleontologist Timothy Myers described the fossil and named the species Aetodactylus halli in recognition of its discoverer, Lance Hall. The discovery showed that certain types of toothed pterosaurs remained part of North American ecosystems even during parts of the Late Cretaceous when they had previously been considered largely extinct.The teeth of Aetodactylus seen in these snout fossils were organized with the teeth at the front of the mouth projecting forward, while the largest teeth were concentrated near the tip of the jaw and decreased in size toward the back. Unlike some ornithocheirid pterosaurs, Aetodactylus lacked a crest on its lower jaw. Alamodactylus Temporal Range: 88 million years ago Geographic Range: Texas Species: A. byrdi Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Alamodactylus was a medium-sized pterosaur that lived above the Western Interior Sea during the Late Cretaceous. It is currently considered to be a close relative of animals like Nyctosaurus , another Interior Sea pterosaur whose fossils are found in Kansas. Scientists first studied Alamodactylus from a partial wing skeleton discovered in the Atco Formation of Texas. It was initially thought to be related to Pteranodon but in 2013 it was determined to be a distinct genus was named Alamodactylus byrdi after fossil collector Gary Byrd. Cimoliopterus Temporal Range: 95 million years ago Geographic Range: Texas, the UK Species: C. dunni, C. cuvieri, C. colorhinus Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Cimoliopterus was a genus of pterosaur that lived in parts of what are now England and North America during the Cretaceous Period. Its snout was tall and narrow, with only a slight widening at the tip, unlike the broader jaw expansions seen in some related fish-eating pterosaurs. Its crest began farther back on the upper jaw and differed in shape and position from those of closely related genera. Its teeth were also organized in a distinctive way with larger teeth near the front of the jaws and smaller, more widely spaced teeth farther back, most likely an adaptation for snagging fish from the surface of the water. Its fossils were first found in the 19th century but it wasn't formally given its own name until a review published in 2013 concluded that the material represented a distinct genus, leading to the establishment of Cimoliopterus . A specimen described in 2015 widened its range to include parts of Texas in what was at that time the southern part of the Western Interior Sea Nyctosaurus Temporal Range: 85 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas Species: N. gracilis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Nyctosaurus was a pterosaur whose most famous characteristic was an enormous forked crest that projected upward and backward from the skull. In some individuals, this crest was disproportionately large compared to the rest of the body. Nyctosauru s was also one of only a few pterosaurs to lose all of its smaller clawed fingers except the elongated fourth finger that supported the wing membrane. Because of this reduced hand structure, scientists think that Nyctosaurus was highly specialized for flight and may have spent very little time moving on the ground. Its fossils were found in the 19th century in Kansas. Pteranodon Temporal Range: 86 million years ago - 78 million years ago Geographic Range: Central US, Alabama Species: P. longiceps, P. sternbergi Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Pteranodon is by far the best known type of pterosaur, essentially synonymous with the use of the outdated term “pterodactyl”. It had a long pointed toothless beak, and a large bony crest extending from the back of its skull. Its name, which means “toothless wing,” reflects this lack of teeth. With wingspans that could exceed 6 meters (20 feet), Pteranodon ranked among the largest flying animals of its time and was considered the largest pterosaur genus up until the discovery of larger Azdarchid pterosaurs like Quetzalcoatlus . Its lightweight skeleton, elongated wings, and aerodynamic body made it especially well suited for sustained flight above the waters of the Western Interior Sea. Paleontologists believe it fed mainly on fish, which it likely captured from the ocean surface using its long beak. Currently there are two widely accepted species of Pteranodon ; Pteranodon longiceps, which had a long thin crest, and Pteranodon sternberg i which had a wider roughly diamond-shaped crest. Some workers consider Pteranodon sternberg i to be its own genus, Geosternbergia . When fossils of Pteranodon were found in chalk deposits from Kansas in the 19th century, the paleontologist Othniel Charles Marsh initially placed the remains in another group close to the smaller European genus Pterodactylus , but in 1876 he recognized their unusual toothless jaws and established the genus Pteranodon . Over the following decades many more of their fossils were found. In some parts of Kansas, their fossils are extremely abundant and comparatively easy for fossil hunters to find. (BELOW) A model of a Pteranodon longiceps skull on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Most fossils of these animals found in rocks from western Kansas have been compressed or flattened within the rock surrounding the fossils. (BELOW) The middle bones of the wings of a Pteranodon at the KU Natural History Museum. This is part of a composite skeleton. The three fingers on the left side of the image are a feature seen in most pterosaurs with the exception of Nyctosaurus and its closest relatives. The spur of bone between the radius and the 4th metacarpal is called the pteroid bone. This structure anchors the front-most wing membrane, a feature known as the brachiopatagium. Crocodylomorphs (Crocodylomorpha) Giant Crocs of the Western Interior Sea Crocodylomorphs are a group of archosaurian reptiles which includes modern crocodilians and many of their extinct relatives. Today’s crocodylomorphs are generally recognized by their elongated snouts, powerful jaws equipped with conical teeth, protective bony armor embedded in the skin, and muscular tails that they use when swimming. Although many types of extinct crocodylomorphs lived in rivers, lakes, and coastal environments, others became highly adapted to different habitats and niches, including borrowing, terrestrial locomotion, herbivory and life in marine settings. Fossils found in the layers of rock left behind by the Western Interior Sea preserve the remains of both open ocean specialist crocodylomorphs and animals that preferred to live in near-shore and estuarine habitats. Deinosuchus Temporal Range: 82 million years ago - 73 million years ago Geographic Range: North Carolina, Texas, Montana Species: D. hatcheri, D. rugosus, D. riograndensis, D. schwimmeri Diet: Carnivorous, large prey, dinosaurs, fish, turtles Deinosuchus was one of the largest crocodylomorphs known from the fossil record. Its broad skull, heavily constructed jaws, and thick, crushing teeth were adapted for tackling large prey, possibly even hunting large dinosaurs. Its body was protected by robust bony armor plates known as osteoderms. Deinosuchus had a diet composed of a variety of prey, including fish, turtles, and large terrestrial animals that approached waterways. Its range extended over both sides of the Interior Sea with fossils found in North Carolina, Texas and Wyoming in areas which were once swamplands, river basins and coastal estuaries. These animals seem to have been fairly closely related to today’s crocodilians. It would have looked very similar to today’s alligators but with a large bulb-shaped extension on the tip of its snout which is a feature absent in today’s broad-snouted crocodilians. Terminonaris Temporal Range: 96 million years ago - 91 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Alberta Species: T. browni, T. robusta Diet: Carnivorous, fish, marine reptiles, large prey Terminonaris was a marine crocodylomorph that lived in coastal regions of the Western Interior Seaway during the Late Cretaceous. It had a long, slender snout and narrow jaws which were equipped with thin, interlocking teeth well suited for capturing fish and other small aquatic animals. Terminonaris was a large predator, but its skull shape suggests a feeding strategy different from that of today’s broad-snouted crocodilians that are adapted for crushing larger prey and could have possibly been more similar to the fish-hunting strategies seen in today’s gharials. The first fossils from this animal were described in 1904 and given the name “Teleorhinus ”. Because that name had already been used for another organism, the genus was subsequently renamed Terminonaris. Its fossils have since been found in parts of Alberta and Kansas. Media Gallery Suggested References: Archosauria Adams, Thomas L.; Polcyn, Michael J.; Mateus, Octávio; Winkler, Dale A.; Jacobs, Louis L. (2011). "First occurrence of the long-snouted crocodyliform Terminonaris (Pholidosauridae) from the Woodbine Formation (Cenomanian) of Texas". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 31 (3): 712–716. Bell, A. and Everhart, M.J. (2009). “A new specimen of Parahesperornis(Aves: Hesperornithiformes) from the Smoky Hill Chalk (Early Campanian) of western Kansas”. Kansas Academy of Science, Transactions 112(1/2):7-14. Bennett, S.C. (1992). “Sexual dimorphism of Pteranodon and other pterosaurs, with comments on cranial crests”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 12 p. 422-434.\ Bennett, S.C. (2001). “The osteology and functional morphology of the Late Cretaceous pterosaur Pteranodon. Part I. General description of osteology”. Palaeontographica, Abteilung A, 260:1-112. Carpenter, K (2003). "Vertebrate Biostratigraphy of the Smoky Hill Chalk (Niobrara Formation) and the Sharon Springs Member (Pierre Shale)". High-Resolution Approaches in Stratigraphic Paleontology. Topics in Geobiology. 21: 421–437. Carpenter, K., Dilkes, D., & Weishampel, D. B. (1995). “The Dinosaurs of the Niobrara Chalk Formation (Upper Cretaceous, Kansas)”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 15(2), 275–297. Carpenter, K. and Everhart, M. J. (2007). “Skull of the ankylosaur Niobrarasaurus coleii (Ankylosauria: Nodosauridae) from the Smoky Hill Chalk (Coniacian) of western Kansas”. Kansas Academy of Science, Transactions, 110(1/2): 1-9. Chinsamy, A., L. D. Martin and P. Dodson. (1998). “Bone microstructure of the diving Hesperornis and the volant Ichthyornis from the Niobrara Chalk of western Kansas”. Cretaceous Research 19:225-235. Cole, V. B. (2007). “Field notes regarding the 1930 discovery of the type specimen of Niobrarasaurus coleii, Gove County, Kansas”. Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science 110(1/2): 132–134. Cossette, Adam P.; Brochu, Christopher A. (2020). "A systematic review of the giant alligatoroid Deinosuchus from the Campanian of North America and its implications for the relationships at the root of Crocodylia". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 40 Cumbaa, S.L. and Tokaryk, T.S. (1999). “Recent discoveries of Cretaceous marine vertebrates on the eastern margins of the Western Interior Seaway”. In: Summary of Investigations 1999, Vol. 1, Saskatchewan Geological Survey, Sask. Energy Mines, Miscellaneous Report 99-4.1, p. 57-63. Everhart, M. J. and K. Ewell. (2006). “Shark-bitten dinosaur (Hadrosauridae) vertebrae from the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Coniacian) of western Kansas”. Kansas Academy of Science, Transactions, 109 (1-2):27-35. Hamm, S. A. and M. J. Everhart. (2001). “Notes on the occurrence of nodosaurs (Ankylosauridae) in the Smoky Hill Chalk (Upper Cretaceous) of western Kansas”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 21(suppl. to 3): 58A. Hone, David W.E.; Witton, Mark P.; Habib, Michael B. (2018). "Evidence for the Cretaceous shark Cretoxyrhina mantelli feeding on the pterosaur Pteranodon from the Niobrara Formation". PeerJ. 6 e6031. Liggett, G. A. 2005. A review of the dinosaurs from Kansas. Kansas Academy of Science. Transactions 108(1/2): 1-14. Lucas, Spencer G.; Sullivan, Robert M. (2006-01-01). Late Cretaceous Vertebrates from the Western Interior: Bulletin 35. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. Witton, Mark P. (2013). “Pterosaurs: Natural History, Evolution, Anatomy”. Princeton University Press. ISBN 0691150613. McIntosh, A. P.; Shimada, K.; Everhart, M. J. (2016). "Late Cretaceous marine vertebrate fauna from the Fairport Chalk Member of the Carlile Shale in southern Ellis County, Kansas, U.S.A." Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science. Myers, T.S. (2010). “Earliest occurrence of the Pteranodontidae (Archosauria: Pterosauria) in North America: New material from the Austin Group of Texas”. Journal of Paleontology 84(6):1071-1081. Myers, T. S. (2015). "First North American occurrence of the toothed pteranodontoid pterosaur Cimoliopterus". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 35 (6): 1–9 Pêgas, R. V.; Holgado, B.; Leal, M.E.C. (2019). "On Targaryendraco wiedenrothi gen. nov. (Pterodactyloidea, Pteranodontoidea, Lanceodontia) and recognition of a new cosmopolitan lineage of Cretaceous toothed pterodactyloids". Historical Biology. 33 (8): 1–15. Prieto-Márquez, A. (2011). "Revised diagnoses of Hadrosaurus foulkii Leidy, 1858 (the type genus and species of Hadrosauridae Cope, 1869) and Claosaurus agilis Marsh, 1872 (Dinosauria: Ornithopoda) from the Late Cretaceous of North America". Zootaxa. 2765: 61–68. Reynaud, F. (2006). “Hind limb and pelvis proportions of Hesperornis regalis: A comparison with extant diving birds”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 26(3):115A. Shimada, K., and Parris, D.C., (2007). “A long-snouted Late Cretaceous crocodyliform, Terminonaris cf. T. browni, from the Carlile Shale (Turonian) of Kansas”. Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science 110(1):107-115. Witton, Mark (2010). "Pteranodon and beyond: The history of giant pterosaurs from 1870 onwards". Geological Society, London, Special Publications. 343 (1): 313–323
- Gallery of recent extinctions | Prehistoric Midwest
Over a dozen species of Midwestern animals have become extinct over the last 250 years, including several bird, fish and insect species. Visit our virtual gallery to see illustrations of these lost animals Gallery Of Recent Extinctions Midwestern animals who have disappeared in the last 250 years Over the last two and a half centuries, over a dozen species once found in the Midwestern United States have become extinct. Some of these animals, such as the passenger pigeon, were once so common that they would have been a common fixture on the landscape for generations of people living in this area. Other species were confined to very small ranges and occupied ecological niches which became impossible to hold once humans began to impact the land or water around them. Although ecological factors such as droughts undoubtedly had an impact on the populations of some of these animals, the primary causes of all these extinctions were generated by human activity, including overhunting or overfishing, logging, intentional culls of pests, introduction of non-native competitor species or pollution. Click on the animals to learn more
- Miocene artiodactyls part 2 | Prehistoric Midwest
Artiodactyla (continued) Protoceratids (Protoceratidae) Synthetoceratines of the Ogallala Formation Protoceratids are a now-extinct group of even-toed ungulates. These animals had long skulls and a set of horns at the back of their heads. In some earlier genera the front of the mouth would have held a set of enlarged upper teeth similar to the fangs seen in musk deer. In the later forms known from the Ogallala Formation however, the front of the snout often supported a tall fused ossicone. These structures were not composed of the same materials as the rear horns of these animals. Instead of being covered in a keratinous outer sheath, these bony ornaments which sat over the noses of these animals may have been covered in hair. In some later groups of protoceratids in the subfamily Synthetoceratinae, the bony structure over the nose took on a Y-shape or a slingshot-shaped form. Artiodactyls Not all artiodactyls are listed on this page. See the list below for the order in which entries are listed This page Previous Page Family Dromomerycidae Bouromeryx Cranioceras Dromomeryx Procranioceras Yumaceras Pediomeryx Family Camelidae Aepycamelus Vampyrocamelus Alforjas Floridatragulus Megatylopus Oxydactylus Pleiolama Procamelus Protolabis Gigantocamelus Homocamelus Megacamelus Titanotylopus Family Tayassuidae Mckennahyus Mylohyus Platygonus Prosthennops Protherohyus Skinnerhyus Stirtonhyus Family Moschidae Blastomeryx Longirostromeryx Superfamily Merycoidodontoidea Merychyus Ticholeptus Ustatochoerus Family Protoceratidae Lambdoceras Prosynthetoceras Synthetoceras Family Antilocapridae Capromeryx Cosoryx Merycodus Proantilocapra Ramoceros Texoceros Sphenophalos Paracosoryx Previous Page Lambdoceras Temporal Range: 20.6 - 13.6 million years ago Geographic Range: Great Plains from South Dakota to Texas Species: L. hessei, L. siouxensis, L. siouxensis Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Lambdoceras was a Miocene protoceratid from North America and a member of the subfamily Synthetoceratinae. Although its body shape was superficially similar to that of a deer it was unrelated to true deer and would have had permanent skull ornaments rather than antlers shed each year. Lambdoceras had widely curving horns behind its eyes and a large rostral ossicone at the tip of its snout. Lambdoceras was quite different from earlier protoceratids whose skulls lacked these complex cranial appendages. Later Middle Miocene protoceratids also seem to have undergone a trend towards larger body sizes and developed taller molar crowns in order to move from a browsing diet of a mixed diet of grasses and woody plants. Along with these specializations shared among many protoceratids known from the Ogallala Formation, Lambdoceras also had unfused metatarsals and side toes that were larger than those of many modern hoofed mammals. Prosynthetoceras Temporal Range: 20.6 - 13.6 million years ago Geographic Range: Southern Great Plains and southeastern North America Species: P. francisi, P. orthrionanus, P. texanus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Prosynthetocera s was a North American protoceratid which was a close relative of the genus Sythetoceras and was part of the subfamily Synthetoceratinae, an advanced protoceratid subfamily known for elaborate cranial ornamentation. In Prosynthetoceras , a seires of bony plates on the maxillary bones were fused together into a single structure which created the shared base of the nasal ornament which is seen in all synthetoceratines. However, this structure had a tip which was less deeply forked than the rostral horn of animals like Synthetoceras, which divided near its tip into a prominent slingshot-shaped bony projection. Sythetoceras Temporal Range: 12.5 - 4.7 million years ago Geographic Range: Nebraska, Texas, Florida, Species: S. tricornatus, S. davisorum Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Synthetoceras was a North American protoceratid from the late Miocene and the namesake of the subfamily Synthetoceratinae. In fossil skeletons which seem to belong to males of this genus, the skull is heavily ornamented. They would have had a pair of elongated postorbital horns which curved outwards and upward above the eyes, as well as a larger rostral horn projecting from the tip of the snout. This nasal appendage was formed from a fused base which then separated near its end into a slingshot-like Y-shaped fork. Very few types of non-synthetocerine protoceratids had this same set of horns and large forked ossicones. More basal forms such as the genus Leptotragulus lacked horns entirely, whereas the Early Miocene genus Syndyoceras retained two separate rostral horns. Synthetoceras appears to represent the peak of complex cranial ornamentation within the family Protoceratidae. Females of this genus seem to have been hornless or had much smaller appendages. The horns likely functioned as display structures used to signal maturity and fitness, although their precise function remains uncertain Pronghorns (Antilocapridae) Ancient Pronghorns of the Ogallala Formation Antilocaprids are an endemic North American family of hoofed ruminants whose closest living relatives are giraffes and okapis, despite often being described colloquially as “antelopes.” Fossils from the Miocene and Pliocene deposits of the Ogallala Formation show us that this family was once considerably more diverse than it is today. The Great Plains were once home to several early smaller forms of antilocaprids, including animals similar to the genus Merycodus, as well as later antilocaprids such as Texoceros , which more closely resembled modern pronghorns and may in fact be the closest extinct relative of all of today’s antilocaprids. These animals are often distinguished by the shapes of their horn cores, which can be long and sharp, palmate, or form 3 pairs of rounded horn apexes. Although their horns are similar in appearance to those of cows, goats and other bovids, the outer coverings of these horns are shed periodically, similar to the antlers of deer. Some ancient antilocaprids were grassland specialists and fed on a diet primarily composed of grass, although some ancient antilocaprid varieties from the Miocene epoch seem to have had a greater preference for browsing on leaves. Capromeryx Temporal Range: 5 million years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North and South America Species: C. arizonensis, C. furcifer, C. gidleyi, C. mexicanus, C. minor Diet: Herbivorous, grasses, twigs, leaves Capromeryx , also known as the dwarf pronghorn, was the smallest known antilocaprid genus. It lived in North America from the start of the Pliocene to the late Pleistocene epoch, with its fossils having been found from Nebraska to as far south as central Mexico. The smallest species of Capromeryx had estimated adult body weights in the area of around 25 pounds, making them much smaller that today’s pronghorns. The horns of Capromeryx were arranged into four points. Unlike in Stockoceros or Tetrameryx where their horns point in opposite directions, forwards and backwards, in Capromeryx the horn cores seem to be positioned parallel to one another on each side of the skull. In the remains of some individuals the front and rear horns are of roughly equal length while in others the front horns are considerably shorter than the rear horns. In general it seems as though later species of Capromeryx had smaller horns than their relatives in the Pliocene. Cosoryx Temporal Range: Middle Miocene Geographic Range: Western parts of North America Species: C. furcatus, C. cerroensis, C. ilfonensis Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Cosoryx was an extinct genus of antilocaprids which had relatively simple, branching horn cores which seem to have supported a pair of slingshot-shaped horns. Each horn core separates into two similarly sized tines. The teeth of these animals are also fairly useful for identifying this genus; its premolars were reduced, and the cheek teeth lacked an ectostylid, a type of enamel projection present in some other types of ruminants. Based on known skeletal material, it seems as though Cosory x was a relatively small animal, similar in size of many early antilocaprids traditionally classified as merycodontines. The genus lived during the Miocene, with fossils attributed to it discovered in Nevada and the Santa Fe Group of New Mexico. Its taxonomic position remains uncertain because some paleontologists consider Cosoryx to be synonymous with a similar genus, Merycodus. Merycodus Temporal Range: 17 - 10 million years ago Geographic Range: Western North America from Saskatchewan to central Mexico Species: M. crusensis, M. hookwayi, M. joraki, M. major, M. minimus, M. minor, M. necatus, M. nenzelensis, M. prodromus, M. sabulonis, M. warreni, M. osborni Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Merycodus was a genus of pronghorns whose horn cores had relatively short forked shafts that were usually divided into two tines of approximately equal size. This makes the, quite distinct from the strongly asymmetrical horns found in fossils of the related genus Ramoceros. Their horns are somewhat similar to those of animals in the genus Cosoryx and the two genera have occasionally been considered synonymous. Specimens of Merycodus once assigned to another genus, “Meryceros ”, were identified as a separate group of animals since they had larger, more laterally flattened horns, although “Meryceros " is now frequently considered synonymous with Merycodus . Like other grazing antilocaprids, Merycodus also would have had high-crowned cheek teeth suited to resisting wear from coarse grasses. Its range extended across much of western North America, particularly in areas which would have been dominated by open habitats and grasslands. Proantilocapra Temporal Range: Middle Miocene Geographic Range: Western North America, Nebraska Species: P. platycornea Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Proantilocapra was an extinct genus of antilocaprids known from fossils discovered in deposits from the Ash Hollow Formation in parts of Nebraska. The genus can be separated from other contemporary antilocaprids by the unique shape of its horn cores. Rather than having the strongly forked horns seen in modern pronghorns, Proantilocapra had shorter horn cores which were somewhat flattened from side to side. This flattened appearance is the namesake of the species “platycornea”, which means “flat-horned.” The horn cores of these animals extended upward and outward above the eyes and ended in rounded apexes. Proantilocapra also had high-crowned cheek teeth that would have helped it process coarse, abrasive vegetation such as tough grasses. Much like living pronghorns, the long, thin limbs of Proantilocapra suggest that it was an active and agile animal which would have been able to outrun many of the large carnivores found in the ancient Miocene savannahs Ramoceros Temporal Range: 13.6 - 10.3 million years ago Geographic Range: Great Plains, western North America Species: R. brevicornis, R. marthae, R. merriami, R. osborni, R. palmatus, R. ramosus Diet: Herbivorous mixed feeder, grass, leaves Ramoceros was a bizarre genus of antilocaprids best known for their asymmetrical horns. Most antilocaprids, including the living pronghorn, had/have paired horns of approximately equal size. Ramoceros would not have followed this pattern and instead developed one horn that was considerably larger than the other. In some individuals, the larger horn reached three or four times the size of its smaller counterpart. Its horns were antler-like and formed a series of deep forks. They are very different from the more regularly arranged multiple horns of other extinct genera such as Stockoceros and Hexameryx (See our entries about these animals in our Pleistocene guide). Ramoceros was a comparatively small antilocaprid with an estimated body mass of approximately 10 to 20 kilograms. It lived in North America during the Clarendonian interval of the Miocene and belonged to the group of ancient antilocaprids traditionally classified as part of the now extinct merycodontines. Most merycodontines were also fairly small animals, usually around 2/3 the size of extant pronghorns in the genus Antilocapra. Rare and Polyphyletic Antilocaprids Some antilocaprid genera from the Ogallala Formation are known from very fragmentary or poorly documented fossils while others are composed of fossil material which may belong to many other types of antilocaprids who are likely to be distantly related to one another. Information about these other genera is listed below. Other Antilocaprid Genera Sphenophalos : An antilocaprid which would have had short, slightly twisted horns which ended in two short tines, one of which faced forward, the other facing towards the rear. These animals had fairly short and compact snouts when compared with other contemporary antilocaprids. They seem to have been close relatives of the genus Ilingocera s, an antilocaprid with corkscrew-shaped horns which is known from fossils found in deposits further to the west in parts of Nevada. Texoceros : A mid-sized genus of antilocaprids. It seem to have been a larger animal than early members of the antilocaprid family such as the genus Merycodus but it seems to have been smaller than the living pronghorn genus Antilocapra. Its teeth were distinctive enough that the type species, Texoceros altidens, was originally named primarily from relatively incomplete dental and jaw material. Dental wear from fossils of these animals which were found in central Mexico most closely resembles the types of wear found on the teeth of browsing and mixed-feeding ruminants. This most likely means that these animals were feeding on a mixture of different plant sources, instead of specializing solely on grass. Paracosoryx : Likely a wastebasket taxon composed of several species who aren't particularly closely related to one another, forming a polyphyletic group See our other entries about Ogallala artiodactyls by returning to the previous page Previous Page Suggested References: Artiodactyls Chen, Katheryn. (2015). Ecology and Morphology of the Late Miocene Musk Deer, Longirostromeryx wellsi (Artiodactyla: Moschidae: Blastomerycinae). Frick, C. (1937). "Horned ruminants of North America". Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History. 69: 1–669. Janis, Christine M.; Theodor, Jessica M.; Boisvert, Bethany (2002). "Locomotor evolution in camels revisited: a quantitative analysis of pedal anatomy and the acquisition of the pacing gait". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 22 (1): 110–121 Marriott, Katherine; Prothero, Donald R.; Lukowski, Stephanie M.; Forcellati, Meghan R. (2026). "CHAPTER 10: VAMPYROCAMELUS WELSHI, A NEW GENUS AND SPECIES OF GIRAFFE-LIKE CAMEL (ARTIODACTYLA: CAMELIDAE)". New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin. 104: 221–233. Lander, B. (1998). "Oreodontoidea". In Janis, C.M.; Scott, K.M.; Jacobs, L.L. (eds.). Evolution of Tertiary mammals of North America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 402–425 Prothero, Donald (2007). The Evolution of Artiodactyls. Johns Hopkins University Press. Sánchez, Israel M.; Cantalapiedra, Juan L.; Ríos, María; Quiralte, Victoria (2015). "Systematics and Evolution of the Miocene Three-Horned Palaeomerycid Ruminants (Mammalia, Cetartiodactyla)". PLoS One. 10 (12) Semprebon, Gina; Janis, Christine; Solounias, Nikos (2004). "The Diets of the Dromomerycidae (Mammalia: Artiodactyla) and Their Response to Miocene Vegetational Change". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 24 (2): 427–444 Semprebon, G.M.; Rivals, F. (September 2007). "Was grass more prevalent in the pronghorn past? An assessment of the dietary adaptations of Miocene to Recent Antilocapridae (Mammalia: Artiodactyla)". Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 253 (3–4): 332–347. Sowls, Lyle K. (1997). Javelinas and Other Peccaries: Their Biology, Management, and Use (2nd ed.). Texas A&M University Press . pp. 67–68. Stevens, M.S.; Stevens, J.B. (1996). "Merycoidodontinae and Miniochoerinae". In Prothero, D.R.; Emry, R.J. (eds.). The terrestrial Eocene-Oligocene transition in North America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 498–573.
- Squamates | Prehistoric Midwest
A field guide to mosasaurs and other marine squamates from the Western Interior Sea, including Tylosaurus, Mosasaurus, Clidastes and Platecarpus Squamata Lizards, Snakes and Mosasaurs Squamates form a group of reptiles which includes all of today’s snakes, lizards and their closest relatives. During the Late Cretaceous, the Western Interior Sea was home to a variety of marine squamates, including mosasaurs and dolichosaurids. Mosasaurs were large, fully aquatic reptiles that evolved from lizard-like ancestors and became the dominant marine predators of the seaway. They had streamlined bodies, paddle-shaped limbs, powerful tails, and flexible jaws that allowed them to hunt a wide range of prey, including fish, sharks, turtles, seabirds, and other marine reptiles. By the Late Cretaceous, mosasaurs were the largest carnivorous animals found in the world’s seas and oceans Dolichosaurids were smaller elongated marine lizards that retained many terrestrial features, including functional limbs. They likely swam by undulating their bodies and tails and fed on small fish and invertebrates in shallow coastal waters. Both of these squamate groups seem to have been close relatives of today’s monitor lizards and snakes. Anatomy (ABOVE) A labeled diagram of the skeleton of the medium-sized mosasaur Platecarpus Skeletal Anatomy Although they originated from terrestrial lizard ancestors, mosasaurs underwent significant evolutionary changes in order to move into fully marine environmental niches and become effective swimmers. The backbones of these animals were heavily built yet fairly flexible which would have allowed their bodies to move in powerful lateral waves as they swam. In contrast to land-dwelling lizards, mosasaurs had limb bones modified to support broad flippers. The bones of the arms and legs became shortened and flattened over millions of years while the phalanges of the front and back feet grew longer in fully aquatic species who no longer had to support their own weight on land. Many species also developed more finger and toe bones than their terrestrial ancestors which increased the surface areas of their flippers. The skulls of mosasaurs were built similarly to those of living monitor lizards but with a few added features which helped them survive at sea. Their heads were long and thin and were lined with sharp, cone-shaped teeth ideal for seizing slippery prey. Much like many of today’s snakes, mosasaurs had an extra set of pterygoid teeth on the roofs of their mouths which helped them hold onto prey and guide it into the throat during swallowing. The tails of mosasaurs also became increasingly specialized in order to give these animals more propulsion when swimming. Their tail bones ended in a downward bend which may have supported a crescent-shaped fin which was somewhat similar to that of a shark or an ichthyosaur. The extent of this tail fluke in different mosasaur genera and their exact shapes remain uncertain however, since fossils preserving these tail flukes are very rare. Some mosasaurs may have had a more paddle-like tail instead of a full fluke. (BELOW) The bones of the skull of the mosasaur Platecarpus . The pterygoid bone which supports the extra set of teeth at the back of the mosasaur's mouth is somewhat obscured in this drawing but it extends all the way to the back of the skull. (BELOW) The bones of the forelimbs and hindlimbs of a mosasaur. Many bones in the skeletons of mosasaurs were connected with extensive amount of cartilage instead of bone, a feature seen in many types of marine tetrapods. External Anatomy Mosasaurs had a sleek, streamlined body shape that was well suited for movement through the water. Their bodies became more narrow toward the tail, while their necks remained relatively short. This would have given these animals a smooth, torpedo-like profile. Their limbs were transformed into sturdy flippers, which were used to help with steering and balance rather than propulsion. Their primary driving force for swimming came from their large tails. Rare soft-tissue fossils have provided valuable insights into the skin covering of mosasaurs. These remains tell us that the bodies of mosasaurs were covered in small, closely packed scales that created a smooth outer surface and likely helped reduce water resistance. Most scales were rhomboidal or diamond-shaped and overlapped one another in a pattern similar to those seen in many modern reptiles. In certain specimens, slightly enlarged scales are found along the back, creating a shallow ridge that may have improved stability while swimming. Fossilized skin impressions also indicate that scale size and shape varied across different regions of the body, with smaller scales found around joints and other areas that might have needed more flexibility (BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of the mosasaur Platecarpus . Fossils from this particular genus which preserve patches of skin tell us that different areas on the bodies of these animals had their own specific scale types and textures. (BELOW) A fossil on display at the KU Natural History Museum preserves a patch of scales from a Tylosaurus. Note the small ridges, or keels, running along the middle of each of these small scales, similar to those seen in some living snakes. (BELOW) Artistic reconstructions of a mosasaur with two types of tail structures. The evidence in favor of the approach in illustration A is a fossil of Prognathodon which shows what appears to be the outline of a soft tissue tail lobe situated above the caudal vertebrae at the end of the tail. However, it is not clear from this fossil alone just how common this feature would have been within the mosasaur family tree. Some mosasaurs may have had a more paddle like tail as in illustration B. Squamates Clade Mosasauria Clidastes Dallasaurus Ectenosaurus Eonatator Globidens Gnathomortis Jormungandr Latoplatecarpus Mosasaurus Platecarpus Plesioplatecarpus Plioplatecarpus Prognathodon Russellosaurus Selmasaurus Tylosaurus Family Dolichosauridae Coniasaurus Mosasaurs (Mosasauroidea) Giant Ocean Lizards Mosasaurs were a group of large marine reptiles that lived during the Late Cretaceous. These sea reptiles were descended from terrestrial animals related to living monitor lizards and they evolved a suite of adaptations for life in the water. Their bodies were long and streamlined, reducing drag as they swam and their limbs transformed over millions of years into broad, paddle-like flippers used for steering. A powerful tail, which may have ended in a crescent-shaped fluke would have helped push them through the water. Some of the best known features of mosasaurs have to do with characteristics found in their skulls. They had strong jaws lined with sharp, backward-curving teeth designed to grasp slippery prey. Flexible joints in the skull and lower jaw may have allowed them to swallow large animals whole, much like many of today's snakes. They had a second set of teeth behind their palates which helped them keep ahold of their food. Some mosasaur species only grew to be around 5 feet long while others were behemoths who could measure over 50 feet in length. Clidastes Temporal Range: 85 - 70 million years ago Geographic Range: Central and eastern North America, parts of Europe and Asia Species: C propython, C. iguanavus? Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid, seabirds Clidastes was a mosasaur genus which lived in the Late Cretaceous seas that covered much of North America, including the Western Interior Sea. Although it belonged to the same broader lineage as later giants such as Mosasaurus, Clidastes was much lighter and more streamlined in build, generally reaching lengths of around 10-20 feet. Its slender body was ideally suited for speed and agility in the water. One of the defining characteristics of Clidastes was the specialized structure of its vertebral column. The genus' name translates roughly to “locked vertebrae” which refers to the way adjacent vertebrae interlocked with one another. This would have given this genus a backbone that was both strong and flexible. This arrangement gave Clidastes extra stability while swimming without hampering the side-to-side motion needed for effective propulsion through the water. Compared with many later mosasaurs, Clidastes had a more gracile physique. These mosasaurs had narrow skulls, elongated bodies, and powerful tails. The rear portion of the tail was reinforced by enlarged neural spines and lower chevrons that anchored strong swimming muscles. Its jaws were equipped with numerous sharp, recurved teeth designed to seize and hold slippery prey. Rather than crushing large animals, Clidastes likely specialized in catching fish, soft-bodied cephalopods, and other small marine organisms. (BELOW) A skull of Clidastes on display at the KU Natural History Museum. The skull is positioned upside-down with the mandibles on either side of the cranium. The shapes of the palate and the pterygoid teeth are visible in center frame (BELOW) A fossil Clidastes tooth. Original photo taken by Dylan Falkner/Prehistoric Alabama Dallasaurus Temporal Range: 93.9 - 89.8 million years ago Geographic Range: Northern Texas Species: D. turneri Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Dallasaurus is an important animal for those studying mosasaurs because it preserves a rare glimpse into the early stages of mosasaur evolution. Unlike the giant, fully aquatic mosasaurs that dominated the oceans later in the Cretaceous, Dallasaurus retained a mix of basal and derived features that reveal how these reptiles transitioned from life on land to life at sea. Fossils of this small predator were discovered in Turonian-aged rocks near Dallas County, Texas, giving the genus its name. One of the most distinctive characteristics of Dallasaurus was its limb structure. Rather than having fully developed flippers like later mosasaurs, it retained relatively unspecialized limbs with recognizable digits and joints. These limbs were better suited for movement on land than those of more derived mosasaurs, suggesting that Dallasaurus occupied a transitional stage between terrestrial lizards and fully marine reptiles. At the same time, Dallasaurus already displayed adaptations for life in the water. Its body and tail were already deeper than those of its terrestrial relatives, a feature which is sometimes seen in animals who are moving into an aquatic niche. This would suggest that aquatic adaptations evolved in mosasaurs before the complete transformation of the limbs into flippers. Dallasaurus is also notable for its relatively small size. At approximately 3 feet long, Dallasaurus was tiny compared with later mosasaur giants such as Mosasaurus and Tylosaurus . Its diminutive size likely allowed it to hunt in shallow coastal environments and pursue smaller prey. Ectenosaurus Temporal Range: 85.8 - 82 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, northern Texas, Alabama Species: E. clidastoides, E. everhartorum, E. tlemonectes, E. shannoni Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Ectenosaurus was an animal whose name means “drawn-out lizard,” a name which refers to its elongated snout and jaws. This long skull is one of the genus’s defining traits. Unlike the broader skulls of many mosasaurs, Ectenosaurus had a narrow, streamlined snout that likely allowed it to capture small, fast-moving prey with precision. This skull shape is one of the key features used to differentiate Ectenosaurus from close relatives such as Platecarpus. Perhaps the most important fossil discoveries associated with Ectenosaurus are the rare traces of its skin and associated soft-tissue impressions. These fossils revealed that these animals were covered in tightly anchored scales supported by an intricate network of fiber bundles within the skin. The arrangement of these tissues suggests that the front portion of the body was relatively rigid rather than highly flexible. This evidence somewhat changed our view of mosasaur locomotion. Early reconstructions often portrayed mosasaurs swimming like giant eels or sea snakes by undulating their entire bodies. The preserved soft tissues of Ectenosaurus indicate instead that much of the body remained stiff during swimming, with propulsion generated primarily by the tail. This swimming style, which was likely used by most types of mosasaurs, would have been more efficient and hydrodynamic than simple undulation and would have echoed the swimming styles of modern sharks and other fast marine predators. Eonatator Temporal Range: 84 - 72 million years ago Geographic Range: North America, parts of South America, northern Europe Species: E. sternbergii, E. coellensis Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid, sea turtles Eonatator was a relatively small mosasaur that lived in the oceans of the Late Cretaceous and belonged to the specialized halisaurine branch of the mosasaur family. Adults were only about 9 feet long, making them one of the smaller members of the mosasaur group. The name Eonatator , means “dawn swimmer,” which reflects its status as an early representative of the halisaurines. The femurs of these animas were unusually long and narrow, while the vertebral column contained fewer pygal vertebrae than is seen in many other mosasaurs. Their skulls also had a somewhat rounded process on its quadrate bone, a distinctive characteristic that separates Eonatator from closely related genera such as Halisaurus . These differences were significant enough that paleontologists ultimately classified Eonatator as a separate genus. Globidens Temporal Range: 85 - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: Parts of the US, Colombia, Angola, Brazil, Jordan Species: G. alabamensis, G. dakotensis, G. phosphaticus, G. simplex Diet: Durophagous: ammonites, turtles Globidens was among the most highly specialized mosasaurs of the Late Cretaceous and stood apart from most of its relatives because of its globe-shaped dentition. Whereas many mosasaurs had long, sharp teeth adapted for seizing fish and other soft-bodied prey, Globidens had distinctive rounded teeth shaped like small domes or spheres. This unusual dental arrangement was so characteristic that it inspired the genus name, which translates to “globe tooth.” Globidens ' teeth gave it the ability to feed on hard-shelled animals. Its rounded teeth were designed for crushing rather than piercing which would have made them less likely to break during feeding. Instead of impaling prey, the teeth acted much like heavy-duty crushing tools capable of breaking shells and armor. This specialized feeding strategy allowed Globidens to consume organisms such as ammonites, nautiloids, clams, and marine turtles that many other mosasaurs would have struggled to break open. Globidens also had a heavily constructed skull and powerful jaw apparatus. The skull was built to withstand repeated high-pressure bites, while the strongly articulated jaws generated the force necessary to crack open durable shells. (BELOW) A fossil Globidens tooth shown from above (A) and below (B). Original photo taken by Dylan Falkner Gnathomortis Temporal Range: 81 - 79 million years ago Geographic Range: Colorado Species: G. stadtmani Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Gnathomortis was a large mosasaur that lived during the Late Cretaceous in the ancient seaway that covered parts of Colorado. Although it was originally classified as a species of Prognathodon, in 1999 it was moved into its own new genus. Gnathomortis' n ame means “jaws of death.” The most impressive feature of Gnathomortis would have been its massive jaw apparatus. Its lower jaws measured roughly 4 feet long and were supported by extremely powerful muscles. Evidence for these muscles comes from a depression on the outer surface of the mandible, a feature also seen in some modern lizards. This feature suggests that Gnathomortis was capable of generating a particularly strong bite, enabling it to tackle very large prey. Jormungandr Temporal Range: 80 million years ago Geographic Range: North Dakota Species: J. walhallaensis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Jormungandr is among the most recent mosasaurs to be described in the twenty-first century. This marine reptile was recovered from the Pierre Shale deposits of North Dakota and its remains date back to roughly 80 million years ago during the Late Cretaceous. It was described and named in 2023. The genus takes its name from Jörmungandr, the legendary sea serpent of Norse mythology. Because the fossil material includes an almost complete skull along with portions of the rest of the skeleton, scientists have been able to study its anatomy in a great deal of detail. The most distinctive aspect of Jormungandr is its combination of anatomical traits that link different stages of mosasaur evolution. Its skeleton has features associated with both early and more advanced mosasaurine species. For instance, it retained the relatively large number of teeth characteristic of more basal forms such as Clidastes , but it also would have had thickened skull elements that resemble those of later genera such as Mosasaurus. Because of these similarities, researchers initially suspected that the specimen belonged to an early member of the genus Mosasaurus before determining that it was distinct enough to represent an entirely new genus. Latoplatecarpus Temporal Range: 80 - 79 million years ago Geographic Range: Central North America, western Russia Species: L willistoni, L. nichollsae Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Latoplatecarpus was a plioplatecarpine mosasaur whose fossils have been discovered in several regions, including the Western Interior Seaway of North America, the Gulf Coast, and parts of Russia. It was also one of the larger plioplatecarpine mosasaurs, with some individuals exceeding 25 feet in length. The name Latoplatecarpus translates to “wide flat wrist” which highlights the animal’s unique broad foreflippers. These paddle-like limbs were not used for propulsion alone but also played an important role in steering and maintaining stability in the water. Their expanded shape suggests that Latoplatecarpus could make quick turns and precise movements while pursuing prey. Its body design suggests that it was a predator that relied on speed, agility, and quick reactions to capture its food. Latoplatecarpus fossils were originally assigned to the genus Plioplatecarpus before being later recognized as belonging to a separate genus, Mosasaurus Temporal Range: 82.7 - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: Central North America, parts of Europe and Africa Species: M. missouriensis, M. hoffmani, M. conodon, M. lemonnieri Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Mosasaurus missouriensis was one of the largest Interior Sea mosasaurs, likely hunting for sharks, sea turtles, and other marine reptiles living within the waters of its shallow ocean habitat. These animals were close relatives of the european species Mosasaurus hoffmani , one of the most massive known species of mosasaurs. The history of the discovery of Mosasaurus missouriensis is closely tied to the early development of American paleontology. Fossils attributed to this species were among the earliest mosasaur remains discovered in North America. As early as 1804, members of the Lewis and Clark Expedition reported finding the remains of a large aquatic animal along the Missouri River in what is now South Dakota. Additional fossils were collected during the 1830s from the same general region, attracting the attention of scientists and naturalists. The species was formally described in 1834 and initially named Ichthyosaurus missouriensis because its true identity was not yet understood. Later discoveries and comparisons with other marine reptiles revealed that the animal was actually a mosasaur. Subsequent studies reassigned the species to the genus Mosasaurus , where it remains to this day. Platecarpus Temporal Range: 84 - 81 million years ago Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Species: P. tympaniticus, P. coryphaeus? Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Platecarpus was a medium-sized genus of mosasaur. Its fossils are particularly common in the Niobrara Chalk deposits of central and western Kansas, where it was one of the most successful mosasaurs of its time. Platecarpus grew to be about 19 feet long. Its skull was more lightly built than the skulls of giant mosasaurs such as Tylosaurus . It had a wider body than many other more gracile mosasaurs like Mosasaurus and Tylosaurus . Fossil evidence suggests that Platecarpus primarily fed on moderate-sized fish and may also have consumed squid. Some fossils of Platecarpus are found with the remains of fish bones still inside of their abdominal cavities. Exceptional fossil discoveries have alsp preserved rare soft-tissue details from these animals, most notably fossilized skin impressions, which show that they had different shapes of scales on different parts of their bodies. Platecarpus would later evolve into larger and more heavily built mosasaurs like Plioplatecarpus which show up in rock layers from later in the Cretaceous period. (BELOW) A skull of a Platecarpus on display at the KU Natural History Museum. In this particular mount the bones of the sclerotic ring are visible in the orbit. In life these rings of small bony plates would encircle the outside of the animal's eyes. (BELOW) A skeleton of Platecarpus on display at the Sternberg Museum of Natural History. The forelimb bones of this animal are shown at the bottom of the photo. Note the truncated humerus and forearm bones. Plesioplatecarpus Temporal Range: 88 - 84 million years ago Geographic Range: Central and western North America Species: P. planifrons Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Plesioplatecarpus was a mid-sized mosasaur that was found the seas of the Late Cretaceous. For many years, its fossils were assigned first to the genus Clidastes and later to Platecarpus , but subsequent research revealed enough anatomical differences to justify the creation of a separate genus. Its name, meaning “similar to Platecarpus ,” acknowledges its close relationship to that genus. It was most likely a slender and quick swimmer like many of the other plioplatecarpine mosasaurs. Plioplatecarpus Temporal Range: 82 - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: Central North America, parts of Europe and Africa Species: P. marshi, P. depressus, P. primaevus, P. peckensis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Plioplatecarpus was a highly specialized mosasaur that lived during the late Cretaceous period. Although not as large as famous giants such as Mosasaurus or Tylosaurus , it was a successful marine predator in its own right that lived in shallow seas across North America and Europe. Most species reached lengths of about 19 feet, making them medium-sized members of the mosasaur family. One of the most distinctive features of Plioplatecarpus was its relatively short skull combined with fairly large eyes. The enlarged eyes may have been an adaptation for hunting in dimly lit environments, possibly allowing it to forage at greater depths than many other mosasaurs. Its broad geographic distribution suggests that it was well adapted to life in open waters rather than being limited to shallow coastal habitats. These mosasaurs were probably comparatively fast and maneuverable, with body proportions that differed from those of the larger predators of the Late Cretaceous. Some researchers have even compared their swimming style and agility to those of modern pinnipeds like seals and sea lions. Their tooth structure suggests that, like Platecarpus , they specialized in feeding on soft-bodied animals like fish and squid. Prognathodon Temporal Range: 83.6 - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: Found in North America, Europe, western Asia, Africa Species: P. overtoni, P. solvayi, P. giganteus, P. hashimi, P. hudae, P. lutugini, P. primus Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Prognathodon was one of the most heavily-built mosasaurs of the Late Cretaceous oceans. While many mosasaurs were built for catching fish and other soft-bodied prey, Prognathodon evolved a skull and dentition designed to deliver a much more powerful bite. Its name means “forejaw tooth” and refers to the massive jaws and prominent teeth that made it somewhat unique among mosasaurs. Fossils of Prognathodon have been discovered in Europe, North America, Africa, the Middle East, and even New Zealand. One of the characteristic features of the genus Prognathodon was its extremely deep skull. Its jaw muscles were heavily developed, allowing it to generate a powerful bite force compared to many other mosasaurs. Its teeth were large, thick, and strongly built, with heavily striated crowns and a shape suited for gripping, crushing, and tearing prey. Another unusual trait was the curvature and arrangement of the front teeth, which were more strongly curved than those of most other mosasaurs. Unlike the slender teeth of fish-eating mosasaurs, Prognathodon ’s teeth could withstand a lot of stress which suggests that it was capable of hunting and tearing apart very large prey. (BELOW) A Prognathodon tooth apex from the Campanian Ozan Formation of Texas. Fossil collected and original photo taken by Jared Cooke/ jcookepaleo Russellosaurus Temporal Range: ~90 million years ago Geographic Range: Northern Texas Species: R. coheni Diet: Carnivorous, fish, squid Russellosaurus was a small and gracile mosasaur that lived during the Turonian stage of the Late Cretaceous. Although it lacked the enormous size of later mosasaurs such as Mosasaurus and Tylosaurus, it is one of the most scientifically important early members of the group. Fossils recovered from Texas represent some of the oldest well-preserved mosasaur remains known from North America and add a valuable insight into the early evolution of these marine reptiles. The skull of Russellosaurus was relatively narrow and slender in its construction. It had sixteen teeth in both the upper and lower jaws, a broad snout tip, and delicate cranial bones that created a streamlined appearance. Rather than being adapted for crushing large prey, its skull structure suggests it would have been an animal built for making quick turns while pursuing small animals. Russellosaurus is the namesake of the Russellosaurina, a group that includes several basal mosasaurs and helps bridge the evolutionary gap between early forms and later lineages such as the tylosaurines and plioplatecarpines. Selmasaurus Temporal Range: 86.3 - 84 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Alabama Species: S. johnsoni, S. russelli Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Selmasaurus was a relatively small mosasaur whose fossils have been discovered in Alabama and Kansas. The genus is represented by two species, S. russelli and S. johnsoni. Selmasaurus had an unusualy well-fused skull. Unlike most mosasaurs who had flexible skulls capable of widening to accommodate large prey, many of the bones of the Selmasaurus' head were very strongly connected to one another and lacked the extensive cranial flexibility seen in other members of the group. As a result, it likely focused on smaller prey that could be swallowed whole. This is also supported by its relatively low tooth count. For a long time it was considered to be the mosasaur genus with the fewest teeth. Tylosaurus Temporal Range: 92.1 - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: Central North America, parts of Europe and Africa Species: T. proriger, T. rex, T. nepaeolicus, T. kansasensis, T. ivoensis, T. iembeensis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Tylosaurus was among the largest and most powerful marine reptiles of the Late Cretaceous and could grow to be over 43 feet long. One of its most distinctive features was a blunt, toothless snout extension whose purpose remains mysterious. This cranial feature gives Tylosaurus its genus name, translating approximately to “knob reptile”. As a top predator in the seas of western North America, Tylosaurus hunted a wide variety of animals, including fish, sharks, sea turtles, seabirds, plesiosaurs, and even other mosasaurs. Tylosaurus is one of the best known animals from the Western Interior Seaway. It would have occupied the highest level of the food chain and played a role similar to that of modern large toothed whales. Tylosaurus has even been designated the state ocean fossil of Kansas (BELOW) A skeleton of Tylosaurus on display at the Sternberg Museum of Natural History. Despite the large size of this particular skeleton this animal had not reached maximum size at the time of its death (BELOW) A closeup view of the skull of Tylosaurus on the skeleton in Hays. In this mount the pterygoid teeth at the back of the jaw are visible just below the cheekbones and the orbit. These teeth were used to hold prey in place before swallowing (BELOW) An illustrated panel about Tylosaurus made for our Instagram account (BELOW) A Tylosaurus skull on display at the KU Natural History Museum. This particular skull is very large. Its crushed appearance is a result of taphonomic processes which changed the shape of the bones while it was in the ground (BELOW) A skull of a smaller species of Tylosaurus, Tylosaurus kansasensis, on display at the Sternberg Museum (BELOW) A Tylosaurus tooth from the Campanian of Texas. Fossil collected and original photo taken by Jared Cooke/ jcookepaleo Dolichosaurs (Dolichosauridae) Snake-like Swimming Lizards Dolichosaurids were a group of small to medium-sized marine lizards that were related to mosasaurs and possibly closely related to the evolutionary lineage leading to modern snakes. They had elongated, snake-like bodies with reduced limbs and flexible necks. Despite their aquatic adaptations, they retained many features of their terrestrial lizard ancestors such as feet with small toes. Fossils of dolichosaurids such as Coniasaurus have been recovered from marine sediments in Kansas, confirming their presence within the seaway's diverse faunal communities. They preyed primarily on fish, crustaceans and other small aquatic organisms. Coniasaurus Temporal Range: 100 - 84 million years ago Geographic Range: Kansas, Germany, parts of the UK Species: C. crassidens, C. gracilodens Diet: Carnivorous, small fish, squid Coniasaurus was a small marine lizard that lived during the Late Cretaceous. These animals measured only about 3 feet in length, far smaller than later marine reptiles, yet they occupied a key evolutionary position near the base of the mosasaur lineage. Fossils of Coniasaurus have been found in Europe and North America, including deposits from the Western Interior Seaway of Kansas. One of the most distinctive features of Coniasaurus was its elongated body plan. It had a long neck, an extended trunk, and a slender tail which would have given it a serpentine appearance. Its skull was relatively long and narrow, and its dentition was highly specialized. The species Coniasaurus crassidens would have had enlarged hind teeth that differed markedly from those of many living lizards. These teeth may have allowed it to process tougher prey items, while its slender jaws were well suited for capturing fast moving food. Media Gallery Suggested References: Squamata Augusta, B.G.; Zaher, H.; Polcyn, M.J.; Fiorillo, A.R.; Jacobs, L.L. (2022). "A Review of Non-Mosasaurid (Dolichosaur and Aigialosaur) Mosasaurians and Their Relationships to Snakes". In Gower, D.J.; Zaher, H. (eds.). The Origin and Early Evolutionary History of Snakes. Cambridge University Press. pp. 157–179. Caldwell M.W. & Cooper J.A. (1999). "Redescription, palaeobiogeography and palaeoecology of Coniasaurus crassidens Owen, 1850 (Squamata) from the Lower Chalk (Cretaceous; Cenomanian) of SE England" (PDF). Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society. 127 (4): 423–452. Evans, S.E. (2022). "The Origin and Early Diversification of Squamates". In Gower, D.J.; Zaher, H. (eds.). The Origin and Early Evolutionary History of Snakes. Cambridge University Press. pp. 5–110. Everhart, M. J. (2002). “New data on plesiosaur remains found as stomach contents of a Tylosaurus proriger (Squamata; Mosasauridae) from the Niobrara Formation of western Kansas”. (Abstract) Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science Everhart, M. J. (2002). “Remains of immature mosasaurs (Squamata; Mosasauridae) from the Niobrara Chalk (Late Cretaceous) argue against nearshore nurseries”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22(suppl. to 3):52A. Everhart, M. J. and S. E. Johnson. (2001). “The occurrence of the mosasaur, Platecarpus planifrons, in the Smoky Hill Chalk (Upper Cretaceous) of western Kansas”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 21 Everhart, M.J. (2005). “Tylosaurus kansasensis, a new species of tylosaurine (Squamata: Mosasauridae) from the Niobrara Chalk of western Kansas, U.S.A.” Netherlands Journal of Geosciences, p. 231-240. Everhart, M. J. (2002). "New data on Cranial Measurements and Body Length of the Mosasaur, Tylosaurus nepaeolicus (Squamata; Mosasauridae), from the Niobrara Formation of Western Kansas". Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science. 105 (1–2): 33–43. Everhart, M. J. (2002). "New data on Cranial Measurements and Body Length of the Mosasaur, Tylosaurus nepaeolicus (Squamata; Mosasauridae), from the Niobrara Formation of Western Kansas". Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science. 105 (1–2): 33–43. Geist, N. R., Carpenter, S., and Stewart, J. D. (2002). “Chemical and morphological analysis of soft tissue preservation in a mosasaur”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22 Hattin, D. E. (1982). “Stratigraphy and depositional environment of Smoky Hill Chalk Member, Niobrara Chalk (upper Cretaceous) of the type area, western Kansas”. Kansas Geol. Survey Bull. 225, 108 pp. Holmes, R., M. W. Caldwell, and S. L. Cumbaa. (1999). “A new specimen of Plioplatecarpus (Mosasauridae) from the lower Maastrichtian of Alberta: Comments on allometry, functional morphology, and paleoecology”. Canadian Journal of Earth Science 36: 363-369. Kass, M. S. (1999). “Prognathodon stadtmani (Mosasauridae): A new species from the Mancos Shale (Lower Campanian) of western Colorado”. In Gillette, D. D. (ed.), Vertebrate Paleontology in Utah, Utah Geological Survey, Miscellaneous Publication 99-1: 275-294. Kiernan C.R., (2002). “Stratigraphic distribution and habitat segregation of mosasaurs in the Upper Cretaceous of western and central Alabama, with an historical review of Alabama mosasaur discoveries”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 22 (1): 91–103. Lindgren J, Caldwell MW, Konishi T, Chiappe LM (2010), “Convergent Evolution in Aquatic Tetrapods: Insights from an Exceptional Fossil Mosasaur”. PLoS ONE 5(8): e11998. Mekarski, M.M. (2017). “The Origin and Evolution of Aquatic Adaptations in Cretaceous Squamates”. University of Alberta. Polcyn, M. J., and Everhart, M. J., (2008), “Description and phylogenetic analysis of a new species of Selmasaurus (Mosasauridae: Plioplatecarpinae) from the Niobrara Chalk of western Kansas: In: Proceedings of the Second Mosasaur Meeting”.Fort Hays Studies, Special Issue number 3, p. 13-28. Russell, D. A. (1988). “A check list of North American marine Cretaceous vertebrates including fresh water fishes.” Royal Tyrrell Museum Zietlow, Amelia R.; Boyd, Clint A.; Van Vranken, Nathan E. (2023). "Jormungandr walhallaensis: A New Mosasaurine (Squamata: Mosasauroidea) from the Pierre Shale Formation (Pembina Member: Middle Campanian) of North Dakota". Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History. 464 (1).
- Rays, Guitarfishes and Skates | Prehistoric Midwest
Explore the different types of rays, skates, chimaeras and guitarfishes who lived during the Cretaceous period in the Western Interior Sea Chimaeras and Batomorphs Rays, Ratfishes and Hybodonts of the Cretaceous Seas The seas of the Cretaceous period were home to many types of cartilaginous fishes besides sharks. These included rays, skates, guitarfishes and chimaeras, all of which had skeletons made up mostly of cartilage rather than bone. Because cartilage rarely fossilizes these animals are typically represented in the fossil record by their teeth, tooth plates, fin spines, and tiny dermal denticles. Just as in today’s oceans many flat-bodied cartilaginous fishes lived in a range of habitats from shallow coastal waters to deeper parts of the seaway. The broad, flattened bodies of Cretaceous rays, skates and guitarfishes were well suited for life on the sea floor where they preyed on shellfish, crustaceans, and other benthic organisms. Chimaeras, often referred to as ghost sharks or ratfishes, formed another distinctive group within this marine ecosystem. These animals are part of a very ancient lineage which has survived to the present day. They have mouths filled with powerful crushing tooth plates and also specialize in feeding on hard-shelled animals. Some extinct groups of cartilaginous fishes could also be found in the waters of the Western Interior Sea who have no direct living descendents. The rajiform order of fishes included the extinct sclerorhynchoidei, a line of fishes who closely resembled today’s sawfishes with their long spiny rostrums despite not being particularly related to living sawfishes or sawsharks. The seas of the Cretaceous period were also home to hybodonts. Although they outwardly would have closely resembled sharks, hybodonts are usually considered to be part of their own separate order which disappeared at the end of the Cretaceous. Anatomy (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeleton of an eagle ray, Myliobatis, showing the positions of the various cartilages which support the bodies of these animals in life. Some of the shapes of the ceratotrichia have been simplified for this diagram Skeletal Anatomy Rays and other non-shark cartilaginous fishes have skeletal systems composed primarily of cartilage rather than bone. In rays and guitarfishes, the skeleton supports a flattened body plan, with greatly expanded pectoral fins which are connected to the sides of the head. The skull and jaw apparatuses are supported by specialized arch-shaped cartilaginous structures that also connect to the gills and sensory organs. Stingrays and skates generate most of their forward movement by flapping their pectoral fins whereas animals like guitarfishes and presumably extinct sclerorhynchoid fishes still had small tail flukes which they could use to push themselves forward. Many of these animals have flattened teeth that are very good for crunching down on hard-shelled prey. Some groups even independently developed saw-like rostral organs covered in long tooth-like denticles used to slash at soft-bodied prey animals. Chimaeras have an even more specialized condition. Instead of having separated individual teeth these animals have large, durable tooth plates that grow continuously throughout their lifespans. They also differ from rays and sharks since they have a single external gill opening on each side of the head and an upper jaw that is permanently fused to the rest of the skull. Because cartilage rarely fossilizes, the fossil record of these fishes is mostly composed of durable elements such as teeth, tooth plates, fin spines, vertebral centra, and dermal denticles, although some exceptional fossils do exist which preserve the entire bodies of extinct cartilaginous fishes. Rays, Hybodonts and Batomorphs Stingrays (Order Myliobatiformes) Dasyatis Myliobatis Rhombodus Skates (Order Rajiformes) Ischyrhiza Onchopristis Ptychotrygon Texatrygon Walteraja Chimaeras (Order Chimaeriformes) Edaphodon Ischyodus Hybodonts (Order Hybodontiformes) Lonchidion Meristodonoides Guitarfishes (Rhinopristiformes) Pseudohypolophus Rhinobatos Myledaphus Proplatyrhina Stingrays (Myliobatiformes) Temporal Range: ~130 million years ago - Present Diet: Some genera are durophagous, others are filter feeders Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Rhombodus, Dasyatis, Brachyrhizodus, Myliobatis The order Myliobatiformes includes stingrays, manta rays, devil rays and eagle rays. These fishes have flattened bodies with large pectoral fins which make up a large portion of the tissues of the sides of their bodies. Many members of this group also have smaller pelvic fins further to the rear of their bodies. These large fins are the main source of forward propulsion for these animals. Many species live on or near the seafloor where they use highly sensitive electroreceptors, known as the ampullae of Lorenzini, to locate prey hidden beneath sand or mud. Others are pelagic animals who live in open water and act as filter feeders who strain through the water in order to capture microscopic plankton. Most myliobatiform fishes have long, narrow tails which sometimes end in venomous barbs used for protection against predators. (ABOVE) The genus Rhombodus from the Late Cretaceous and early Paleogene. Found in North Dakota, South Dakota, New Jersey. Species: R. laevis, R. microdon (BELOW) The genus Dasyatis, a genus of stingrays found from the Cenomanian stage to the present day. Species in the Interior Sea: D. northdakotaensis . Found in North Dakota (BELOW) The genus of cownose ray Brachyrhizodus from the Late Cretaceous. Species in the Western Interior Sea: B. wichitaensis, B. ellipsis. Found in New Jersey, Alabama, Mississippi, Texas, Kansas, South Dakota (BELOW) The genus Myliobatis from the Maastrichtian stage of the Late Cretaceous to the present day. Species in the Western Interior Sea: M. foxhillsensis. Found in North Dakota (BELOW) A pair of Myliobatis eagle ray teeth. These animals became particularly common in the marine fossil record starting in the Paleogene period but their first fossils are found at the very end of the Cretaceous period. Skates (Rajiformes) Temporal Range: ~190 million years ago - Present Diet: Some genera are durophagous, others are soft prey specialists Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Walteraja, Onchopristis, Ptychotrygon, Ischyrhiza, Texatrygon The order Rajiformes includes skates and their extinct relatives the sclerorhynchoids, also known as the sawskates. These animals have different tail anatomies than the long thin tails seen in myliobatiform fishes. Skates instead have sturdy tails that lack venomous stinging barbs. Their tails are sometimes covered in a row of short spines. This feature is taken a step further in the case of the sclerorhynchoids. These extinct fishes who were very common during the middle and Late Cretaceous developed long, flattened snouts lined with rows of tooth-like denticles along their edges, producing a distinctive saw-like appearance. Species such as Onchopristis and Ischyrhiza most likely used their elongated rostra to slash at prey or to search through layers of sediment for hidden animals. Many of these animals also seem to have had several sets of spiny denticles along their backs and on the edges of their pectoral fins. Skates and their closest relatives reproduce by laying soft egg cases known as “mermaid’s purses.” (BELOW) The genus Walteraja from the Late Cretaceous, Maastrichtian stage. Found in North Dakota. Species: W. exigua (BELOW) The genus Onchopristis from the early and Late Cretaceous, Barremian stage - Cenomanian stage. Species found in the Western Interior Sea: O. dunklei. Found in Texas. (BELOW) The genus Ptychotrygon from the early and Late Cretaceous, Albian stage - Maastrichtian stage. Found in Texas, Alabama, North Dakota. Species found in the Western Interior Sea: P. greybullensis, P. winni (BELOW) A Ptychotrygon oral tooth. This particular genus seems to have undergone a process called "depristification" where their rostra do not seem to have had large outward-facing spiny denticles (BELOW) The genus Ischyrhiza from the late Cretaceous, Cenomanian - Maastrichtian stages. Species found in the Western Interior Sea: I. avonicola. Found in Texas, North Dakota, Wyoming, Montana (BELOW) The genus Texatrygon from the Late Cretaceous. Found in Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Texas, Utah Species: T. brycensis Chimaeras (Chimaeriformes) Temporal Range: ~350 million years ago - Present Diet: Durophagous, hard-shelled prey Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Ischyodus, Edaphodon The order Chimaeriformes is a group within the larger subclass of cartilaginous fishes called the holocephali. This is a very old group of fishes and the fossil record of their relatives goes back as far as the Devonian period. These fishes have a single external gill opening on each side of their heads which is covered by a fleshy operculum. Most other types of cartilaginous fishes have multiple gill slits behind or below their heads. The upper jaws of chimaeras are usually fused to the rest of their skulls which gives these animals a more solid anchor for their crushing tooth plates. Living chimaeras tend to live deep in the ocean and as a result often have large eyes which allow them to see even in low light conditions. This feature may have been present in extinct North American Cretaceous chimaeras as well since the deepest parts of the Western Interior Sea would have been far enough below the surface that only a limited amount of light would have reached the seafloor. (BELOW) The genus Ischyodus from the Jurassic period to the middle Miocene epoch. Species found in the Western Interior Sea: I. rayhassi. Found in North Dakota. (BELOW) The genus Edaphodon from the Early Cretaceous to the Pliocene epoch. Species found in the Western Interior Sea: E. hesperis. Found in British Columbia Hybodonts (Hybodontiformes) Temporal Range: 360 - 66 million years ago Diet: Carnivorous, soft prey specialists Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Meristodonoides, Lonchidion The order Hybodontiformes is an extinct group of shark-like cartilaginous fishes who persisted through to the end of the Mesozoic but ultimately became extinct at the end of the Cretaceous. Although they are often referred to as sharks, hybodonts do not fall within the division selachii and are therefore not true members of the shark group. These animals had very tall spines on each of their dorsal fins. These spines are often covered in ridges or groove-like markings. These spines probably helped ward off potential attacks from other marine predators. Male hybodonts had two small cephalic spines on their head, a feature thought to have played a role in reproduction although their exact purpose remains unclear. Fossils of different types of hybodonts have been recovered from saltwater, freshwater and brackish environments. (BELOW) The genus Meristodonoides from the Early and Late Cretaceous, Aptian - Maastrichtian stages. Found in New Jersey, Texas, Montana, Wyoming, Minnesota, Mississippi. Species: M. butleri, M. montanensis, M. novojerseyensis, M. rajkovichi, M. multiplicatus (BELOW) The genus Lonchidion from the Triassic to the Late Cretaceous period. Guitarfishes (Rhinopristiformes) Temporal Range: 150 million years ago - Present Diet: Carnivorous, fishes, invertebrates Genera in the Western Interior Sea: Rhinobatos, Pseudohypolophus The order Rhinopristiformes is the group which contains guitarfishes, sawfishes, and their relatives. The members of this order have long bodies with flattened heads and forebodies, while the rear portion of the body is similar to the rear halves of sharks, ending in a well-developed tail. Most rhinopristiform fishes are benthic predators that use their mouths which are positioned on the ventral surfaces of their bodies to feed on invertebrates and small fishes hiding in the seafloor sediment. Like many types of rays they have electroreceptors that help them to detect prey concealed beneath layers of sand or mud. (BELOW) The genus Rhinobatos from the late Jurassic period - Present. Species found in the Western Interior Sea: R .incertus. Found in Colorado, Kansas, Texas, Montana (BELOW) The genus Pseudohypolophus from the Late Cretaceous. Unclear affinities, some studies recover it as a member of Myliobatiformes. Found in Texas, Utah, Montana, Kansas (BELOW) The genus Myledaphus from the Late Cretaceous, Turonian-Maastrichtian stages. Species found in the Western Interior Sea: M. bipartitus, M. pustulosus. Found across southern and central North America, from Alberta to Alabama (BELOW) The genus Protoplayrhina from the Late Cretaceous, Maastrichtian stages. Species found in the Western Interior Sea: P. renae. Found in Colorado, Wyoming, North Dakota Suggested References: Chimaeras, Batomorphs Case, G.R. (1965). “An occurrence of the sawfish, Onchopristis dunklei, in the Upper Cretaceous of Minnesota”. Journal, Minnesota Academy of Science, 32(3):183. Cicimurri, D., (2000). “Cretaceous elasmobranchs of the Greenhorn Formation (Middle Cenomanian-Middle Turonian), western South Dakota”. 6th Fossil Conference Proceedings volume. :27-43. Duffin, C. J., (2001). “A chimaerid (Holocephali, Chimaeriformes) vomerine toothplate from the Upper Cretaceous of Belgium”. Palaeontology, 44(6)1179-1188. Everhart, M.J. (2017). “Oceans of Kansas - A Natural History of the Western Interior Sea, Second Edition”. Indiana University Press, 460 pp. Everhart, M. J. (2005). “New stratigraphic records (Albian-Coniacian) of the guitarfish, Rhinobatos incertus (Chondrichthyes; Rajiformes), from the Cretaceous of central and western Kansas”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 25(Supplement to 3): 55A. Lucas, Spencer G.; Sullivan, Robert M. (2006). “Late Cretaceous Vertebrates from the Western Interior: Bulletin 35”. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. McNulty, C. L. Jr. and B. H. Slaughter. (1964). “Rostral teeth of Ischyrhiza mira Leidy from northeast Texas.” Texas Jour. Sci. 16:107-112. McNulty, C. L. Jr. and B. H. Slaughter. (1972). “The Cretaceous selachian genus, Ptychotrygon Jaekel 1894”. Eclog. Geol. Helvetiae 65(3):647-656. Shimada, K. (1993). “Upper Cretaceous elasmobranchs from the Blue Hill Shale Member of the Carlile Shale, Western Kansas”. Kansas Academy of Science Abstracts, 12(78). Villalobos-Segura, Eduardo; Underwood, Charlie J.; Ward, David J.; Claeson, Kerin M. (2019). "The first three-dimensional fossils of Cretaceous sclerorhynchid sawfish: Asflapristis cristadentis gen. et sp. nov., and implications for the phylogenetic relations of the Sclerorhynchoidei (Chondrichthyes)". Journal of Systematic Palaeontology. 17 (21): 1847–1870. Welton, B. J., and R. F. Farish (1993). "The Collector's Guide to Fossil Sharks and Rays from the Cretaceous of Texas." Before Time, Lewisville, Texas, 204 pp.
- Sharks page 2 | Prehistoric Midwest
Explore the different types of small sharks who lived during the Cretaceous period in the Western Interior Sea, including ground sharks, angel sharks and dogfishes Sharks (continued) Sharks Not all sharks are listed on this page. See the list below for the order in which shark entries are listed Previous Page This page Order Orectolobiformes Chiloscyllium Cretorectolobus Orectoloboides Plicatoscyllium Order Lamniformes Archaeolamna “Carcharias” Cardabiodon Cretolamna/Cretalamna Cretodus Cretoxyrhina Dallasiella Johnlongia Leptostyrax Odontaspis Paranomotodon Protolamna Pseudocorax Pseudomegachasma Ptychodus Scapanorhynchus Squalicorax Previous Page Order Carcharininiformes Archaeotriakis Galeorhinus Palaeogaleus Squatigaleus Order Synechodontiformes Paraorthacodus Synechodus Order Squatiniformes Squatina Order Heterodontiformes Heterodontus Order Squaliformes Squalus Order Hexanchiformes Hexanchus Unclear Affinities Aquilolamna Ground sharks (Carchariniformes ) Cat Sharks, Hound Sharks Carcharhiniform sharks are an order of sharks commonly known as the ground sharks. This group represents the most diverse order of living sharks and includes tiger sharks, bull sharks and hammerheads. Like many types of true sharks, these animals have five gill slits, an anal fin, two dorsal fins lacking spines and a nictitating membrane that protects their eyes while biting into their prey. The members of this group have highly variable tooth shapes depending on their ecological niche, ranging from long thin teeth for catching small fish to the blade-like teeth of the tiger shark. Fossils of carchariniform shark teeth are less common in rock layers from the Western Interior Sea than the remains of their lamniform cousins. Many of the roles occupied by today’s requiem sharks and larger ground sharks were filled by these extinct mackerel shark genera, and most remains of Cretaceous ground sharks seem to be those of smaller animals. Nevertheless, a few genera known from fairly complete skeletal remains dating back to the Cretaceous still have living members found in the world’s oceans today. Archaeotriakis Temporal Range: 75 million years ago Geographic Range: Wyoming, Canada, Montana Species: A. rochelleae, A. ornatus Diet: Carnivorous, fish, small invertebrates Archaeotriakis was a small prehistoric carcharhiniform shark which is considered a member of the false catshark family Pseudotriakidae. Its teeth were tiny but strongly built, with large central cusps with two smaller cusps on each side. The largest of these side cusplets are still about half the size of the main cusp of the tooth. These teeth also had distinct ridges running vertically along the lower margins of their cusps. The main cusps of these teeth are shorter than those found in many other types of sharks. Some features of its teeth look a lot like those of early ancestral ground sharks, while others, such as the unusually large side cusps and curved cutting edges, are rarely seen in related species. This may be a sign that Archaeotriakis would have occupied a unique role in the marine ecosystem and possibly fed on different types of prey than other carcharhiniform sharks. Its fossils are found in areas which would have been near the coastline in shallow waters and possibly in estuarine or nearshore river environments. Galeorhinus Temporal Range: 97 million years ago - present Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Species: G. cuvieri, G. duchaussoisi, G. girardoti, G. glickmani, G. louisi, G. muelleri, G. tenius, G. galeus Diet: Carnivorous, fish, cephalopods Galeorhinus is an extant genus of hound shark whose fossil remains are also known from the Cretaceous period. They are also known as school sharks. These animals have very long, narrow snouts. Their mouths are broad and curved, and the teeth in both jaws are very similar in size and shape. These teeth are small, triangular and flat when viewed from the side. The distal edge of each tooth is covered in a row of prominent serrations. These teeth seem to be suited both for catching and cutting through soft-bodied prey. The bodies of these sharks are long and narrow and the first dorsal fin is located just behind the pectoral fins, while the second dorsal fin is nearly equal in size to the anal fin and positioned directly above it. These sharks are known from many different species found from the middle Cretaceous period onwards but only one species is found today, Galeorhinus galeus . Palaeogaleus Temporal Range: Late Cretaceous, parts of the Paleogene Geographic Range: Parts of North America, Europe, Africa Species: P. navarroensis, P. larachei Diet: Carnivorous, fish, cephalopods Palaeogaleus was an extinct hound shark. Its teeth were generally small and narrow, roughly similar to those of animals like Galeorhinus , with a sharp central cusp and smaller cusps on either side. Compared with the larger, broader cutting teeth found in many larger carcharhiniform sharks, the teeth of Palaeogaleus appear to have been better suited for catching and holding smaller prey. These animals are some of the first members of the houndshark family Triakidae to appear during the late Cretaceous period. The genus has no living members. Squatigaleus Temporal Range: 75 million years ago - 66 million years ago Geographic Range: Central North America, parts of Europe and Africa Species: S. sulphurensis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles Squatigaleus was a rare extinct carcharhiniform shark that is known mainly from fossil teeth found in Late Cretaceous rocks. The best-known species is Squatigaleus sulphurensis which has been identified from fossil deposits in Texas and is classified within the hound shark family, Triakidae. Its teeth are quite different from those of other types of hound sharks. These teeth have much more prominent main cusps which are very wide and slightly curved when viewed from the side. Based on the size of their teeth and the appearances of their living relatives, Squatigaleus was probably a smaller shark with a long, thin body. Synechodontiformes Synechodontiformes is an order of cartilaginous fishes which has its origins in the Permian period and which managed to survive past the end-Cretaceous mass extinction event all the way up until the middle of the Paleogene period. Their exact classification within the cartilaginous fish family tree remains a subject of debate. They are sometimes considered to be true members of the shark division Selachii as an early line branching off from the Galean sharks. Other studies consider them to fall outside of the true shark group and instead recover them as a separate group which spilt off from the common ancestors of sharks and rays. Synechodus Temporal Range: Triassic to the early Paleogene, possible Permian record Geographic Range: North America, parts of Europe and eastern Russia Species: S. dubrisiensis, S. antiquus? Diet: Carnivorous, fish, cephalopods Synechodus is a very old genus of sharks, with the first members of this genus dating back to the early Triassic and possibly parts of the Permian period. In addition to fossils of its teeth, some Synechodus fossils preserve the shape of the animal’s entire body. Synechodus teeth had a thin central cusp flanked by three to five smaller cusps on each side. These teeth were better suited for grasping and holding prey than for cutting large pieces of flesh. The roots of the teeth were very wide but very thin with a gentle curve positioned beneath the area supporting the main cusp of each tooth. Fossil skeletons show that Synechodus had a broad head, a rounded snout, and large pectoral fins attached to a relatively compact body. It had a single dorsal fin positioned further along the animal’s back which did not feature the defensive fin spines seen in some ancient shark groups. Paraorthacodus Temporal Range: 200 million years ago - 37 million years ago Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Species: P. andersoni, P. antarcticus, P. clarkii, P. conicus, P. eocaenus, P. jurensis, P. nerviensis, P. patagonicus, P. recurvus, P. sulcatus, P. validus, P. helveticus Diet: Carnivorous, fish, cephalopods Paraorthacodus was a genus of shark very similar to the related genus Synechodus. Some fossils are known from this genus which preserve the entire shape of the animal's body which show us that, like many of its relatives, these animals would have had blunt, rounded snouts, short fins and a dorsal fin located further along the animal’s back. Their teeth were similar to those of Synechodus but can be distinguished by the order of the sizes of their lateral cusplets, which decrease in size more slowly than those of their relatives as they move further away from the main tooth cusp. Angelsharks (Squatiniformes ) Angelsharks are a very unique group of sharks who are adapted to spend their lives as ambush hunters, partially burying themselves on the seafloor. Their bodies are roughly similar to those of electric rays or guitarfishes, although the arrangement of their teeth and positions of the gill slits indicate that they are, in fact, members of the true shark group. Their pectoral fins are quite large and they join up with the body just below the base of the head. The rest of their bodies are extremely flat and dorso-ventrally compressed. Squatina Temporal Range: 118 million years ago - Present Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Species: S. cranei, S. prima, S. crassa, S. minor, S. baumbergensis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, benthic invertebrates The genus Squatina is a type of angel shark. This group of sharks is rather strange since its members resemble rays more than they look like typical sharks. Instead of having the streamlined body shape seen in most sharks, angel sharks have broad, flattened bodies and large, wing-like pectoral and pelvic fins. This body design allows them to rest comfortably on the seafloor and remain well camouflaged in sandy or muddy habitats. Even though they look similar to rays they still have many important features found in other sharks, including a muscular tail, two dorsal fins, and gill slits positioned along the sides of their heads. There are several species of Squatina angelsharks found in today’s oceans but their fossil record dates all the way back to the early Cretaceous. Although they are rare in the central US, their fossils are occasionally found in deposits formed by the Western Interior Sea. Angel sharks are ambush predators. Rather than swimming actively in search of prey angel sharks spend much of their time lying motionless on the seabed. They often cover themselves in a thin layer of sediment to add to their disguises. With only their eyes and spiracles visible they can remain hidden until a fish or other prey item comes within range. Bullhead sharks (Heterodontiformes ) Bullhead sharks are a group of cartilaginous fishes whose first fossil remains date back to the Jurassic period. These tend to be rather small sharks who specialize in feeding on benthic invertebrates near the seafloor. They have eyes which are positioned above their bodies and dorsal fins which are equipped with sharp protective spines. Heterodontus Temporal Range: ~155 million years ago - Present Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Species: H. rugosus Diet: Carnivorous, fish, marine invertebrates The genus Heterodontus is a group of sharks commonly known as bullhead sharks. These animals are used for their very unique teeth and mouthparts which are quite different from those of large macropredatory sharks. The teeth at the front of their jaws are sharp and pointed so that the shark can hold on to its prey while the teeth at the back of the mouth are more broad and flattened for crushing hard-shelled animals such as sea urchins, crabs, and mollusks. This combination of different tooth types is uncommon among sharks and is the reason for the name Heterodontus, which means “different teeth.” These animals are also easily identifiable thanks to the shape of their heads. They have a short, blunt snout and prominent ridges above their eyes that look like small horns. They also have two dorsal fins, each supported by a strong spine. These dorsal fin spines are a feature that is rare among modern sharks but is found in many types of extinct sharks and shark relatives. They likely provide protection from predators. Dogfish (Squaliformes ) Dogfishes as a group of relatively small sharks which show up at the start of the Cretaceous period. They are easily distinguished from other types of sharks by their lack of an anal fin in between their pelvic fins and caudal fluke. Living dogfish sharks are known to travel extremely long distances, in some cases for thousands of miles, as part of migrations or in search of food. They usually feed on soft-bodied prey animals Squalus Temporal Range: 89 million years ago - Present Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Species: S. ballingsloevensis Diet: Carnivorous, fish, cephalopods Squalus is a genus of dogfish sharks. These are a smaller variety of sharks which have long, thin bodies. Members of this genus also have a sharp spine located in front of each of their two dorsal fins. These spines give them some extra protection from predators and are one of the defining traits of the genus. These animals also do not have an anal fin. Squalus sharks also have a slender body, a pointed snout, and relatively uniform teeth in both the upper and lower jaws. Unlike sharks with highly specialized teeth for cutting or crushing, dogfish sharks have sharp, blade-like teeth that are well suited for capturing and eating small fishes and invertebrates. Sixgill sharks (Hexanchiformes ) Sixgill sharks, which are still found in the world's oceans today, first appear in the fossil record during the early Cretaceous period. Their tooth fossils are fairly rare in Cretaceous deposits from the Western Interior Sea but they may have spent their lives hunting at the bottom of deeper areas in the sea, much like their living descendants. Hexanchus Temporal Range: 110 million years ago - Present Geographic Range: Worldwide distribution Species: H. agassizi, H. andersoni, H. casieri, H. gracilis, H. microdon Diet: Carnivorous, fish, sharks, marine reptiles The genus Hexanchus is a group often known as the sixgill sharks. As their name suggests, Hexanchus had six gill slits on each side of its body. Most modern sharks have only five gill slits, making this extra pair a key feature that separates sixgill sharks from nearly all other shark groups. Hexanchus species have only one dorsal fin instead of the two found in most other extant sharks. This genus is particularly old among extant true sharks and their strange anatomical features hint at their separation from most other branches on the shark family tree. Their tooth shape and arrangement is also rather odd. The lower jaw contains large, comb-shaped teeth with multiple sharp cusps, while the upper jaw is lined with smaller, narrower teeth. This arrangement makes it easier for sixgill sharks to grip and tear apart a variety of prey. Unlike most shark species that are commonly found in shallow coastal waters, Hexanchus sharks are primarily deep-water animals. Their fossil teeth occasionally show up in Cretaceous rocks linked to the presence of the Interior Sea. Unclear affinities Aquilolamna Temporal Range: 93 million years ago Geographic Range: Central Mexico Species: A. milarcae Diet: Filter feeder, plankton, copepods, algae Aquilolamna is a very strange type of shark whose body shape was only recently revealed. Fossils showing the anatomy of the animal’s entire body have been recovered from the Agua Nueva Formation in Mexico, which sat just below the southern edge of the Western Interior Sea during the Late Cretaceous. These animals had a body design unlike that of any shark living today. Although it had the streamlined body and tail typical of sharks, its most striking feature was its enormous wing-like pectoral fins. These fins were so large that the animal's wingspan exceeded its body length which gave it an appearance more similar to that of a manta ray than a traditional shark. This combination of shark and ray-like characteristics makes Aquilolamna unique among known elasmobranchs. These animals also seem to have a diet similar to that of today’s manta rays, with its small teeth and relatively wide mouth possibly suggesting that it was a filter feeder that fed on plankton in open water. See the rest of our entries about Cretaceous sharks by returning to the previous page Previous Page Media Gallery Suggested References: Sharks Case,G. R.;H. Cappetta. (1997). “A new Selachian Fauna from the Late Maastrichtian of Texas” (Upper Cretaceous/Navarroan; Kemp Formation) . Münchner Geowiss. Abh. (A)(34):131–189 Cook, T.D.; Newbrey, M.G.; Murray, A.M.; Wilson, M.V.H.; Shimada, K.; Takeuchi, G.T.; Stewart, J.D. (2011). "A partial skeleton of the Late Cretaceous lamniform shark, Archaeolamna kopingensis, from the Pierre Shale of western Kansas, U.S.A.". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 31 (1): 8–21 Everhart, M. J. (2004). “Late Cretaceous interaction between predators and prey. Evidence of feeding by two species of shark on a mosasaur”. PalArch, vertebrate palaeontology series 1(1):1-7. Everhart, M.J. (2017). “Oceans of Kansas - A Natural History of the Western Interior Sea”, Second Edition. Indiana University Press, 460 pp. Everhart, M. J. (2005). “Bite marks on an elasmosaur (Sauropterygia; Plesiosauria) paddle from the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Cretaceous) as probable evidence of feeding by the lamniform shark, Cretoxyrhina mantelli”. PalArch, Vertebrate paleontology 2(2): 14-24. Everhart, M. J. and K. Ewell. (2006). “Shark-bitten dinosaur (Hadrosauridae) vertebrae from the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Coniacian) of western Kansas”. Kansas Academy of Science, Transactions, 109 (1-2):27-35. Jambura, P.L.; Stumpf, S.; Kriwet, J. (2021). "Skeletal remains of the oldest known pseudocoracid shark Pseudocorax kindlimanni sp. nov. (Chondrichthyes, Lamniformes) from the Late Cretaceous of Lebanon". Cretaceous Research. 125 Lucas, S. G.; Sullivan, R. M. (2006). “Late Cretaceous Vertebrates from the Western Interior: Bulletin 35.” New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science. Maisey, J. G., (1996). Discovering Fossil Fishes. Henry Holt and Company, New York. McAllister, J. A. (1985). “Reevaluation of the formation of spiral coprolites” - University Kansas Paleontology Contributions, Paper 114, 12 p. McIntosh, A. P.; Shimada, K.; Everhart, M. J. (2016). "Late Cretaceous marine vertebrate fauna from the Fairport Chalk Member of the Carlile Shale in southern Ellis County, Kansas, U.S.A." Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science. Schwimmer, D. R., J.D. Stewart, and G. D. Williams. (1997). “Scavenging by sharks of the genus Squalicorax in the late Cretaceous of North America”. PALAIOS, 12:71-83. Shimada, K. (2007). "Skeletal and dental anatomy of lamniform shark, Cretalamna appendiculata from Upper Cretaceous Niobrara Chalk of Kansas". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, 27(3):584–602. Shimada, K. (2008). “Ontogenetic parameters and life history strategies of the Late Cretaceous lamniform shark, Cretoxyrhina mantelli, based on vertebral growth increments”. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology 28(1):21-33. Shimada, K. and Cicimurri, D.J. (2005). “Skeletal anatomy of the Late Cretaceous shark, Squalicorax (Neoselachii: Anacoracidae).” Paläontologische Zeitschrift 79(2): 241-261. Shimada, K and M. J. Everhart. (2003). “Ptychodus mammillaris (Elasmobranchii) and Enchodus cf. E. schumardi (Teleostei) from the Fort Hays Limestone Member of the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Cretaceous) in Ellis County, Kansas”. Kansas Academy of Science, Transactions 106(3-4):171-176. Shimada, K. and M. J. Everhart. (2004). “Shark-bitten Xiphactinus audax (Teleostei: Ichthyodectiformes) from the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Cretaceous) of Kansas”. The Mosasaur 7, p. 35-39. Shimada, K. and D. J. Martin. (1993). “Upper Cretaceous selachians from the basal Greenhorn Limestone in Russell Co., Kansas”. Kansas Academy of Science Abstracts, 12(78). Shimada, K. (1993). Upper Cretaceous selachians from the Fort Hays Limestone Member of the Niobrara Formation in Ellis County, Kansas. Kansas Academy of Science Abstracts, 12(78). Shimada, Kenshu; Ewell, Keith; Everhart, Michael J. (2004). "The First Record of the Lamniform Shark Genus, Johnlongia, from the Niobrara Chalk (Upper Cretaceous), Western Kansas". Transactions of the Kansas Academy of Science. 107 (3/4): 131–135. Shimada, Kenshu; Popov, Evgeny V.; Siversson, Mikael; Welton, Bruce J.; Long, Douglas J. (2015). "A new clade of putative plankton-feeding sharks from the Upper Cretaceous of Russia and the United States". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 35 (5) Shimada, Kenshu; Everhart, M.J. (2019). "A new large Late Cretaceous lamniform shark from North America, with comments on the taxonomy, paleoecology, and evolution of the genus Cretodus". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 39 (4) Siverson, M. and J. Lindgren. (2005). “Late Cretaceous sharks Cretoxyrhina and Cardabiodon from Montana, USA”. Acta Palaeontol. Pol. 50(2) 301-314. Underwood, C.J.; Cumbaa, S.L. (2010). "Chondrichthyans from a Cenomanian (Late Cretaceous) bonebed, Saskatchewan, Canada". Palaeontology. 53 (4): 903–944. Welton, B. J., and R. F. Farish (1993). "The Collector's Guide to Fossil Sharks and Rays from the Cretaceous of Texas." Before Time, Lewisville, Texas, 204 pp. Williamson, T. E., J. I. Kirkland and S. G. Lucas. (1993). “Selachians from the Greenhorn cyclothem ("Middle" Cretaceous: Cenomanian-Turonian), Black Mesa, Arizona, and the paleogeographic distribution of Late Cretaceous selachians”. J. Paleon. 67(3):447-474.
- Inquiry Services Page | Prehistoric Midwest
Explore our services and get in touch Our Services 01. Custom Paleo Art Commission a unique piece of artwork depicting your favorite prehistoric creature or a scene from ancient life in the Midwest. Our artists specialize in scientifically accurate yet artistically compelling paleo art, perfect for collectors or educational displays. Get a personalized vision brought to life with detailed textures and vibrant portrayals of ancient worlds. This service is ideal for individuals seeking bespoke art for their collections or projects. Show more 02. Detailed Animal Study Go beyond the basics with our in-depth profiles on specific prehistoric animals from the Midwest region. Each package includes detailed biological information, habitat reconstruction, and a curated selection of related artwork. Understand the ancient ecosystems and the creatures that inhabited them with scientifically-grounded insights. Ideal for educators, enthusiasts, and researchers seeking comprehensive data. Show more 03. Paleo Art Print Own a piece of prehistoric wonder with high-quality prints of our featured paleo artwork. Available in various sizes, these prints are perfect for decorating home offices, educational spaces, or any enthusiast's collection. Each print captures the majesty and mystery of extinct life in vivid detail. Enhance your environment with stunning visuals from a bygone era. Show more
- Carnivorans | Prehistoric Midwest
Discover different types of extinct saber-toothed cats, bears and canids found in the Midwest during the Pleistocene epoch, including animals like Smilodon and the dire wolf Carnivora Bears, Dogs, Cats and their Relatives Carnivora is a diverse order of mammals which includes all of today’s cats, dogs, bears, weasels, skunks, otters, raccoons, coatis, seals and sea lions, along with their closest relatives. The name carnivora refers to the meat eating diets common amongst the members of this group, but it should be noted that not all carnivorous animals are carnivorans and not all carnivorans are carnivorous. Although many carnivorans almost exclusively eat meat, some members of this group, like raccoons and grizzly bears, eat a mixed diet of meat and plant matter. Furthermore other carnivorans, like the olinguito and kinkajou, almost exclusively eat fruit. During the Pleistocene epoch the Midwest was home to several types of large carnivorans which have since disappeared. The most famous of these extinct carnivorans are without a doubt the large saber-toothed cats like Smilodon and Homotherium , but other animals like short-faced bears, American lions and giant jaguars were also found in this region at the time. Anatomy (BELOW) Features of the cranial and mandibular anatomy of a dire wolf. In many types of carnivorans a large set of teeth called the carnassial complex is positioned along the rear edges of the mouth in order to help with cutting through meat. Skeletal Anatomy Most terrestrial carnivorans are built to be cursorial animals who are very good runners. As a result, the bones of their limbs are usually fairly long which gives many carnivorans a long stride length. Aquatic and burrowing carnivorans tend to have shorter limbs and specialized hand and foot anatomies which help them to move through water or to claw through dirt. Many carnivorans are digitigrade, meaning that they walk on the bones of their tiptoes instead of walking with their heels against the ground. This type of locomotion is another hallmark of animals who are adapted for running. In contrast, some species, including bears, are plantigrade and place their entire foot on the ground while walking. The forelimbs of carnivorans are often more flexible than those of other types of mammals owing to the presence of a reduced or loosely attached clavicle which gives these animals a greater range of limb movement. Carnivorans also tend to have skeletal features which help them hunt down prey, although some vegetarian or insect-eating carnivorans do also exist. Their skulls are strongly built and tend to support very powerful jaw muscles. Their large canine teeth are used for grasping and restraining prey, while the specialized carnassial complexes along the sides of their mouths help to cut or shear through meat. (BELOW) A labeled diagram of the skeletal anatomy of a dire wolf, based on a skeletal mount of bones from the La Brea Tar Pits which is on display at the KU Natural History Museum. External Anatomy Over millions of years, carnivorans have evolved many soft tissue structures which help different groups of these mammals to function better in their preferred ecological niches. One particular feature found in most carnivorans is their forward-facing eyes which give them a greater degree of binocular vision and a far more accurate sense of depth perception. This trait is particularly helpful when it comes to hunting and navigating complex terrain or when climbing trees. Most of these animals also have rather large external ears with distinctive shapes which allow them to pick up on subtle sounds which fall outside of the human hearing range. Many carnivorans have long whiskers surrounding their snouts that serve as sensory organs that help detect nearby objects. The facial structures of carnivorans can vary greatly between different groups. Some species have long snouts and muzzles, while others, such as felids, have shorter and more rounded faces. The limbs of carnivorans are typically strong and muscular and are adapted for a wide range of behaviors including climbing, burrowing, and swimming. Most species have paws tipped with several digits and sharp claws. In some groups these claws are habitually held off the ground when retracted while in other carnivorans the nails tend to contact the ground at all times. Tail structure differs among different species but in groups with longer tails, these parts of their bodies work as tools for communication or for keeping balance while moving through trees or when running at high speeds. (BELOW) Features of the external anatomy of an American cheetah. Most carnivorans have whiskers, padded feet and flexible spines which absorb the physical stress created by bodies while running at high speeds. Bears (Ursidae) Short-faced bears By the end of the Pleistocene, North America was already home to the brown, black and polar bears we associate with the continent today, but a few other types of now extinct bears would have also made their home in this area at that time. These were the short-faced bears which are known from two main species found in Pleistocene deposits. The largest of these was the Giant short-faced bear Arctodus simu s, while a smaller species, Arctodus pristinus, lived in parts of Florida and the area which would one day become the southeastern US. Lesser short-faced bear Arctodus pristinus Temporal Range: 2.5 million years ago to approximately 500,000 years ago Geographic Range: Southern and eastern North America Species: A. simus, A pristinus Diet: Omnivorous, fish, meat, roots, invertebrates, carrion Arctodus pristinus was a smaller species of short-faced bear whose fossils are found in the southeastern US in deposits from the early Pleistocene. In the parts of its range which extended into Florida, it would have lived alongside yet another species of short-faced bear, Tremarctos floridanus , as well as saber-toothed cats like Xenosmilus and large canids. Although it was smaller than Arctodus simus, Arctodus pristinus would still have grown to larger sizes than many types of bears still found in North America today. Like all other short-faced tremarctine bears, Arctodus pristinus had a tall shoulder, long legs and a somewhat shortened snout. Arctodus pristinus is thought to have had an omnivorous diet, feeding on carrion, fruits, tubers, fish and possibly occasionally hunting for live prey. They may have used their large body sizes to frighten other carnivores away from their kill sites. This behavior involving opportunistically stealing food from other animals is sometimes seen in living grizzly bears in western North America so it is not unreasonable to think that short-faced bears may have engaged in similar behaviors. Giant short-faced bear Arctodus simus Temporal Range: 2 million years ago to approximately 12,800 years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, Alaska to Mexico Species: A. simus, A pristinus Diet: Omnivorous, fish, meat, roots, invertebrates, carrion The giant short-faced bear, Arctodus simus , was the largest bear found in North America during the Pleistocene epoch. These animals would have been larger than today’s polar bears. They were well over five feet tall at the shoulder and would have easily stood over 10 feet tall standing on their hind legs. Arctodu s was part of a subfamily of bears called Tremarctinae, a group whose only living member is the spectacled bear found in parts of the Andes mountains in South America. The tremarctine subfamily first appears in the fossil record at the end of the Miocene epoch with remains of animals like Plionarctos found in parts of central North America. Many of the larger tremarctine bears like Arctodus simu s and the South American Arctotherium angustiden s appeared later on in the Pleistocene. Although it is often called the “short faced” bear, Arctodus ’s face was not as flattened as is seen in older paleoart. Although its snout was shorter than that of a living grizzly bear, Arctodus ’s nasal tissues would have extended the length of their noses further forward than the shape of the animal’s skull would initially suggest. (BELOW) The skull of a short-faced bear on display at the KU Natural History Museum. Although the muzzles of these animals were shorter than those of grizzlies or black bears, these extinct bears would still have had a distinct snout Cats (Felidae) Sabertooths and ancient felines Cats form a family of carnivorous mammals with short snouts who typically have retractable claws. All members of the cat family are hypercarnivorous, almost exclusively eating meat. The ancestors of cats crossed into North America from Eurasia sometime during the Miocene epoch and by the start of the Pleistocene, the Midwest was home to several types of large cats, many of which were endemic to the North American continent. The best known prehistoric cats from this time period are saber-toothed cats like Smilodon and Homotherium . Extinct relatives of the pantherine cats, like American lions and giant jaguars, could also be found in this region, living alongside relatives of today’s mountain lions who had independently developed long legs adapted for chasing down fast moving prey Scimitar-toothed cat Homotherium serum Temporal Range: 4 million years ago to approximately 12,000 years ago Geographic Range: Genus found in the Americas, Eurasia, Africa Species: H. serum, H. latidens, H, ischyrus, H. venezuelensis Diet: Carnivorous, large mammalian prey The scimitar-toothed cat, Homotherium, was one of the most widely distributed genera of saber- toothed cats. Its fossils have been found in Europe, Asia, Africa, North America and South America, a range comparable to the historic distribution of the genus Panthera. Like most of its relatives it had a short tail and longer limbs than many of today’s cats. Compared with animals like Smilodon, Homotherium had shorter saber teeth and a longer skull. Homotherium is special since it is not only known from fossils of its bones. A recently discovered mummy of a Homotherium latidens cub from Siberia tells us that this species had reddish-brown fur as cubs. This information may not carry over to the North American species of Homotherium, Homotherium serum , but it nevertheless gives us a surprisingly detailed insight into the appearances of at least some of these ancient cats. Homotherium ’s short sabers may not have been visible when these cats had their mouths closed in life. Like many of today’s cats, it’s likely that they kept their canine teeth sheathed inside of fleshy pockets lining the outside edges of their gum tissues of the lower jaw. American cheetah Miracinonyx inexpectatus, M. trumani Temporal Range: 2.5 million years ago to approximately 16,000 years ago Geographic Range: Genus is found across North America Species: M. inexpectatus, M. trumani Diet: Carnivorous, large mammalian prey Despite its name, the American cheetah, Miracinonyx , was not a close relative of today’s cheetahs. These long-legged cats were instead distant relatives of today’s mountain lions. Two species of Miracinonyx are currently recognized; Miracinonyx inexpectatus and Miracinonyx trumani. Miracinonyx trumani is the most cheetah-like of the two species, with a narrow body and longer legs than most cats. The purpose of these long legs is unclear, with some studies suggesting that they would have filled a similar ecological role to the living cheetah, using bursts of speed to chase down pronghorns or deer. Other studies point out that these animals did not have the same foot structure seen in living cheetahs, possibly indicating that these animals were not as well suited to running down prey as we may have once thought. Miracinonyx inexpectatus had a body shape much more similar to that of today’s mountain lions. These animals may have been the ancestors of Miracinonyx trumani. American lion Panthera atrox Temporal Range: 129,000 years ago to approximately 13,000 years ago Geographic Range: North America as far south as Guatemala Species: P. atrox Diet: Carnivorous, large mammalian prey One of the largest cats found in Pleistocene North America was not a saber-toothed cat at all, but rather a member of the same genus as today’s leopards, tigers and lions. This was the American Lion, Panthera atrox , possibly one of the largest cats ever to exist. These giants were around 25-30% larger than today’s lions, standing nearly four feet tall at the shoulder. American lions are thought to have descended from a population of Eurasian cave lions who crossed over into North America during the late Pleistocene. They may also be known from fossil material found in South America. Since Eurasian cave lions are known from cave art to have been maneless cats, it’s likely that even male American lions also lacked this feature. Given their large size, American lions would have been able to hunt many of the larger herbivorous mammals found in North America during the Pleistocene, bringing down bison, pronghorns, large deer, muskoxen and possibly even mammoths and mastodons. We know very little about their social structures but they may have lived and/or hunted together in prides like today’s lions. There is some evidence from cave paintings to suggest that their cave lion ancestors also lived in groups which may lend further credence to the idea that these American lions also spent time living together. (BELOW) Some bones belonging to American lions were recovered from the Natural Trap Cave site in Wyoming. These remains, comprising a skull, cervical vertebrae, pelvis, femur and ungual bones, are on display at the KU Museum Giant jaguar Panthera onca augusta Temporal Range: 1.8 million years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout North America Species: P. onca augusta Diet: Carnivorous, large mammalian prey The Giant Jaguar, Panthera onca augusta , was a large subspecies of jaguar once found as far north as Oregon. These animals are known from some fairly fragmentary remains but by scaling these fossils using the bones of living jaguars, it seems as though the largest members of this subspecies were up to 20% larger than their modern relatives, possibly as an adaptation for hunting larger prey in open habitats. Their legs are considerably longer than those of living jaguars, making them taller as well as more massive than their possible descendents. There are also trackways suggested to have been made by a giant jaguar in Tennessee at Blue Spring Cave. It is possible that the giant jaguar may be the direct ancestor of the living jaguar species found in parts of North and South America today. Today’s jaguars seem to have a preference for living in dense forests but they are also found in more open semi-arid environments. Some jaguars are even found today within the southernmost parts of the continental US. Smilodon fatalis Temporal Range: 700,000 years ago to approximately 11,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America, possible South American material Species: S. fatalis, S. gracilis, S. populator Diet: Carnivorous, large mammalian prey Smilodon is the best known genus of saber-toothed cats. Smilodon fatalis was the dominant species in North America, descended from its smaller ancestor, the earlier Smilodon gracili s. Some Smilodon populations even managed to cross the Isthmus of Panama and reached South America, becoming their own separate species, Smilodon populato r. North American Smilodon found in the Midwest at the end of the Pleistocene epoch were slightly smaller than their relatives in South America but would still have been some of the largest cats found on the continent at that time. Their characteristic sabers seem to have been surprisingly fragile. Some fossils of Smilodon are occasionally found with broken saber teeth showing signs of wear indicating that they broke while the animal was still alive. Their exact purpose as part of Smilodon ’s hunting strategy remains a matter of debate with some suggesting that they may have been used in order to quickly sever blood flow in the necks of their prey. Although they are often colloquially referred to as “saber-toothed tigers”, Smilodon and other sabertooths were not particularly closely related to today’s lions and tigers. Sabertoothed cats are now classified within their own separate subfamily, Machairodontinae, which has no living members. Many of the later members of this group had very short tails. (BELOW) A Smilodon skeleton on display at the KU Natural History Museum. This skeleton is mounted in such a way that the mouth is open at nearly its maximum gape. These animals could have opened their mouths much wider than living pantherines in order to account for the length of their saber teeth. Dogs and Wolves (Canidae) Canids in the Midwest Canidae is the family of carnivoran mammals which includes today’s dogs, wolves, jackals, raccoon dogs and dholes. They are part of the caniform group of carnivorans meaning that they are more closely related to bears, weasels and otters than they are to cats or hyaenas. Most members of the canid family have long narrow snouts. They also have a set of large upper fourth premolars and a pair of specialized lower first molars used to cut through meat. During the Pleistocene epoch, the Midwest was home to some of the ancestors of today’s gray wolves and red wolves, as well as a variety of other extinct canids, most famously the dire wolf, Aenocyon dirus. Aenocyon armbrusteri Temporal Range: 850,000 years ago to approximately 13,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found across North America Species: A. armbrusteri Diet: Carnivorous, large mammalian prey Armbruster’s wolf was a species of canid found throughout North America during the Pleistocene epoch. Much like the dire wolf, these animals were originally placed within the genus Canis along with living dogs and wolves, but have since been placed within a separate genus; Aenocyon. Armbruster’s wolf shared many skeletal features in common with dire wolves and may in fact be the direct ancestor of Aenocyon dirus. Its fossils were first found in Maryland but remains belonging to Armbruster’s wolves have since been found throughout the US. It seems to have been most abundant during the early and middle Pleistocene epoch. Aenocyon dirus Temporal Range: 125,000 years ago to approximately 10,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found in parts of North and South America Subspecies: A. dirus dirus, A. dirus guildayi Diet: Carnivorous, large mammalian prey The dire wolf, Aenocyon dirus, was originally considered to be a close relative of the gray wolf, placed alongside it within the genus Canis . More recent analyses of their bones have suggested that dire wolves may have actually been part of a more distantly related lineage which diversified and spread throughout the Americas. This research led the dire wolf to be placed in a different genus, Aenocyon . In popular culture, dire wolves are usually represented as much larger versions of gray wolves. In reality, these animals were around the same height as the largest living gray wolves, although they were generally more heavily built than living wolves. Dire wolf remains are some of the most common mammal bones found at the La Brea Tar Pits in Los Angeles. Thousands of dire wolf bones have been found at this site, most likely drawn to the pits by the sounds of other animals who had already become trapped in the thick pools of tar. The sheer number of dire wolf remains found at these sites is considered evidence that these animals would have lived together in large packs, possibly using their numbers to bring down very large prey. Canis edwardii Temporal Range: 2.3 million years ago to approximately 300,000 years ago Geographic Range: Found throughout most of North America Species: C. edwardii Diet: Carnivorous, meat, invertebrates Edward’s wolf, Canis edwardii, is a canid with uncertain evolutionary relationships with other Pleistocene canids from North America. These animals are currently considered to be the ancestors of today’s coyotes. In terms of their size, Edward’s wolves were smaller than gray wolves but still quite a bit larger than living coyotes. Their snouts were long and thin and they seem to have been well adapted for hunting larger prey, unlike today’s coyotes which have a more generalist diet and feed primarily on smaller mammals and birds. Little is known about the social structures or possible pack sizes for Edward’s wolf. Media Gallery Suggested References: Carnivora Christiansen, P.; Harris, J. M. (2009). "Craniomandibular morphology and phylogenetic affinities of Panthera atrox: implications for the evolution and paleobiology of the lion lineage". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 29 (3): 934–945. Christiansen, Per (2008). "Phylogeny of the great cats (Felidae: Pantherinae), and the influence of fossil taxa and missing characters". Cladistics. 24 (6): 977–992. Christiansen, Per; Harris, John M. (2005). "Body size of Smilodon (Mammalia: Felidae)". Journal of Morphology. 266 (3): 369–84. Eshelman, R. E.; Bell, C. J.; Graham, R. W.; Semken, H. A.; Withnell, C. B.; Scarpetta, S. G.; James, H. F.; Godfrey, S. J.; Mead, J. I.; Hodnett, J.-P.; Grady, F. V. (2025). "Middle Pleistocene Cumberland Bone Cave Local Fauna, Allegany County, Maryland: A Systematic Revision and Paleoecological Interpretation of the Irvingtonian, Middle Appalachians, USA". Smithsonian Contributions to Paleobiology. 108: 1–305. Fowler, Nicholas L.; Spady, Thomas J.; Wang, Guiming; Leopold, Bruce D.; Belant, Jerrold L. (2021). "Denning, metabolic suppression, and the realisation of ecological opportunities in Ursidae". Mammal Review. 51 (4): 465–481. Schubert, Blaine; Hulbert, Richard; MacFadden, Bruce; Searle, Michael; Searle, Seina (2010). "Giant Short-faced Bears (Arctodus simus) in Pleistocene Florida USA, a Substantial Range Extension". Journal of Paleontology. 84 (1): 79–87. Martin L. D.; Naples V. L; Babiarz J. P. (2011). "Revision of the new World Homotheriini". The Other Saber-tooths: Scimitar-tooth Cats of the Western Hemisphere. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. pp. 185–194. Meachen-Samuels, J.; Binder, W. (2010). "Sexual dimorphism and ontogenetic growth in the American lion and sabertoothed cat from Rancho La Brea". Journal of Zoology. 280 (3): 271–279. Meachen, Julie A.; O'Keefe, F. Robin; Sadleir, Rudyard W. (2014). "Evolution in the sabre-tooth cat, Smilodon fatalis, in response to Pleistocene climate change". Journal of Evolutionary Biology. 27 (4): 714–723. Perri, Angela R.; Mitchell, Kieren J.; Mouton, Alice; Álvarez-Carretero, Sandra; Hulme-Beaman, Ardern; Haile, James; Jamieson, Alexandra; Meachen, Julie; Lin, Audrey T.; Schubert, Blaine W.; Ameen, Carly; Antipina, Ekaterina E.; Bover, Pere; Brace, Selina; Carmagnini, Alberto (2021). "Dire wolves were the last of an ancient New World canid lineage". Nature. 591 (7848): 87–91. Rincón, Ascanio D.; Prevosti, Francisco J.; Parra, Gilberto E. (2011). "New Saber-Toothed Cat Records (Felidae: Machairodontinae) for the Pleistocene of Venezuela, and the Great American Biotic Interchange". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 31 (2): 468–478. Schubert, Blaine; Kaufmann, James (2003). "A partial short-faced bear skeleton from an Ozark Cave with comments on the paleobiology of the species". Journal of Cave and Karst Studies. 65. Schubert, Blaine W.; Wallace, Steven C. (2009). "Late Pleistocene giant short-faced bears, mammoths, and large carcass scavenging in the Saltville Valley of Virginia, USA". Boreas. 38 (3): 482–492. Tedford, Richard H.; Wang, Xiaoming; Taylor, Beryl E. (2009). "Phylogenetic Systematics of the North American Fossil Caninae (Carnivora: Canidae)". Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History. 325: 1–218. Van Valkenburgh, Blaire; Hayward, Matthew W.; Ripple, William J.; Meloro, Carlo; Roth, V. Louise (2016). "The impact of large terrestrial carnivores on Pleistocene ecosystems". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 113 (4): 862–867. Van Valkenburgh, B.; Sacco, T. (2002). "Sexual dimorphism, social behavior and intrasexual competition in large Pleistocene carnivorans". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 22 (1): 164–169.
- Bivalves | Prehistoric Midwest
An illustrated guide to the Cretaceous bivalves of the Western Interior Sea including rudists and giant inoceramid clams. Bivalves Clams, Mussels, and Oysters Bivalves are a class of mollusks whose bodies are enclosed within two shells or valves. These animals have specialized gill structures which are also used to grab ahold of food to help them filter feed. Their shells are mostly made of calcium carbonate but in some animals, elements of their shells are occasionally composed of other minerals, such as aragonite. The two halves of the body of the bivalve are joined at a point called a hinge which is fastened by a strong ligament which allows the shells to open and close. In many types of bivalves, a large lower soft tissue element called a foot protrudes outside of the animal’s valves and can be used to burrow or to help the bivalve move along the seafloor. Bivalves are also some of the oldest groups of extant invertebrates and their fossil record stretches all the way back to the early Cambrian period. Anatomy Shell Structure Bivalves have two hard shells, or valves, connected along their dorsal margins by a hinge mechanism. The hinge includes a ligament and a series of interlocking teeth that keep the valves aligned while allowing them to open and close. Powerful adductor muscles are attached to the inner shell surface, and their points of attachment leave oval-shaped scars on each side of the shell. Between these scars there is a shallow groove on the inside of the shell called the pallial line. This line marks the edge of the internal soft mantle of the bivalve. The shell itself is built from a series of layers, each with their own particular composition. The outer protective covering, known as the periostracum, is built from a protein called conchiolin and shields the shell from environmental wear and chemical damage. Beneath this is the main structural part of the shell, composed of calcium carbonate. In some species, the innermost layer of the shell is made of a substance called nacre, which makes the inside of the shell appear iridescent. The outside surface of the shell is usually marked by a series of concentric growth lines. The outer shell can further be covered in vertical ribs, like those seen in scallops. Along the dorsal edge of each valve the oldest area on the shell and the first growth rings surround a small elevated point called the umbo, which is usually positioned above the hinge of the bivalve. Shell Variation Bivalves in the Western Interior Sea came in many forms, some of which would be familiar to our eyes, while other extinct groups would seem very strange to us. Among the most distinctive bivalves found in these ancient environments were the rudists, a group of bivalves which were unique to the Mesozoic era and whose shells were shaped like cylinders, cones or crescents. Rudists were some of the main reef-building animals during the Cretaceous period. Fossilized corals are rather rare in deposits from the Interior Sea but we have a huge array of fossils representing large accumulations of rudist colonies along parts of the seafloor. Inoceramid clams would also have been a common sight in these ancient seaways, some of which could grow to be more than eight feet wide. Most of these unique bivalve groups went extinct at the end of the Cretaceous period but many groups whose fossils are known from Cretaceous rocks, such as the true mussels, cockles, ark clams and oysters, managed to survive to the present day. Most bivalves are suspension feeders but the exact shapes of their shells are determined by their strategies for catching food. Some bivalves are somewhat mobile and can move along the seafloor in search of places to burrow. Others are completely stationary and will cement themselves to rocks, driftwood or other types of harder substrates, even forming reef-like colonies of thousands of bivalves living in the same area. Bivalves (Browse by order) Order Adapedonta Leptosolen Panope Panopea Siliqua Superorder Anomalodesmata Anatyma Cuspidaria Geniomya Laternula Pholadomya Psilomya Order Arcida Breviarca Cuculea Idonearca Limopsis Parallelodon Protarca Order Cardiida Callistina Cardium Cyclorisma Nelltia Protocardia Protodonax Solyma Tancredia Tellina Tellinimera Trachycardium Order Carditida Crassatella Opis Venericardia Order Hippuritida Durania Eoradiolites Hippurites Proradiolites Sauvagesia Order Lucinida Clissocolus Ctena Lucina Nympholucina Sexta Order Myalinida Cremnoceramus Inoceramus Myalinida Mylitoides Volviceramus Order Myida Caryocorbula Corbula Opertochasma Parmicorbula Pholas Ursirivus Order Mylitida Brachidontes Botula Crenella Lithophaga Modiolus Volsella Order Nuculanida Malletia Nuculana Yoldia Order Nuculida Acila Nucula Order Ostreida Crassostrea Exogyra Gervilliopsis Gryphaea Lopha Nanostrea Pseudoperna Pycnodonte Tenuipteria Texigryphaea Order Pteriida Phelopteria Pteria Order Pectinida Anomia Lima Pecten Plicautula Neithea Syncyclonema Order Solemyida Solemya Order Trigoniida Trigonia Order Venerida Arctica Callistina Corbicula Cyclorisma Cyprimeria Dentonia Flaventia Legumen Adapedonta Temporal Range: 460 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Burrowers, mobile Adapedonta is the order which includes today’s razor clams. They are typically found in saltwater environments and many species prefer to live very close to the shoreline. They often burrow into the sand using the “foot” section of their bodies, while it uses its siphon to pull in water and food. Their diets are primarily composed of plankton. Most members of this order have long, thin shells or oval/trapezoidal shells. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Adapedonta: A. Panopea , B. Panope, C. Siliqua , D. Leptosolen Gallery: Adapedonta - click to expand images Anomalodesmata Temporal Range: 480 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae, occasionally copepods Lifestyle: Stationary and mobile forms, some are burrowers The superorder Anomalodesmata is best represented in the Cretaceous fossil record of the Western Interior Sea by the members of the family Laternulidae, also known as the lantern clams, as well as the superfamily pholadomyoidea. These animals share some basic behavioral similarities with razor clams, as they sit below the substrate of the seafloor with their siphons exposed above the sand or muddy surface in order to draw in food. Lantern clams have long, thin, roughly oval-shaped shells whose umboes protrude somewhat from the surfaces of the valves around the hinges. In living genera the outsides of the shells of these bivalves are usually mostly white in color, occasionally with some darker spots. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the superorder Anomalodesmata, A. Anatymia , B. Laternula , C. Geniomya , D.Cuspidaria, E. Pholadomya , F. Psilomya Gallery: Anomalodesmata - click to expand images Arcida Temporal Range: 484 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Stationary and mobile forms, some are burrowers Arcida is the order of bivalves which includes ark clams, false ark clams and bittersweets. The outside texture of their valves varies widely between families. Limopsids have mostly smooth outer valve surfaces, ark shells and their relatives have horizontal ridges running along the outsides of their valves, and parallelodontids have vertical ridges on their shells. These animals are mostly found in saltwater environments. Some are capable of forming burrows. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Arcida, A. Breviarca , B. Idonearca , C. Cucculea , D. Parallelodon , E. Protarca , F. Limopsis Gallery: Arcida - click to expand images Cardiida Temporal Range: 450 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Stationary and mobile forms, some are burrowers Cardiida is the order of bivalves which includes cockles, bean clams, wedge shells, tellin clams, and venus clams. Their shells vary in shape, some are oval, some are heart-shaped, others, as with many bean clams, are almost triangular. They are usually smooth with some families exhibiting some very faint horizontal ridges on the outsides of their valves, but others can have very prominent vertical ribs similar to those of scallops, as is the case with many cockles. Members of this genus prefer saltwater habitats but some are found very near the shoreline. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Cardiida, A. Trachycardium, B. Cardium, C. Sourimis, D. Cyclorisma, E. Protocardia, F. Tancredia, G. Linearia, H. Nelltia, I. Solyma, J. Tellinimera, K. Callistina, L. Tellina, M. Protodonax Gallery: Cardiida- click to expand images Carditida Temporal Range: 480 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Mobile, some are burrowers Cariditida is an order of bivalves usually found in marine habitats. Members of this order have rounded, trapezoidal or triangular shells. Some members of this group have smooth shells or shells with strong horizontal or concentric ribbing. Members of the family Carditidae have very strong vertical ribbing which makes them appear very similar to scallops. Members of this group are often fairly mobile and some are capable of forming burrows. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Carditida, A. Opis, B. Crassatella, C. Venericardia Gallery: Carditida- click to expand images Hippuritida Temporal Range: ~152 million years ago - 66 million years ago Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Stationary, anchored to seafloor Hippuritida is an extinct order of bivalves who are better known as rudists. Rudists were bivalves who took on a distinctive tube-like shape. In many Cretaceous forms, one cylindrical or cone-shaped valve formed the lower portion of the animal’s outer body, while the other valve formed a roughly circular “lid” which covered the animal’s soft internal body. Other shapes are also known from these animals, including some whose valves would each have formed half of a crescent-shaped body plan. Some of these animals could grow to be very large, well over 4 feet across in some cases. Rudists first appear in the fossil record of the late Jurassic period and by the Cretaceous period they were abundant enough to form large reefs composed of their shells. They disappeared during the mass extinction at the end of the Cretaceous period. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Hippuritida, A. Sauvagesia, B. Proradiolites, C. Hippurites, D. Durania, E. Eoradiolites Gallery: Hippuritida- click to expand images Lucinida Temporal Range: ~445 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Mobile, some are burrowers An order of bivalves which includes cleft clams and hatchet shells. Their shells are usually rounded, deep, and sometimes trapezoidal. Some families have valves which are very wide and dome-shaped. Members of this order are burrowing suspension feeders who feed on plankton. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Lucinida, A. Lucina, B. Nympholucina, D. Ctena, E. Clissocolus, C. Sexta Gallery: Lucinida - click to expand images Myalinida Temporal Range: 478 million years ago - ~10 million years ago Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Stationary, attached to seafloor Myalinida is an extinct order of bivalves which includes the giant inoceramid clams. Their shells are mostly smooth, although some exhibit low horizontal ridges. The largest members of this group had shells which were longer than a fully grown person. In some parts of the Niobrara Chalk formation, their shells are extremely common, although they are rarely preserved intact. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves or the order Myalinida, A. Mylitoides, B. Cremnoceramus, C. Inoceramus, D. Volviceramus Gallery: Myalinida - click to expand images Myida Temporal Range: ~320 million years ago - present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Liftstyle: Mostly stationary, some are burrowers An order of bivalves which includes shipworms, softshell clams and their relatives. They are found in saltwater habitats and are almost exclusively burrowing animals with soft, somewhat flexible shells and pronounced siphons. In some members of this group, such as shipworms, the shell is extremely reduced and most of the animal’s body is exposed. Some genera live by burrowing into driftwood. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Myida, A. Ursirivus, B. Corbula, C. Caryocorbula, D. Parmicorbula, E. Pholas, F. Opertochasma Gallery: Myida - click to expand images Mytilida Temporal Range: ~480 million years ago - present million years ago Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Stationary Mytilida is an order of bivalves which includes sea mussels and all true mussels. They have valves which are somewhat asymmetrical and attach themselves to rocks or other surfaces using a web of filamentous structures called a byssus. They often form in large groups where substrates permit them to do so and they are found in both marine and estuarine habitats. Most of their shells are oval or otherwise elongated in their shape. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Mytilida, A. Volsella, B. Crenella, C. Modiolus, D. Brachidontes, E. Lithophaga, F. Botula Gallery: Mytilida - click to expand images Nuculanida Temporal Range: 485 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Mobile, most are burrowers Nuculanida is an order of small saltwater clams. Many members of this group are less than a centimeter long. They tend to have smooth, elongated shells which are either oval or trapezoidal in shape. Their shells are thin-walled and composed of the mineral aragonite. Some smaller forms appear translucent and may have an iridescent appearance. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Nuculanida, A. Malletia, B. Yoldia, C. Nuculana Gallery: Nuculanida - click to expand images Nuculida Temporal Range: ~480 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Mobile, slow-moving Nuculida is an order of small saltwater clams which includes nut clams and their closest relatives. Many members of this group are very good burrowers and tend to live in areas with very fine sand or mud on the seafloor. Their shells are rounded, oval-shaped, or nearly triangular with rounded edges. Some genera have ornamentation on the outsides of their valves, horizontal ridges and/or vertical ribs, which can sometimes give their outer surfaces a crosshatched appearance. Most of their shells have a layer of nacre on the inside. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Nuculida, A. Nucula, B. Acila Gallery: Nuculida - click to expand images Ostreida Temporal Range: ~480 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Stationary, cemented to rocks, wood or substrate Ostreida is the order of bivalves which includes true oysters and honeycomb oysters. The outsides of their valves usually have a rough bark-like texture. Bivalves in this order tend to grow with their shells cemented to a hard surface, such as a rock, a larger shell or a piece of driftwood. Large groups of these animals can form coastal reefs. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Ostreida, A. Crassostrea, B. Gervillia, C. Ostrea, D. Lopha, E. Texigryphea, F. Pycnodonte, G. Gervilliopsis, H. Nanostrea, I. Gryphaea, J. Pseudoperna, K. Pseudoptera, L. Exogyra, M. Tenuipteria Gallery: Ostreida - click to expand images Pectinida Temporal Range: ~470 million years ago -Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Stationary, most attach themselves to substrate or to solid objects Pectinida is an order of bivalves which includes most types of animals commonly referred to as scallops as well as kittenpaws and jingleshells. These animals live in both brackish and saltwater habitats. Most extant members of this group are able to attach themselves to a substrate but some Cretaceous members of this order are unable to do so. In some families, namely the true scallops, the outsides of the shells are covered in very pronounced vertical ribs. Other groups, like jingleshells, have smoother shells or shells with an uneven pavement of divots and ridges. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Pectinida, A. Lima, B. Pecten, C. Neithea, D. Anomia, E. Syncyclonema, F. Plicautula Gallery: Pectinida - click to expand images Pteriida Temporal Range: ~460 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Stationary, cemented to rocks, wood or substrate Pteriida is an order of bivalves which includes pearl oysters and pen shells. The bivalves in this group come in many different shapes. Some have long, thin shells shaped like flattened cones, others have long wing or spike-like projections on the outsides of their valves near their hinges. Like the bivalves in the order Ostreida, these bivalves attach themselves firmly to the seafloor by cementing themselves beside rocks or the outsides of larger shells. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Pteriida, A. Phelopteria, B. Pteria Gallery: Pteriida- click to expand images Solemyida Temporal Range: 483 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Mobile The order Solemyida includes the bivalves commonly known as awning clams. Their shells are usually long and oval in shape and they are found in both shallow and deep water marine habitats. The members of this group are typically burrowing bivalves who are able to tunnel into soft substrate using an enlarged lower foot structure. Some members of this order have shells with shallow vertical ribs issuing outwards from the area around the umbo. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Solemyida, A. Solemya Trigoniida Temporal Range: ~415 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Mobile Trigoniida is an order of marine saltwater clams whose members have a lot of variation in their shapes and ornamentation. Some members of this order are superficially similar to scallops, with several families known to have pronounced vertical striations along their shells. The hinge teeth of many of the members of this order are particularly elaborate. In some extinct genera, one larger valve will encompass the second smaller valve. The members of this group were mostly known from fossil material until the discovery of living examples of Trigoniid clams off the coast of Australia during the 19th century. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Trigoniida, A. Trigonia Gallery: Trigoniida - click to expand images Venerida Temporal Range: ~450 million years ago - Present Diet: Suspension feeder, plankton, algae Lifestyle: Mobile Venerida is an order of clams which includes animals which are found in both saltwater and freshwater habitats. Members of this group include venus clams, duck clams and kelly clams. They tend to have smooth shells with limited ornamentation aside from their growth lines. Their shells are usually oval or trapezoidal in shape. (ABOVE) Cretaceous bivalves of the order Venerida; A. Callistina, B. Flaventia, C. Cyclorisma, D. Sinonia, E. Legumen, F.Cyprimeria, G. Dentonia, H. Arctica, I. Corbicula Gallery: Venerida - click to expand images Suggested References: Bivalves Cox, L. R. et al. (1969). “Bivalvia”, in R. C. Moore ed., Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part N, Mollusca 6, Volume 2. The University of Kansas and Geological Society of America. 1224 pp. Crampton, J.S. (2004). “Shell composition, cryptic costae, complex composite molds and taphonomic chicanery in Mytiloides (Inoceramidae, Bivalvia).” Journal of Paleontology 78(6):1091-1096. Digital Atlas of Ancient Life. (n.d.). “Bivalvia”. Cretaceous Atlas of Ancient Life | Bivalvia. https://www.cretaceousatlas.org/classes/bivalvia/ Everhart, M.J. "Inoceramids" Oceans of Kansas website: http://oceansofkansas.com/Inoceramids.html Everhart, M.J. (2017). “Oceans of Kansas - A Natural History of the Western Interior Sea, Second Edition.” Indiana University Press, 460 pp. Selden, P. A., ed. (2009). “Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. Part L, Mollusca 4, Revised, vol. 2.” The University of Kansas Paleontological Institute. Lawrence, Kansas Hattin, D. E. (1988).” Rudists as historians; Smoky Hill Member of Niobrara Chalk (upper Cretaceous) of Kansas”, Fort Hays Studies, Third Series, 10:4-22. Henderson, R. (2004). “A Mid-Cretaceous association of shell beds and organic-rich shale: Bivalve exploitation of a nutrient-rich, anoxic sea-floor environment.” Palaios, 19(2):156-169. Stephenson, L.W., & Stenzel, H.B. (1952). Larger invertebrate fossils of the Woodbine formation (Cenomanian) of Texas, with Decapod Crustaceans from the Woodbine formation of Texas. Stewart, J.D. (1990). “Niobrara Formation symbiotic fish in inoceramid bivalves. p. 31-41 In S. Christopher Bennett (ed.), 1990 Society of Vertebrate Paleontology Niobrara Chalk excursion guidebook”. Museum of Natural History and the Kansas Geological Survey, Lawrence, Kansas

